8 ms·
Why Tap a Wheel of Cheese?
- JoeAltmaier 2y agoWill an AI be able to do this too? Probably. Hey! I don't think it's a good idea. But if it's cheap and effective, guess how long it will take?
- mano78 2y agoNot even an AI, there are simpler ways. But as an italian, I will be in the pitchforks-armed horrified mob if this will be proposed. Not a chance.
- chuckadams 2y agoPresumably the mob would be armed with little hammers.
- alwa 2y agoTechnically? Not long. Socially and politically? My money’s on the battitore.
- maxbond 2y agoIt's been possible to automate this job away for decades, with no AI necessary. You could image these cheese wheels with ultrasound or X-rays and establish thresholds for the size of voids which are tolerable. This must be a concern wherever parts are cast, so surely there are off the shelf solutions. Presumably this isn't news to the relevant parties and they value having human battitores over the savings.
- pvg 2y agoThe 'savings' could also take an unreasonably long time to realize. The capital outlay is not small (the scanning machines, their maintenance, still need humans to categorize the cheeses) and artisanal cheese probably isn't all that high-volume a business nor is it particularly bound by precision and tight tolerances - it can matter a lot that some doodad that goes into a machine is defect free, less so with a hunk of cheese.
- Ekaros 2y agoML algorithm probably could do parts of the job. The tap and sound. But there is most likely also large amount general QA of environment going on. Are things done right, is temperature right, is humidity right, is there weird touch. And so on. All of this is much harder to understand and gather under scope of AI... Lot of it is likely not even conscious...
- dfxm12 2y agoJust like people sometimes question the human element in judging sports, I wonder if there are cheesemakers who think these guys are simply against them or favorable to their neighbors. One thing I've also wondered about this process. When I buy Parmigiano Reggiano, it's just sold as "Parmigiano Reggiano". There's no discernable branding beyond that (compared to the Pecorino Romano I buy, which has "Locatelli" plastered all over it). Is this true all over? Do any HNers seek out Parmigiano Reggiano from their favorite dairy?
- lores 2y agoFrom what I understand, all parmigiano is sold through a consortium/coop. The only dairy identifying mark is three digits stencilled onto the rind. https://www.parmigianoreggiano.com/product-guide-seals-and-marks https://www.parmigianoreggiano.com/product-guide-seals-and-m...
- zeitg3ist 2y agoIf you buy it vacuum-sealed from a shop, the packaging usually has additional branding from the producer. Not a "favorite dairy", but if it's convenient to do so, I usually look for the "vacche rosse" type, which is more expensive but also noticeably different (and better). Of course it would be a waste to grate it over pasta; better to eat it on its own.
- darkwater 2y agoVacche rosse 24 months and a glass of red wine, you just made me salivate. The 36 months is too strong in my opinion, still delicious but I like the 24 more.
- SamBam 2y agoI am glad that this continues to be done by hand, and expect, based on Italian attitudes towards food and tradition, that it will continue being done by hand for another hundred years. It is interesting how important it seems to us that jobs like this remain done in the traditional way. For all their expertise, I am sure a technical solution would also easily be able to detect what they are looking for: voids within the cheese, or lack of uniform density. This does not seem to be a case where the human expertise and artistry is actually important to the final product, besides the feeling of tradition. Perhaps the best argument for keeping traditional jobs like this is that, even if that exact job could be done by machine, replacing these humans with machines would be the start of a short process that would end up with indistrially-produced bad cheese.
- BobaFloutist 2y agoThe problem is it's actually a super fun thought experiment/engineering problem to try to figure out how to do this technologically, but any such attempt would (rightly) be taken as an attack on this profession because even if it was a silly blog post about overthinking a silly problem, silly blogposts are potentially upstream of (maybe even someone else) a commercial implementation that eventually destroys a profession. It sucks.
- thierrydamiba 2y agoDo professions really get destroyed? Or does the world just change? I used to get paid to do OCR on tax forms. I used n gram models, BERT,etc and it took weeks to get the forms right. Now you can do it in seconds with an api. I wouldn’t say the profession got destroyed. I just work with different tools now. Instead of running ngrams, I’m testing different apis or embedding models. The old job doesn’t exist anymore, in many ways I am the classic example of losing your job to AI-but I wouldn’t say it destroyed the profession. People just use different tools today to get intelligence from PDFs.
