6 ms·
I've never been so conflicted about a technology
- bitpush 2y agoDisappointed with the article, especially because it uses "think of the planet" as a weak argument against this technology. > Firstly, there’s the environmental impact Their own blog contributes to climate crisis they are now crying about. We can argue someone in a developing country writing a similar article saying "all these self publishing technologists are making climate crisis worse" and it'll have a stronger point. I say this without discounting the real environmental costs associated with technology, but LLMs / AI isnt uniquely problamatic. Your latest macbook, iphone, datacenter, ssds.. all have impact.
- kelseyfrog 2y agoCorrect. We have to order by impact and refrain from spending effort on all but the issue at the top of the list. If we choose to affect any lower-priority issue, it is an example of hypocriticality that de-legitimizes the whole project.
- nicce 2y agoIf we had stayed farmers, we wouldn't have these issues. Most people would be still happy. Intelligence is both destruction and savior.
- criddell 2y ago> farmers are 3.5 times more likely to die by suicide than the general population https://www.fb.org/in-the-news/modern-farmer-farmers-face-a-mental-health-crisis-talking-to-others-in-the-industry-can-help https://www.fb.org/in-the-news/modern-farmer-farmers-face-a-...
- nicce 2y agoDo you think that study applies if we would go 2000 years back? World was kinda different.
- kirubakaran 2y ago"Many were increasingly of the opinion that they’d all made a big mistake in coming down from the trees in the first place. And some said that even the trees had been a bad move, and that no one should ever have left the oceans." - Douglas Adams
- frereubu 2y agoYour argument seems to be flattening everything so it's just the same - "everything has an impact" - but different things have different impacts, and each needs to be measured against their utility. Me ordering a coffee at my local cafe has an impact, but it's a good deal less than me driving from London to Edinburgh. The author's argument, as I read it and generally agree, is that we don't really need LLMs to get things done, but their use comes with a large environmental cost. I don't think that will stop its use, unfortunately. There's just too much capital behind them at the moment.
- zdragnar 2y agoWe don't really need LLMs like we don't really need the internet. We don't really need that blog, nor do we really need Netflix, porn or Facebook. Individuals value things differently, so attempting to do society-wide prioritization is always going to be a reductive exercise. For example: Your local cafe doesn't need to exist at all. You could still drink coffee, you'd just have to make it yourself. That cafe is taking up space, running expensive commercial equipment, keeping things warm even when there aren't customers ordering, keeping food items cool that aren't going to be eaten, using harsh commercial chemicals for regular sanitization, possibly inefficient cooling or heating due to heavy traffic going in and out the door, so on and so forth. Imagine the environmental impact of turning all cafes into housing and nobody driving to go get a coffee.
- frereubu 2y agoAgain, this just feels like throwing your hands up in the air and saying "it's too hard to decide!" But we have to take decisions somehow if we're going to do anything.
- roywiggins 2y agoTake one fewer hot shower a week and you've saved enough energy to power a lot of ChatGPT queries. Play one fewer hour of Minecraft. Turn off raytracing. Eat one fewer burger per month. All of those things would save more energy than forgoing a few ChatGPT conversations.
- vaylian 2y ago[flagged]
- jll29 2y ago[flagged]
- jll29 2y ago(I thought it would be funny - in a self-referential way - to use our especially fine-tuned LLM to analyze bias in the OP in order to prove that LLMs can be useful by showing how they may be usefully applied to the OP itself.)
