10 ms·
Avoiding AI is hard – but our freedom to opt out must be protected
- lacker 2y agoI think most people who want to "opt out of AI" don't actually understand where AI is used. Every Google search uses AI, even the ones that don't show an "AI panel" at the top. Every iOS spellcheck uses AI. Every time you send an email or make a non-cryptocurrency electronic payment, you're relying on an AI that verifies that your transaction is legitimate. I imagine the author would respond, "That's not what I mean!" Well, they should figure out what they actually mean.
- leereeves 2y agoI imagine the author would respond: "That's what I said" "Opting out of AI is no simple matter. AI powers essential systems such as healthcare, transport and finance. It also influences hiring decisions, rental applications, loans, credit scoring, social media feeds, government services and even what news or information we see when we search online."
- mistrial9 2y agotech people often refer to politicians as somehow dumb, but big AI safety legislation two years ago on both sides of the North Atlantic, deeply dives into exactly this as "safety" for the general public.
- Robotbeat 2y agoOkay, then I guess they’ll agree to paying more for those services since they’ll cost more to deal with someone’s boutique Amistics.
- codr7 2y agoIf I was given the choice, I would without exception pay more for non-AI service.
- Gigachad 2y agoSome businesses have done similar. Some banks in Australia announced they will be charging a fee for withdrawing cash at the counter rather than at ATMs, other businesses charge fees for receiving communications by letter rather than email.
- codr7 2y agoAs long as there's a choice it allows the market to influence decisions. The big issue is forcing AI down everyone's throat without being the least concerned about their experience.
- lacker 2y agoIt's not even about paying more. Think of email. Every time you send an email, there's an AI that scans it for spam. How could there be a system that lets you opt out, but keep sending email? Obviously all the spammers would love to opt out of spam filtering, if they could. The system just fundamentally does not work without AI. To opt out of AI, you will have to stop sending email. And using credit cards. And doing Google searches. Etc etc etc...
- tkellogg 2y agoSomewhere in 2024 I noticed that "AI" shifted to no longer include "machine learning" and is now closer to "GenAI" but still bigger than that. It was never a strict definition, and was always shifting, but it made a big shift last year to no longer include classical ML. Even fairly technical people recognize the shift.
- JackeJR 2y agoIt swings both ways. In some circles, logistic regression is AI, in others, only AGI is AI.
- jedbrown 2y agoThe colloquial definitions have always been more cultural than technical, but it's become more acute recently. > I think we should shed the idea that AI is a technological artifact with political features and recognize it as a political artifact through and through. AI is an ideological project to shift authority and autonomy away from individuals, towards centralized structures of power. https://ali-alkhatib.com/blog/defining-ai https://ali-alkhatib.com/blog/defining-ai
- poslathian 2y agoI’ve worked in this field for 20+ years and as far as I can tell the only consistent colloquial definition of AI is “things lay people are surprised a computer can do right now”
- mjburgess 2y agoAI has always been a marketing term for computer science research -- right from the inception. It's a sin of academia, not the public.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoAs if anyone in the public cared about marketing for CS research. Hardly anyone is even exposed to it. AI in the public mind comes from science fiction, and it means the same thing it meant for the past 5+ decades: a machine that presents recognizable characteristics of a thinking person - some story-specific combination of being as smart (or much smarter) than people in a broad (if limited) set of domains and activities, and having the ability (or at least giving impression of it) to autonomously set goals based on its own value system. That is the "AI" general population experiences - a sci-fi trope, not tech industry marketing.
- drivingmenuts 2y agoI'm just not sure I see where AI has made my search results better or more reliable. And until it can be proven that those results are better, I'm going to remain skeptical. I'm not even sure what form that proof would take. I do know that I can tolerate non-deterministic behavior from a human, but having computers demonstrate non-deterministic behavior is, to me, a violation of the purpose for which we build computers.
- simonw 2y ago"I'm just not sure I see where AI has made my search results better or more reliable." Did you prefer Google search results ten years ago? Those were still using all manner of machine learning algorithms, which is what we used to call "AI".
- lacker 2y agoEven 20 years ago, it wasn't using AI for the core algorithm, but for plenty of subsystems, like (IIRC) spellchecking, language classification, and spam detection.
