10 ms·
Isaac Asimov describes how AI will liberate humans and their creativity (1992)
- lenerdenator 2y ago> One wonders what Asimov would make of the world of 2025, and whether he’d still see artificial and natural intelligence as complementary, rather than in competition. I mean, I just got done watching a presentation at Google Next where the presenter talked to an AI agent and set up a landscaping appointment with price match and a person could intervene to approve the price match. It's cool, sure, but understand, that agent would absolutely have been a person on a phone five years ago, and if you replace them with agentic AI, that doesn't mean that person has gone away or is now free to write poetry. It means they're out of an income and benefits. And that's before you consider the effects on the pool of talent you're drawing from when you're looking for someone to intervene on behalf of these agentic AIs, like that supervisor did when they approved the price match. If you don't have the entry-level person, you don't have them five years later when you want to promote someone to manage.
- gh0stcat 2y agoAnother thing I have noticed with automation in general is that the more you use it, the less you understand the thing being automated. I think the reason why a lot of things today are still being manually done is because humans inherently understand that for both short AND long term success with a task, a conceptual understanding of the components of the system, whether that is partially or fully imagined in the case of complex business scenarios, is necessary, even though it lengthens time to complete in the short term. How do you modify or grow a system you do not understand? It feels like you're cutting a branch at a certain length and not allowing it to grow beyond where you've placed the automation. I will be interested to see the outcome of the increased push today for advanced automation in places where the business relies on understanding of the system to make adjacent decisions/further business operations.
- akuchling 2y agoAsimov's story The Feeling of Power seems relevant: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Feeling_of_Power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Feeling_of_Power
- baxtr 2y agoThe 1980 version of your comment: >Just saw a demo of a new word processor system that lets a manager dictate straight into the machine, and it prints the memo without a secretary ever touching it. Slick stuff. But five years ago, that memo would’ve gone through a typist. Replace her with a machine, and she’s not suddenly editing novels from home. She’s unemployed, losing her paycheck and benefits. And when that system malfunctions, who’s left who actually knows how to fix it or manage the workflow? You can’t promote experience that never existed. Strip out the entry-level roles, and you cut off the path to leadership.
- lenerdenator 2y agoThe difference between the 1980 version of my post and the 2025 version of my post is that in 1980 there was conceivably a future where the secretary could retrain to do other work (likely with the help of one of those new-fangled microcomputers) that would need human intelligence in order to be completed. The 2025 equivalent of the secretary is potentially looking across a job market that is far smaller because the labor she was trained to do, or labor similar enough to it that she could have previously successfully been hired, is now handled by artificial intelligence. There is, effectively, no where for her to go to earn a living with her labor.
- seadan83 2y agoHow can we reconcile this with how much of the US and world are still living as if it were the 1930s or even 1850s? Travel 75 to 150 miles outside of a US city and it will feel like time travel. If so much is still 100 years behind, how will civilization so broadly adopt something that is yet more decades into the future? I got into starlink debates with people during hurricane helene. Folks were glowing over how people just needed internet. Reality, internet meant fuck all when what you needed was someone with a chainsaw, a generator, heater, blankets, diapers and food. Which is to say, technology and its importance is a thin veneer on top of organized society. All of which is frail and still has a long way to go to fully penetrate rural communities for even recent technology. At the same time, that spread is less important than it would seem to a technologist. Hence, technology has not uniformly spread everywhere, and ultimately it is not that important. Yet, how will AI, even more futuristic, leap frog this? My money is that rural towns USA will look almost identical in 30 years from now. Many look identical to 100 years ago still.
- mandmandam 2y ago> if you replace them with agentic AI, that doesn't mean that person has gone away or is now free to write poetry. It means they're out of an income and benefits. That's capitalism for ye :/ Join us on the UBI train. Say, have you ever read the book 'Bullshit Jobs'...
- lenerdenator 2y ago> That's capitalism for ye :/ Join us on the UBI train. The people with all of the money effectively froze wages for 45 years, and that was when there were people actually doing labor for them. What makes you think that they'll peaceably agree to UBI for people who don't sell them labor for money?
- mandmandam 2y ago> The people with all of the money effectively froze wages for 45 years Yep. And they didn't accomplish that 'peaceably' either, for the record. A lot of people got murdered, many more smeared/threatened/imprisoned etc. Entire countries get decimated. > What makes you think that they'll peaceably agree to UBI for people who don't sell them labor for money? I don't imagine for a moment that they'll like UBI. There is no shortage of examples over recent millenia of how far the parasite class will go to keep the status quo. History also shows us that having all the money doesn't guarantee that people will do things your way. Class awareness, strikes, unions, protest, and alternative systems/technological advance have shown their mettle. These things scare oligarchs because they work.
