4 ms·
This, as the article makes clear, is a concern I am alert and receptive to. Ban production of anything visual from an LLM; I'll vote for it. Just make sure they
by tptacek 1y ago
This, as the article makes clear, is a concern I am alert and receptive to. Ban production of anything visual from an LLM; I'll vote for it. Just make sure they can still generate Mermaid charts and Graphviz diagrams, so they still apply to developers.
- hatefulmoron 1y agoWhat is unique about graphic design that warrants such extraordinary care? Should we just ban technology that approaches "replacement" territory? What about the people, real or imagined, that earn a living making Graphviz diagrams?
- tptacek 1y agoThe article discusses this.
- hatefulmoron 1y agoDoes it? It admits at the top that art is special for no given reason, then it claims that programmers don't care about copyright and they deserve what's coming to them, or something.. "Artificial intelligence is profoundly — and probably unfairly — threatening to visual artists" This feels asserted without any real evidence
- tptacek 1y agoLLMs immediately and completely displace the bread-and-butter replacement-tier illustration and design work that makes up much of that profession, and does so by effectively counterfeiting creative expression. An coding agent writes a SQL join or a tree traversal. The two things are not the same. Far more importantly, though, artists haven't spent the last quarter century working to eliminate protections for IPR. Software developers have. Finally, though I'm not stuck on this: I simply don't agree with the case being made for LLMs violating IPR. I have had the pleasure, many times over the last 16 years, of expressing my discomfort with nerd piracy culture and the coercive might-makes-right arguments underpinning it. I know how the argument goes over here (like a lead balloon). You can agree with me or disagree. But I've earned my bona fides here. The search bar will avail.
- hatefulmoron 1y ago> LLMs immediately and completely displace the bread-and-butter replacement-tier illustration and design work that makes up much of that profession And so what? Tell it to the Graphviz diagram creators, entry level Javascript programmers, horse carriage drivers, etc. What's special? > .. and does so by effectively counterfeiting creative expression What does this actually mean, though? ChatGPT isn't claiming to have "creative expression" in this sense. Everybody knows that it's generating an image using mathematics executed on a GPU. It's creating images. Like an LLM creates text. It creates artwork in the same sense that it creates novels. > Far more importantly, though, artists haven't spent the last quarter century working to eliminate protections for IPR. Software developers have. Programmers are very particular about licenses in opposition to your theory. Copyleft licensing leans heavily on enforcing copyright. Besides, I hear artists complain about the duration of copyright frequently. Pointing to some subset of programmers that are against IPR is just nutpicking in any case.
- tptacek 1y agoOh, for sure. Programmers are very particular about licenses. For code.
- hatefulmoron 1y agoI get it, you have an axe to grind against some subset of programmers who are "nerds" in a "piracy culture". Artists don't deserve special protections. It sucks for your family members, I really mean that, but they will have to adapt with everybody else.
- mwcampbell 1y agoI disagree with you on this. Artists, writers, and programmers deserve equal protection, and this means that tptacek is right to criticize nerd piracy culture. In other words, we programmers should respect artists and writers too.
- 1y ago
- palmfacehn 1y ago>This feels asserted without any real evidence Things like this are expressions of preference. The discussion will typically devolve into restatements of the original preference and appeals to special circumstances.
- omnimus 1y agoIt’s more question of how it does what it does. By making statistical model out of work of humans that it now aims to replace. I think graphic designers would be a lot less angry if AIs were trained on licensed work… thats how the system worked up until now after all.
- hatefulmoron 1y agoI get where you're coming from, but given that LLMs are trained on every available written word regardless of license, there's no meaningful distinction. Companies training LLMs for programming and writing show the same disregard for copyright as they do for graphic design. Therefore, graphic designers aren't owed special consideration that the author is unwilling to extend to anybody else.
- omnimus 1y agoOf course i think the same about text, code, sound or any other LLMs output. The author is wrong if they are unwilling to give same measure to everything. The fact this is new normal now for everything does not make it right.
- fennecfoxy 1y agoI don't think most artists would be any less angry & scared if AI was trained on licensed work. The rhetoric would just shift from mostly "they're breashing copyright!" to more of the "machine art is soulless and lacks true human creativity!" line. I have a lot of artist friends but I still appreciate that diffusion models are (and will be with further refinement) incredibly useful tools. What we're seeing is just the commoditisation of an industry in the same way that we have many, many times before through the industrial era, etc.
- omnimus 1y agoIt actually doesn't matter how would they feel. In currently accepted copyright framework if the works were licensed they couldn't do much about it. But right now they can be upset because suddenly new normal is massive copyright violation. It's very clear that without the massive amount of unlicensed work the LLMs simply wouldn't work well. The AI industry is just trying to run with it hoping nobody will notice.
- throw310822 1y ago> Ban production of anything visual from an LLM That's a bit beside the point, which is that AI will not be just another tool, it will take ALL the jobs, one after another. I do agree it's absolutely great though, and being against it is dumb, unless you want to actually ban it- which is impossible.
- speleding 1y agoHasn't that ship sailed? How would any type of ban work when the user can just redirect the banned query to a model in a different jurisdiction, for example, Deepseek? I don't think this genie is going back into the bottle, we're going to have to learn to live with it.
- victorbjorklund 1y agoWhy not the same for texts? Why are shitty visual art more worth than the best texts from beloved authors? And what about cooking robots? Should we not protect the culinary arts?
- GoblinSlayer 1y agoOn the other hand it can revive dead artists. How about AI generated content going gpl in 100 days after release?