6 ms·
Tracking types of non-parents in the United States
- PaulKeeble 2y agoInteresting data showing a trend of less people wanting children at all. What I want is the reasoning for not wanting children broken down, that is the crux of the issue and while its good to see a breakdown to the barriers for those wanting children I feel like the not wanting isn't as simple as just no.
- dijksterhuis 2y agoUK survey five years ago - https://yougov.co.uk/society/articles/25364-why-are-britons-choosing-not-have-children https://yougov.co.uk/society/articles/25364-why-are-britons-... top 5 ranked > too old > don’t want lifestyle changes > too expensive > overpopulation > don’t like children more recently, but free text answers classified by ML model (which seems to removes some nuance in the categories) - https://yougov.co.uk/society/articles/51749-why-do-some-britons-not-want-children https://yougov.co.uk/society/articles/51749-why-do-some-brit...
- like_any_other 2y agoOverpopulation concern is the funniest one of all for the UK: Why Britain needs more migrants - It cannot fix its population-growth slowdown without them - https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2022/01/14/why-britain-needs-more-migrants https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2022/01/14/why-brit... Britain ‘must rely on immigration’ to compensate for falling birth rate - https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2025/03/26/rise-in-older-mothers-means-britain-must-rely-on-migration/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2025/03/26/rise-in-olde... UK will be reliant on immigration for nearly 80 years due to falling birth rates - https://www.independent.co.uk/world/population-fertility-immigration-uk-b2516198.html https://www.independent.co.uk/world/population-fertility-imm... Birth rates in the UK are now, according to the ONS, at their lowest levels since records began in 1938, at a rate of 1.44 children per woman. With a rapidly ageing population, migrants will be essential to replace UK-born workers - https://www.tradeandbusiness.uk/news/six-reasons-why-the-uk-needs-immigration https://www.tradeandbusiness.uk/news/six-reasons-why-the-uk-... It's like an iterated prisoner's dilemma, but one prisoner refuses to defect or learn anything, despite the other constantly defecting.
- dijksterhuis 2y agoas someone who squarely falls into the “probably don’t want kids because of overpopulation” category — i get the irony you’re trying to point out. but global overpopulation is not the same as national overpopulation. at some point we’re gonna run out of fucking food as a species. * the sooner we can get our heads out of our arses and past the primitive tribalism of “we need to have more than the other lot” as a species, the better. i squarely fall into the “migration is the solution, not the problem” camp too [0]. exactly because of that global perspective. plenty of people in the world. maybe it’s time we learned to share as a species? although fuck all chance of that happening any time soon in the current political climate. * someone usually attempts a retort about “technology will magically save all of us” to this point. which is just kicking the can down the road. [0]: edit to note that the problem i’m referring to here is national underpopulation specifically
- oezi 2y agoSome problems need tackling at the right time. We don't need to get too crazy about declining populations when we are facing more urgent issues. Maybe the world in 2050 will be so different that the issue has resolved itself. Always remember that the world was fine with 2bn people just 100 years ago.
- dijksterhuis 2y ago> Always remember that the world was fine with 2bn people just 100 years ago. we’ve gone from ~2 billion to ~8 billion in 100 years. compared to the (highly estimated) figures from before 100 years ago — that’s a massive increase. the graph is basically a line going straight up compared to the rest of (highly estimated) population data for the last 10k years. and growth is continuing. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/population https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/population > Maybe the world in 2050 will be so different that the issue has resolved itself “maybe a miracle might happen” — is just kicking the can down the road in my book. we are out of balance with our surrounding environment. there will be a readjustment — whether we choose to make that readjustment ourselves (take responsibility for the problem), or let the readjustment happen (the problem really becomes a problem), is up to us as a species. > Some problems need tackling at the right time. some problems take a really long time and a lot of effort to work on so maybe starting to work on them early and proactively might be a good idea. like climate change. > We don't need to get too crazy about declining populations when we are facing more urgent issues. speaking of climate change, global overpopulation kinda has an impact on it! more people -> use more resources -> screwing up the planet faster
- gaiagraphia 2y agoLeft high school in the UK thinking that anything connected with family and having children was some type of carnal sin. Seemed the idea of anything traditional was an aboslute taboo to most of the staff. When I compare schooling experiences to people from other countries, it seemed everything was so negative and guilt-ridden in comparison.
- PaulHoule 2y agoBy the way people respond you'd think that the mainstream thinks natalism is the ultimate squick.
- trollbridge 2y agoThis is definitely a belief system isolated to certain social classes. Lots of other classes of people thinking having children is great, love going to children's birthday parties, get excited when a relative is expecting a baby, and so forth.
- apwell23 2y agoyou are assuming that people who have them are making conscious choice to have them. I live in india and everyone here has them by default, there is no flowchart with a diamond. its just something ppl do, like going to the bathroom. in the west answer is that there are more forms of entertainment and fulfillment available now and there is actually a flowchart with diamond in it.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoEven in India, there increasing proportions of adults with no children. It happens everywhere where women gain economic and social freedom. https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/ind/india/fertility-rate https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/ind/ind... https://www.niussp.org/fertility-and-reproduction/increasing-childlessness-driven-by-higher-female-education-in-india/ https://www.niussp.org/fertility-and-reproduction/increasing...
- apwell23 2y ago> Even in India, there are more and more who choose to have fewer, and sometimes no children. thank god!! its suffocating over here. curious why do you think women have gained economic and social freedom in india?
