10 ms·
OpenAI's Stargate project struggling to get off the ground, due to tariffs
- toomuchtodo 2y agoRelated: SoftBank Stargate Venture With OpenAI Snags on Tariff Fears - https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-05-12/softbank-stargate-venture-with-openai-hits-snags-on-tariff-fears https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-05-12/softbank-... | https://archive.today/Vi5Gr https://archive.today/Vi5Gr - May 12th, 2025
- lenerdenator 2y agoIt's almost as if we shouldn't have one person arbitrarily raising taxes on a whim. Hell, it's almost as if taxation without the ability of the people being taxed to give their input on said taxation is the whole reason the US exists in the first place.
- exe34 2y ago[flagged]
- Etheryte 2y agoI hope you understand that this whole binary us versus them is a very large part of why many people voted for the government you guys have today. If you say everyone who doesn't vote like you want is a racist, that's bound to get a counter reaction. I'm European, so no horse in the race outside of the global economy.
- neilv 2y agoNot again already. We're still cleaning tea out of harbor here in Boston.
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoYou've had, like, a couple of centuries. I know that public works programs take time in Massachusetts, but...
- shadowgovt 2y agoThe resources were reallocated for the Big Dig.
- captainclam 2y agoSounds like there's not enough tax revenue!
- candiddevmike 2y agoI don't think that's tea
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sigmoid10 2y agoTbf, back then as well as now it's not like the average working class had any input. It's because a certain group of super-wealthy individuals wanted to become even more rich and thought that a radical change in governance might get them to pay fewer taxes. And to be honest, their chances originally looked much better with Trump than they did with George Washington.
- guywithahat 2y agoAlthough we don't have enough data to make a confident statement on the matter, it would seem election spending doesn't have a statistically significant impact on presidential elections https://thomashansen.xyz/blog/election-spending-isnt-statistically-significant.html https://thomashansen.xyz/blog/election-spending-isnt-statist...
- sigmoid10 2y agoThe existence of super-PACs invalidates any attempt like this to attribute finances to candidates. And they make up billions by now. It's essentially a loophole for the rich to funnel unlimited anonymous money to a campaign.
- briandear 2y agoDo other countries not have tariffs? Is it only when the U.S. chooses to retaliate that it enrages certain people?
- JohnFen 2y agoThis isn't the US "retaliating" (retaliating against what?). This is the US swinging a club in an attempt at beating up the rest of the world and hitting itself on its head.
- fragmede 2y agoYou mean the certain people that are affected by those tarrifs? How enraged do you get by something that doesn't affect you?
- jagged-chisel 2y agoIt’s not they exist. We’ve had tariffs. They’ve had tariffs. It’s raising them arbitrarily high on a whim - that’s the problem.
- gameman144 2y agoThe parent isn't objecting to tariffs, as far as I can tell. They're objecting that tariffs, which are a power vested in Congress, are being driven by one man (the President) in the executive branch.
- klipt 2y agoCongress has the ability to rein in presidential power. In extreme they can threaten impeachment. Republicans control Congress so they are complicit in what Trump is doing.
- gameman144 2y agoTotally, they have the ability to rein in the executive branch for sure! I think the parent's frustration is very justified (and might even be more valid -- there exists a clear path to not have tariffs imposed by edict, and our representatives just aren't taking it).
- fragmede 2y agoFun fact: That slogan is only half of the story. Smuggling was prolific in those days, with John Hancock and Samuel Adams were among them. They were involved with smuggling cheaper Dutch tea and the Sons of Liberty were protecting their own economic interests. Aka those taxes would ruin their smuggling business because the Tea Act of 1773 would let the British sell their tea for cheaper than the smugglers, and the protests were because that threatened their ability to sell their smuggled, but more expensive Dutch Tea.
- bloppe 2y agoI don't think it's called smuggling if you're paying taxes on it. If anything, actual smugglers would've supported the taxes because it gives them an edge over legal importers
- ceejayoz 2y agoThey weren't paying taxes on it. They worried the legal (and taxed, and higher quality) British tea would be, despite the tax, cheaper than the smuggled (untaxed) Dutch tea, which would destroy their smuggling businesses. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tea_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tea_Act > A related objective was to undercut the price of illegal tea, smuggled into Britain's North American colonies. > Reducing or eliminating the duties paid when the tea was landed in Britain (if it was shipped onward to the colonies) would further lower the final cost of tea in the colonies, undercutting the prices charged for smuggled tea. Colonists would willingly pay for cheaper Company tea, on which the Townshend tax was still collected, thus legitimizing Parliament's ability to tax the colonies.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 2y agoHow was smuggled tea more expensive? The shipping costs for both products would be the same (right?), so the price differentiator should be the presence/absence of additional government charges. Unless smuggled tea had to accept more losses due to…piracy?