- woah 2y agoThere’s no course to learn the niche skills and nuances of this trade; Alessandro accompanied and apprenticed with Renato and other experts for about 3 years, learning through firsthand experience how to assess each form. “The particularity of this profession to me is that it’s like it was 2 years ago, and it’s a skill that’s handed down from dev to dev. You go around with the most expert, most experienced BERTitori, and you watch and listen to them, and slowly they start to give you the keyboard. You try with them next to you, piano piano, and gradually, you begin to do more on your own,” explained Stocchi. “It’s a big responsibility, you have to be really capable of doing it, you can’t damage the forms.”
- dr_dshiv 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 2y agoThe website makes me think they want lots of money. It's as if they are saying leave the cheese to the experts. As a hacker I wonder how much of that is true.
- tecleandor 2y agoIf you want to see it in action: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8Zg3nAtyDc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8Zg3nAtyDc
- jtbayly 2y agoThanks. I almost missed this because I searched the comment page for “video” so I’m mentioning video here so others can find it. :)
- 1970-01-01 2y agoTLDR: The Italian way of doing acoustic, non-destructive testing of a material. This is also done in many other things such as pipelines, chairlifts, and welded metals or machines that have pre-recorded acoustic signatures or sound recordings. Hit it with a hammer, listen to the tone. If it sounds very different, inspect or reject.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thenthenthen 2y agoWhy not!
- nancyminusone 2y agoI saw a How it's Made episode about cheeses like this the other day. They mix the ingredients in a giant electric mixer - but dump them in by hand. The inspection is still done by ear with a hammer - but when then need to flip the wheels over every few weeks they have a robot grabber thing do it. Obviously, there's some balance in technology that is about right, but where do you draw the line? Because this could absolutely be done fully by hand or fully autonomously. The episode after that showed a machine to milk cows which was fully automated with no human involvement at all!
- alnwlsn 2y agoThis reminds me of a news piece from my area about 10 years ago. A field was to be mowed, and they were considering options. They could get some high tech self guided lawn mower, or they could let a herd of goats graze on it. They went with the goats. It did not go over well with the former lawn mower operators, who found themselves no more employed than they would have been if the robotic lawn mower took their job instead.
- bluGill 2y agoWith goats someone has to fix the fence, apply vaccines, and lots of other labor. Not as much as a lawn mower operator though.
- some_random 2y agoMaybe there were indeed more jobs created by using the goats, but those jobs were likely filled by people other than the human lawn mowers.
- bluGill 2y agothe problem with automating inspections is humans are good at noticing things that are 'different'. I can make a machine see the common wrong things but if I miss one rare situation that passes bad product. many farmers don't use automated milking machines because you still need a human to inspect each cow and thus the machine doesn't save much labor.
- taxicabjesus 2y agoThere was a time when I was consuming a lot of industrial cheese. I developed a rash on my legs... One day I realized the rash was certainly being caused by my cheap cheese habit. I'm certain it was related to the "vegetarian enzymes" used as an industrial substitute for the traditional animal rennet. I stopped buying the cheap cheese, and my rash went away. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rennet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rennet Contaminants are a common problem in industrial food manufacturing: citric acid (fungal contaminants), vitamin C (heavy metals), and "enzymes" (?). I'm glad Italians insist their cheeses be made following the traditional methods.
- lblume 2y ago> I'm certain it was related to the "vegetarian enzymes" How can you be so certain? I did not find any credible source correlating microbial rennet to rash. Thus I would not rule out that this was simply a coincidence or at least not applicable for most people.
- antisthenes 2y ago> How can you be so certain? "Vibe diagnosing"
- usepgp 2y agoVibagnosis
- blahaj 2y ago[dead]
- BenjiWiebe 2y agoMaybe it was an allergic reaction to the mold inhibitor? Vegetarian rennet and animal rennet are both chymosin.
