7 ms·
Private Equity Is Coming for America's $12T in Retirement Savings
- leokeba 2y agohttps://archive.ph/smkN4 https://archive.ph/smkN4
- nobodyandproud 2y agoSo it’s happening. I was talking about something similar with a family friend (in the high finance space) a few years back. When will passive investments and indexes be manipulated and carved out for “wealth extraction”? With the funds locked away for years by law/policy preventing a move to safer territory, without any FDIC guarantees to keep retirees solvent; the plans were a tempting pool of money. With social security being pushed for insolvency; I think my generation is well-and-truly in trouble.
- Spooky23 2y agoIt’s happening already. Indexing propelled the Tesla scam, by shoveling lots of dumb money into it. If you’re a boglehead with your money in VTI, you have 1.5% of your money in a meme stock. Big scammy companies like Tesla drag the whole market down when they pop.
- cogman10 2y agoYeah, I really hate the rise of private equity. So much financial protection comes from public companies trading. But that's also means it's somewhat harder to gamble on the system and manipulate the market. With companies going private and private equity being more commercialized, we are going to see some nasty stuff. Finance has always had nasty parts, however, no good comes from less transparency. We need new financial regulations around private equity ASAP. Up to and including making the trade of private equity illegal. Having a private black market for equity is bad for everyone other than insiders.
- gruez 2y ago> Up to and including making the trade of private equity illegal. How would this even work? "Private equity" just means shares in non-public companies. How would private companies raise capital, which are often are done in the form of trading equity for cash? Should a startup be forced to go public just to raise their series A? Even outside silicon valley or wall st, even something as benign as a neighborhood coffee shop is technically "private equity". Should such business owners be barred from selling their businesses to anyone? >Having a private black market for equity is bad for everyone other than insiders. I understand the justification for banning private equity for individual investors on the basis that they can't be expected to discern scams from non-scams (hence the concept of "accredited investors"), but it's far less clear why institutions can't be trusted to do their own due diligence before engaging in a trade.
- cogman10 2y ago> How would this even work? A good question that I don't have a good answer for. I don't have anything really against individual investors taking a risk on a private business. However, I have big issues with there being a large market for these risks to be traded, swapped, and financialized. That's where I see most of the danger, it isn't the first hand selling of equity but rather having a literal market for such equity. I shouldn't be able to short kim's coffee shop. > it's far less clear why institutions can't be trusted to do their own due diligence before engaging in a trade. Because they, frankly, aren't trustworthy. How much money by VC firms has been dumped into obvious ponzi schemes such as FTX? The issue I have with institutions is they aren't concerned with due diligence, they are concerned with turning a profit. That means they are more than happy to turn a blind eye to obvious company problems if they think they can get in and out before a meltdown (IE, pump and dump).
- Ekaros 2y agoThe whole rewarding model for these institutions reads like pure scam if you apply any cynicism. Make money win or lose. Make even more money when "win" even if all that win is purely on paper. And if you lose just roll the stuff under some new name that happened to win. Record looks good. Even if other records were losers... At least with publicly traded stocks you can have substantial market depth so valuations can be "real". But move to private equity and well even that little goes away...
- Avicebron 2y agoMost of my generation doesn't even consider "passive investments" because the previous generations have ruined any chance of owning a home let alone building wealth outside of a few very lucky individuals showered with VC money. Not sure you're going to find sympathy nobody
- nobodyandproud 2y agoI can’t speak for most of my generation because I always lived beneath my means; my first and only home was right after the Great Recession, because home prices just grew to insane levels. I would still be renting otherwise. The problem of housing is real, and this should be solvable because it’s first and foremost a policy problem which causes a supply problem. For example I live in an area that encourages the rebuilding of single family homes into townhouses. It’s a nice compromise and more cities should be adopting this; yet it’s certain states like California that represent a bi-partisan problem with outdated policies grandfathered in. Certain segments of the population won’t vote against their self-interest; but these individuals will be the least impacted by destroying 401k, ironically enough.