- pvg 2y agoIt's not particularly funny and generated comments are discouraged on HN https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20%22generated%20comments%22&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- codydkdc 2y ago> Firstly, there’s the environmental impact. Models require massive amounts of electricity and water (to cool servers). An AI chatbot contributes more to the climate crisis than a Google search. I really dislike the "people should be better and use less energy" argument for solving macro-problems like this > My naive optimism led me to believe that technology would help us fight climate change. I was wrong: AI and Crypto are net negatives in this regard. ...why? why would technology that specifically requires a lot of energy help "fight climate change"? this entirely article is missing any point to me -- it's very vague and speaking in generalities. > “If you’re going to use generative tools powered by large language models, don’t pretend you don’t know how your sausage is made.” why? if you generate code with a LLM, then read and deeply understand the code, what's wrong? > I can’t help but feel the web would be a better place if the technology had never existed in the first place. if we didn't invent the wheel, we wouldn't have so many cars/trucks polluting the planet
- lucianbr 2y ago> ...why? why would technology that specifically requires a lot of energy help "fight climate change"? There's no good reason it would. Nevertheless, proponents of both AI and crypto have claimed multiple times it would. So I think it is quite fair to bring it up. https://ia.samaltman.com/ https://ia.samaltman.com/
- alfiedotwtf 2y agoYou do realise most cryptocurrencies aren’t PoW, so your point is living in the past, man!
- proxynoproxy 2y agoOnly the one big pow coin matters tho. Turns out, PoS coins are worthless! I also dislike energy frugality arguments. They come from a Luddite place. A civilization is defined by its energy usage. Let’s be advanced civilization.
- 2y ago
- lordnacho 2y agoI think it's harsh to start the accounting so soon after the breakthrough. Yes, of course AI uses a lot of energy. But we have to give it a bit of time to see if there are benefits that come with this cost. I think there will be. Whether the tradeoff was worthwhile, I think we are not even close to being able to conclude. Something like social media, which has a good long while behind it, I could accept if you started to close the book on the plus-minus.
- jebarker 2y agoYou can't have it both ways, i.e. deploy the technology as rapidly and widely as possible but then say you have to wait to do any accounting of the pros/cons.
- candiddevmike 2y agoSame arguments folks had with cryptocurrencies.
- breuleux 2y agoYou have to start the accounting immediately, because once a technology becomes entrenched, it's very difficult to backtrack. If it spins out of control and half of all energy is sunk into AI because half of services depend on it and workforces have been laid off, you won't be able to do anything about it without disrupting half of services. The window of opportunity to keep a technology in check, unfortunately, often occurs before the problems it causes become obvious.
- spyckie2 2y ago[flagged]
- roywiggins 2y agoSome iron age tech really was very nasty: https://www.science.org/content/article/ancient-romans-likely-breathed-lead-pollution https://www.science.org/content/article/ancient-romans-likel...
- frereubu 2y agoI see where you're coming from, but the planet was not on the verge of a climate breakdown at the time. I think that's the implicit context in the block post that your reply misses.
- roywiggins 2y agoThe marginal impact of AI on global climate probably rounds down to zero, or at least is not the thing driving us over the cliff: > Global energy consumption in 2023 was around 500,000 GWh per day. That means that ChatGPT’s global 3GWh per day is using 0.0006% of Earth’s energy demand. https://andymasley.substack.com/p/a-cheat-sheet-for-conversations-about?open=false https://andymasley.substack.com/p/a-cheat-sheet-for-conversa...
- frereubu 2y agoThat may be true, but I guess my approach to it would be that as a general principle we shouldn't be using things that increase energy usage for little real gain, and this is something that is in my professional field that I can do something about personally. It does come somewhat from a place of feeling like the world as a whole is absolutely failing to get to grips with the significant large-scale changes that are needed.
- roywiggins 2y agoa single hot shower uses more Watt-hours than most people spend on ChatGPT in a week, or a month. if people really want to cut down on how many watt-hours they're using on frivolous things there are dozens of things they should do first. if people are spending time worried about their ChatGPT energy use more than they are spending time going vegan or getting used to cold showers then they have been grossly misinformed about what the relative impact is (to be clear: I'm not vegan. but most people, incl. myself, could be quite easily, and it would save several orders of magnitude more energy and water)
- roywiggins 2y ago> Models require massive amounts of electricity and water (to cool servers). Does it? https://prospect.org/environment/2024-09-27-water-not-the-problem-artificial-intelligence/ https://prospect.org/environment/2024-09-27-water-not-the-pr... > training GPT-3 used as much water as just under twice what is required for the average American’s beef consumption. In other words, just two people swearing off beef would more than compensate. https://andymasley.substack.com/p/a-cheat-sheet-for-conversations-about https://andymasley.substack.com/p/a-cheat-sheet-for-conversa... > It would be a sad meaningless distraction for people who care about the climate to freak out about how often they use Google search. Imagine what your reaction would be to someone telling you they did ten Google searches. You should have the same reaction to someone telling you they prompted ChatGPT.
