4 ms·
> my first thought is "my favorite store is having a sale." This gets repeated a lot, but unless you already had most of your portfolio in cash it’s not actual
by Aurornis 2y ago
> my first thought is "my favorite store is having a sale."
This gets repeated a lot, but unless you already had most of your portfolio in cash it’s not actually a net win to see a drawdown like this.
The course of the global economy was just altered. The best case scenario would be if the proposed tariffs go away completely, but even then the markets will be cautious for the next 4 years at minimum.
The market is down because the future prospects for those businesses just got much worse. Yeah you can buy them at a cheaper price, but their corresponding future output remains down as well.
It’s like seeing a thing you wanted to buy go on sale, but upon closer inspection it’s on sale because it became damaged and you’re buying damaged goods.
The best case scenario is that the administration pulls the “just kidding” card, reverses course, and claims some sort of victory while returning to the previous status quo. If that happens, stocks were briefly on sale even though they’re not rebounding back right away. However, if the administration digs their heels in and tries to push forward then the market is going to continue downward.
This isn’t a normal drawdown. This is a crisis with the leadership of the United States.
- kortilla 2y ago>This isn’t a normal drawdown. This is a crisis with the leadership of the United States. The same thing happened just 4 short years ago when covid hit. Mass panic and then intervention kicked in. The intervention could have been taken away at any time but the market went extremely risk-on anyway and you would have gotten left behind if you sold out. >but even then the markets will be cautious for the next 4 years at minimum. You are overestimating the cautiousness of the market. Unless there are better returns offered in some other investment, the capital is going to pile back in if something like tariff deals start getting announced.
- Aurornis 2y ago> The same thing happened just 4 short years ago when covid hit. COVID was a natural disaster. Leadership responded to it. This is the opposite. Markets were going well. Leadership intervened to crash them. Do you see the difference? It’s not the same. > You are overestimating the cautiousness of the market. You are underestimating the impacts of risk premia. This administration just showed that they don’t know what they’re doing, but they’re willing to go all-in on disastrous economic policy. They’ve already waffled on previous policy and then came back and doubled down. They’re still talking about more tariffs. This isn’t a little “oopsie” any more. It’s a pattern. It’s going to be a long 4 years until we can get back to stability. > Unless there are better returns offered in some other investment You are so close. It’s not just returns, it’s risk. Trump just made the market hyper risky.
- redserk 2y agoYeah, I think it’s worth emphasizing: we are in Month 4 and there’s already been an enormous amount of chaos. We haven’t even seen the effects of the agencies getting cut. Sure they’re running for now, but burnout can set in quick for the remaining employees and some YC investor-clown’s delusional dream of an “AI” workforce isn’t going to save us. I’m just one fish in the sea of retail investors but I won’t be in any rush to convert cash savings into investments with this current trajectory. Besides, cash is infinitely more useful for my mortgage payments — especially if layoffs in the private sector start.
- ModernMech 2y ago> we are in Month 4 I know this is shocking, but it hasn't even been 3 months yet. 2 months and 18 days.
- kortilla 2y ago>but they’re willing to go all-in on disastrous economic policy. They did it to stem the covid bleeding too. >It’s not just returns, it’s risk. Trump just made the market hyper risky. What market do you think Trump didn’t make risky that this capital will flight to? All kinds of bond default risk shot up across the board as well.
- kortilla 2y agoThe market returns today should make you re-evaluate your position on this. Anyone following your thesis would have sold out at the bottom.
- graeme 2y agoThe covid crisis was an actual event in physical reality not caused by admin policies. This crisis is the admin taking a sledgehammer to international capitalism. No obvious intervention other than "stop doing that". I'm sure at some point the fed would have some kind of response but inflation of tariffs is a huge risk and that limits what the fed can do unless they have co-ordination with the admin.
- disgruntledphd2 2y ago> The covid crisis was an actual event in physical reality not caused by admin policies. Sortof yeah, but also sortof not. Basically any non-Trump president would have been briefed about Covid in January 2020, and most of the previous ones invested a bunch of resources into making sure that the disease was contained far away from US shores. Even Bush II would have done that (and did, I believe for SARS).
- graeme 2y agoIt's a possibility. SARS II was much harder to contain though. The first SARS actually made it to North American hospitals, but was contained. It didn't spread in the populace. Once SARS II made it out of China, only globally coordinated net 0 case policies could have stopped it. I think it would have been worth trying for but there was no appetite for it.
- disgruntledphd2 2y ago> It's a possibility. SARS II was much harder to contain though. The first SARS actually made it to North American hospitals, but was contained. It didn't spread in the populace. Totally fair, but as I recall he didn't even try to keep it away from US soil (which had always been the CDC approach).
- j4coh 2y agoWho intervenes if it’s the leadership manufacturing the crisis?
- JohnnyMarcone 2y agoPressure from the electorate, business leaders and foreign governments could spur Congress to act.
- motorest 2y ago> (...) the capital is going to pile back in if something like tariff deals start getting announced. What leads you to believe that scenario is realistic? I mean, the list of US trading partners is dominated by less than a dozen trading blocks: EU, Mexico, Canada, ASEAN, China. That's it. Trade with India is as significant as trade with Italy alone, and a massive deal with them would barely move the needle in this trade war. Unless the US somehow makes it's own trade war go away with the likes of Canada and the EU, there is no bright outlook for the market and economy. Trump's administration is repeatedly threatening both with annexation. To make matters worse, do you really believe any trading block will move back to preserve economic ties with the US after this mess? Not a chance in hell. The EU, which thanks to the Trump administration is already scrambling to prepare for a war with Russia, is excluding the US from supplying them arms. This is the extent to which these trading blocks are going to shed ties with the US. Do you think things will just go back to how things were 6 months ago? The Trump administration ensured this is impossible.
