10 ms·
NYC Drivers Who Run Red Lights Get Tickets. E-Bike Riders Get Court Dates
- throw84i 1y ago[flagged]
- bookofjoe 1y agohttps://archive.ph/FM4mH https://archive.ph/FM4mH
- memset 1y agoThis article makes the mistake of conflating “bicycles” and “e-bikes.” It does this to garner sympathy for its position that these laws are bad. Expanding bicycle lanes is great. Bicycles are great and I’m a fan of reclaiming more land from car traffic for cyclists and pedestrians. However many e-bikes - I don’t know what percentage - are just technically under the legal limit for being classified as motorcycles. That is not the intended use of the bike lanes. Similarly, Amazon now has motorized delivery vehicles driving through the bike lanes in the city. They are exactly the width of the lane. It’s great to prevent congestion on streets, and a clever piece of engineering, but again, not a bicycle, even though it has pedals. If you’re driving a motorized vehicle then don’t ride in the bike lane! If you’re on a road then follow the laws and don’t run red lights!
- aqme28 1y agoI think you're confused about what this article is about. Which law are you pointing to when you say "its position that these laws are bad"? Because you're talking about ebikes on bike lanes, but this article is entirely about court cases vs traffic tickets for red light violations. It mentions bike lanes only offhand as evidence of general trends.
- john-h-k 1y agoIt does provide reasoning for the asymmetry: > “Since e-bikes do not require a license, drivers of e-bikes can simply ignore their traffic summons with no repercussions whatsoever, making any enforcement futile,” the police spokesperson said. However, the new requirement that cyclists appear in court, or face an arrest warrant if they fail to, creates “a strong incentive to show up in court.”
- bombcar 1y agoIsn’t a ticket just a summons to court that you have an option to do something else (pay the fine)? And if you don’t, you lose your license. But there is no licensing for bikes or e-bikes, so the leverage they have isn’t there.
- consp 1y agoIt's also misleading as there is a natural penalty asymmetry. The penalty for crossing though red and getting hit by a car is death for any cyclist and a likely accident but very survivable for a car. Around here the fines are equal in money but you can lose your license to drive a murder machine. (Sarcasm) It might be worse if the allowed speeds around intersections and cultural preference to speed though red are higher. And by allowed speeds I mean natural speed through traffic calming.
- john-h-k 1y ago> The penalty for crossing though red and getting hit by a car is death for any cyclist and a likely accident but very survivable for a car. But the legal penalty is nothing to do with what risks you took. You could have the view that the state should punish making mistakes that can kill your (in which case the bike penalty would be higher), but I (and I assume most) people wouldn't say this. The reason the penalty exists is to disincentivise the action. If people were truly rational with all these risks, the problem wouldn't exist in the first place. It would be incredibly odd to suggest, say, that burglars should have lower sentences if they risked their lives while doing the burglary.
- consp 1y agoI phrased it wrongly. My bad. The point should have been: if you drive a machine which can result in deadly harm to others you should be more responsible and thus the fine heavier (no longer being allowed to use such machine). Try killing someone with a bike. Not impossible but more a challenge than with a car.
- radlad 1y agoThe article uses the term e-bike in the headline but it's not clear to me if the court summons are limited only to e-bikes or analog bikes as well?
- xattt 1y agoIt sounds like a general rant about chicken tax workarounds for personal mobility where those modes of transport reek of personal entitlement. There are e-bikes (1) that are essentially electric Vespas with unusable pedals sticking out the sides. Depending on the jurisdiction, they may even be “technically” allowed on sidewalks because the wheel size would be under a certain diameter (~ <24”). They are very intimidating to pedestrians, and there is usually no enforcement because there may be no by-law to enforce. Getting on one breaks a social contract about what it means to respect one another’s safety and comfort. I want to see these folks try to pedal their “e-bikes” without busting up their ankles. (1) https://emmo.ca/collections/electric-scooter-ebike https://emmo.ca/collections/electric-scooter-ebike
- sokoloff 1y agoIf an e-bike meets the legal standard for being a bike and using the bike lanes, that seems like the right place for them to be. If the law needs to change, we have processes to change the laws. Same for the Amazon ones. They either are or aren't bikes/are or aren't eligible for the bike lanes. "not the intended use of the bike lanes" doesn't have the same force and certainty of "not allowed to use the bike lanes by statute".