- perrygeo 2y agoI don't understand the "whatboutism" angle. Running LLMs requires massive amounts of electricity and water. Period. That beef consumption and other activities also require massive amounts of resources is independent. Both can be true. And both need to be addressed. We no longer have the luxury to pick and choose which climate interventions we find most convenient; we need to succeed on all fronts. If the patient is dehydrated and bleeding, do doctors sit around debating if they should give them water or gauze? No, they do both immediately.
- metalcrow 2y agoThey would if the patient is alive and fighting them! In our case, the patient is society and it is quite definitely not all unified that we cannot pick and choose. If the doctors want to save their patient, they either need to tie them down and do what is needed, or they need to work within the confines of what the patient allows while trying to convince them to allow more.
- dgb23 2y agoThe patient is kicking and screaming, because they are an addict. Regardless, I’m not convinced by the parent comment. It basically suggests we solve this without analysis of costs and effects. Sounds insane to me. Especially since the most promising solutions come from rapidly developing technologies and research. Turning off the lights just sends us backwards.
- acomjean 2y agoI think AI is interesting, but I wonder what it will do to progress when used very extensively. Trained on all the things/ideas of the past and creating a larger barrier of entry for new ideas. Thinking about new computer languages, who would use one that AI couldn’t help you code in?
- blizdiddy 2y agoWhen chatGPT came out, i thought we would stagnate with new languages, but not anymore. Now we have small models that can be fine tuned for less than $20 and we have huge models that can learn a new programming language in-context if you provide the docs.
- furbolapp 2y agoI think its the other way around, it wont create barriers instead it will focus on detecting/recognizing/aknowledging originality and new ideas
- _rpxpx 2y ago"I've never been so conflicted"? Err, where's the sense of conflict? All I see is: "it sucks, it's helping kill the planet, but I need a job."
- jebarker 2y ago> “If you’re going to use generative tools powered by large language models, don’t pretend you don’t know how your sausage is made.” This isn't a very hopeful quote given how many people continue to eat sausages even though we all know how sausages are made.
- staunton 2y ago> we all know how sausages are made. I'm doubtful. There's a few documentaries showing the process and I've had people tell me multiple times that they were genuinely shocked by it. I'm assuming those people "knew" and it's just that knowing "it's all the waste at the butcher getting stuffed into guts" is not quite the same as seeing it first hand.
- jebarker 2y agoI wasn't even really thinking of the actual sausage stuffing process so much as how the meat gets to the butcher (which is really a meat grinding factory in most cases) in the first place.
- raincole 2y agoAnd what happened after they told you they were shocked? Did they all become vegan once and for all?
- staunton 2y agoMost just expressed their shock (which didn't seem staged) but changed nothing. One person became vegetarian for about a year, then started to eat meat again. I'm not sure if they still eat sausages.
- mvdtnz 2y agoPeople get upset because we use every part of an animal for food? I think it's absolutely great. I am a meat-eater who doesn't feel ethically great about it, but I'd feel much worse if I knew a large percentage of a carcass went to waste.
- 2y ago
- JKCalhoun 2y ago> Firstly, there’s the environmental impact. Surely, like everything else in tech, this too shall pass. I expect power requirements to fall away since there is no doubt strong incentives to do so. > My naive optimism led me to believe that technology would help us fight climate change. Yeah, proceeding full steam ahead with planet destruction and praying tech will save us is kind of naive. You're not alone though. > There are also ethical concerns regarding the methods used to obtain data for training AI models. This one hasn't registered as problematic for me. Maybe I'm unethical? > Content creators can't even determine which parts of their work were used to train the model… "Content creators" don't develop their style from a vacuum either. I'm not conflicted about this one either. > LLMs are also contaminating the web with generic content produced without care or thought. The web has been contaminated ever since SEO. Maybe AI will kill the web. So it goes.