- Avicebron 2y ago> it’s first and foremost a policy problem It's not though, at least at the scale that it matters, it's an economic problem brought on by a decrease in individual's relative capex. If in 1970 a person (let's say carpenter because I like biblical analogues) could purchase a truck for $2,600, even if their entire yearly salary was $10K, they had a 2/3 left over after a major life changing purchase. If in 2025, someone makes $50K, they may be in a higher income bracket in their relative area, but the truck costs 50k and must be financed over ~"time(indebt)", that's happening across all sectors and is the issue
- nobodyandproud 2y agoIt is. Housing prices doubled or tripled between 2000 and 2007, and your generation (and mine) are still dealing with the aftermath. If you're willing take a journey with me: Near the end of Bill Clinton's second term, a bi-partisan bill was passed in 1999: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gramm%E2%80%93Leach%E2%80%93Bliley_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gramm%E2%80%93Leach%E2%80%93Bl... For Republicans, this represented a long-term desire by the WSJ crowd, to free-up money and assets locked in commercial banks; and make it available into the Investment Banking side. For Democrats and the DEI crowd of then, relaxing the lending rules was considered a win for minorities who had a hard time buying property--mostly because of strict but impartial lending requirements, which was still pegged as "racist". Around that time, China joined the WTO and by the early to mid 2000s the US was flush lenders wanting to get in on the mortgage-backed security action. This is when home prices doubled or tripled in value, in the span of 6 to 8 years, and was a nation-wide phenomena. It's only risk adverseness and a quip from a mortgage lender, when my family was denied many years earlier because we were quite poor, that saved me from a major financial mistake. After the bust--which hit minorities the hardest, by the way--there should have been a price correction and this peaked in 2009: For a brief time in the early 2010s there was, with a supply of distressed properties, but strangely enough prices never corrected nationwide to the levels they should have and this is because of the long influx of cash from tech, which delayed things for another 10-12 years and kept the prices growing in areas that had jobs. Your generation was responsible for the last 4-6 years of prices not getting corrected; when I pushed for unions and trade guilds at the cost of spiky income--proudly been doing so since the late 1990s, thank you--you can absolutely bet that I was shouted down recently as back in the 1990s and 2000s, whenever the topic steered near that direction. Today, what we're left with are: Homes continuing to be built for those flush with money or nearing the highs of their career; and overpriced homes purchased during the early 2000s that at best are losing value through inflation.
- iknowSFR 2y agoI would love to see a multi-decade model of 4 scenarios measuring quality of life, economic growth, and wealth distribution specifically around the re-allocation of this $12T. 1. Baseline Status quo - no changes. 2. Move all $12T into reducing the $36T of US debt. 1 time payment. All 401k’s are reduced to $0. 3. Allow for PE to productize into this $12T, siphoning off various amounts over time. 4. 401k holders can choose their own non-traditional investments. I’m not advocating for any specific outcome because I know nothing on this topic but as a starting point, show me what happens with each, normalized and compared.
- delfinom 2y agoSo with #2, steal everyone's money, even people contributing into 401k while making dogshit pay, and pay off the country's debt bill ran up by someone else? I can tell you this scenario results in french revolutions
- lesuorac 2y agoEverybody loves to quote french revolution or 2nd amendment but all these revolutions are all centrally lead (by somebody/group performing a power grab). Whose leading the revolution against 401k theft? Is Vanguard going to invite people with 401ks to a rally in DC?
- asdffdasy 2y agowhen you put it like that, it might actually works. Specially now that the people stealing the 401k will be ones shadowbanning all the angry tweets. also: see the preemptive strike on revolutions https://gking.harvard.edu/files/gking/files/censored.pdf?mod=article_inline https://gking.harvard.edu/files/gking/files/censored.pdf?mod...
- sofixa 2y agoThe French revolution wasn't lead centrally, it was a higher classes which boiled over to grassroots explosion of public discontent that ran away from everyone, had a life of its own, and devoured its children. Economically, little changed for the regular people. The church was ruined, and so were many high class families. Socially, a lot did (there was an expectation of humans having rights, the church was forever relegated to a secondary role and out of governance, etc). Most social revolutions (changing the social order, so the US war of independence doesn't count) have a grassroots component that is often highjacked by educated professionals (lawyers are a bit overrepresented) for their own social and economic agenda (which, to be clear, is a net positive compared to the previous order)
- Spooky23 2y agoYou’re pretty cooked if you’re under 40. The new alignment seems to be devaluing the dollar and you need to be worried about things like US treasury default. I’d prepare for a rough decade. Focus on paying off the mortgage more than than the advice that you typically get in the past.
- nobodyandproud 2y agoI think the most impacted will be those between 30 to 55, because they have the most locked into 401k plans. Otherwise, I agree it will be rough.
