6 ms·
The wake effect: As wind farms expand, some can ‘steal’ each others’ wind
- glkindlmann 1y agoThe word "rights" surprisingly didn't come in that piece. By analogy to "water rights" [1], "wind rights" are a thing, both in the basic sense of permission to extract wind power from some chunk of land [2] and the messier sense of that article: conflicts between upstream and downstream users of the wind [3] (recent article and fascinating read) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riparian_water_rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riparian_water_rights [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_rights [3] https://eelp.law.harvard.edu/wind-wakes-and-the-right-to-wind-power-generation/ https://eelp.law.harvard.edu/wind-wakes-and-the-right-to-win...
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoWind rights, as presently constructed, are more analogous to air rights than water rights. They convey the right to use a space versus resource.
- tantalor 1y agoFrom the article: "you can't steal something that can't be owned - and nobody owns the wind"
- timewizard 1y agoDrainage! Drainage, Eli, you boy. Drained dry. I'm so sorry. Here, if you have a milkshake, and I have a milkshake, and I have a straw. There it is, that's the straw, you see? Watch it. Now my straw reaches acroooooss the room, and starts to drink your milkshake. I drink your milkshake!
- dp-hackernews 1y agoI presume this is a quote from a film, but which one? Or, if not where from?
- tantalor 1y agoThere Will Be Blood
- ta12653421 1y agoExactly ++1
- dp-hackernews 1y agoTnx
- curiouscavalier 1y agoThanks for posting this. Water rights and who gets priority was the first thing that came to mind. The thought of “wind augmentation plans” is fun to think about.
- p0w3n3d 1y ago> Wind farms produce energy, and that energy is extracted from the air. And the extraction of energy from the air comes with a reduction of the wind speed," says Peter Baas, a research scientist Sorry, but this is something that any 8th grade primary school student could say. It's the energy conservation principle.
- hyghjiyhu 1y agoAs you say it obviously reduces the wind speed. But what is not obvious is whether the reduction is negligible or not, and what problems it could lead to. How much fields hamper each other. Whether it messes with bird ability to glide on updrafts, sailing, water aeration. Fortunately it seems to be fine from these perspectives.
- p0w3n3d 1y agoIf wind has kinetic energy - E, the amount that can be harvested is < E, and that was kinda obvious from the start. Turbines stop the wind, hence one country can stop wind blowing towards another country if they put many fields on the "track". And apparently it hasn't been taken into account when making those optimistic statements regarding zero emission energy. Also this IS ecology altering, and might have an effect in global weather, but not sure how much (wind mainly blows at high altitudes).
- Dylan16807 1y ago> If wind has kinetic energy - E, the amount that can be harvested is < E, and that was kinda obvious from the start. Yes. > Turbines stop the wind No. > And apparently it hasn't been taken into account No.
- bamboozled 1y agoPeople seem to love finding faults with wind farms, even if the contents of the article are purely factual, we need them ,we need to keep experimenting with them and developing better solutions. We can't let wind turbines be like "nuclear"; the dirty word which could've saved our civilization.
- chgs 1y agoWind has been common in the U.K. for decades, I remember driving past them as a kid in the 90s on holiday It’s only recently that the right wing has become particularly against them
- bamboozled 1y agoThat's my point, there is some sort of anti-wind religious crusade going on, and it's bullshit.
- chgs 1y agoThere are people who spend money to make more pollution in their local neighbourhoods https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolling_coal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolling_coal It’s unsurprising that nimbys don’t want wind in their back yard despite acknowledging the benefits.
- mikeyouse 1y agoThe argument I've seen a lot recently that seems the most disingenuous is that the blades aren't recyclable. Completely inert fiberglass blades that are useful in generating GWH of energy over their multi-decade lifespan and people are pretending to be mad we're going to bury them in the same landfills that we bury millions of tons of other trash? A close second is some dramatic image of a turbine with a gearbox issue that leaked gearbox oil all down the side about how much oil they use, "100 liters per turbine" or some such bullshit that ignores that all of that is fully recycled so you might 'consume' 100 liters in a development in a year but even that's not turned into CO2, it's just leaked into the environment.