- danielmarkbruce 2y ago[flagged]
- drivingmenuts 2y agoSure, but at least with encryption, someone can demonstrate how the result was reached, since the result is based on a formula. With AI, people seem perfectly happy to be building a black box and just hoping for good result. We also don't abdicate our decision-making to encryption processes.
- danielmarkbruce 2y agoRead a little bit about key generation. We abdicate decision making to random processes in many places. Quant finance, all kinds of physical processes simulation and optimization where decisions are made in real time by systems (like oil refineries). And really, AI models are only black boxes in the aggregate. You can go through and understand every single calculation. You can understand it in training (except perhaps at initialization), you can understand it in inference (except perhaps if you want to use randomness in sampling). I'd suggest that Google Search pre-ML was a black box in the aggregate too... no one could really understand it all.
- simonw 2y agoCame here to say exactly that. The use of "AI" as a weird, all-encompassing boogeyman is a big part of the problem here - it's quickly growing to mean "any form of technology that I don't like or don't understand" for a growing number of people. The author of this piece made no attempt at all to define what "AI" they were talking about here, which I think was irresponsible of them.
- BlueTemplar 2y agoYes, yet another example why the word 'AI' should be tabooed : use 'machine', 'software', "software using neural networks" (or another specific term) instead.
- djoldman 2y ago> Imagine applying for a job, only to find out that an algorithm powered by artificial intelligence (AI) rejected your resume before a human even saw it. Or imagine visiting a doctor where treatment options are chosen by a machine you can’t question. I wonder when/if the opposite will be as much of an article hook: "Imagine applying for a job, only to find out that a human rejected your resume before an algorithm powered by artificial intelligence (AI) even saw it. Or imagine visiting a doctor where treatment options are chosen by a human you can’t question." The implicit assumption is that it's preferred that humans do the work. In the first case, probably most would assume an AI is... ruthless? biased? Both exist for humans too. Not that the current state of AI resume processing is necessarily "good". In the second, I don't understand as no competent licensed doctor chooses the treatment options (absent an emergency); they presumably know the only reasonable options, discuss them with the patient, answer questions, and the patient chooses.
- leereeves 2y ago> In the second, I don't understand as no competent licensed doctor chooses the treatment options (absent an emergency); they presumably know the only reasonable options, discuss them with the patient, answer questions, and the patient chooses. I wish that were the case, but in my experience it is not. Every time I've seen a doctor, they offered only one medication, unless I requested a different one.
- linsomniac 2y ago>they offered only one medication I've had a few doctors offer me alternatives and talk through the options, which I'll agree is rare. It sure has been nice when it happened. One time I did push back on one of the doctor's recommendations: I was with my mom and the doctor said he was going to prescribe some medication. I said "I presume you're already aware of this but she's been on that before and reacted poorly to it and we took her off it because of that. The doctor was NOT aware of that and prescribed something else. I sure was glad to be there and be able to catch that.
- zdragnar 2y agoThere's a few possible reasons this can happen. First is that the side effect profile of one option is much better known or tolerated, so the doctor will default to it. Second is that the doctor knows the insurance company / government plan will require attempting to treat a condition with a standard cheaper treatment before they will pay for the newer, more expensive option. There's always the third case where the doctor is overworked, lazy or prideful and doesn't consider the patient may have some input on which treatment they would like, since they didn't go to medical school and what would they know anyway?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- daft_pink 2y agoi’m not sure it’s just code. it’s just an algorithm similar to any other algorithm. i’m not sure that you can opt out of algorithms.
- mianos 2y agoUsing a poem from 1897 to illustrate why AI will be out of control? The web site name is very accurate. That's sure to start a conversation.
- jackvalentine 2y agoYou’re probably more familiar with the poem as depicted in Fantasia. https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x620yq4 https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x620yq4
- Bjartr 2y ago> Imagine applying for a job, only to find out that an algorithm powered by artificial intelligence (AI) rejected your resume before a human even saw it The article says this like it's a new problem. Automated resume screening is a long established practice at this point. That it'll be some LLM doing the screening instead of a keyword matcher doesn't change much. Although, it could be argued that an LLM would better approximate an actual human looking at the resume... including all the biases. It's not like companies take responsibility for such automated systems today. I think they're used partly for liability cya anyway. The fewer actual employees that look at resumes, the fewer that can screw up and expose the company to a lawsuit. An algorithm can screw up too of course, but it's a lot harder to show intent, which can affect the damages awarded I think. Of course IANAL, so this could be entirely wrong. Interesting to think about though.