- Spooky23 2y agoI agree — but I suspect juicing the market will probably help the older people, at least for awhile.
- skippyboxedhero 2y agoPassive equity investments have close to the worst risk/reward, largely because they are so accessible so effectively support the creation of vast amounts of worthless equity (the return on the average US stock is 0% and has been for many decades). Also, most equity indexes are nonsense, in most of the world the state is heavily involved in which companies list so they are and have always been historically and culturally contingent. The reason why this is happening is because some institutions have been extremely successful doing this. I assume you are familiar with the ones like Ontario Teacher's (because they seem to own everything) or endowments but has also been true for Superannuation funds in Australia. In the latter case, they have (I believe) the highest levels of average wealth (higher than the US) but incomes that are lower, largely because of Super funds. Speaking generally, one of the biggest drivers of wealth inequality is that the rich have access to financial products that go up in a straight line, and other people do not...despite "other people" in aggregate holding most of the wealth. Germany is one of the most famous examples of this, GDP per capita is very close to the top ten, median net financial wealth equal to Greece. Saving options are non-existent so everyone is funneled into deposits, and the banks take that money and give it at -2% to a billionaire (whose family got suspiciously and suddenly very wealthy in the 30s). China is effectively the same model but Germany is a bit more notorious...because people continue for vote it. The alternative is Singapore, everyone knows this model cannot work with US politics (to keep it brief). So what is happening is the obvious thing to do. Same thing is happening in the UK under a left-wing government btw. The US is already somewhat ahead of the curve in that their exists a deep pool of people who have decades of experience running funds for savers and institutions this way (again, people in the US miss this context...the UK is doing a similar thing, the issue is that there is almost no-one with this experience). It is right to say plan sponsors should do this, the statements by Biden and Trump quoted are both correct (and not contradictory). As the article points out, DB plans have used these for decades shrug However, there is also stuff here that is also known bad: it sounds like they want to incorporate this into funds that offer daily liquidity...how did CEFs work for PE funds pre-08? Not good (the solace with this kind of thing is that PE funds lose out just as much doing this, it is a bad idea that has failed every time but they just can't resist).
- kacesensitive 2y agoThis is exactly the kind of quiet financial engineering that changes the game for average savers—without their input. Most people already don’t understand how their 401(k) works, and now we’re going to default them into opaque, illiquid private equity products? Sure, PE firms want access to that $12T market, but let’s be real: this is about locking in long-term capital with limited transparency and even more fees. The risk/reward profile is completely different from stocks/bonds. And it’s all being decided over a Zoom call between megafunds a week before Trump’s second inauguration. Not a great look. But unfortunately this is towards the bottom of the list of egregious shit that has happened in the last couple of months.
- nobodyandproud 2y agoIt’s one of the long-game problems that will be a disaster a decade or more from now, and it’s the middle-income majority that will be left dealing with the problem. But will it be the younger millennials, gen-Z, and younger generations cleaning up the mess? Or will it be Gen-X and older millennials out in the streets and homeless? Or something else? The young generation asked how they were handed a bag of problems. This is their moment to help decide how to address the problems of tomorrow, because it’s a battle to do so and policy changes and consequences are by design invisible to the typical worker.
- d4mi3n 2y agoIt's sad to me that we pin so many expectations on the following generations when they're just starting their journey as adults. We're just kicking the can down the road, and they're arguably less equipped (in resourcing and current influence) to fix these problems than the generations before them.
- nine_zeros 2y agoYou are hitting a real point here. Elders are supposed to create an environment for the future generations to thrive. Here we are with elders (corporations and politicians really) creating many opportunities for themselves to suck the life out of younger people.
- ilamont 2y agoFewer than one in 10 plans offer any kind of alternative investment, according to an American Retirement Association survey. Only 2.4% make private equity available. Just what retirees need. PE and VC vultures don't have access to dumb institutional money anymore, so they're lining up to suck the blood out of tens of millions of little people. They know that there are many who are either ignorant or desperate enough to go all in on crypto, AI, NFTs, inflated "unicorns" or whatever other hot scam that rises up in the future. Bagholders will be retirees who have no recourse when 99% of these schemes fail, while the hyenas laugh all the way to the bank.
- OutOfHere 2y agoSarcasm is inappropriate for online conversation even when it's obvious to you because it leaves great room for misinterpretation when you least expect it. As an engineer, one must value precise and clear communication.