- ziofill 2y agoProbably I'm biased because I'm Italian and I grew up eating them, but Parmigiano Reggiano and Grana Padano are hands down the best cheeses there can be. Many people know and consume them only grated on pasta dishes, but they are especially delicious on their own with some good bread or grilled polenta. Also, the crust can be chopped up and added to risotto (as you're cooking it) and they turn into wonderful little chewy chunks.
- qwertox 2y agoI absolutely love them. I don't like how it melts on pasta, so I eat it directly.
- hk__2 2y agoI can’t really rate cheeses on a scale; A 36-months comté or emmental has very different flavours from a 36-months Parmigiano and I wouldn’t rate one "better" than the other. Like any good cheese, I agree that Parmigiano Reggiano is best eaten on its own. I’m French and something that surprise me is that both Italy and France have very good cheeses, but only in France we eat cheese on its own as part of the meal: the traditional French meal is: starter / main plate / cheese (sometimes with salad) / dessert. In Italian restaurants you sometimes find them as antipasti, but not always, and (at least in my experience) at home people don’t really eat cheese on its own.
- thierrydamiba 2y agoWhy do you think this happens? In America eating cheese by itself is usually seen as a very fancy activity. I can’t think of the last time I had a spread of just cheese in the US, and it was probably a fancy place.
- mauvehaus 2y agoThe Co-op food stores in Hanover and Lebanon NH did a March madness cheese bracket. We hosted a small bracket party with a selection of unfamiliar cheeses for friends to try while filling out our brackets. It was weirdly fancy (eating good cheese), and weirdly not (I don't think of March madness brackets as a particularly refined thing). It was all delicious though!
- talkingtab 2y agoCheese, not the kind that comes in plastic bags, is incredibly cool and delicious. It is nothing like what most people think of as cheese. There are some youtube videos about people making artisanal cheeses: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vM102CO8JL0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vM102CO8JL0 and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ImpROVueIcE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ImpROVueIcE Kids! Do this at home!!! I've been making cheese at home for the last year. It is hard - but not as hard as programming and tastes much, much, better.
- globular-toast 2y agoWhat do you do with the whey? I make paneer at home and use the whey to make chapati (bread).
- saltcured 2y agoI'm wondering if I remember an urban legend or other apocryphal story. From the headline, I immediately thought of an answer I swear I learned about in some machine learning class years ago. People were struggling with a food inspection device that tapped (cheese? fruit?) like this, trying to emulate what a human expert did. The punchline was that the human expert didn't really know how to articulate their decision either, and it wasn't listening to the drumming sounds at all, but merely dispersing some odors to do a better sniff test.
- kulahan 2y agoAlmost sounds like it’s related to some fermented product, so it wouldn’t surprise me if it was indeed cheese. I don’t think scent is great for much besides checking current state.
- kazinator 2y agoThis is like if Toyota were to announce that for each shipping car, they kick all the tires, slam the doors, and honk the horn. It is probably just a joke for show and to fool naive competition. Behind closed doors, they must do some actual quality tests.
- verelo 2y agoMy 100% favourite part of this write up is the mention of "piano piano". In 2018 i was renovating my house in Little Italy Toronto (Canada). There was this 91 year old Italian woman, Assunta, living alone in the house next to mine. She was always curious (or nosey?), but only spoke Italian, so we struggled to communicate. She would always say in broken English encouraging statements like "You make it nice", "lot of work, you do so good" to which I would say "thanks" and often talk about the amount of work ahead of me. She would always follow up with "eh, piano piano...". I had no idea what she meant until one day I Googled this term and i learnt it essentially means "slowly slowly" or "take it slowly". Assunta is gone now, but she was a lovable character. I think my dog misses her treats, and I miss the snacks she would bring me when I was working on the house.
- ggambetta 2y ago"Piano piano" does mean "slowly slowly" in a literal way, but I guess she meant it as a reference of the full saying "piano piano si va lontano", meaning "slowly slowly you get far". You were commenting on the amount of work ahead, and she was telling you "it's a marathon, not a sprint".