- GeorgeCurtis 2y ago> It also influences hiring decisions, rental applications, loans, credit scoring, social media feeds, government services and even what news or information we see when we search online. I think, more frighteningly, the potential for it to make decisions on insurance claims and medical care.
- danielmarkbruce 2y agoThere is an underlying assumption there that is certainly incorrect. So many stupid comments about AI boil down to "humans are incredibly good at X, we can't risk having AI do it". Humans are bad at all manner of things. There are all kinds of bad human decisions being made in insurance, health care, construction, investing, everywhere. It's one big joke to suggest we are good at all this stuff.
- chii 2y agoThe fear is that by delegating to an ai, there's no recourse if the outcome for the person is undesirable (correctly or not). What is needed from the AI is a trace/line-of-reasoning to which a decision is derived. Like a court judgement, which has explanations attached. This should be available (or be made as part of the decision documentation).
- roxolotl 2y agoReminds me of the wonderful Onion piece about a Google Opt Out Village. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lMChO0qNbkY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lMChO0qNbkY I appreciate the frustration that, if not quite yet, it’ll be near impossible to live a normal life without having exposure to GenAI systems. Of course as others say here, and the date on the Onion piece shows, it’s not sadly not a new concern.
- AiSparky 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- plsbenice34 2y agoI can't even reply to your comment without my words being stolen and used to train "AI". I have no option to opt out. So you will only get this chilled response.
- jkuli 2y ago[flagged]
- yoko888 2y ago[dead]
- chii 2y ago> silence is interpreted as consent silence is indeed concent (of the status quo). You need to vote with your wallet, personal choice and such - if you want to be comfortable, choosing the status quo is the way, and thus consent. There's no possibility of a world where you get to remain comfortable, but still get to have a "choice" to dictate a choice contrary to the status quo.
- yoko888 2y ago[dead]
- BlueTemplar 2y agoQuite a lot of people try(ied) to buy it with blood and still fail(ed) : https://samzdat.com/2017/06/01/the-meridian-of-her-greatness/ https://samzdat.com/2017/06/01/the-meridian-of-her-greatness... (Note how depending how one (mis)reads what you wrote, this is human nature, and there no escaping it, and you would likely be miserable if you tried.)
- yoko888 2y ago[dead]
- hedora 2y agoMaybe people will finally realize that allowing companies to gather private information without permission is a bad idea, and should be banned. Such information is already used against everyone multiple times a day. On the other hand, blocking training on published information doesn’t make sense: If you don’t want your stuff to be read, don’t publish it! This tradeoff has basically nothing to do with recent advances in AI though. Also, with the current performance trends in LLMs, we seem very close to being able to run models locally. That’ll blow up a lot of the most abusive business models in this space. On a related note, if AI decreases the number of mistakes my doctor makes, that seems like a win to me. If the AI then sold my medical file (or used it in some other revenue generating way), that’d be unethical and wrong. Current health care systems already do that without permission and it’s legal. Fix that problem instead.
- heavyset_go 2y ago> On the other hand, blocking training on published information doesn’t make sense: If you don’t want your stuff to be read, don’t publish it! There's a difference between reading something and ripping it off, no matter how you launder it.
- MoltenMan 2y agoI think the line is actually much blurrier than it might seem. Realistically everything is a remix of things people have done before; almost nothing is truly brand new. So why specifically are people allowed to build on humanity's past achievements, but not AI?
- chii 2y ago> So why specifically are people allowed to build on humanity's past achievements, but not AI? because those people seem to think that individuals building it will be too small a scale to be commercially profitable (and thus the publisher is OK to have them be a form of social credit/portfolio building). As soon as it is made clear that these published data can be monetized (if only by large corporations with money), they want a piece of the pie that they think they deserve (and not getting).
- jkuli 2y ago[flagged]
- Lirael 2y ago[dead]
- curtisszmania 2y ago[dead]
- Imnimo 2y agoThis is going to end with me having to click another GDPR-style banner on every website, isn't it?