- delfinom 2y agoYea but the wealthy elite need more bagholders to continue transferring the world's wealth to themselves. And the wealthy elite are now in complete and full control of the US government. This is going to happen guaranteed now.
- JohnFen 2y agoPrivate equity firms have a strong tendency to make everything worse for anybody who isn't the private equity firm. I guess it's time to find a different place for my retirement funds.
- eulers_secret 2y agoHuh, I guess my 401(k) has already been mistreated. I made most of the money I have for retirement when I worked at Intel, and seeing the lawsuit is really interesting/concerning. Guess it's time to roll over the 401(k) to my new job and take a more active role in managing it - I want it almost all explicitly in the market (and not in private equity) at this point in my life. Thanks for posting this, my retirement funds are a big deal to me and I hate that people less informed will probably be screwed by moves like this.
- asdffdasy 2y agowhen the market is what it is today... potato, potahtoh? I mean, you will still have x and xai and the upcoming openAi-for-profit-corp, tesla and meme coin exchanges on your portfolio.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- xnx 2y agoI hope that electorally there's a huge swing in the other direction and we can do big things like tax carried interest properly.
- soupfordummies 2y agoI just can't comprehend the level of greed rampant in today's world. I don't like to give into the reddit-style sensationalism but it really does feel like it's not enough that they have so much-- others need to have less.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoWhen does the realization set in that sensationalism is really just reality? https://www.visualcapitalist.com/a-visual-breakdown-of-who-owns-americas-wealth/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/a-visual-breakdown-of-who-o... https://www.oxfamamerica.org/press/press-releases/worlds-top-1-own-more-wealth-than-95-of-humanity-as-the-shadow-of-global-oligarchy-hangs-over-un-general-assembly-says-oxfam/ https://www.oxfamamerica.org/press/press-releases/worlds-top...
- chgs 2y agoIf the economy grows by 2.5% a year but the wealthiest grows by 9% a year, where is the money coming from.
- hackable_sand 2y agoig we will find out if Mario has any long-lost brothers
- rconti 2y agoJust saw this bit on NBC News about PE buying retirement communities and completely altering the terms of the deals the residents signed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xnWYh7N5goE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xnWYh7N5goE It scared me because my parents were looking into a buying into a retirement community where you have a "guaranteed" payout amount depending on how many years you stay; that payout amount slowly declines over time to something like 80%. The deal is clear. Pay a bunch of money to buy in. Pay pretty high monthly maintenance fees. They handle everything else. Food, medical care, etc. If you need long term care, dementia, etc. Then if/when you want to move out you get between 100% and 80% paid back out, depending on when you leave. (And, presumably, it works the same way for your heirs). They make money on: * The spread between what you pay as maintenance fees and what it actually costs to support you * The (hopeful, for them) appreciation in the market value of the housing you 'buy' (which is an incentive to keep the community desirable). * The decline in "ownership" % you have over time. And of course ultimately they're gambling that you won't have an incredibly long, expensive decline, but will die relatively quickly once the costs mount. This all makes sense, because it's a form of risk pooling. But it was infuriating that someone could come along and buy out the place and just alter the terms. I still don't understand why/how it's legal, it seems like that should only be allowable under something like bankruptcy.
- nine_zeros 2y agoYep, any alteration of terms should require consent or full refund. That is only fair. But currently America is a crooked corrupt country so I am not holding my breath.
- chgs 2y ago> I still don't understand why/how it's legal Who’s richer? This is the same at every level of society. Those millionaires buying a comfy retirement have never been worried about the bottom rungs of society and the lack of legal support, healthcare, the difficulties with police etc Turns out that the forces that drain the working population are now after the comfortable ones. Won’t take long for exponential growth to eat through the 50-90%ile, and in 10-15 years it will be the 90-99% that are bled dry, and 5 years after that the 1% start cannibalising themselves. It’s inevitable.
- lesuorac 2y agoIf only there was some way for Private Equity to receive funds from the public. Maybe some kind of offering they could do where the public gives them money in exchange for rights to portions of future profits?
- anonymousiam 2y agoIt may be obvious to most people here, but I just want to point out that money is power, even when it's not yours. Fund managers have the power to collude with one another and make or break the markets. In recent times, many have done so to promote (or punish) political behaviors that had nothing to do with finance, and may not have been in the best interests of their clients.