- Philpax 2y agoI am hoping that will be our saving grace this time around as well, but my fear is that the oligarchs will control more autonomous power than we can meaningfully resist, and our existence will no longer be strictly necessary for their systems to operate.
- someguyorother 2y ago
- jes5199 2y agoif the AI transition really turns into an Artificial Labor revolution - if it really works and isn’t an illusion - then we’re going to have to have a major change in how we distribute wealth. The bad future is one where the owner class no longer has any use for human labor and the former-worker class has nothing
- foobarian 2y agoTBH this is already how the US got into the current mess.
- milesrout 2y agoBut we have had the same thing happen constantly. Automation isn't new. How many individuals are involved in assembling a car today vs in the 1970s? An order of magnitude fewer. But there aren't loads of unemployed people. The market puts labour where it is needed. Automation won't obsolete work and workers it will make us more productive and our desires will increase. We will all expect what today are considered luxuries only the rich can afford. We will all have custom software written for our needs. We will all have individual legal advice on any topic we need advice on. We will all have bigger houses with more stuff in them, better finishings, triple glazed windows, and on and on.
- jes5199 2y agoyeah and then what. I don’t think desire is infinite.
- milesrout 2y agoIt is uncapped and indefinite. People always want more than they have. We get used to what we have. What was considered a luxury is baseline today. Today's luxuries will before long be considered part of the "poverty line".
- Spooky23 2y agoNot necessarily. The reality is the landscaping guy is struggling to handle callbacks or is burning overhead. Even then, two girls in the office hits a ceiling where it doesn’t scale quickly, now you’re in a call center scenario. Call center based services always suck. I remember going to a talk where American Express, who operated best in class call centers, found that 75% of their customers don’t want to talk to them. The people are there because that’s needed for a complex relationship, the more stuff you can address earlier in the funnel, the better. Customers don’t want to talk to you, and ultimately serving the customer is the point.
- nicbou 2y agoIn theory, the economy should create new avenues. Labour costs are lower, goods and services get cheaper (inflation adjusted) and the money is spent on things that were once out of reach. In practice I fear that the savings will make the rich richer, drive down labour's negotiating power and generally fail to elevate our standard of living.
- vannevar 2y agoI don't think Asimov envisioned a world where AI would be controlled by a clique of ultra-wealthy oligarchs.
- code_for_monkey 2y agoor that it would aggressively focused on doing the work of already low paid creative field jobs. I dont want to read an AI's writing if theres a person who could write it.
- Spooky23 2y agoAsimov’s future was pretty dark. He didn’t come out and say it, but it was implied that we had a lot of big entities ruling everything. Many of the negative political people were painted as “populist” figures. If you are a fan of the foundation books, recall that many of the leaders of various factions were a bunch of idiots little different than the carnival barkers we see today.
- vonneumannstan 2y agoMay want to reread. U.S. Robots and Mechanical Men is pretty prominent in his Robot stories.
- ruffrey 2y agoAs I recall, many of his early stories involved "U.S. Robot & Mechanical Men" which was a huge conglomerate owning a lot of the market on AI (called "robots" by Asimov, it included "Multivac" and other interfaces besides humanoid robots).
- tumsfestival 2y agoI remember reading his book 'The Naked Sun' back in highschool and one of the things that stuck to me was how Earth was kind of a dump bereft of robots, meanwhile the Spacer humans were incredibly rich, had a low population and their society was run by robots doing all the menial work. You could argue he envisioned our current world even if accidentally.
- klabb3 2y agoYes. When I hear dreams of the past it makes me nostalgic because they all come from a pre-exploited era of tech with the underlying subtext that humanity is unified in wanting tech to be used for good purposes. The reality is tech is a vessel for traditional enrichment, such as resource wars of say oil or land have been. Both domestically and geopolitically, tech is seen that way today. In such a world, tech advancements offers opportunities for the powerful to grab more, changing the relative distribution of power in their favor. If tech shows us anything is that this relative notion of wealth or social posturing is the central axis around which humans align themselves, wherever on the socioeconomic ladder you are and independent of absolute and basic needs.
- gmuslera 2y agoWhat we are labeling as AI today is different than was thought to be in the 90s, or when Asimov wrote most of his stories about robots and other ways of AI. Saying that, a variant of Susan Calvin role could prove to be useful today.
