4 ms·
> In a pilot program launched in Singapore, the tech giant now blocks the installation of certain sideloaded apps—particularly those requesting sensitive permis
by Aurornis 1y ago
> In a pilot program launched in Singapore, the tech giant now blocks the installation of certain sideloaded apps—particularly those requesting sensitive permissions such as SMS access or accessibility services—if they are downloaded via web browsers, messaging apps, or file managers.
There are a lot of qualifiers on this: Only in Singapore, only on apps requesting certain permissions frequently used by scams, and only when downloaded via certain paths.
I don’t see the full details but this implies that it’s still possible for advanced users to side load whatever they want. They don’t want to make it easy for the average user to start sideloading apps that access SMS permissions or accessibility controls.
If it takes a few extra steps for the advanced user to sideload these apps that’s not really a big infringement on freedom like this purism PR piece is trying to imply. Unfortunately sideloaded apps are a problematic scam avenue for low-tech users.
> The move, developed in partnership with Singapore’s Cyber Security Agency, is designed to prevent fraud and malware-enabled scams.
This explains why it’s only in Singapore for now.
- blacksmith_tb 1y agoUnless they block ADB, I wouldn't say it's accurate to claim they're "blocking sideloading". That said, it's clearly a balancing act between protecting people from installing malware but allowing them to intentionally install things they really do want to install, regardless of what permissions they need.
- jeroenhd 1y agoThey don't, and they don't even block F-Droid. You can also just disable Play Protect (though Google won't let you while you're on a call, probably a smart move). According to the Singapore police, scammers also have victims download VPNs of Google Play to work around the regional restrictions. I don't think the restrictions are doing much for victims. I assume Google was pressured into doing this by the authorities, or may be doing this to get in a good spot politically.
- cAtte_ 1y agorequiring a user to own a PC in order to sideload apps (with adb) would, in fact, count as blocking sideloading, albeit partially. so i don't think that's the right limit
- FergusArgyll 1y agoI've sideloaded apps for other people. They don't have to own a PC but it's true that it'll slow it down, so you do have a point.
- Zak 1y agoEvery time the technical sophistication required to install apps from anywhere but Google's store (I don't love the term "sideloading" since it kind of denormalizes the act) is increased, the chances anyone will put in the effort to distribute apps any other way goes down. It also means apps Google doesn't want in its store are less likely to get made; I'd really like to see something that prioritizes notifications for me, for example, and I think that's against Google's rules. I'm sure making it harder to obtain software outside a first-party app store provides some protection to some users from scams, but I really don't want that to be the answer. I don't claim to have a good one myself.
- mystified5016 1y agoYeah, just like you can sideload on iPhone by desoldering the flash, decrypting it, and modifying the OS. Just because something is technically possible does not make it a solution
- blacksmith_tb 1y agoThat's a little higher bar than plugging in a usb cable and running ADB... but I would agree that most users probably won't figure out how to sideload from a terminal.
- soulofmischief 1y agoI think you're dismissing legitimate concerns without fully understanding them, because through the right lens you realize how this can be anticompetitive in the mass market. Even if some technically inclined folk can install what they want, the masses will stay in the walled garden so that Google can get their cut and exert ideological control. Even now, both Google and Apple engage in practices across their product that are designed to scare people away from third party applications. From Google's terminology when describing Google in banners as "a more secure browser" etc, to Apple requiring a secret incantation in order to run unsigned apps. All of this kind of mind control bullshit should be eradicated via regulation. Companies should not have a license to be deceptive towards their users.
- Klonoar 1y agoThe comment you're responding to includes the line: > The move, developed in partnership with Singapore’s Cyber Security Agency, is designed to prevent fraud and malware-enabled scams. Your comment seems to disregard it and instead lay this entirely at Google's feet as if they're seeking anti-competitive behavior - but if this was driven by a government, does Google really deserve all the blame? (Note that I am explicitly not endorsing the move. I think sideloading should be left mostly untouched.)
- card_zero 1y ago> partnership Could mean anything from reluctant to opportunistic.
- azalemeth 1y agoSingapore is far from a nation known for free speech or to pick the side of liberty should it come into conflict with security. I've no doubt whatsoever that approved apps on a CTS "hardware backed" remote attestation phone is more secure. It's also possible to remotely own such a device unambiguously, and provides a central place where apps can be taken offline. It's win win from the point of view of a security agency. It's not from mine.
- soulofmischief 1y ago
- Lammy 1y agoOnce it's normalized it's just one more step to block everything. No thanks.
- aiauthoritydev 1y agoIt will always be possible to side-load apps on Android if you really want. It is one big strength of Android. There are many Android's no-internet deployments in the wild that rely on this feature.
- IshKebab 1y agoBoiling the frog though... Obviously they're not going to roll it out all in one go.
- kgeist 1y ago>There are a lot of qualifiers on this: Only in Singapore, We had a big client from Singapore who only agreed to buy our SaaS subscription after we integrated SingPass (Singapore's national digital identity system) for user login. When I read "Singapore" in the OP I immediately remembered about it. The client is not with us anymore, but we still have this thing somewhere in the codebase :)
- Dylan16807 1y ago> There are a lot of qualifiers on this: Only in Singapore, only on apps requesting certain permissions frequently used by scams, and only when downloaded via certain paths. Only certain permissions actually matter. That's one of three. But "only in singapore so far" is not reassuring. And "downloaded via certain paths"? Browsers and file managers are the normal ways to put files onto a phone. That doesn't reassure me at all.
- eddd-ddde 1y agoBrowsers and file managers are absolutely not the "normal ways" to put apps in a phone however.
- Dylan16807 1y agoWell sure but "app store" is already excluded by the context of sideloading.
- hiccuphippo 1y agoThey can still add more locations later. I would prefer if Google moved in the direction of giving apps fake permissions. Otherwise the scammers will just move onto another layer.
- thaumasiotes 1y ago> There are a lot of qualifiers on this: Only in Singapore, only on apps requesting certain permissions frequently used by scams, and only when downloaded via certain paths. Those "certain paths" include "file managers"; how exactly would you sideload an app without providing the file?