- yoyohello13 2y agoSo I'm genuinely curious. Are the people that work in PE just straight up sociopaths? Or is there some kind of charitable interpretation that let's them sleep at night. Like it blows my mind the kind of evil our society lets rich people get away with.
- an0malous 2y ago[flagged]
- s1artibartfast 2y agoPE is just a fancy name for non-public investment. The charitable interpretation is that if your typical teachers and government worker pension can invest in PE to maximize return, why cant your corporate 401k do the same? Why would someone have trouble sleeping at night?
- jppope 2y agoI'd like to get a deeper take on this if anyone has any numbers to back it up. To me it "feels" like the last 2 decades of easy money and lack of investment into building entrepreneurship as a whole has led to a place where theres a lot of good money chasing two few deals or bad investments. That is to say the growth machine is responding to bad inputs over the last 25 years. To make matters worse there are only 2 possible solutions to any problem now: Technology or Regulation. These are hot takes/ observations though. I'd love to know what the average retirement is built out of, what its return has been. What has happened Entrepreneurship over the same time, and what has happened to VC/hedge fund returns in the last 10 years. If anyone has deeper expertise I would love to learn more.
- ryandrake 2y agoIt's not quite clear what exactly they want. From the article: > As of now, there’s nothing to prevent 401(k) plans from adding private equity investments if they feel the benefits outweigh the risks. 401(k) plan administrators already can offer this crap, but nobody's asking for it, and most of them, so far, are not stupid enough to default retirement savers into them. And even if P.E. do manage to muscle/bribe their way into a 401(k) administrator's offerings, nothing stops me, as an investor, from allocating my assets into public-markets-only funds. My employer's 401(k) administrator could choose to add all sorts of crazy funds to their menu--I'm not choosing any of them. If I had more money, maybe I would even try them. Something like <1% into a crazy private equity black hole might make sense if I was already set for retirement, and could afford to lose it.
- bluGill 2y agoSo long as you get a choice. I've been in 401k where the indexfund had a high expense ratio tripple the vanguard equivelent and the other options were worse. I've at least always had an index option - many don't even get that option.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoIsnt that when you would want to move your 401k funds into an self directed IRA?
- bluGill 2y agoAs soon as I left I did. So law doesn't allow moving a 401k like that though and you can but far more into a 401k than ira so you are often stuck.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI cant quite parse what you said. My understanding is that the law does allow rollovers with no limit. The bottleneck, as I understand it, is contribution limits for people who dont have a 401k to start with. https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-tege/rollover_chart.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-tege/rollover_chart.pdf
- blindriver 2y agoThe entire wealth management industry is extremely corrupt but no one really realizes this or cares. Case in point: Sometimes you get extremely large fund managers like Fidelity buying into absolutely ridiculous investment rounds for pre-IPO companies. Why? Because the hedge funds/VCs, etc will promise Fidelity first grabs at OTHER companies in their portfolio. Like, "if you invest in X now at this ridiculous valuation, we'll let you invest in Y, Z and W as well." I've seen so much of this type of mutual backscratching in hedge funds and PE, but no one seems to care. I've seen some PE companies force one of their portfolio companies to take a very terrible loan that they didn't need at a rate that was terrible. Why? Because the bank would give better deals for their other portfolio companies now and in the future. The people left holding the bag are the investors, and Fidelity and their ilk don't give a fuck, because their AUM is huge, so what if they waste $100M on a shitty investment? SEC turns a blind eye to all these shenanigans and investment bankers make their money and fund managers make money and the only ones left holding the bag are the retail investors.
- zwilliamson 2y agoInvest in our S&P 500. It’s a win win for our country and citizens who retire. A great motivation to contribute as well.
- chgs 2y agoA pyramid scheme.
- throw0101a 2y agoAIUI, private equity is more illiquid and has less price discovery than public markets. Seems like like a bad combination to me. Ben Felix, investment officer at a Canadian wealth management firm, did a video on the topic a few years ago and concludes that net-of-fee returns aren't much better index funds—and you have to deal with illiquidity: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ik169Fd_G1E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ik169Fd_G1E He links to the published papers that he used in his analysis in the description. He also co-hosts the Rational Reminder podcast, and private equity has come up on a few episodes: * https://rationalreminder.ca/podcast-directory https://rationalreminder.ca/podcast-directory
- Jameskibi10 2y ago[flagged]
- Jameskibi10 2y ago[flagged]