- empath75 2y agoNot sure that I agree with that. People have been imagining human-like AI since before computers were even a thing. The Star Trek computer from TNG is basically an LLM, really. AI _researchers_ had a different idea of what AI would be like, as they were working on symbolic AI, but in the popular imagination, "AI" was a computer that acted and thought like a human.
- NoTeslaThrow 2y ago> The Star Trek computer from TNG is basically an LLM, really. The Star Trek computer is not like LLMs: a) it provides reliable answers, b) it is capable of reasoning, c) it is capable of actually interacting with its environment in a rational manner, d) it is infallible unless someone messes with it. Each one of these points is far in the future of LLMs.
- sgt 2y agoYet when you ask it to dim the lights, it dims either way too little or way too much. Poor Geordi.
- sgt 2y agoFor what it's worth, I was referring to the episode when he set up a romantic dinner for the scientist lady. Computer couldn't get the lighting right.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 2y agoTheir point is that it seems to function like an LLM even if it's more advanced. The points raised in this comment don't refute that, per the assertion that each of them is in the future of LLMs.
- kogus 2y agoI think we need to consider what the end goal of technology is at a very broad level. Asimov says in this that there are things computers will be good at, and things humans will be good at. By embracing that complementary relationship, we can advance as a society and be free to do the things that only humans can do. That is definitely how I wish things were going. But it's becoming clear that within a few more years, computers will be far better at absolutely everything than human beings could ever be. We are not far even now from a prompt accepting a request such as "Write a another volume of the Foundation series, in the style of Isaac Asimov", and getting a complete novel that does not need editing, does not need review, and is equal to or better than the quality of the original novels. When that goal is achieved, what then are humans "for"? Humans need purpose, and we are going to be in a position where we don't serve any purpose. I am worried about what will become of us after we have made ourselves obsolete.
- empath75 2y ago> But it's becoming clear that within a few more years, computers will be far better at absolutely everything than human beings could ever be. Comparative advantage. Even if that's true, AI can't possibly do _everything_. China is better at manufacturing pretty much anything than most countries on earth, but that doesn't mean China is the only country in the world that does manufacturing.
- Philpax 2y ago> AI can't possibly do _everything_ Why not? There's the human bias of wanting to consume things created by humans - that's fine, I'm not questioning that - but objectively, if we get to human-threshold AGI and continue scaling, there's no reason why it couldn't do everything, and better.
- seadan83 2y agoWhy not - IMO you perhaps underestimate human complexity. There was a guardian article where researchers created a map of a mouse's brain, 1 cubic millimeter. Contains 45km worth of neurons and billions of synapses. IMO the AGI crowd are suffering expert beginner syndrome.
- Fin_Code 2y agoI'm just hoping it brings out an explosion of new thought and not less thought. Will likely be both.
- shortrounddev2 2y agoI have found there to be less diversity in thought on the internet in the last 10 years. I used to find lots of wild ideas and theories out there on obscure sites. Now it seems like every website is the same, talking about the same things
- TimorousBestie 2y agoI find this difficult to understand. There was a great explosion of conspiracy theories in the last ten years, so you should be seeing more of it.
- shortrounddev2 2y agoEven the conspiracy theory community has become like this. What used to be a community of passionate skeptics, ufo-ologists, and rabid anti-statists has turned into the most overtly boot licking right wing apologists who apply an incredible amount of mental energy to justifying the actions of what is transparently and blatantly the most corrupt government in American history, so long as that government is weaponized against whatever identity and cultural groups they hate
- willy_k 2y agoYou’re describing Twitter not conspiracy communities in general. On the UFO front at least I am aware of multiple YouTube channels and Discord servers with healthy diversity of thought, and I’m sure the same goes for other areas.
- immibis 2y agoMaybe they're all the same conspiracy theories. All the current conspiracy theories are that immigrants are invading the country and Biden's in on it. Where is the next Time Cube or TempleOS?
- chuckadams 2y agoIt certainly is liberating all our creative works from our possession...
- vonneumannstan 2y agoIntellectual Property is a questionable idea to begin with...
- mrdependable 2y agoWhy do you say that?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chuckadams 2y agoIt's not the loss of ownership I'm lamenting, it's the loss of production by humans in the first place.
- Philpax 2y agoHumans will always produce; it's just that those productions may not be financially viable, and may not have an audience. Grim, but also not too far off from the status quo today.