- BugsJustFindMe 2y ago> I expect power requirements to fall away This sounds extremely naive to my ears. Performance demands currently outpace resource utilization reductions and it's not clear that we're at the point where that will change soon. Also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox > > There are also ethical concerns regarding the methods used to obtain data for training AI models. > This one hasn't registered as problematic for me. Maybe I'm unethical? Yeah, the real ethical concern comes from the explosion of pernicious slop output that is utterly destroying everything good about the internet and media, not the training.
- pixl97 2y agoYou mean speeding up the destruction of the internet and media? The problem is it was falling apart before generative AI. This AI has just hastened its demise.
- BugsJustFindMe 2y agoSure, yes, but it has definitely gotten a lot worse.
- computerex 2y ago> AI and Crypto are net negatives in this regard. Not sure how anyone can with certainty say that AI will be a net negative in the long run for climate change. Logic I think says the opposite.
- candiddevmike 2y agoHow can AI be a net positive for climate change? We know what needs to happen to fix it, how would AI telling us the same thing "hit differently"?
- senordevnyc 2y agoMaybe AI will help us actually create or implement something that fixes it, instead of idealistic approaches that are never going to happen?
- philipkglass 2y agoThe cost of energy generated from burning fossil fuels is dominated by the cost of the fuel itself; the power plant costs much less. Non-combustion energy is the opposite: fuel costs are tiny or zero, so the construction cost for the initial plant is much more important. If you generate a terawatt hour of electricity with natural gas, most of the cost will be from the fuel. A nuclear plant will have a tiny fraction of the cost come from fuel for the same amount of energy. A solar farm will have none of the cost come from fuel. If AI lowers construction costs, it will improve the relative economics of non-fossil energy compared to fossil energy. A natural gas plant constructed at half the cost will have its final energy cost decrease just a little whereas a half-as-expensive solar farm will have its final energy cost decrease nearly by half. Making clean energy cheaper than fossils means that it will out-compete dirty energy even in locations where there are no explicit policies to reduce CO2 emissions. You can see the effects on pricing advantage with this interactive simulation of electricity supply in the United States. If you cut the overnight construction cost in half for all generating technologies, solar and wind dominate the country: https://calculators.energy.utexas.edu/lcoe_map/#/county/tech https://calculators.energy.utexas.edu/lcoe_map/#/county/tech Some example modeling of gas/solar electricity economics in the United Kingdom here: https://electrotechrevolution.substack.com/cp/160279905 https://electrotechrevolution.substack.com/cp/160279905 Companies have already started using robotics and AI to construct solar farms faster and at lower cost: https://www.aes.com/press-release/AES-Launches-First-AI-Enabled-Solar-Installation-Robot https://www.aes.com/press-release/AES-Launches-First-AI-Enab... https://cleantechnica.com/2025/02/27/leaptings-ai-powered-robot-is-transforming-solar-panel-installation-in-australia/ https://cleantechnica.com/2025/02/27/leaptings-ai-powered-ro... https://www.renewableenergyworld.com/solar/cool-solar-tech-whos-ready-for-ai-powered-construction-robots-and-quantum-dots/ https://www.renewableenergyworld.com/solar/cool-solar-tech-w...
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y ago> Sources used to train models are kept secret. I've been using Perplexity, and it annotates its recommendations, as to sources. Maybe it isn't very complete, though.
- olalonde 2y agoI guess it makes sense if you're genuinely worried about an imminent climate crisis. I am just not...