- morkalork 1y agoFrom TFA the wake can stretch 100km from a windfarm and reduce output of another by 10%. Interesting so it sounds like an optimization at country scale, how to place windfarms to maximize overall output when accounting for these effects.
- Retric 1y agoSome level at 100km OR 10% if very close, but not both at the same time.
- collinmcnulty 1y agoI would like to see this effect compared to other obstructions, like regular buildings. I understand that wind farms are built in areas that are mostly otherwise flat, so the effects matter, but I just don’t feel like my scale is calibrated. I would think an individual tall building would have more effect than an individual wind turbine, but what about a typical small town center vs a wind farm?
- polishdude20 1y agoThis made me think of a cool sci Fi post apocalyptic idea. A colony that has its base in the middle of violent tornado or storm country but it has a huge array of wind machines that harvest the storm for energy. On the leeward side of the array, where the colony lives, the air is calm, robbed of its energy.
- m-r-r 1y agoThis sounds a lot like the plot of The Horde of Counterwind by Alain Damasio
- OutOfHere 1y agoThis has in the past been scientifically proposed as a legitimate way to cure the US of tornadoes while yielding significant energy in the process.
- SlowTao 1y agoSounds like an idea that is technically sound but economically a dead end. Like harvesting lightening for electricity. It might not seem it locally but the energy is too defuse at a large scale.
- freeone3000 1y agoA Valley Without Wind 2…
- glumreaper 1y agoOh, the wailing and gnashing of teeth over wake losses. Let's get some figures: * From their own study: the cumulative wake loss impact of four new wind farms in the Irish Sea on Orsted's existing estate is 3.28% [0] * "Wind turbines are found to lose 1.6±0.2% of their output per year." [1] So, wake losses turn a brand new wind farm into a 2-year-old wind farm. Given the yuuuuuge lifespan of wind farms, it seems kinda trivial. [0] https://www.rechargenews.com/wind/-catastrophic-wake-losses-threaten-existence-of-orsted-irish-sea-wind-farms/2-1-1785911 https://www.rechargenews.com/wind/-catastrophic-wake-losses-... [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0960148113005727 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S096014811...
- vlovich123 1y agoI think that’s a glib dismissal without any analysis of the financials that motivate the investment being profitable in the first place.
- cududa 1y agoAre you doing a Jordan Peterson bit? The one where someone asks him "Do you believe in" and he says "Well what is the meaning of do, and what do you mean by you? And what is believe?"
- vlovich123 1y agoI really am insulted by the analogy. All I said is that painting a 3% drop as trivial and not worth thinking about is completely ignoring that that could be the entire profit margin for the wind mill installation in the first place and thus the financing and capital investment math could have been done incorrectly and push the profitability negative. Pretty sure I presented a clear description of what my issue with such a glib dismissal is.
- Dylan16807 1y agoThe difference between a wind farm being barely barely profitable and barely barely losing money doesn't really matter when we're building these in bulk.
- aaron695 1y ago> The mysterious effect plaguing wind farms "mysterious" "plaguing" - zero examples...... very mysterious. The dumb shit the BBC feeds HN Doomers, there is no solution other than big pharma's fluoxetine to the CO2 devil. Other wind farms will cut into their profits..... always a good idea to get the competition shut down.
- amai 1y agoThat really is only a problem if the direction of the wind never changes. But if the direction of the wind turns around the farm stealing the wind and the farm being robbed of wind switch roles.
- fensgrim 1y agoAlso, isn't it really stupid to treat the wind the same way we do with rivers or with electrical current (which is actually flowing the opposite way to electrons, so not like the river/wind at all)? E.g. country A is saying that country B is stealing their incoming (upstream) wind, but there's currently a zone of negative pressure (based on the mountains/shore/passing by cyclone/whatever) on the country A's territory which actually allows for the pressure gradient to form through both countries A and B - so there's more energy potential available to tap into on country A's territory?
- Ekaros 1y agoThinking of wind direction. I would imagine that wind farms in general are build in areas where there is tendency for prevalent winds. That is known to have certain direction and speed. As these are most sensible places for most production. Areas with more changing wind patterns are likely less desirable.