- vonneumannstan 2y agoPeople made the same argument about Cameras vs Painting. "Humans are no longer creating the art!" But I doubt most people would subscribe to that view now and would say Photography is an entirely new art form.
- NitpickLawyer 2y ago> People made the same argument about Cameras vs Painting. I remember that from a couple of years ago, when Stable Diffusion came out. There was a lot of talk about "art" and "AI" and someone posted a collection of articles / interviews / opinion pieces about this exact same thing - painting vs. cameras.
- renewiltord 2y agoIt is an interesting time for LLMs to burst on the scene. Most online forums have already turned people into text replicators. Most HN commenters can be prompted into “write a comment about slop violating copyright” / “write a comment about Google violating privacy” / “write a comment about managers not understanding remote work”. All you have to do is state the opposite. A perfect time for LLMs to show up and do the same. The subreddit simulators were hilarious because of the unusual ways they would perform but a modern LLM is a near perfect approximation of the average HN commenter. I would have assumed that making LLMs indistinguishable from these humans would make those kinds of comments less interesting to interact with but there’s a base level of conversation that hooks people. On Twitter, LLM-equipped Indians cosplay as right wing white supremacists and amass large followings (also bots, perhaps?) revealed only when they have to participate in synchronous conversation. And yet, they are still popular. Even the “Texas has warm water ports” Texan is still around and has a following (many of whom seem non-bot though who can tell?). Even though we have a literal drone, humans still engage in drone behaviour and other humans still engage them. Fascinating. I wonder whether the truth is that the inherent past-replication of low-temperature LLMs is likely to fix us to our present state than to raise us to a new equilibrium. Experiments in Musical Intelligence is now over 40 years old and I thought it was going to revolutionize things: unknown melodies discovered by machine married to mind. Maybe LLMs aren’t going to move us forward only because this point is already a strong attractor. I’m optimistic in the power of boredom, though!
- dkdcwashere 2y ago> I would have assumed that making LLMs indistinguishable from these humans would make those kinds of comments less interesting to interact with but there’s a base level of conversation that hooks people. I think it is heading in this direction, just takes a very long time. 50% of people are dumber than average
- seadan83 2y agoDumber than median*
- tim333 2y ago
- slibhb 2y agoLLMs are statistical models trained on human-generated text. They aren't the perfectly logical "machine brains" that Asimov and others imagined. The upshot of this is that LLMs are quite good at the stuff that he thinks only humans will be able to do. What they aren't so good at (yet) is really rigorous reasoning, exactly the opposite of what 20th century people assumed.
- Balgair 2y ago[flagged]
- n4r9 2y agoI've only read the first Foundation novel by Asimov. But what you write applies equally well to many other Golden Age authors e.g. Heinlein and Bradbury, plus slightly later writers like Clarke. I doubt there was much in the way of autism awareness or diagnosis at the time, but it wouldn't be surprising if any of these landed somewhere on the spectrum. Alfred Bester's "The stars my destination" stands out as a shining counterpoint in this era. You don't get much character development like that in other works until the sixties imo.
- throwanem 2y agoHeinlein doesn't develop his characters? Oh, come on. You can't have read him at all!
- n4r9 2y ago[The italics and punctuation suggest your comment is sarcastic, but I'm going to treat it as serious just in case.] Yeah, I'd say characterisation is a weakness of his. I've read Stranger in a Strange Land, The Moon is a Harsh Mistress, Starship Troopers, and Double Star. Heinlein does explore characters more than, say, Clark, but he doesn't go much for internal change or emotional growth. His male characters typically fall into one of two cartoonish camps: either supremely confident, talented, intelligent and independent (e.g. Jubal, Bernardo, Mannie, Bonforte...) or vaguely pathetic and stupid (e.g. moon men). His female characters are submissive, clumsily sexualised objects who contribute very little to the plot. There are a few partial exceptions - e.g. Lorenzo in Double Star and female pilots in Starship Troopers - but the general atmosphere is one of teenage boy wish fulfilment.
- Longtemps 2y ago[dead]
- koiueo 2y ago[flagged]
- aszantu 2y agoFunny thing About Asimov was how he came up with the laws of robotics and then cases on how they don't work. There are a few that I remember, one where a robot was lying because a bug in his brain gave him empathy and he didn't want to hurt humans.
- bell-cot 2y agoGuess: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liar!_(short_story) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liar!_(short_story)
- soulofmischief 2y agoThat is still one of my favorite stories of all time. It really sticks to you. It's part of the I, Robot anthology.
