10 ms·
Deafening Silence from the Cybersecurity Industry
- Spooky23 2y agoDuh. There’s cash to be grabbed.
- begueradj 2y agoIf they don't shout to defend you, they're happy about what happened to you (perhaps that's because you made lots of enemies)
- hobs 2y agoThere's two options, either they are fools to believe it is a good thing (and they should not be in security) or they are cowards because they think the same fate will befall them.
- qiqitori 2y ago[flagged]
- _cenw 2y agoMy experience is that everyone who's not close to any of these impacts is apathetic or treating events like they're reality TV, and even light attempts at convincing that there's more going on and that we might be in a historic and bad situation is met with hostility as if you just told someone's small kid that Santa isn't real. At best they care about the financial parts of the news.
- i80and 2y agoPeople only caring about immediate financial impacts is so deeply disheartening
- bognition 2y agoWelcome to America where the only God is the greenback
- phkahler 2y agoI see that as a broad trend. Very very few people have guiding principles these days. The "problem" with principles is that living by them sometimes means going against something we want right now. People don't want to concede anything, even for their own ideals.
- ramesh31 2y ago>People don't want to concede anything, even for their own ideals. People cannot concede anything anymore. We are all trapped in survival mode at this point.
- lukan 2y agoIn true survival mode, you likely would not hang out around here.
- ramesh31 2y agoThe people who hang out here are the lucky 90th percentile of our society that are just barely able to tread water at this point. Everyone else is drowning. Try to imagine living on $60k, then think about the fact that that’s a good salary to a majority of US workers.
- CalRobert 2y agoSome of us are scared shitless but have been called hysterical for years. Some of us emigrated.
- throwaway984393 2y ago[flagged]
- ndsipa_pomu 2y agoIt might be wiser to emigrate if you cannot trust your fellow citizens and neighbours to care about your country becoming fascist. If you've got brown skin, then you'd be better off leaving on your own terms rather than being exported to a concentration camp in El Salvador.
- markbnj 2y agoLike using a throwaway account to accuse someone of cowardice.
- myvoiceismypass 2y agoAnd Congress is full of cowards afraid to offend their god-king.
- roenxi 2y ago[flagged]
- _cenw 2y ago
- pjmlp 2y agoWhen events aren't taken seriously, eventually "Then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak for me" There is still time to react, in a year from now it will be like something like McCarthy, only worse.
- belorn 2y agoPolitics and media has for the last two decades been operated on generating engagement through outrage, and it seems that we have arrived at the peak of what that model was able to do, with a very sharp decline into apathy. More outrage will not convince people to care. Even the financial parts had very limited impact towards political engagement.
- ethbr1 2y agoA related change on the people's part has been decreased understanding of how to leverage their own political power. Congress-critters are concerned about losing reelection. (And of being primaried even in safe districts) Yet the minification of attention spans has confused the average American voter that they're impotent, when really they're just lazy, ignorant, and unwilling to muster real-world action. When's the last time you saw someone pepper a House district with self-made signs? There are things every single person can do, but just doesn't. And because of this, media has been able to turn political engagement into profitable passive consumption.
- ryandrake 2y ago> When's the last time you saw someone pepper a House district with self-made signs? Never, because it would be totally ineffective. Incumbents in Congress have about a 95% win rate[1]. For almost everywhere in the country, districts are what they are and no amount of hand drawn signs are going to change it. 1: https://ballotpedia.org/Election_results,_2024:_Incumbent_win_rates_by_state https://ballotpedia.org/Election_results,_2024:_Incumbent_wi...
- ethbr1 2y agoConsidering only ~50% of federal legislature primaries and ~16% of state legislature were contested [0], that 97% incumbent win rate looks less impressive. Primaries are the place to beat candidates in most districts. [0] https://ballotpedia.org/Primary_election_competitiveness_in_state_and_federal_government,_2024 https://ballotpedia.org/Primary_election_competitiveness_in_...
- 2y ago
- Noumenon72 2y agoDeafening silence about what the executive order actually says or any facts about the case.
- smallmancontrov 2y agoNo, the article sums it up correctly. He refused to go along with the "stolen election" narrative Trump was trying to build (and a few others) and is now being punished for it. > Krebs, through CISA, falsely and baselessly denied that the 2020 election was rigged and stolen, including by inappropriately and categorically dismissing widespread election malfeasance and serious vulnerabilities with voting machines https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/04/addressing-risks-from-chris-krebs-and-government-censorship/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/04/addr...
- ripe 2y agoThank you for posting the link. Should have been part of the article. WTF? Black is white, and white is black.