- Swenrekcah 1y agoCertainly it is a much more serious offense to run a red light in a car than on any kind of bicycle (also electric bicycle, limited to some speed like 15mph or similar).
- Filligree 1y agoThe article points out that, no, running the light on a bicycle is a more serious offence. We can argue about whether it should be.
- Swenrekcah 1y agoRegardless of the law, the physical reality of the world says it is more serious to run a red light in a car, due to speed and weight.
- AStonesThrow 1y agoAre you proposing a Trolley Problem here?
- radlad 1y agoE-bikes in the US are limited to 28 mph in the highest class but can be deregulated. They're also closer to 75 lbs than 25. Agree completely on regular bicycles though.
- alecst 1y agoThey are giving court dates to (regular) cyclists, they are harsher on bikes than cars, and they are stopping cyclists at a higher rate than they stop drivers of cars. https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2025/04/18/exclusive-cops-writing-15-of-their-red-light-tix-to-cyclists-who-are-just-2-of-road-users https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2025/04/18/exclusive-cops-writin... https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2025/05/02/policy-change-nypd-will-write-criminal-summonses-not-traffic-tickets-for-cyclists https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2025/05/02/policy-change-nypd-wi... If the police don't care about the difference, why do you?
- AlgorithmicTime 1y ago[dead]
- addicted 1y agoNo, the question is are bicyclists killing and injuring pedestrians disproportionately than cars. And the answer is no. Every time a bike lane is installed on a street/avenue the safety rate for pedestrians increases dramatically.
- const_cast 1y ago> If the police don't care about the difference, why do you? Because the police are more often wrong than they are right. We shouldn't be modeling our laws over what's most convenient for police, that's just asking for abuse.
- tstrimple 1y agoThe police also didn't care to intervene in Uvalde. Should we not care as a result? I don't even know what this line of argument is. Some weird appeal to authority?
- burnt-resistor 1y agoRemember Casey Neistat's film about being ticketed for going around an obstacle in the bike lane? NYC uses the public as a for-profit revenue source and will extract it from the weakest people.
- curtisszmania 1y ago[dead]
- john-h-k 1y agoImportant context that may explain it somewhat further down in the article. > “Since e-bikes do not require a license, drivers of e-bikes can simply ignore their traffic summons with no repercussions whatsoever, making any enforcement futile,” the police spokesperson said. However, the new requirement that cyclists appear in court, or face an arrest warrant if they fail to, creates “a strong incentive to show up in court.” Cannot speak for its accuracy. Anecdotally (London not NYC) I feel like I am "endangered" by e-bikes much more often than cars, because they seem to regularly skip red lights and come silently shooting out from the other side of a car while you are crossing, which a car simply cannot do. They are far heavier than a normal bike and seem to be closer to a small incredibly quiet moped. Obviously lives-saved is the most important metric, but that doesn't mean the "feeling of safety" component is worthless. The comparison around deaths is only useful if those figures are primarily car deaths caused by running red lights. I feel like the most sensible policy is requiring licenses for e-bikes above a certain power level (not easy!) and then bringing parity to the treatment of cars vs e-bikes after that
- wnolens 1y ago> e-bikes above a certain power level This is already true in NYC. It just another law that there aren't enough resources to be enforced IMO
- addicted 1y agoIt's largely enforced fine with e-bikes. However, you do have car lane legal scooters that also ride in the bike lanes when convenient which are a real problem. These aren't e-bikes, however, and are not supposed to be in the bike lane in the first place.