- teruakohatu 2y agoI feel the points made in this article have been debated many times on HN. The argument about power usage for developers, as opposed to consumers, is probably insignificant compared to the inefficient use of compute resources for deployed software today. Arguably LLMs are probably enabling some web developers to create native applications rather than Electron monstrosities saving many P-core CPU cycles multiplied by the number of their users. Optimising server applications with an LLM could eliminate unnecessary cloud servers. Of course all the above could be done without LLMs, but LLMs can empower people to do this kind of work when they were not able before.
- BeetleB 2y ago> The argument about power usage for developers, as opposed to consumers, Except with MCP, essentially most consumers will become "programmers". See my other comment for the rationale (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43997227 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43997227). (TLDR: MCP lets non-programmers convert their prompts into programs, for all practical purposes. Currently there is a barrier to entry to automate simple tasks: The need to learn programming. That barrier will go away)
- teruakohatu 2y ago> Except with MCP, essentially most consumers will become "programmers" You are more optimistic than I am. Most people I have seen are using LLMs are at best as an alternative to Grammarly or a document/web summary, or at worst making decision based on outdated LLM advice or as an inaccurate fact-engine. The average person could code using Excel, but most don't even if they know how to use IF() and VLOOKUP().
- BeetleB 2y agoThat's because most people don't have access to MCPs. It will take 1-2 years to hit critical mass - once it's easy to plug in to ChatGPT and once major companies (e.g. Google for Gmail) provide easy to configure MCP servers. > The average person could code using Excel, but most don't even if they know how to use IF() and VLOOKUP(). Using Excel (even without IF) is way more complicated than what I am saying. MCPs will enable people to program with natural language. It's not like vibe coding where the natural language will produce code we'll run. The prompt will be the program. You need to put in a lot more effort to learn the basics of Excel.
- raincole 2y agoI think it's just most programmers finally got the reality check: we're menial laborers, not superstars.
- BeetleB 2y agoThe environmental cost can't be overstated. When I AI code, it's more convenient for me to type in a prompt to change the name of a variable. This involves sending a request to the LLM provider, doing very expensive computations, and then doing a buggy job at it. Even though my IDE can do it for what 0.1% of the energy usage? Or even less? Try running an LLM locally on a CPU and you'll get a glimpse of how much energy it is using to do this simple task. But coding with AI isn't that huge. What will become huge this year or next is MCP. It will bring "programming" to the masses, all of whom will do stupid queries like the above. Consider this: I wrote an MCP server to fetch the weather forecast, and have separate tools to get a broad forecast, an hourly forecast, etc. I often want to check things like "I'm thinking of going to X tomorrow. It will be a bummer if it's cloudy. Which hours tomorrow have less than 50% cloud cover?" I could go to a weather web site, but that's more effort (lots of clicks to get to this detail). Way easier if I have a prompt ready. OK - that doesn't sound too bad. Now let's say I want to do this check daily. What you have to realize is that with MCP the prompt above is as good as a program! It's trivial for an average non-programmer to write that prompt and put it as part of a cron job, and have the LLM email/text you when the weather hits a predefined criteria. Consider emails. I sign up for deals from a retailer.[1] Now deals from them are a dime a dozen so I've been programmed to ignore those emails. But now with MCP, I can set a simple rule: Any email from that retailer goes to the LLM, and I've written a "program" that loosely describes what I think is a great deal, and let the LLM decide if it should notify me. Everyone will do this - no programming required! That prompt + cron is the program. Compared to traditional programming, this produces 100-1000x more CO2 emissions. And because there is no barrier to entry, easily 1000x more people will be doing programming than are doing now. So it's almost a millionfold in CO2 emissions for tasks like these. [1] OK, I don't do it, but most people do.
- elpocko 2y agoI would like to see a comparison of the amount of electrity used to run AI and the total electricity used to run computer games. I'm quite sure we're wasting much more resources on computer games, just for entertainment.
- _7acn 2y agoPlz don’t be conflicted. The Earth has an unlimited source of energy, the Sun, and water cannot be “saved” because our planet is a closed cycle.
- curtisszmania 2y ago[dead]