- g42gregory 1y agoIf windfarms reduce overall wind speed around them and if there are enough of them built, wouldn't this measurably reduce the wind speed in the environment? And if the wind speed of the environment is measurably reduced, wouldn't this affect the environment itself? What are the negative effects of this on birds, climate, insect population, etc...? Do positive effects significantly outweigh negatives?
- PaulKeeble 1y agoThe amount we can extract is tiny compared to the volume of energy put into the air every day by the sun. At a certain scale it could definitely become an issue and change the local environment and reduce wind speeds, we have seen that with some of the biggest solar farms where the air temperature is changed and the shade increases vegetation and wildlife so presumably wind speed reductions will have some effect. But compared to the CO2e it saves from being emitted its absolutely worth it currently.
- vlovich123 1y ago> But compared to the CO2e it saves from being emitted its absolutely worth it currently. Funny. That’s a huge part of the argument made to justify that burning fossil fuels is OK. The problem with letting small problems linger while you scale is that suddenly you have a huge problem you can’t do anything meaningfully about because suddenly it’s a critical part of your economy.
- Dylan16807 1y ago"It reduces CO2 emissions" is being used to justify burning fossil fuels? And is "a huge part" of the argument? I think you explained yourself wrong.
- vlovich123 1y agoNo, it’s being used to say that ignoring the problems with Wind farms scaling to a huge scale (and fossil fuels is massive and wind has made less than a noticeable dent) means that you’ve solved one set of problems for another and hopes the second set isn’t as bad. I didn’t say the only alternative is to go back to fossil fuels. I personally think that nuclear has much better and cleaner scaling properties with fewer issues than wind and solar (for example it still remains generally true that the only countries that have meaningfully reduced CO2 emissions are those that have offset it using nuclear while solar and wind have a very poor record) .
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- acyou 1y agoThat's amazing, it's remarkable that we can harvest energy from the environment so effectively. Is global warming expected to increase or decrease wind farm output? Apparently warm air is less dense than colder air, warm, moist air is even less dense, but it would seem like with global warming you have more energy in the system overall.
- SlowTao 1y agoThat is a good question. Warm moist air is a known issue at some airports due to the loss in lift but that doesn't take into account wind speed. With wind turbines, I suspect additional wind speed due to additional energy would cancel out the drop in density.
- roxolotl 1y agoThere’s a fun study from ten years ago modeling out what this looks like with hurricanes. Not particularly likely to ever happen but it’s a fun read. One of the things that surprised me is the authors assert that you don’t have to worry about building especially strong turbines because they progressively sap the energy of the storm as it approaches meaning the eyewall wouldn’t be as bad. Study: https://www.nature.com/articles/nclimate2120 https://www.nature.com/articles/nclimate2120 Article: https://www1.udel.edu/udaily/2014/feb/hurricanes-wind-turbines-022614.html https://www1.udel.edu/udaily/2014/feb/hurricanes-wind-turbin...
- 0xDEAFBEAD 1y agoHow about hurricane-chasing drone ships full of turbines? Kill two bird with one stone! Sap hurricane energy and turn it into renewable energy.
- elric 1y agoWhere does the energy go in this case? The ships would have to be pretty large to have any kind of impact. Should they extract CO2 from the air using the generated power?
- 0xDEAFBEAD 1y agoYeah that sounds good. How about making natural gas using the electricity, as I understand that Terraformer is doing using solar power? The ships will get plenty large if the operation is profitable :-)
- smusamashah 1y agoTo move forward in wind/hurricane the propellers/turbine wings need to move faster than they currently are with the wind. Basically more energy is required to chase the wind. Unless the ship drops and settles inside the hurricane, it won't work.
- 0xDEAFBEAD 1y ago
- Klaus_ 1y ago[dead]
- DocTomoe 1y agoEveryone with a functional understanding of thermodynamics knows that you cannot extract energy from a system and expect there to be the same energy in the source after the extraction. I do wonder if - in 20 to 50 years - we find out that we somehow screwed up the ecosphere with renewable energy production in a subtle and catastrophic way, much like we did with coal-powered or nuclear plants.