- 2y ago
- guywithahat 2y agoThe phrase is "taxation without representation", and Trump is the representation. The original founders were upset England could raise taxes and they couldn't vote or do anything about it. We now have elected officials who decide taxes
- Gregaros 2y agogtfo. Nobody voted Trump to _raise_ taxes.
- klipt 2y agoIf republicans don't like Trump's behavior they should call their senators and tell them to threaten Trump with impeachment and conviction. That's the only leverage Congress has over the president. Republicans control Congress and the presidency, so there's nobody else to blame here.
- CamperBob2 2y agoThose who were paying attention the first time and still voted for Republicans voted for exactly that outcome (SALT, anyone?) Those who were not paying attention last time shouldn't have been allowed to vote this time, but... That Would be Bad, mmmkay.
- _1 2y agoCongress voted for him to do exactly that.
- autoexec 2y agoYes they did. He made it very clear that he wanted massive tariffs which by necessity would mean that people would have to pay massive taxes on everything they want to buy. Before the election experts were very clear that those tariffs would cost the consumer and importer. People were told that he wanted to go crazy with tariffs, they were repeatedly told that tariffs would take money out of their pockets, and they voted for that. Nobody should be surprised by that now.
- 2y ago
- madeofpalk 2y agoThe US did give their input. The US voted for Trump who explicitly campaigned on this. The people of the US got what they asked for.
- mikestew 2y agoThe US voted for Trump who explicitly campaigned on this. Campaigned on raising taxes? Not only would a citation be needed, I would defy you to find a single Trump voter who thinks taxes needed to be raised. This whole “it’s what people voted for” meme isn’t always an appropriate answer, and is many times just lazy commenting IMO.
- NeutralCrane 2y agoHe campaigned on tariffs, which are taxes.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoIn the first question of the debate, Harris pointed out that Trump's promises would increase taxes on the average American by $4000.
- no_wizard 2y agoNot taxes, tariffs - which is of course a tax - which the general public did not, by all available evidence, understand was a tax. Trump campaigned on raising tariffs quite heavily, and Trump voters by a wide margin really thought they were a good idea, largely because they didn't seem to actually understand how they work. I am left wondering if Trump fully understands how tariffs work. He spoke at length on multiple occasions about how other countries were going to pay for the tariffs, which runs entirely counter to what a tariff is. The only conclusion I can reasonably make from this is that Trump didn't understand tariffs either
- autoexec 2y ago> Not taxes, tariffs - which is of course a tax - which the general public did not, by all available evidence, understand was a tax. Experts were pretty clear in telling the public that it was a tax. The only people who can say they didn't understand that would have to be people who not only didn't know what tariffs were in the first place, but who also didn't bother to listen to the many many people trying their best to explain it to them. I'm 100% convinced that trump doesn't understand them and refused to listen to the many many people who have tried to explain it to him, which is why he had to suddenly start walking them back. Only his ego is getting in the way now.
- stuaxo 2y agoWasn't it just some rich people that didn't want to pay taxes ?
- bloppe 2y agoThat would be a strange motivation, since American colonists actually paid lower taxes than British citizens, until the American tax rate duly went up after the revolution.
- xyst 2y agoI didn’t vote for this cunt. But I am guessing the neoclassical/neoliberal economists here did because they aspire to be like Peter Thiel (who has backed Trump and GOP since forever). (( note it will _never_ happen and you folks vote against your own interests ))
- klaff 2y agoStargate wants to raise $500B not the paltry $500M as mentioned in the article.
- badFEengineer 2y agoStargate is $500 billion, not $500 million - surprised the article is off by a factor of 1000x
- 0cf8612b2e1e 2y agoIt’s such a ridiculous number that the author probably thought the source had the typo.
- jasonjmcghee 2y agoThe cynical part of me thinks it could be engagement bait. It's absolutely the type of typo someone would make in a tweet to help it go viral.
- tibbydudeza 2y agoMove it to Saudi HUMAIN ???. It will work out stunningly as NEOM :).
- neilv 2y agoBesides the tariffs added to buildout cost... > Investors are also growing wary of an overcapacity spike. As Bloomberg notes, tech giants including Microsoft and Amazon have adjusted their data center strategies, in some cases pulling back on construction projects. Is "overcapacity" concern here bundling up all the other effects of disruptions by the current administration? And are there significant concerns about Stargate and OpenAI specifically, separate from those traceable to the administration or economy?
- rsynnott 2y agoEven before Trump's trade war, there was some pullback there. I'd assume that some of the hyperscalers are just getting nervous that the bubble may have peaked.