- addicted 1y ago> Anecdotally (London not NYC) I feel like I am "endangered" by e-bikes much more often than cars Speaking of NYC, not London, there are several reasons I see for this. 1. NYC has used bike lanes as pedestrian safety infrastructure, siting the bike lanes right against sidewalks, providing a buffer from cars. NYC DOT has done a lot of research every time a new bike lane has been added, and every time they did that pedestrian deaths and severe injuries dropped. However, the flip side is that you're gonna have e-bikes much closer to you than cars. 2. Street infrastructure, including red light timing, etc. is entirely based on cars and not bikes. The bike lights, for example, switch directly from green to red, providing no "yellow" period to stop. This actually makes sense because bikes are significantly safer, but it leads to different behavior than cars, which some pedestrians feel is "unfair". What would actually be fair would be to design the infrastructure suitable for bikers as well. 3. Pedestrians simply have different expectations of cars/ebikes. You will reliably see tourists not even look for bikes while crossing the bike path and stand in the middle of the bike path or walk in the bike path in a way they never would with a car lane. 4. Bikes are just given much poorer infrastructure. In NYC, you have narrow bike lanes, several of which are interrupted with slick and dangerous sewer gratings, and with no space to pass, with car parking right next to them leading to people constantly hopping through the bike lane from their cars to the sidewalk without looking, constantly creating a danger of opening their doors without looking causing bikes to be "doored", etc. There's way too much "feels" in this discussion. It's about time someone provided some actual data that bikes, and even e-bikes, have even slightly increased risks to pedestrians, when all the actual data suggests otherwise, and it's about time we recognize that at least in places like NYC, the "danger" caused by bikes/e-bikes, is literally because the city has made bikers a buffer to protect pedestrians from the actual dangers on the road, the 1-2 ton cars traveling at incredible speeds through dense urban areas.
- colanderman 1y agoMixed feelings about this, as a pedal cyclist. Modern e-bikes are large and fast, and many of their riders ride unsafely and abuse bicycle infrastructure (which have been designed to accommodate pedal cyclists, who did the work fighting for them), making bike lanes and bike/walking paths dangerous for unpowered users. I'm of the opinion that they should be licensed and treated like motorcycles/scooters/mopeds unless limited (and inspected) to operate below a certain speed. But restricting smaller e-bikes and pedal bikes from proceeding through red lights when safe is also excessive. Forcing cyclists to wait for when the cars next to them can move puts them at danger of right hooks. I've spoken with Cambridge MA bicycle police about this (who've been issuing warnings to cyclists doing this) and they were willfully obstinate and disingenuous to the point I wondered if they'd ever ridden a bicycle before. I believe it's called the "Dutch protocol" or something (EDIT: "Idaho stop"!), that cyclists should treat stop signs as yield signs, and red lights as stop signs, which is an accepted and safe way to adapt car infrastructure to bicycles. NYC and Cambridge politicians and police seem too thick headed to understand bicycle safety though. (Larger e-bikes I maintain should be subject to the same rules as motorcycles for lights and stop signs. They're immaterially different.) In any case, criminal summons is ridiculous. Abuse of power that is putting noncitizens in danger.
- dylan604 1y ago> I've spoken with Cambridge MA bicycle police about this (who've been issuing warnings to cyclists doing this) and they were willfully obstinate and disingenuous to the point I wondered if they'd ever ridden a bicycle before. So what is a bicycle police if not one that rides a bike?
- colanderman 1y agoPolice that enforce bicycle laws.
- dylan604 1y agoSo there's so many cops in your area that they have some dedicated to just policing bicycle laws? Or is your area one of those where "with all other crime being solved..." that they are now policing bicycle laws? In my area, bicycle cops are the officers on bicycles, so of course they've ridden bikes before. In my area, officers that enforce bicycle laws are just, you know, officers.
- numpad0 1y agoyeah, if you operate a $thing without a license through a legal exception, it comes without the protection offered by the point system, and violation events go straight to the court like an illegal function call without try-catch. I thought the point framework apply for licensed drivers, though. I guess that's where lawyers' license comes into play.
- bko 1y ago> There is an irony embedded in the enforcement push. Cyclists who blow through red lights without endangering anyone else can now be forced to appear in court. Drivers who commit the same violation cannot. Instead, drivers face the same traffic ticket they always have, a moving violation with a fine payable by mail. The difference with drivers is that moving violations often result in higher insurance rates. If you don't pay, you eventually can't register their car, can't get insurance and lose their license. Similar enforcement doesn't exist on e-bikes. I'm not sure how many people would pay e-bike tickets, but I imagine the penalty and repercussions of not paying would be a big enough deterrence. They should consider doing something similar for toll evaders on subways and buses. Increased enforcement doesn't really scale but you can make the cost much greater to deter criminal activity. Make that person go to court. About 45% of bus fares are evaded in NYC, and it make sense. If a ticket is $3 and a fine is up to $100 after the first offense, then enforcement has to be really high. https://www.mta.info/press-release/icymi-governor-hochul-announces-subway-fare-evasion-down-26-percent-new-york-city https://www.mta.info/press-release/icymi-governor-hochul-ann...