- meltyness 2y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20250130231413/https://www.cisa.gov/topics/election-security/rumor-vs-reality https://web.archive.org/web/20250130231413/https://www.cisa.... Here's an article supposedly of Krebs provenance, which implicitly lumps Trump himself in as a "malicious actor". > can lead to uncertainty in the minds of voters; uncertainty that can be exploited by malicious actors Maybe not something I would want said or repeated by my administration either, disregarding the veracity. There's no date or byline either, so according to the authoritative FAQ, if this were to stand, it would be an admission of acting in bad faith. Given federal government communications sprawl, it's quite a needle, pretty good performance in my opinion to root this out, disregarding sowing doubt about a federated election and who's will specifically it should / will service. Voter inclusion (who should / may vote) is itself at issue, but even in the assessment here given DOGE findings unveils possible oversights, FWAB in the FAQ is cited to depend in part on SSNs and in light of the DOGE findings regarding 150+ year olds collecting social security, the security assessment itself does not describe a system that is definitively air-tight, or even terribly reassuring, if there's doubt in your mind about who voted, and how.
- anovikov 2y agoThese days it does not matter anymore if something is legal or not. Which may be bad news for the tech industry actually, because it's all about valuations, and valuations suffer if property rights are not guaranteed.
- jonahbenton 2y agoThe silence from cybersec, with a couple of exceptions, about DOGE is stunning to me. Not this story but what I thought the headline referred to.
- ragazzina 2y ago>what I thought the headline referred to. I thought the same. https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1913023007263543565.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1913023007263543565.html
- shlip 2y agoIs this discussed on HN ? Edit: Yep, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43691142 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43691142
- specialp 2y agoYou see this in other areas too like academia being afraid they will get the ire of the administration and lose money. For a lot of firms they don't want to suddenly get their government contracts dropped by speaking out. This is how things slowly become more authoritarian, and freedom of speech dies. This is also why the gradual expansion of executive power was not good. If the threat of financial loss stops people from criticizing actions, imagine what it would be like if you would be investigated and jailed on sham charges like in some other countries.
- trw_speech 2y ago[flagged]
- shadowgovt 2y agoWhen did the Obama or Biden administrations cut university funding due to their speech policies?
- specialp 2y ago
- nonrandomstring 2y agoWe are not "silent", we're just not being heard. Those are not the same things. You'll find plenty of critique and analysis, anticipating and commenting on the unfolding cybsersecurity calamity [0,1,2] ... [0] https://www.schneier.com/ https://www.schneier.com/ [1] https://cybershow.uk/blog/ https://cybershow.uk/blog/ [2]https://www.dataandpolitics.net/trump-is-a-critical-vulnerability https://www.dataandpolitics.net/trump-is-a-critical-vulnerab... When those who own and control the means of discourse are donors to, and so in collusion with the problem, don't expect to hear opposition.
- rbanffy 2y ago> [2]https://www.dataandpolitics.net/trump-is-a-critical-vulnerab https://www.dataandpolitics.net/trump-is-a-critical-vulnerab... Is CVE-47 taken?
- keyringlight 2y agoAnother one [0] SpyCast - DOGE Layoffs and the Counterintelligence Threats They Pose Also on their podcast RSS, but it seems they haven't added a webpage to link to for that individual show [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=foLsTVQwBIg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=foLsTVQwBIg
- akuchling 2y agoAlso Violet Blue's weekly cybersecurity roundups: the most recent is https://www.patreon.com/posts/cybersecurity-15-126689368 https://www.patreon.com/posts/cybersecurity-15-126689368 .
- ripe 2y agoThe administration needs to be sued in court. What else can be done? This is awful.
- rbanffy 2y agoWould that still work? It seems the administration can safely ignore court orders.
- bambax 2y ago> What else can be done? Civil war. It will probably have to come to this, some day or other.
- deadbabe 2y agoIf you’re not willing to pick up arms and fight, chances are no one else is, so it will never happen. Most likely nothing can be done and people will just live under a totalitarian fascist regime for the duration of their lives. Keep talking about civil war, you’ll be imprisoned and silenced. You should delete your post.
- jasonjayr 2y agoThey should NOT delete their post. Do not comply in advance.
- deadbabe 2y agoDo NOT resist compliance unless you’re willing to go all the way with it. It’s not worth losing your comfortable life.
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoDoes "Give me liberty or give me death" ring a bell? But yeah, actually meaning that is harder than saying it.