- lokar 2y agoThey include no functional definition of what counts as AI. Without that the whole thing is just noise
- Nasrudith 2y agoThis seems like one of those 'my personal neurosis deserve to be treated like a societal problem' articles. I've seen the exact same sort of thing when complaining about inability to opt out of being advertised to.
- JimDabell 2y agoArticle 22 of the GDPR already addresses this, you have the right to human intervention.
- beloch 2y ago>* "AI decision making also needs to be more transparent. Whether it’s automated hiring, healthcare or financial services, AI should be understandable, accountable and open to scrutiny." You can't simply look at a LLM's code and determine if, for example, it has racial biases. This is very similar to a human. You can't look inside someone's brain to see if they're racist. You can only respond to what they do. If a human does something unethical or criminal, companies take steps to counter that behaviour which may include removing the human from their position. If an AI is found to be doing something wrong, one company might choose to patch it or replace it with something else, but will other companies do the same? Will they even be alerted to the problem? One human can only do so much harm. The harm a faulty AI can do potentially scales to the size of their install base. Perhaps, in this sense, AI's need to be treated like humans while accounting for scale. If an AI does something unethical/criminal, it should be "recalled". i.e. Taken off the job everywhere until it can be demonstrated the behaviour has been corrected. It is not acceptable for a company, when alerted to a problem with an AI they're using, to say, "Well, it hasn't done anything wrong here yet."
- amelius 2y agoThe question I have is: should an AI company be allowed to push updates without testing by an independent party (e.g. in self driving cars)?
- BlueTemplar 2y agoNot sure why you used the example of a human when those actually have legal responsibility and, as you suggest, are unique ? Rather, why would LLMs be treated any differently from other machines ? Mass recall of flawed machines (if dangerous enough) is common after all.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 2y agoWhy even look at the LLM? A human deployed it and defers to its advice for decision-making; the problem is in the decision-making process, which is in full control of the human. It should be obvious how to regulate that: be critical of what the human behind the LLM does.
- caseyy 2y agoYou can’t outlaw being an asshole. You can’t outlaw being belligerent. And you can’t outlaw being a belligerent asshole with AI. There isn’t a question of “should we”. We have no means, as things stand. Our intellectual property, privacy, and consumer protection laws were all tested by LLM tech, and they failed the test. Same as with social media — with proof it has caused genocides and suicides, and common sense saying it’s responsible for an epidemic of anxiety and depression, we have failed to stop its unethical advance. The only wining move is to not play the game and go offline. Hope you weren’t looking to date, socialize, bank, get a ride, order food at restaurants, and do other things, because that has all moved online and is behind a cookie warning saying “We Care About Your Privacy” and listing 1899 ad partners the service will tell your behavioral measurements to for future behavior manipulation. Don’t worry, it’s “legitimate interest”. Then it will send an email to your inbox that will do the same, and it will have a tracking pixel so a mailing list company can get a piece of that action. We are debating what parts of the torment nexus should or shouldn’t be allowed, while being tormented from every direction. It’s actually getting very ridiculous how too little too late it is. But I don’t think humanity has a spine to say enough is enough. There are large parts of humanity that like and justify their own abuse, too. They would kiss the ground their abusers walk on. It is the end stage of corporate neo-liberalism. Something that could have worked out very well in theory if we didn’t become mindless fanatics[0] of it. Maybe with a little bit more hustle we can seed, scale and monetize ethics and morals. Then with a great IPO and an AI-first strategy, we could grow golden virtue retention in the short and long-run… [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33668502 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33668502
- tim333 2y agoThe trouble with his examples of doctors or employers using AI is it's not really about him opting out, it's about forcing others, the doctors and employers, not to use AI which will be tricky.
- bamboozled 2y agoIt's absolutely never going to happen...there I said it.
- simonw 2y agoThere's a larger context here which is really interesting: as far as I can tell (and I'd love to hear confirmation from people more credible than me) the way LLMs and other models train on unlicensed data is NOT legal under current UK copyright law. The UK government and trying to make it legal, presumably for concern over staying competitive in this rapidly growing space. Baroness Kidron, mentioned in this story, is the leading figure in UK parliament who is pushing back against this.
- ilteris 2y agoDo you think our freedom to opt out from electricity protected?