- nitwit005 2y agoI was always a bit surprised other sci fi authors liked the "three laws" idea, as it seems like a technological variation of other stories about instructions or wishes going wrong.
- nthingtohide 2y agoNarratives build on top of each other so that complex narratives can be built. This is also the reason why Family Guy can speedrun through all the narrative arcs developed by culture in 30 seconds clip. Family Guy Nasty Wolf Pack https://youtu.be/5oW9mNbMbmY https://youtu.be/5oW9mNbMbmY The perfect wish to outsmart a genie | Chris & Jack https://youtu.be/lM0teS7PFMo https://youtu.be/lM0teS7PFMo
- buzzy_hacker 2y agoSame here. A main point of I, Robot was to show why the three laws don't work.
- aszantu 2y agoThe story from iRobot is one of Asimov s stories and it works exactly as intended. The AI figured that to keep humans safe you have to put them in cages. Humans will always fight over something
- darepublic 2y agoSeeing the creativity most people employ, that is for selfish loopholes and inconsiderate behaviour, I am a little wary of empowering them.
- lupusreal 2y agoMost creative work is benevolent or at least harmless. Certainly some people are malevolent, maybe even everybody some of the time, but you shouldn't believe that to represent the majority of creativity. That's way too misanthropic.
- hoseyor 2y agoI have a genuine question I can’t find or come up with a viable answer to, a matter of said “unpleasantness” as he puts it; how do people make money or otherwise sustain themselves in this AI scenario we are facing? Has anyone heard a viable solution, or even has one themselves? I don’t hear anything about UBI anymore, could that be because after roughly 60+ million alien people flooding into western countries from countries with a populations so large that are effectively endless? What do we do about that? Will that snuff out any kind of advancement in the west when the roughly 6 billion people all want to be in the west where everyone gets UBI and it’s the land of milk and honey? So what do we do then? We can’t all be tech industry people with 6-figure plus salaries, vested ownership, and most people aren’t multi-millionaires that can live far away from the consequences while demanding others subject themselves to them. Which way?
- janalsncm 2y agoI have soured on UBI because it tries to use a market solution to deal with problems that I don’t think markets can fix. I want everyone to have food, housing, healthcare, education, etc. in a post scarcity world. That should be possible. I don’t think giving people cash is the best way to accomplish that. If you want people to have housing, give them housing. If you want people to have food, give them food. Cash doesn’t solve the supply problem, as we can see with housing now. You would think a rise in the cost of housing would lead to more supply, but the cost of real estate also increases the cost of building.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- slfnflctd 2y agoI've always thought there should be a 'minimum viable existence' option for those who are willing to forego most luxuries in exchange for not being required to do anything specific other than abide by reasonable laws. It would be very interesting to see the percentage breakdowns of how such people chose to spend their time. In my opinion, there would be enough benefit to society at large to make it worthwhile. For a large group (if not the majority), I'm certain the situation would turn out to be completely temporary-- they would have the option to prepare themselves for some type of work they're better adapted to perform and/or enjoy, ultimately enhancing the culture and economy. Most of the rest could be useful as research subjects, if they were willing of course. Obviously this is a bit of a utopian fantasy, but what can I say, Star Trek primed me to hope for such a future.
- janalsncm 2y ago> Isaac Asimov describes artificial intelligence as “a phrase that we use for any device that does things which, in the past, we have associated only with human intelligence.” This is a pretty good definition, honestly. It explains the AI Effect quite well: calculators aren’t “AI” because it’s been a while since humans were the only ones who could do arithmetic. At one point they were, though.
- azinman2 2y agoAlthough calculators can now do things almost no humans can do, or at least in any reasonable time. But most (now) wouldn’t call it AI. It’s a tool, with a very limited domain
- janalsncm 2y agoThat’s my point, it’s not AI now. It used to be.
- hinkley 2y agoSimilarly, we esteem performance optimizations so aggressively that a lot of things that used to be called performance work are now called architecture, good design. We just keep moving the goal posts to make things more comfortable.
- saalweachter 2y agoI mean, at one point "calculator" was a job title.
- timewizard 2y agoThe abacus has existed for thousands of years. Those who had the job of "calculator" also used pencil and paper to manage larger calculations which they would have struggled to do without any tools. That's humanity. We're tool users above anything else. This gets lost.
- musicale 2y ago
- josefritzishere 2y agoIsaac Asimov's view of the future has aged surprisingly well. But techno-utopianism has not.