- 2y ago
- derriz 2y agoIt seems that the idea that someone could be motivated simply by having integrity, valuing honesty and pride in simply "doing their job" correctly is so alien to the current US administration that they see political motives everywhere and in everyone's actions. The fact that people with such a cynical and amoral worldview wield so much power not only in US but globally and are willing to wield that power in capricious and petty ways is deeply upsetting. But what is more horrifying for me is that apparently this administration remains representative of a large section of the US population - with seemingly unshakeable approval by between 40% and 50% of the US adult population according to polls. I love the US, have friends and family there, have a first cousin in the marines, grandfather born there, etc., and have visited many many times and just find it difficult to reconcile my positive experiences with the place and people with the idea that more than 4 out of 10 US adults could approve of the cruel and vindictive actions of this administration. I'm not being over dramatic by stating that it has genuinely shaken my world-view and belief in the innate goodness of humanity.
- pm90 2y agoTo a certain extent this is a result of living in a media ecosystem where most of the population doesn’t actually see an unbiased reporting of facts but whatever is shown to them by certain right wing news networks. But I do agree at some point people need to take responsibility for their information diet. Fwiw media manipulation of American opinion isn’t new, its been a huge part of how America works since at least the Spanish American war of 1896.
- LastTrain 2y agoThere is no such thing as unbiased reporting of facts. People not understanding that, and the fact that there is nothing inherently wrong with bias, is a big part of the problem.
- sheepdestroyer 2y agoObjective reality, it exists. Telling your audience obviously false / anti-factual lies, without any regard for fact checking, is not just "biased reporting". And it is inherently wrong, malevolent, evil. Anyway, I'm amazed each time I hear right wingers who did not get the joke seemingly complaining about how Reality has a left leaning political bias...
- kayo_20211030 2y agoThe second line of the EO. > Yet in recent years, elitist leaders in Government have unlawfully censored speech and weaponized their undeserved influence to silence perceived political opponents and advance their preferred, and often erroneous, narrative about significant matters of public debate Isn't the executive a branch of government? Physician, heal thyself.
- mikeyouse 2y agoIt seems to be a feature of this type of brain dead odious politics to revel in the hypocrisy. Reminded also of the Harvard EO that simultaneously decried their DEI efforts and hiring/admissions not based on merit and then demanding that every department install a bunch of conservatives.. https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/4/15/agencies-demands-to-harvard/ https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/4/15/agencies-demand...
- mindslight 2y agoPlease stop calling them "conservatives". The term is a dishonest cover that they shouldn't have been able to continue hiding behind after they openly put themselves at odds with our society's institutions during the first Trump term. As a libertarian who didn't particularly love the status quo, I held my nose and voted actually conservative in 2024 - that was Harris/Walz. The new radical Republican party is free to come up with a new label that accurately describes the goals of their movement. Until then I propose we just use maggots, fascists, or destructionists, which capture the only consistent values I've been able to discern.
- seethishat 2y agoIf I have not seen evidence for or against something, then I would not offer an opinion either. Sometimes, people speak confidently when they are ignorant of the context and the facts. That's not the right thing to do. It's better not to say anything when you don't actually know what you are talking about.
- hobs 2y agoDid you watch the TV on Jan 6? Did you hear Trump repeatedly lie about the election? Are you saying your eyes and ears were lying to you? What are you saying here - that unless you walk around the barn all four sides might not be red? You are not a perfect witness, you are reporting on the most obvious fact of the matter.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y agoWhat does that have to do with anything? We're up to our neck in evidence.
- elicksaur 2y agoThis is interesting when you run it up the abstraction ladder. What if we take this perspective from “knowledge of news topic of the day” and apply it to “knowledge of the virtue of commenting on a topic”. Are you qualified to actually speak on that subject? Am I? Maybe best not to say anything, since I’m not sure.
- EasyMark 2y agoThey are actively attacking free speech right now with colleges, dem states are threatened if they don't follow MAGA doctrine, same with cities, Trump threatens law firms who worked against him in the past. People elected him to lower prices and have business friendly policies, not to wreck our reputation in the world and cause the next great depression. You should be looking for new news stories I think. They are constantly calling our elections as fake and full of fraud when in truth we have some of the most secure elections in the world.