- tim333 2y agoI think a lot of the concern is OpenAI and others have provided LLMs cheap or free which has led to a large take up and a lot of demand for data center capacity. But at some point they'll have to charge something related to their costs which would reduce demand a fair bit leading to overcapacity. I'm guessing it'll go something like the fiber build out in the dot com boom. Huge build out up to 2000 using investor money with losses on the business, 2000-2005 companies go bust, restructured, 2005 on something like equilibrium between cost and income.
- bigyabai 2y agoWho can act surprised? "Sparks of AGI" is what, 2 years old now? Meanwhile Masayoshi Son is promising AI "10,000 times smarter” than humans in a decade. It's a ruse by hardware manufacturers to bolster sales of niche IP. It's dumbfounding that corporate America, much less American politics, fell for the scheme. Projects like this serve to create unattainable goals that practically hand peer powers a victory. Not because these peers are more powerful, but because they can define what they want and work towards a real goal and not handwavy vaporware nonsense.
- horhay 2y agoThey're gonna say this at a time where people are starting to question how farther we can scale hardware with the scientific knowledge that we've had? It doesn't even take researchers to know that GPU capabilities aren't scaling as much as it used to. And then what's clearer lately is that it seems hardware scaling isn't helping AI companies as much as it used to anymore. Things that have so many question marks like that should be treated with a lot more pragmatism. But that's certainly not a language the Silicon Valley folks speak. Everybody's promising the next iPhone moment anytime they bring something out.
- lwansbrough 2y ago“I'm not going to agree with [Trump] on everything, but I think he will be incredible for the country in many ways!” - Altman Probably should have stuck to his guns on Trump. Trump, serial liar and king of fraud, lies to these guys one time and they spontaneously develop amnesia and praise him. Naive and hilarious.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- xnx 2y agoIs Stargate a real thing? I thought it was just a PR stunt.
- tim333 2y agoI think it was Altman trying it on a bit. Some tweets at the time https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1881944244480565497 https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1881944244480565497
- saubeidl 2y agoI can't help but think this fixation on ever-bigger data centers with ever-more compute is a very American approach. It's the same line of thought that gave us jumbo refrigerators, muscle cars and supersize meals. In the American mind, bigger = better. That that's not necessarily the best way to better results has been demonstrated by the Deepseek shock. I do wonder if more foundational research would be a better investment.
- courseofaction 2y agoBut those damnable universities are just left wing brainwashing facilities, very little room for profit there. Cut their funding, educated people don't vote right /s
- Closi 2y agoIt’s not an either/or - it can be both! If you have the best foundational research, but then find yourself blocked by compute, that’s a bad place to be in. At the moment compute is a constraint too (at least for the smaller shops, maybe not OpenAI!) We don’t necessarily know that the next AI breakthrough will need less compute either! A breakthrough that gives 5x performance for 20x training compute and 2x inference cost would still be a giant breakthrough and need a lot of hardware! Although this sort of breakthrough is unlikely, and it’s likely to be smaller steps forward - but I think it might be the case that models continue to get more computationally expensive even if there are breakthroughs that make models more efficient because we will want higher capability.
- saubeidl 2y agoI think it's often been shown that constraints are what brings out true breakthroughs, so I'm skeptical of scaling up throw brute force - to me it seems like a lazy way out that will prevent you from challenging your base assumptions and figuring out better ways of doing things.
- Closi 2y agoI think there is a world where you have both - a portion of research sitting under constraints, and also massive computing capability to help build the next big model. Put another way - I doubt OpenAI would have built GPT-3 faster if they had less compute.
- jsheard 2y agoI'm sure the tariffs don't help, but might the fact that they're asking for Half A Trillion United States Dollars also have something to do with it? They already had one of the biggest funding rounds in history and that was an order of magnitude smaller than this, now we're talking about capital on the scale of upper-end national GDPs for a company which still isn't profitable and has no real moat to speak of. They may as well cut to the chase and ask for all of the money in the world.
- spiderfarmer 2y agoDeepseek was one nail in the coffin. The tariffs the second. More will follow.
- tccuuchffhfu 2y ago[dead]
- captainclam 2y agoTo be clear, I'm pretty sure the half-trillion figure is the projected combined investment between SoftBank, OpenAI, Oracle, and MGX. Not public, US tax-payer dollars. If that's not what you meant my apologies. Reason I'm quick to point this out is I think some of the writing/headlines around are suggestive of this misconception.
- mvdtnz 2y agoNo one said anything about taxpayer dollars in this thread until you.
- tim333 2y ago>They may as well cut to the chase and ask for all of the money in the world Sam Altman was going around the middle east last year seeing if he could get $7tn. I'm a believer in AI but I don't think giving all the money to Altman is the way to do it.
