6 ms·
I agree directionally with this but it drives me nuts how much special pleading there is about what high-profile companies like OpenAI do, vs. what low-profile
by tptacek 1y ago
I agree directionally with this but it drives me nuts how much special pleading there is about what high-profile companies like OpenAI do, vs. what low-profile industry giants like Cisco and Oracle have been doing for a whole generation. The analysis can't credibly start and end with what OpenAI is doing.
- kennywinker 1y ago[flagged]
- vFunct 1y ago[flagged]
- sneak 1y agoGitHub (Microsoft) supports US ICE which runs concentration camps in Texas. It works much the same everywhere.
- dralley 1y agoNot every war is genocide. Calling it genocide over and over doesn't actually make it one if it literally doesn't meet the legal definition.
- cookiengineer 1y ago[flagged]
- ipv6ipv4 1y agoEven the Irish, who can’t be accused of being pro-Israel, recognize that the genocide accusation is bunk. The Irish solution is to try to redefine the term to fit their agenda. About par for the course. https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/ireland-wants-expansion-of-the-definition-of-genocide-under-the-geneva-convention-says-taoiseach/a1112529887.html https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/ireland-wants-expansio...
- kennywinker 1y agoThe irish literally call it genocide. They want an expansion to include blocking aid as genocide, so that deniers like yourself can’t deny so flippantly
- ipv6ipv4 1y agoThe Irish call it genocide, but find that nobody agrees with them. Well, because the definition doesn’t agree with them. So they want to change the definition. As you yourself just admitted, it’s not a genocide as per the definition. Otherwise, there would be no need to change it so that “I can’t be flippant”
- dralley 1y ago>If four ICC judges are sanctioned by the corrupt Trump administration because of their rulings that it is a genocide They have done no such thing. The only ruling thus far was basically equivalent to a grand jury indictment. There has been no ruling that the Gaza conflict is or was a genocide, only that the claim was plausible enough to proceed through the legal process. It came with an order to preserve evidence and produce reports for the court and take steps to ensure a genocide did not occur. There was no ruling that a genocide is or was occurring. That is false. I expect you to retract your claim. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c3g9g63jl17o https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c3g9g63jl17o
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- cookiengineer 1y ago> There was no ruling that a genocide is or was occurring. That is false. I expect you to retract your claim. The ICC specifically ordered Israel to introduce immediate measures to prevent genocide. That is the exact wording of the order. [1] A trial will happen once the president and/or generals of the IDF set foot on European land, or once they are extradited, which they likely will never do. Both the ICC and the ICJ came to the same conclusion that the blockades of humanitarian aids, the destruction of religious and medical institutions, combined with military rocket strikes against civilians are evidence that Israel is "destroying Palestinians in Gaza", and that it is genocide. Additionally, multiple NGOs have come to the same conclusion, including Amnesty International [2] and the ECCHR [3] [1] https://www.icc-cpi.int/sites/default/files/CourtRecords/0902ebd1809a40bf.pdf https://www.icc-cpi.int/sites/default/files/CourtRecords/090... [2] https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2024/12/amnesty-international-concludes-israel-is-committing-genocide-against-palestinians-in-gaza/ https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2024/12/amnesty-inter... [3] https://www.ecchr.eu/fileadmin/Q_As/ECCHR_Q_A__Gaza_and_Genocide_20241210.pdf https://www.ecchr.eu/fileadmin/Q_As/ECCHR_Q_A__Gaza_and_Geno...
- dlubarov 1y ago> The ICC specifically ordered Israel to introduce immediate measures to prevent genocide. Can you quote the order you're referring to? That doesn't sound right, ICC would have no authority (under its own rules) to issue injunctive orders of that sort. > Both the ICC and the ICJ came to the same conclusion ... that it is genocide. ICJ made no such finding (so far) - the finding at this stage was that Palestinians had a "plausible right" to be protected from genocide, not that one is occurring. This doesn't sound right for the ICC either, since it's at the pre-trial stage where they don't make such findings of fact.
- vFunct 1y ago[flagged]
- dralley 1y agoI mean, that's pretty clearly false. Very recently, a certain orange man and his (until this past week) peppy sidekick have been referring to the predicament of Afrikaner farmers as genocide - I'm pretty sure you would agree with me that that isn't the case in actual reality. Therefore, I'm pretty sure you would agree there are some claims of genocide that are in fact false and made for cynical political reasons. Was dropping the atomic bomb on Japan "genocide"? Was firebombing Dresden "genocide"? We could probably even agree that these were ethically wrong, even perhaps war crimes, but nobody calls them genocide, because they aren't.