- franze 2y agoI let Gemini 2.5 Pro (the image is from ChatGpt) write a short sci fi story. I think it did a decent job. https://show.franzai.com/a/tiny-queen-zebu https://show.franzai.com/a/tiny-queen-zebu
- 34679 2y agoAsk it to count the words.
- logicallee 2y agoyour link is broken now
- franze 2y agofixed
- Jgrubb 2y ago> humanity in general will be freed from all kinds of work that’s really an insult to the human brain. He can only be referring to these Jira tickets I need to write.
- BeetleB 2y agoThere is a Jira MCP server...
- fragmede 2y agooh woah https://glama.ai/mcp/servers/@CamdenClark/jira-mcp https://glama.ai/mcp/servers/@CamdenClark/jira-mcp and MCP can work with deepseek running locally. hmm...
- m463 2y agoflashback to Tron: "MCP is highly intelligent and yet ruthless. It apparently wants to get rid of humans and especially users." https://disney.fandom.com/wiki/Master_Control_Program https://disney.fandom.com/wiki/Master_Control_Program
- icecap12 2y agoAs someone who just got done putting a bullet in some long-used instances, I both appreciated and needed this laugh. Thanks!
- palmotea 2y agoI wouldn't put too much stock in this. Asimov was a fantasy writer telling fictional stories about the future. He was good at it, which is why you listen and why it's enjoyable, but it's still all a fantasy.
- timewizard 2y agoThere's also Frank Herbert. Who saw AI as ruinous to humanity and it's evolution and saw a future where humanity had to fight a war against it resulting in it being banished from the entire universe.
- palmotea 2y ago> There's also Frank Herbert. Who saw AI as ruinous to humanity and it's evolution and saw a future where humanity had to fight a war against it resulting in it being banished from the entire universe. Did he though? Or was the Butlerian Jihad backstory whose function was allow him to believably center human characters in his stories, given sci-fi expectations of the time? I like Herbert's work, but ultimately he (and Asimov) were producers of stories to entertain people, so entertainment always would take priority over truth (and then there's the entirely different problem of accurately predicting the future).
- tehjoker 2y agoI think this is kind of misunderstanding scifi a bit. You're right it was designed to be entertaining, but the kernel of it is that they take some existing trend and extrapolate it into the future. Do that enough times, and some of the stories will start to be meaningful looking backwards and the people who made those predictions still deserve credit even if they weren't entirely useful in the forward direction.
- triceratops 2y agoI always thought the Butlerian Jihad was a convenient way to remove AI as a plot element. Same thing with shields and explosions; it made swordfighting a plausible way to fight in a universe with faster-than-light travel.
- alganet 2y ago92 huh? That is an opinion from a long time ago. The question I have is why AI technology is being so aggressively advertised nowadays, and why none of it seems to be liberating in any way. Once the plow liberated humans from some kinds of work. Some time later it was just a tool that slaves, very non liberated, used to tend to rich people's farms. Technology is tricky. I don't trust who is developing AI to be liberating. The article also plays on the "favorite author" thing. It knows many young folk see Asimov as a role model, so it is leveraging that emotional connection to gather conversation around a topic that is not what it seems to be. I consider it a dirty trick. It is disgraceful given the current world situation (AI being used for war, surveillance, brainwashing). We are better than this.
- tim333 2y ago>why AI technology is being so aggressively advertised nowadays[?] I'm not sure I've actually seen an advertisement for AI. It's being endlessly discussed though on HN and other places, probably because it's at an interesting point at the moment making rapid progress. And also shoved into a lot of products and services of course.
- alganet 2y agoThe definition of advertisement is the least important part of my comment. Focus on what matters for humans.
- ElijahLynn 2y agoReminds me of Jacque Fresco (Venus Project)!
- kreyenborgi 2y agoThe final part of this article is the main point, not the headline
- zifpanachr23 2y agoAsimov is probably my least favorite major science fiction author (that I've read a significant number of works from). Something about his worldview always seemed off to me, although I didn't know he actually seriously held such utopian convictions about AI. It explains an awful lot of the way his stories are.
- lucraft 2y agoHe also wrote a story about how AI will create a non-literate society, because we'll all just talk to the computers whenever we need anything.
- eliaspro 2y agoBack then, when we also believed the access to every imaginable information through the internet and allowing communication across the globe would lead to universal wisdom, world-peace and an unimaginable utopia where common sense, based on science and knowledge prevails. Oh boy, how foolish we've been!
- bdhcuidbebe 2y agoWhat Asimov calls AI is not the same as what Sam Altman and the other sharlatans calls AI. Its usually called AGI these days.