- ashvardanian 2y ago> Per an analysis by TD Cowen cited by Bloomberg, hiked prices for server racks, cooling systems, chips, and other components could contribute to overall build cost rises of 5-15% on average. I can agree that infrastructure generally has much lower margins than software businesses, but I don't know of any mega-projects that wouldn't turn out costlier during construction, and 15% is hardly something that stopped them.
- mmastrac 2y agoWe, as in the rest of the world, need to get off our butts and take advantage of this self-own, forced-error of a presidency. It's the perfect time to build industry outside of the USA which has shown itself to be a bad partner, unreliable and willing to turn on all of us in the span of a few weeks in order to right perceived wrongs that may or may not exist (more likely the latter than former).
- qoez 2y agoIn the EU it just feels like big beaurocracy gets to make all the big decisions about doing things like this and small and medium orgs can't spring up to go against stumbling entities like this because we're taxed out of the wealth needed to do so.
- saubeidl 2y ago[dead]
- spiderfarmer 2y agoI don’t agree with this sentiment. Over the past few years I’ve seen a lot of companies switch to EU based alternatives already because of the data regulations. This is a second wave. And now nobody trusts the US anymore the rest will follow.
- crop_rotation 2y agoWhat switches have you seen. Very curious to know what EU based alternatives are gaining steam.
- bilbo0s 2y agoNot really. There's plenty of wealth in the EU. What they don't have is an appetite for risk. You could lower taxes to zero, but you'd still not get the level of speculative investment in the US without cultivating a much larger appetite for risk. Similar issue exists in places like Japan. Investor classes that are, at the median, more conservative than they are in the US. So in the US we "lose" bigger, but we also "win" bigger. (Of course all of this was pre-Trump. Now, I'm not sure there is enough certainty out there for even the big risk takers. But, historically, we in the US have been more risk-phillic.)
- UrineSqueegee 2y ago>Tariffs *could* greatly increase the cost of data center buildouts So this article is just karma farming on the DT hate?
- meta_ai_x 2y ago100%. If you combine the massive AI-hate with irrational DJT hate you'll get articles exactly like this. Unfortunately, many of self-proclaimed intelligent beings fall for this. (FWIW, I oppose a lot of DJT initiatives/behavior, but I hope it is rational criticisms)
- nottorp 2y agoWhat would they have said if they didn't have tariffs to blame?
- renewiltord 2y agoBro, it's $500 billion not $500 million. $500 million is very easy to invest. That's not Stargate - that's IncandescentBulbGate. https://openai.com/index/announcing-the-stargate-project/ https://openai.com/index/announcing-the-stargate-project/ Trying to get a journalist to understand numbers is like teaching a rock calculus.
- aresant 2y agoThis is a techcrunch link arbitrage to the actual article if we can update https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-05-12/softbank-stargate-venture-with-openai-hits-snags-on-tariff-fears?embedded-checkout=true https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-05-12/softbank-...
- nerevarthelame 2y agoIt's notable that while the initial announcement promised an "immediate" investment of $100 billion, nearly 4 months later SoftBank "has yet to develop a financing template or begin detailed discussions with potential backers." I'm sure tariffs are partly to blame, but it seems criminally misleading to be nowhere near ready to provide that $100 billion.
- rurp 2y agoI for one am shocked shocked that a big investment deal announced by this administration turned out to be vastly overhyped.
- steveBK123 2y agoStuff like this is a reminder that none of this is strategic and well thought out. It's just reactive, tactical, lurching from one self made crisis to the next. From doubling down to then folding on his own unilaterally imposed tariff levels while getting nothing in return.. it's all reaction. If it was well thought out we wouldn't be tariffing intermediary goods and inputs to domestic production. If any of this sticks at anything like the levels imposed, we will have shortages and job losses more than we have any impactful move of manufacturing jobs back to US>
- buyucu 2y agoOpenAI is stuggling in general. They no longer have any technological edge over competitors.
- new_user_final 2y agoElon musk can contribute 400 Billion alone, maybe whole 500 billion by the time it is completed (joking). It is ridiculous how rich people's money are just show off like their lifestyle.
- 93po 2y agoAm I the only one that finds reporting annoying when they boldly imply things as fact, and the source is anonymous "people familiar with the matter"? We have no way to assign the probability or legitimacy of these opinions when zero information is provided on who these people are, how biased they are, and how much they actually know the industry and space and complexities of all the moving parts. You could write literally any article and literally any headline if that's your source. You can find every single variation of opinions and facts depending on who you ask, and they can all still be "familiar with the matter". I feel like this is the basis for most political or politically adjacent journalism these days.