- vFunct 1y agoCorrect. The public consensus doesn't call them genocides, while calling other events as genocides. The only people going against the public consensus are this seeking to commit genocide.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 1y ago> The only people that say something isn't genocide are those that support genocide. I don’t think you meant to phrase it this way. The point in the sibling comment is spot on. If I may, I suspect you want to replace the word “something” with “a credible genocide”. > broad consensus Unfortunately, the consensus comes from an unreliable narrator. (That doesn’t make it wrong, just untrustworthy.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent
- conception 1y agoDefinition Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide Article II In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such: Killing members of the group; Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part; Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group; Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.
- kennywinker 1y agoIt does meet the legal definition. If the International Criminal Court isn’t qualified to decide what is and isn’t a genocide - who is? Because they have called it a genocide. It was a genocide back in January 2024 when the ICC first spoke on this, and since then there has been another year and a half of ongoing genocidal action - targeting of civilians, denial of aid, deliberate starvation and water depravation. These are facts. They are visible in 4K if you have the stomach to watch them.
- dralley 1y ago>Because they have called it a genocide. It was a genocide back in January 2024 They did not. Go read the ruling. They declared the claim "plausible" and ordered Israel to take actions to preserve evidence and take steps to ensure one did not occur. That is not equivalent to declaring that one did occur or was occurring. It was essentially a type of injunction, not a conviction of any kind. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c3g9g63jl17o https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c3g9g63jl17o >> In January, the ICJ delivered an interim judgement - and one key paragraph from the ruling drew the most attention: “In the Court’s view, the facts and circumstances... are sufficient to conclude that at least some of the rights claimed by South Africa and for which it is seeking protection are plausible.” >> This was interpreted by many, including some legal commentators, to mean that the court had concluded that the claim that Israel was committing genocide in Gaza was “plausible”. >> This interpretation spread quickly, appearing in UN press releases, statements from campaign groups and many media outlets, including the BBC. >> In April, however, Joan Donoghue, the president of the ICJ at the time of that ruling, said in a BBC interview that this was not what the court had ruled. >> Rather, she said, the purpose of the ruling was to declare that South Africa had a right to bring its case against Israel and that Palestinians had “plausible rights to protection from genocide” - rights which were at a real risk of irreparable damage. >> The judges had stressed they did not need to say for now whether a genocide had occurred but concluded that some of the acts South Africa complained about, if they were proven, could fall under the United Nations’ Convention on Genocide.
- kennywinker 1y agoSo what you’re saying is that you were wrong when you said “it literally doesn't meet the legal definition”? Because you’ve just cited the ICJ saying it was plausible back in january 2024. So, will you be retracting your incorrect statement that it does not meet the legal definition? Meanwhile, a UN special committee, as well as amnesty international, have both concluded it’s a genocide. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Committee_to_Investigate_Israeli_Practices_Affecting_the_Human_Rights_of_the_Palestinian_People https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Committee_to_Investi... But you got me, the ICJ hasn’t concluded it’s DEFINITELY a genocide. Just that if the actions alleged are true, it’s a genocide. In the mean time, 80% of homes in gaza have been destroyed. Uncountable war crimes have been documented. The ICJ ordered the halt of the rafah offensive and israel ignored that order. Refugee camps were bombed. People seek aid and are shot. People are killed for delivering aid. Water is withheld. If by some technicality it does not get ruled as a genocide by the ICJ, it hardly matters. It’s an atrocity of genocidal proportions and that is why people keep calling it a genocide. Oh, and because it’s also a literal genocide.
- pclmulqdq 1y agoHigh tech has been selling huge computer systems and advanced technology to the UAE for decades. The original intent of the AMD GloFo spinoff was to put a leading-edge fab in Abu Dhabi until that ran into the realities of doing anything in a desert with bad supply chain considerations and no fresh water.
- fakedang 1y agoMost of the declarations of that sort are usually just spin for their people by the government when they make plans to buy out some high-tech company. We saw this with Global Foundries, we're seeing this with Resilience, and we'll eventually see it with some other company down the line (likely OpenAI or Novo Nordisk). The government has to provide its native people the illusion of providing jobs, if not actually provide the jobs. Because not every Emirati can work in ADNOC in a high-paying air-conditioned office.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- fisherjeff 1y agoI mean, I think OpenAI really opened themselves up to being singled out when they framed this as being about, like, promoting democracy when it’s clearly just a cash grab.