- everdrive 2y agoMy impression is that the first Trump presidency left everyone at a loss. If you react with outrage, you're labeled in some negative way. This is really an extension of online trolling, where any emotional reaction proves that you "lost." Everyone has a chance to speak up now, but this actually diminishes the power of everyone's voice. You're one drop in a few billion or a few hundred million now. And to the extent that you do speak up, it's fully partisan; the complaints of "the other side" are never heard nor granted legitimacy. I imagine there are people who would call this cynical and defeatist, but I think often people speaking up is purely counter-productive these days. So many attempts to speak up are just yet another partisan volley which can be written off on partisan grounds alone. Worse, given the way that social media works, the worst and most extreme voices from your faction will be the ones which get the most attention. They will paint your entire faction, and from a public opinion perspective, people will view your side as being far more extreme than it might actually be. I think people have a model in their head of the civil rights movement, and they think that protest alone will be successful just like it once was. It's not clear to me that protest, in and of itself, actually does much these days. Trump seems to enjoy seeing his ideological opponents outraged, and his supporters are either cowed towards him, if not far more vindictive than the man himself. Maybe it's just because I keep seeing the mindless noise from the internet, but real push-back here requires a centralized and most importantly, a focused movement. One that doesn't just incorporate the most extreme policy positions from its wings, and understands how to build a broad coalition. It's something people have forgotten how to do. It might be trite to blame social media, but no one seems to understand how to build a broad coalition in the way that Dr. King did during the civil rights movement. Movements these days tend to exclude, rather than include, and tend to be led by radicals and extremists, which defeat the cause they claim to fight for.
- phirschybar 2y agothis sums up the situation eloquently and perfectly
- lordgrenville 2y agoGreat comment, articulates something I've been feeling lately but didn't quite have the words for. (Not American, but similar situation in my country.) Where do we go from here? What kind of action would be effective?
- cyrnel 2y agoI think this article describes the issue well: https://crankysec.com/blog/community/ https://crankysec.com/blog/community/ > All the cybersecurity companies saying "We don't have anything to say about this situation." is just them being true to their main in-group: for-profit companies that don't want to upset a big current or potential buyer. They are, first and foremost, part of that "community", and they happen to be involved in cybersecurity. Solidarity is happening there, just not to the people in cybersecurity. This sucks and we should change it for sure. So many other industries have successfully become professionalized, unionized, and kicked the grifters to the curb. But it feels more and more like the cybersecurity grifters are the ones holding the reins.
- sylens 2y agoSilence from companies in terms of press releases and official statements, maybe. But almost everyone I know in the industry is somewhere between concerned and outraged over this. Another shining example in the first few months of this administration of how we should not defer leadership to private industry, because they will always be motivated by preserving their bottom line.
- QuietWatchtower 2y agoI've had the same experience about people in the industry being concerned. But private company heads are well aware of what's happening to the folks that have crossed Trump before or recently. Such as Harvard, state of Maine, the law firms strong armed to doing pro-bono. Anyone surprised that the greedy executives at the top don't care if anything were to happen to Chris Krebs, Brian Krebs, Bruce Schneier, etc. under this admin is naive to this new dynamic. Nonetheless, it's disgusting to see.
- Lerc 2y agoFirst they came for the Communists and I did not speak out because I fear they cannot be stopped They will come for more speaking out makes you their next target
- bigolkevin 2y agoBeing their next target is inevitable. Their greed has no bounds. Will you be a silent victim or will you resist? Will you fight back now, when you have more potential allies, or later, when so many have already been erased?
- Lerc 2y agoIt's not something that I necessarily agree with. Just a thought that came into my head when thinking about the "What would I have done?" scenario. Perhaps an alternate form might be --- First they came for the Communists and I did not speak out because they will be coming for people like me If I speak out, they will find me. --- The intuition that I think it expresses is that perhaps people stay silent more from fear than disinterest.
- jillyboel 2y agodead link, it's just a blank page in both chrome & firefox
- ANarrativeApe 2y ago"The Constitution explicitly forbids Congress from issuing bills of attainder—laws that single out individuals for punishment without trial. While that restriction technically applies to the Legislative branch, the spirit of it clearly applies here. A president cannot simply declare someone an enemy of the state for contradicting a political narrative. That’s not national security—it’s authoritarianism, dressed up in executive language." So the Constitution does not forbid it. All executive orders, it could be argued, are authoritarian, not just the ones that you happen to dislike. The moral? Be damned careful to whom you give this authority.
- aqme28 2y agoWell the way it should work is that executive orders are not laws and should not be treated as such. They’re supposed to be memos about how executive agencies should interpret the law. Somehow though, as congress has languished they’ve been accruing more and more power
- pclmulqdq 2y agoCongress largely relinquished that power by creating bills that establish rule-making executive agencies rather than writing the rules themselves. That leaves congresspeople free to do things like trade stocks and raise money for their respective parties. They claim they would be too busy to read all the rules they would have to pass, but (1) that's the point and (2) they pass massive bills they don't read anyway. This version of America is fundamentally broken, but it seems to be the nash equilibrium of the system given greedy congrespeople and a greedy executive.