- lotsofpulp 2y agoBecause they have? Gained doesn’t mean they are completely at par with men. But many have increased their agency relative to women in India in decades past. Many can now get an education, have their own income, live by themselves. Not all, obviously a few hundred million are still probably not close to economic freedom, but more are than before.
- apwell23 2y agosure but how did you relate that to birthrates. did you correlate any datapoints to make that hypothesis about india? like did you look up who many women voluntarily 'live by themselves' in india ?
- msteffen 2y agoI think it’s self-sustaining, in that the needs of people without kids and the needs of people with kids are super duper different. If all your friends don’t have kids and you do, you feel ostracized because they’re not going to rearrange their life over your kids, and you’re constrained by your kids’ schedules (particularly sleep), so you just don’t see them that much anymore. Conversely, if all your friends have kids and you don’t, most of their socializing will probably feel really alien to you (unless you’re a teacher or something and work with kids), so you’ll feel disconnected from them. Anecdotally, in my friend group, once the first two people had kids and started hanging out with each other, it was like the flood gates opened.
- Cyphase 2y agoFor anyone who doesn't want to enable cookies to view the page, here's the PDF: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/jomf.13097 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/jomf.1...
- seydor 2y agoThe rest of the developed world is far more advanced in demographic decline, but it surprises me that we don't see this kind of statistics from other countries. In southern europe, i have not seen diligent and in-depth surveys about demographic trends. The public policy measures taken are crude, handwavy and populist measures which mostly fail
- j_bum 2y agoThe redistribution of “child free” & “not yet parent” from 2017-2023 is massive… a shift of over 10%. I see this anecdotally in my Gen Z/Millenial friend groups, but the numbers backing the observation up is wild. But frankly, I understand it. One of our main pain points for not having kids yet is the cost of childcare (US). That’s not getting better anytime soon, either, from what I can tell.
- croemer 2y agoAs your comment is a bit ambiguous, the figure shows around 10% more people not wanting kids now than 6y earlier.
- api 2y agoEconomically housing costs are huge, because as soon as you have kids you really start to want more stability and space. Small apartment hopping is easy and even kind of fun when you have no kids but things change dramatically when kids arrive.
- bananalychee 2y agoIs the cost of child care a cause, or is it a symptom of a deeper problem? The decline in the fertility rate is not an isolated phenomenon, and it spans many disparate cultures. I know this opens a can of worms, but perhaps we should be more open to the idea that maximizing the labor force participation of both sexes by outsourcing child-rearing is a suicidal model. It manifests as a gradual change in behaviors that we, in our hyper-individualistic society, tend to attribute to personal choice, but I don't think so many people would go "child-free" if we didn't frame child-rearing as a low-value trap that isn't worth sacrificing a professional career over. The supply constraint is a consequence of that value shift.
- watwut 2y ago> if we didn't frame child-rearing as a low-value trap that isn't worth sacrificing a professional career over. In reality, it makes you dependent, very vulnerable and poor. The think is, it is not just value shift, it is women making active decisions so that they life does not become very bad.
- wonderwonder 2y agoDifferent but related topic, Hungary has recently moved forward with a program reducing the tax burden of mothers up to I believe exemption from income taxes for life for those that have 3 or more kids. This seems to be a pretty solid idea with so many people putting off having children due to the associated costs.
- mtndew4brkfst 2y agoOn the face of it that sounds like childless taxpayers of all varieties subsidizing people who have many children. That's a "solid idea"?
- svnt 2y agoIf you want a country in the future, yes.
- mtndew4brkfst 2y agoThe actual existential threat to my own country has little to do with how many children people have or what their personal tax burden is.
- mtndew4brkfst 2y agoWell, I guess a lot of the threat is to do with the children and tax burden of one specific man...
- svnt 2y agoThis has no relevance to whether fertility rates below replacement can end a country.
- BobaFloutist 2y agoGod forbid we relax immigration laws
- 2y ago
- TrackerFF 2y agoI've noticed that for my class (I'm pushing 40), people either got kids when they were 16-20, or well after 30. Something like one third of our class had their first child around age 32-35...lots of COVID children! In our case, there's a pretty clear divide between those that went straight to the workforce after HS, and those that pursued college/university, and typical professional jobs. With the latter being those that become parents late. Those that I still know very close, and have been in the same situation, have all told the same story: - Studied for 5 years to get a masters degree - Worked for some years, until they found their career job - Wanted to travel and focus on themselves, now being more financially secure and having more spare time to do so. And suddenly they were 30. - Spent some time finding a partner they wanted children with. Spent a year or two doing couples stuff, before a kid would take up all their time. And that's pretty much how you end up as a first-time parent almost in your mid 30s. Another observation is that around half of the guys have still not had any children, while around 75% of the women have become parents.
- lordnacho 2y agoI've made similar observations. One of my classmates didn't go the academic route. She has a 25 year old kid now. The others, one had a kid late 20s. Most of the class was mid to late 30s. Several had their first kid past 40. Only two had more than two kids, but they were a couple who met in school. Nobody has four kids. There's still only one person who has an adult (18+) kid.
- npc_anon 2y agoThere was an interesting study earlier this week that is essential to this discussion. I'm afraid I don't have the link but the gist was that most couples do ultimately want and have children. Slightly too less for population replacement but still. However, the far more alarming issue is the lack of couples. Couple forming is falling off a cliff.