- tw04 1y agoCisco and Oracle didn’t start out as non-profits claiming to be focused on the betterment of mankind. This is no different than Google dropping the do no evil and getting roasted for it. Also, you’re suggesting because a company got away with bad behavior in the past we should never expect better of any other company going forward?
- chii 1y ago> getting roasted for it. and making bank. I know which option i'd choose.
- mschoch 1y ago[dead]
- 0x69420 1y agothe nonprofit line has not been believ{ed,able} or relevant for what, in tech, may as well have been a century by now. had this happened around the time the veil was lifted, that would have been something worth discussing, but this was announced last month. it is now only meaningfully addressable along the same avenue as any other american tech giant getting comfy with the us govt's controversial foreign relations.
- jrochkind1 1y agoI think it's worth discussing AI specifically being used by authoritarian governments, because it is so suitable for surveillance and repression. And worth discussing OpenAI as a leader in the field, investing in such collaborations. It's worth talking about the others too for sure. Not every article or essay needs to talk about all of them. Sure, it would be improved if it at least mentioned in passing what is known of any other large corporations making specifically AI deals with authoritarian governments. (Such as all of them with Israel). But not every article needs to talk about everything. The argument that a given article or point should not have been made because it didn't talk about other things -- usually will result in less talk about any of the things, not more. And that's often the intent of such an argument.
- Qwertious 1y ago>what low-profile industry giants like Cisco and Oracle have been doing for a whole generation. It's more than a generation; IBM literally provided computers that ran the holocaust.
- yu3zhou4 1y agoCan you share more about it?
- morsch 1y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dehomag#Holocaust https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dehomag#Holocaust
- neumann 1y ago[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust This was an excellently researched book - the 2012 edition has a lot of additional documentation that really highlighted the level of support IBM threw behind the railway logistics planning.
- kps 1y ago> IBM literally provided computers that ran the holocaust. IBM literally provided punch card record keeping equipment. IBM literally didn't provide computers. Computers literally didn't exist.
- tough 1y agoPunch cards where the literal computers at the time...
- kps 1y agoThe literal computers at the time were people. Computer: 1. One who computes; a calculator, reckoner; spec. a person employed to make calculations in an observatory, in surveying, etc. [OED, 1923] Punch cards held tables of records, and the unit record equipment were nowhere close to the modern meaning of ‘computer’. (The human computers were probably Turing-complete, though.)
- roenxi 1y agoPolitics is the art of the possible, eh? It is annoying but we can be grateful that people are at least attempting to organise around principles, even if the principle is obviously not what motivates them. In this case the woman is obviously mostly writing this because she doesn't like OpenAI specifically, but she has an argument and it is a good one.
- x-complexity 1y ago> In this case the woman is obviously mostly writing this because she doesn't like OpenAI specifically, but she has an argument and it is a good one. Until the same measures are uniformly taken with the rest of the actors in the industry, this is nothing more than virtue signalling. Denouncing X should also mean denouncing actors close to X, for a given domain space F(actor).
- Propelloni 1y ago"Virtue signaling" is moving the Overton window. The far-right got very far with it, so do not dismiss it. Every journey starts with a first step.
- ben_w 1y ago> Denouncing X should also mean denouncing actors close to X, for a given domain space F(actor). Nobody has time for that. For example, one common target for activists is Nestlé. Most people barely have time to think about Nestlé at all, and of those who do, I think most are oblivious that e.g. Maggi is a brand that Nestlé owns. I could probably do this XKCD but about activists and company names instead of geochemists and olivine/feldspar/quartz: https://xkcd.com/2501/ https://xkcd.com/2501/
- buran77 1y ago> what high-profile companies like OpenAI do, vs. what low-profile industry giants like Cisco and Oracle have been doing Not that I disagree but you're whatabouting your way into an argument, and you used to be against it [0]. And you're not even doing it to establish a pattern or bring up some history, it's just for the sake of it. It's an analysis about OpenAI. You agree that the author is not wrong but immediately detract from the credibility of the analysis because they haven't included a specific "whatabout"? [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19872884 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19872884
- kmod 1y agoI agree in general, but I think some important context here is that the author of this post was previously on the OpenAI board (the board that fired Sam Altman).
- jimbokun 1y agoDo Cisco and Oracle engage in the same kind of Orwellian double speak of claiming they are supporting democracy by giving even more power to autocratic dictators?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- nyeah 1y agoLet's say Joe and Jane are both illegally parked. It is not "special pleading" to point out that Joe is illegally parked. That's not the meaning of the phrase.