- jacobgkau 2y agoIt's interesting to me that, from what they describe, they still sell the cheese regardless of the outcome of this tapping test. It's just that they sell it unbranded if it's of the lowest quality, and with a different marking for medium quality than highest-quality. I suppose wheels of cheese can last a lot longer than normal table cheese, so that's why it makes sense to make this distinction.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- paulorlando 2y agoCurious about this quote: "'My elder colleagues tell me you never stop learning, even after 50 years of doing it,' recounted Stocchi. 'The day you think you’ve learned everything is the day you’ll start making errors.'" - To me this implies that there is more variation among the cheese than I'd expect. In this role don't you see every likely cheese over 50 years? It seems like a static product, where production methods don't change, and that should give you very consistent results from tapping.
- throwup238 2y agoCheese cultures have been bred to be relatively genetically stable but they still experience genetic drift over time that can affect the product in unforeseen ways. Contamination can also introduce unknown pathogens and bacteriophages can cause mutations. Cheesemakers can eliminate the vast majority of the variation in the process but its core input is still very much alive and organic so there’s only so much they can control it.
- fracus 2y agoThey make it sound really complicated, requiring years of mentorship, but really, it was just determining if the sound is the same on multiple taps. It would seem pretty obvious if you tap over a hollow.
- cookie_monsta 2y agoYour job looks really easy to an outsider too, regardless of what you do
- fracus 2y agoSeriously, how complicated can a job be that involves only a little hammer and wheels of cheese. Like, come on.
- kulahan 2y agoWait, you just hit keys on a keyboard all day and see if it works??
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- stefantalpalaru 2y ago[dead]
- susiecambria 2y agoThe sharing of the article and comments: Why I love HN. Thank you.
- Uzmanali 2y agoWhat a fascinating and unique craft! The skill of the battitori to detect defects in Parmigiano Reggiano with just a tap is truly remarkable.
- ladelfa 2y agoThis reminded me of the story about Charles Proteus Steinmetz diagnosing the problem inside a generator at Henry Ford's auto plant just by listening to it very carefully. "Ford, whose electrical engineers couldn’t solve some problems they were having with a gigantic generator, called Steinmetz in to the plant. Upon arriving, Steinmetz rejected all assistance and asked only for a notebook, pencil and cot. According to Scott, Steinmetz listened to the generator and scribbled computations on the notepad for two straight days and nights. On the second night, he asked for a ladder, climbed up the generator and made a chalk mark on its side. Then he told Ford’s skeptical engineers to remove a plate at the mark and replace sixteen windings from the field coil. They did, and the generator performed to perfection. Henry Ford was thrilled until he got an invoice from General Electric in the amount of $10,000. Ford acknowledged Steinmetz’s success but balked at the figure. He asked for an itemized bill. Steinmetz ... responded personally to Ford’s request with the following: Making chalk mark on generator $1. Knowing where to make mark $9,999. Ford paid the bill." https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/charles-proteus-steinmetz-the-wizard-of-schenectady-51912022/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/charles-proteus-stein...
- MarceliusK 2y agoFunny how both cheese tapping and generator listening come down to the same core skill: quiet mastery built from experience, not textbooks
- dataflow 2y agoHow much is the legal obligation to pay such a bill, legally speaking? It sounds like they hadn't agreed on a figure beforehand, so could he have billed an arbitrary amount (say, a million dollars) and would Ford have been required to pay that too? What is the limit?
- nandomrumber 2y agoWhat is an appropriate fee to charge any particular customer when what you’re billing for isn’t necessarily time and materials, but more so the skill / experience required to diagnose and rectify an issue, or otherwise provide a solution, in a timely manner? I’d argue the most correct answer is: up to the customers ability to tolerate, such that they’d be inclined to want to become repeat customers.
- trhway 2y agoI wonder whether the cheese would ripen better and get better structure, less defects/voids, if it were subjected to the sound vibrations from Italian opera singing records playing during those months of ripening.
- MarceliusK 2y agoThere's just something incredible about a skill that exists entirely in someone's ears and hands, passed down person-to-person, not taught in a classroom, not automated, not optimized - just learned over time standing next to someone wiser than you
- bcatanzaro 2y agoI'm curious about the False Positive/False Negative rate of the battitore. Do they open up some wheels to double check?