- thebigjewbowski 2y ago> the list of US trading partners is dominated by less than a dozen trading blocks: EU, Mexico, Canada, ASEAN, China. That's it. ASEAN countries are eager to make a deal. The USMCA deal is still in tact with Mexico and Canada. > The EU, which thanks to the Trump administration is already scrambling to prepare for a war with Russia, is excluding the US from supplying them arms. This is the extent to which these trading blocks are going to shed ties with the US. Germany is in an energy crisis and a few other members are close to a sovereign debt crisis. Domestic production of weapons will be tough and expensive. The EU’s plan to sell bonds to pursue war with Russia looks horrid. They’re in no position to be in a trade war. In a few months time when this reality sinks in, they will have to make a trade deal and remove US tariffs.
- disgruntledphd2 2y ago> Germany is in an energy crisis and a few other members are close to a sovereign debt crisis. Domestic production of weapons will be tough and expensive. The EU’s plan to sell bonds to pursue war with Russia looks horrid. They’re in no position to be in a trade war. In a few months time when this reality sinks in, they will have to make a trade deal and remove US tariffs. This really, really depends on how things evolve this week. Like, the EU will 100% tarriff the US (and probably China to prevent dumping) this week. The big question is whether or not they use the Anti-Coercion Instrument, and hit US tech and financial services. Selfishly, I hope they don't (as I work for a US fintech while I am based in the EU), but this will probably happen if Trump retaliates to this week's sanctions (which he probably will). This is gonna get a lot worse before it gets better, unless there's a unilateral pullback on the part of the US (which seems very unlikely).
- danmaz74 2y ago>>This isn’t a normal drawdown. This is a crisis with the leadership of the United States. >The same thing happened just 4 short years ago when covid hit. If by "same thing" you mean the market crashing, then yes, it's similar. But the cause of this isn't the "same thing" at all. For the next 4 years, the USA will have a president who wants to annex Greenland and Canada, who hates most (all?) US traditional allies and trading partners, who doesn't believe in free trade. The effects on the world economy are going to be slower to take effect compared to COVID, but they're going to be much deeper and long lasting.
- kortilla 2y agoThe effects of covid were literally being talked about as the entire world economy grinding to a halt overnight. It was mass panic beyond high tariffs for a foreseeable future. The market was in straight free-fall until all of the major govts stepped in to print trillions. It was like a light switch made the “end of capitalism” disappear in a day.
- kortilla 2y agoThe rally back today on just a pause illustrates my point. No permanent fixes at all, just a pause and the market went up 10% in a day.
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoCOVID keeps getting brought up. Let's remember that it was much worse than it had to be, because the same President actively causing this current catastrophe thought he could just ignore the problem and it would go away.
- motorest 2y ago> The market is down because the future prospects for those businesses just got much worse. Yeah you can buy them at a cheaper price, but their corresponding future output remains down as well. It should be noted that these moronic "buy the dip" claims are happening when Dow Jones is in a freefall, so the poor people who bought the dip on Friday will today wake up with a portfolio loss of >5% without the market even reopening. It's funny when these chants take place when prices start to plummet. It's like investors are screaming for unwitting people to buy the bag off their hands.
- Aurornis 2y agoTo be honest, “buy the dip” is generally cope that people tell themselves. The average investor isn’t sitting on a pile of cash just waiting to move it into the market. People investing periodically over decades have far more in the market than out. The “buy the dip” stuff ends up being a little bit here or there so they can convince themselves not to worry, not an appreciable swing in their portfolio.
- e40 2y agoBuy the dip is what rich people do to get richer.
- Aurornis 2y agoRich people already had their money invested. To buy the dip you need liquid cash sitting around earning very little, hoping the market goes down. Reallocate portfolios if that makes sense, but much of the “buy the dip” stuff implies good market timing: To do it in meaningful amounts you’d have to pick the right times to not invest, accumulating cash at a lower rate, then you’d have to know precisely when to invest it again, switching it back into the stock market.
- arcastroe 2y ago> Reallocate portfolios if that makes sense Yes. This is one of the reasons 80 stocks / 20 bonds is a common strategy. The rebalancing "forces" you to buy low and sell high. When stocks dip, your portfolio might become unbalanced at 70/30, so you reallocate funds to buy stock bringing you back to 80/20. Conversely, if stock market soars, you might get to 90/10, and selling stocks would bring you back to 80/20. Performing this balancing is, in effect, "buying the dip"
- exabrial 2y agoThis opinion is even worse ^; Literally nobody can predict what the bottom is (except magically the group with strong political opinions /s), but what amazes me is people are willing to give out bad advice in an attempt to create a realization of the ideology.
- mjamesaustin 2y agoStatistics say sitting members of Congress and their families are pretty good at knowing when the best time is to buy and sell. I wonder why...
- exabrial 2y agoAlso true, hah. Guess they’re also just lucky
- Timber-6539 2y agoMakes no sense whatsoever. I bet you did not think the course of the global economy was also altered in the many rallies before this crash.