- hbsbsbsndk 1y agoSubway fares disproportionately penalize the poor and force them into encounters with police. Transit should be free.
- staringback 1y ago[flagged]
- micromacrofoot 1y agoI'll get on my soapbox every time to also point out that a fareless system is also cheaper for everyone to operate. Operating and maintaining fare systems costs millions of dollars (hundreds of millions when they upgrade the system), enforcing and gating fares reduces system efficiency. Rolling those costs into taxes instead will always cost less than collecting at point of operation. Fares are already too low to cover operational costs, so at this point it's practically theater.
- TuringNYC 1y agoI'm in Brooklyn quite often, and much more worried about eBikes than cars. With cars, you are usually safe walking on a sidewalk -- but eBikes regularly ride on sidewalks, weave thru crowds on sidewalks, and excessively run red lights. I've had far more near misses with ebikes than cars -- the eBikes can come zipping down through non-lanes when you least expect -- in the wrong direction against traffic, and on walk signals.
- jeffbee 1y agoI can't understand how anybody who's been in Brooklyn can say that you're safe on the sidewalk from cars. https://old.nyc.streetsblog.org/2017/01/31/85-year-old-driver-hits-3-on-brooklyn-sidewalk-killing-1/ https://old.nyc.streetsblog.org/2017/01/31/85-year-old-drive... One of many
- TuringNYC 1y agoNot saying you are 100% safe from cars. However, I cant recall the last time a car almost hit me on a sidewalk -- however an eBike almost hits me on the sidewalk on a monthly basis.
- craftkiller 1y agoI'm also in Brooklyn and this is also my experience, though its not just e-bikes, its also gas-powered mopeds. The 2-wheeled motor vehicles treat the sidewalks like a loophole for 1-way streets. A gas-powered moped even honked at me once for being in their way *on the sidewalk*. I'm all for e-bikes. They're great. We need police to start giving a fuck and ticket people riding on the sidewalk. Even for the ones classified as bicycles, in NYC you're only legally allowed to ride a bicycle on the sidewalk if you are 12 years old or younger.
- K0balt 1y agoThis is kind of a nothing burger, since a court date is the only way to enforce compliance-there is no drivers licence to levy points against for e-bikes. Also, the e-bike problem is a current rampant menace to pedestrians. I’m sure there are relatively few fatalities from e-bikes but low fatalities != low injuries/low danger. The problem is that some cyclists seem to have a tendency to feel that the rules do not apply to to them, and e-bikes create a situation where (essentially) there is a new class of motorcyclists that have the same systemic disregard for traffic regulation. A more stringent approach to enforcement is a logical response to systemic endangerment of pedestrians.
- lolinder 1y agoAnecdotally, I've recently felt far more threatened by e-bikes in NYC than I ever have by cars. Cars in NYC are nuts, but they're a competent kind of nuts. I've never had one get even close to me, and that's with me jaywalking as much as any local. E-bikes are a totally different story. They'll shoot through narrow streets twice as fast as the cars do and blitz through stop signs without even slowing down. There have been multiple occasions where I was nearly hit by one of them. They seem to think that because they're smaller they don't need to care as much, but at the relative speeds of cars and bikes on those narrow streets I'm pretty convinced they'd do more damage to me than the 5-10 mph car would.
- jeffbee 1y ago200 people are injured by cars in NYC every single day.
- sorcerer-mar 1y agoOperative word is "felt"
- matsemann 1y agoBut how much of that is rooted in some kind of motonormativity where one as a pedestrian just "accepts" all the drawbacks of car infrastructure (like not being allowed to cross a street where you want), but then ignoring how cyclists often are forced to share space with pedestrians etc? Aka, you don't get into the conflicts with cars at all, because you're trained to allow the car most of the space and act subservient to them. (But I do think your feelings are off, most stats would show cars are the big offenders, but still, feelings are important and everyone should feel safe in the city) To me, many of the pedestrian <=> cyclist conflicts are due to bad infrastructure and a prioritization of cars, having cyclists and pedestrians forced to share or accept bad solutions. Street lights are for the benefits of cars. To me they should all be just pedestrian crossings where cars have to yield. Pedestrians should be top on the totem pole, and should be able to walk in the city as they please. Having to wait to cross is just a way to increase the throughput of cars, forcing you to press the "begging button". And here's some of the issue as well. If it was only cyclists and pedestrians, we wouldn't need red lights. But how it's built today doesn't take into account that cyclists can pass safely through an intersection if it weren't for the cars. So it feels almost like an affront to you when you have to stop due to the infrastructure being tailored for someone else. I never bomb through a red light myself, as I said, I prioritize pedestrians above cyclists, but I do understand why it's happening. More ticketing or "enforcement" won't help, as it doesn't solve the underlying issue: Cities are prioritizing cars, when it should prioritize humans.