- chii 1y agoThe wind and solar energy would've merely heated up the earth, then get radiated back out. Us capturing some of it, using it, and then re-radiate it back out (at a later date) won't have made any difference. Unless/until the day we paved the entire earth with solar panels and capture the entire atmosphere of their wind, this will continue to be the case. Hopefully, we reach a dyson swarm before that occurs...
- DocTomoe 1y agoI am old enough to remember when similar statements were made about other - now out of favour - energy production methods. NPPs had a "Once in a thousand years" failure rate. Gas was fossil, sure, but the CO2 would be absorbed into the ecosphere (to make plants grow). In the end, all energy eventually dissipates again. That does not mean that we do not have immediate or near-immediate phenomena to consider (like: global warming). Let's take solar ... we now have begun to replace agricultural areas with solar farms. For example: How does this affect biodiversity in that area (the things look not green, but gravel under it)? I'm not even saying it is necessarily a bad thing - just a change. And we should be careful to change running systems, especially considering the stakes. Instead, what I see is proponents of one tech over the other happily shouting down any attempt at critical consideration.
- 3327 1y ago[dead]
- JohnKemeny 1y agoThe book Mine is relevant here. It’s about how people argue over what belongs to whom, especially when ownership is unclear. When one wind farm is upwind, its turbines slow the wind for farms behind it, cutting their energy. In a way, it’s “stealing” some of the wind. The book explains why these kinds of fights over shared resources happen and why we need better rules for such situations. Other examples: upstream hydropower reducing downstream potential energy; a tree in your yard casting shadows on your neighbor’s property, thereby “stealing” sunlight and potential solar power.
- oulipo 1y agoClassical example is rivers crossing two countries, and the country upstream installing dams...
- Theodores 1y agoWe have been here before with the waterwheels that powered the mills at the start of the Industrial Revolution, allegedly. Allegedly this was a problem in the Cotswolds, UK, when the woollen industry was where the big money was. I only know this from school history classes, not from Google, hence my use of the word 'allegedly'. Allegedly, mills placed upstream slowed the flow to existing mills downstream, leading to disputes. In time, mills were built with big chimneys, meaning coal. But why would you go for expensive coal that had to be transported when you had 'free' power from the river? It has been hypothesised that drought may have played a part in this, not the over use of waterwheels.
- grues-dinner 1y agoIt's quite obvious if you look at how a watermill is built. Upstream, there's a wier which diverts water along a culvert into a pond at the level of the weir. The watermill is then driven by water falling from the pond to the level of the river at that point. Depending on the gradient of the river, this can be some distance from the weir. If the weir diverts on average a substantial portion of the flow, anyone wanting to use the river between the weir and the mill will find there's much less water for the purpose. Many British rivers in areas where there were (literal) cottage industries like little mesters are not that big (only a few metres across and under a metre deep) so you can see where conflicts could arise. And also they do dry up to almost trickles in dry weather.
- hulitu 1y ago> The wake effect: As wind farms expand, some can ‘steal’ each others’ wind Next: solar farms who can ‘steal’ each others' sun.
- Kon-Peki 1y agoThe first photo in the article (turbines with a sailboat) is very well chosen! Stealing others’ wind (or making it “dirty”) is a well-known and well-used tactic in sailboat racing. It is very effective. One explanation of tactics: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lh9Hz0TDFxE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lh9Hz0TDFxE
- AngryData 1y agoI kind of wondered about this since I got a big windfarm near me in all the fields. It seems like ideally they would be spread out over a much larger area across the state. Of course there are probably also advantages to having all that electrical infrastructure in one area.
- mensetmanusman 1y agoWhat if wind drops below seed requirements?
- exabrial 1y agoUnpopular opinion: I don't like wind farms ruining natural landscapes. They pollute natural beauty and put industrial infrastructure where it would have never been otherwise. I'm 100% onboard with alternative energy as it's essential to prevent changing our atmosphere. However, as I look across the Kansas plains, I'm saddened by the industrialization and further human encroachment into areas previously untouched.