- danaris 2y agoNo, that's bullshit. Requiring Congress to get involved every time a regulatory agency needs to adapt to new circumstances or new technology would leave us at the mercy of unscrupulous corporations who can and will "move fast and break things." No; Congress relinquished their power when Congressional Republicans chose to become "the party of No" and just prevent anything from happening under Obama. That's when executive orders started to become much more common.
- few 2y agohttps://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/04/addressing-risks-from-chris-krebs-and-government-censorship/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/04/addr... https://www.whitehouse.gov/fact-sheets/2025/04/fact-sheet-president-donald-j-trump-addresses-risks-from-chris-krebs-and-government-censorship/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/fact-sheets/2025/04/fact-sheet-pr... >Krebs ... falsely and baselessly denied that the 2020 election was rigged and stolen This quote coming from "whitehouse.gov/fact-sheets" is pretty wild. This seems to be retribution, plain and simple.
- evanjrowley 2y ago[flagged]
- _cenw 2y agoThis guy? https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/internet/michael-benz-rising-voice-conservative-criticism-online-censorship-rcna119213 https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/internet/michael-benz-rising-vo...
- jasonlotito 2y agoSo, I saw evanjrowley's post before it was flagged, and did my own research, following what his links said, to the sources they linked. Simply put, evanjrowley's links are lies. The Kreb's specific claims are lies. They link to sources that are carefully edited, and even then, it's clear that is being presented by evanjrowley's sites is not what is being said. Simply put, evanjrowley is trying to spread disinformation.
- evanjrowley 2y ago[flagged]
- ndsipa_pomu 2y ago> This seems to be retribution, plain and simple. It's hardly surprising as it's almost the defining feature of Trump - pettiness and revenge minded. (though strangely, he hasn't publicly insulted his Pennsylvania would-be-assassin, but luckily his ear has healed remarkably well and so maybe he feels no need to do so)
- Dildonics4All 2y ago[flagged]
- eutropia 2y agoThat's not the fucking point! The dude is being retaliated against for doing his job and reporting facts that contradict an authoritarian conspiracy; regardless of your personal opinion of the man - this is, like so many other egregious abuses of power this admin has done, an illegal and flagrant abuse of power.
- Dildonics4All 2y ago[flagged]
- markus_zhang 2y agoI don't even know the impact of that...but I agree this government is, how should I put it, not very stable.
- aaron695 2y ago[flagged]
- alabastervlog 2y ago> When you can never ever win, when you will always be called a Nazi, why would you bother? Why... would you bother not supporting fascists and not agreeing with fascist ideas? Is this a real example of the "I wish you weren't making me do this..." comic?
- mapt 2y agoPer yesterday's whistleblower, DOGE is apparently exfiltrating confidential NLRB data en masse while explicitly seeking to leave no logs of them doing so, followed immediately by login attempts to those systems using the same freshly created credentials from Russian IPs. I think we can presume the same pattern with IRS, Census, GSA, OPM, etc that just have not had whistleblower-inclined people in the right place to observe. Espionage shit.
- mkleczek 2y agoLooks like we all have to start believing unbelievable: agent Krasnov is real and the tip of an iceberg. Honestly I can't see any other rational explanation of what's happening.
- gorbachev 2y agoTrump's entire 2nd term is about settling scores. He's set up his entire administration to get back at everyone who slighted him in some way over the past few decades, but especially in 2020. This is what happens when a felon gets to be the president.
- jjani 2y agoMost of this was written by an LLM, with the writer doing post-editing. Susprised not to see any other comments on this yet! That doesn't mean it's a bad piece, I think it's a good writeup.
- fazeirony 2y ago> Many organizations seem to believe they can sidestep this conflict by remaining neutral. you can't be neutral on a moving train. if you think it is bad now, and this will 'blow over,' history is there to prove you wrong.
- nopcode 2y agoOriginal article is removed? https://archive.ph/aylYu https://archive.ph/aylYu
- fosco 2y agoWhy was original article removed?
- afitnerd 2y agoIt looks like the original article has been taken down. https://web.archive.org/web/20250418112529/https://www.forbes.com/sites/tonybradley/2025/04/16/deafening-silence-from-the-cybersecurity-industry/ https://web.archive.org/web/20250418112529/https://www.forbe...