- dfxm12 1y agoIf your first thought is that eBikes are dangerous, please keep a few things in mind: eBikes can be dangerous, OK, we get it, but this discussion is about the uneven enforcement. If this is about keeping peds safe, why are drivers of automobiles not getting this treatment? They're giving court dates to riders of normal bikes as well. It comes down to who usually rides eBikes. They're trying to get the working poor into the criminal justice system. I guess quotas aren't being met now that weed is legal. One person described bike lanes as a war on the working class, yet the bikers interviewed who got hit with a summons were gig workers or construction workers. Please don't fall into this trap of turning against the working class in service of the monied class. I assure you, the construction worker in the bike lane is just trying to the job site. They aren't starting a war.
- haswell 1y ago> why are drivers of automobiles not getting this treatment? FTA > “Since e-bikes do not require a license, drivers of e-bikes can simply ignore their traffic summons with no repercussions whatsoever, making any enforcement futile,” the police spokesperson said. However, the new requirement that cyclists appear in court, or face an arrest warrant if they fail to, creates “a strong incentive to show up in court.” To answer the “why not do this to drivers?” question, the answer is arguably that the enforcement mechanisms for drivers were more effective than the enforcement mechanisms for bikes. Whether or not this justifies what they’re doing is another question.
- dfxm12 1y agoGo ahead, make the argument, because making a worker lose a day's worth of work and wasting the court's time with "legally insufficient" summonses doesn't seem very effective at making pedestrians safer (or anything useful) to me.
- haswell 1y agoI’m not saying it’s a good solution, but the problem itself is real enough. As others have noted, I’ve had more close calls with dangerous e-bike riders as a pedestrian than I’ve ever had with cars, mostly because riders behave as if they’re not piloting a powered vehicle capable of doing quite a bit of harm. Whether or not it’s actually making pedestrians safer is an open question. If the threat of a court date actually leads to less dangerous behavior by riders, it’s entirely possible that it could make pedestrians safer. That still wouldn’t be sufficient to conclude it’s a good policy. Another approach would be to level the playing field between drivers and riders and use the same enforcement policies/mechanisms for both, but that also has side effects that people would not like.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- 0_____0 1y agoIf you're not living in NYC and haven't visited recently, you should know that an incredible amount of e-bike traffic is Delivery Network Company (Doordash et al.) 'workers' who don't seem to abide by any of the same rules of the road as anyone else, cars and cyclists alike. They all ride seemingly the same make of Chinese e-bike, usually wrapped in tape and random tubes and other stuff. It's extremely NYC, and often these folks get included in the general description of e-bike users without distinguishing them from the general population.
- ho_schi 1y agoThis is correct. Riding with an actual bicycle in NYC's traffic between cars and buses is rather safe. The delivery E-Bikes on cycle lane and cycle paths are a danger. It is not the speed. I also ride fast on a roadbike. It is the behavior. They pass you without any space on a small cycle lane between walkway and parked cars. Don't expect "On you left" or "On you right". Which caused this: https://thevillagesun.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/e-bikes-Hudson-River-Park-1-copy.jpg https://thevillagesun.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/e-bikes... PS: I think bicycles and E-Bike shall be not considered as the same type of vehicle. In Austria they distinguish even between roadbikes (can always select safest surface depending on their speed: road, cycle lane, cycle path) and bicycles (should use distinct cycle paths when possible).
- 0_____0 1y agoFunny thing is that the model of citibike in that photo is an electric assist. That's an e-bike, right?
- scyclow 1y agoIf they really cared about cracking down on ebikes then they'd only try to nail ebikes, not regular cyclists. The conspiracy theorist in me thinks that the real reason they're doing this is to help ICE nab a bunch of delivery workers.
- giraffe_lady 1y agoIt's also just that cops hate cyclists. I don't really have a single neat explanation why but it's hard to ride a bike in a large american city without it being obvious that they do.
- dfxm12 1y agoUneven enforcement (like penalties for powdered cocaine vs crack, dress codes, etc.) always come down to classism, racism, etc. It's obvious the prison industrial complex is at play here, whether the appetite is coming from ICE or domestic prisons.
- frenchtoast8 1y agoIt is legal for a bicyclist to run a red light in a specific circumstance (when the light is red but the pedestrian walk signal is lit). This has been a NYC law since 2019, but NYPD is still routinely giving tickets for this, and judges are routinely refusing to vacate them. I can understand a lone NYPD officer not being aware of the law (although I think 6 years is getting ridiculous). But the issue is also the DMV judges that, in some cases, have acknowledged the law but have claimed they have the power to ignore it as it is a NYC law and not NYS law. This argument is bewildering to me - if it was true then what is the reason for NYC laws to exist at all? https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2022/09/06/the-nypd-and-dmv-are-punishing-cyclists-for-legally-crossing-with-the-pedestrian-signal https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2022/09/06/the-nypd-and-dmv-are-... I feel very strongly about bicyclists running red lights, and I'm always the one looking like a nerd who stops at the light. But I am very concerned about bicyclists getting criminal summonses for them when our system of checks and balances is consistently not working even in the unambiguously legal cases.
- neilv 1y agoIn my city (not NYC), as a heavy walker, the "e-bikes" and "e-scooters" have recently gotten much more threatening than cars. It's normal for these motorized vehicles to be speeding down the narrow sidewalks, and also speeding through crosswalks on red. Where there are bike lanes, these motorized vehicles have started using them like their own express lanes, including ignoring red lights (like many bicyclists do, but this time motorized). They also often just barely miss pedestrians, seemingly by intention, like they're confident they can control it and won't slip, and so don't leave much safety margin. When you're on foot, I think being hit by one of these at speed will probably cripple or kill you. I've also seen "e-bikes" that look suspiciously like full-sized electric motorcycles, cruising along sidewalks to beat traffic. Sometimes these are obviously delivery drivers or couriers. Also, I might be noticing a bit more of the random most obnoxious non-motorized bicyclists on the sidewalk than usual. If so, I don't know whether they're emboldened by the e-bike and scooter people they see, or it's all the bike rental stations on the sidewalk now, or something else. Ideally, I want to see people behave responsibly, just because they're conscientious and decent. When that fails, and the behavior will almost inevitably lead to life-altering injury or death for someone else, then we probably need the government to step in. The article contrasts with lax enforcement for cars, and I'd say we need to also enforce cars more. It's gotten worse in recent years here. It used to mostly be many cars not using turn signals, and a convention of a few cars running every red, and people just learned to be careful of the unofficial rules many follow. Now, watch for one light on a busy intersection in town, and you might see half of people on cars moving through the intersection sidewalks while looking at a phone/tablet (sometimes even hands on the device, to the detriment of steering ability). There's also a popular belief on local online forums that car drivers involved in crashes with bicyclists are rarely punished. Before the surge of e-bikes and scooters causing their own problems and precedents, I used to wonder whether some of the irresponsible bicyclist behavior was due to an oppressed defensive mindset from cars, turned combative. Now I have to wonder whether the recklessness of the motorized bikes and scooters is contributing. "Massholes" [1], and their kin from other states, have discovered the motorized "bike", it's in some ways even more dangerous than the car, and we need to change the culture, before healthy walkers end up confined to wheelchairs or morgues. [1] https://www.fodors.com/world/north-america/usa/massachusetts/experiences/news/what-is-a-masshole-and-where-did-the-word-come-from https://www.fodors.com/world/north-america/usa/massachusetts...
- oftenwrong 1y agoRelated: https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2025/05/29/data-dump-e-bike-crashes-were-down-before-nypd-crackdown-contradicting-tischs-rationale https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2025/05/29/data-dump-e-bike-cras... The stated reasoning behind this new policy is not backed by data; e-bike collisions and injuries are down in NYC and are insignificant compared to the harm caused by cars. Rather than looking at the data to determine the urgency of the problem, the police merely listened to complaints from community members and assumed that the complaints had merit.