5 ms·
> everyone knows all the alls on your phone On Android phones. iPhone doesn’t have this privacy deficiency.
by andsoitis 2y ago
> everyone knows all the alls on your phone
On Android phones. iPhone doesn’t have this privacy deficiency.
- piyuv 2y agoRight, only Apple knows, but it’s ok, they’re the good guys
- andrei_says_ 2y agoDefinitely not “good” but I’m still to see anything remotely resembling the complete disregard for privacy and security typical for the adtech-driven android ecosystem. Just a different business model, not a display of moral values. Sure, Pegasus exists but I don’t think it is commodified yet.
- jmb99 2y agoIgnoring the sarcasm... What evidence is there/can you present that Apple is making use of this information in a negative way? How can Apple not have a list of installed apps on your phone while maintaining basic functionality (automatic updates, reinstalling apps from backup, etc)?
- PaulRobinson 2y agoSort of. They have a list of apps you've bought/installed through app store, and they can figure out what you've deleted based on what your phone is pinging for update checks on. If they went beyond that, or disclosed that knowledge, or allowed an app to get that manifest without your permission, it would destroy their brand image built around privacy, in a way that would cause long-term irreparable damage. They decided to not comply with laws compelling them to add back doors to optional encryption on iCloud storage, rather than tarnish that image, because they know how valuable that trust is. You can dump on Apple all you want, but compared to Google who plead with people to use their browser and phones to improve adtech surveillance they can monetize, I think they're doing OK and are a lot more trustworthy.
- criddell 2y ago> they're the good guys In a relative way, they definitely are.
- ctippett 2y agoAre you sure? I know someone in adtech and I'm pretty sure Apple allows a similar app manifest that allows you to check for specific apps. I could be wrong.
- phony-account 2y ago> I know someone in adtech and I'm pretty sure Apple allows a similar app manifest that allows you to check for specific apps. I could be wrong. On iOS an app developer will need to register in advance which external applications their app intends to query, and the list needs to be very short and motivated. [1] Incidentally, “I have a friend who says...” isn’t really a good citation anywhere outside Reddit - which HN resembles more and more each day. [1] https://www.hackingwithswift.com/example-code/system/how-to-check-whether-your-other-apps-are-installed https://www.hackingwithswift.com/example-code/system/how-to-...
- ctippett 2y agoThanks for the information. I suppose a more appropriate term of phrase would've been "I'd heard anecdotally...", but I agree I was lazy with my original reply. I appreciate the feedback.
- collingreen 2y agoYou're nice. I don't appreciate the extremely tired "hn looks more and more like Reddit every day" slop and I think you handled it with grace.
- reaperman 2y agoComparing HN to resdit is explicitly against HN guidelines. Though sometimes I think the only reason it’s never “true” is because Reddit is a moving target. Both HN and reddit get worse over time, so HN never catches up to how bad Reddit is. Also the bots have not invaded HN, which is a truly massive distinction.
- wkat4242 2y agoOn iOS it's kinda worse in some ways. If you enroll into a company MDM they can see all your apps. On Android if they use the work profile (which is the standard method these days) they can only see the apps inside there.
- asah 2y agoget a separate device for work ?
- fashion-at-cost 2y agoI would have to strongly recommend nobody enroll a personal device in a company MDM. If the company needs you to have mobile connectivity that badly, they can give you a device.
- illiac786 2y agoI think it’s a personal decision. I really, really do not want to carry two huge slabs around. One is already too much. Account driven MDM enrolment pushes the Pareto front when it comes to privacy/conveniency compromises from my point of view. I will ask my IT if they have already looked at it.
- fashion-at-cost 2y agoThe benefit with the two device approach is when you can not carry both devices for the majority of the time. If i’m not explicitly on call, my work device isn’t with me. Anything anyone says to me will wait until I’m back in the office. If you have the self control to refuse to ever check Slack and disable all notifications/etc on your personal phone when not on call, this doesn’t apply as much. But for me I default to trying to stay on things and forcing myself to disconnect is a net good, even if it does mean I carry two phones at times. My pockets are large.
- neither_color 2y agoSpeaking of iPhone, Im curious about something. On occasion, I log into the [former] bird app using the web app because it's enough to check up on some key follows. Recently, they released a major update to their LLM feature and I installed the app to check it out. While I had the app installed, every time I checked the mobile website there was a large banner directing me to go to the app. Ad blockers and distraction blockers would not get rid of it. When I deleted the app again, it was gone. What gives? Why does the mobile website know whether I have the app installed? How come content+distraction blockers are enough to block all reminders to use the app when it's not installed, but are irrevocable if I have the app installed?
- js2 2y agoApple calls these Smart App Banners. Webkit cooperates with iOS to present them according to a meta tag in the page: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/webkit/promoting-apps-with-smart-app-banners https://developer.apple.com/documentation/webkit/promoting-a... You can get rid of them with the Unsmartifier extension. https://old.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/q55753/unsmartifier_safari_webextension_to_remove_smart/ https://old.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/q55753/unsmartifier_... The StopTheMadness extension can also remove them (among many other things... this extension is a must have for me): https://underpassapp.com/StopTheMadness/support-ios.html https://underpassapp.com/StopTheMadness/support-ios.html
- hnburnsy 2y ago>Apple calls these Smart App Banners. Webkit cooperates with iOS to present them according to a meta tag in the page JFC. Are they disabled if you ask for the desktop site?
- uni_baconcat 2y agoI think it won’t. I tried open X.com desktop version on iPad, Safari still showed “open with X app”.
- happyopossum 2y ago
- scarface_74 2y agoThis was somewhat mitigated on iOS a few years ago. You could try to communicate with an app via the custom URI scheme and if it succeeded, it would know you have the app installed. Twitter used this for finger printing. An app has to get a special intent and has to list the apps it wants to use it for.
- WuxiFingerHold 2y agoiPhones are less of a privacy nightmare. One of the biggest incentives for creating apps is to scrape all kind of data from the users. Look at how many apps require permission to see you contacts. And how many actually need your contacts to function. That's why I'm still a bit surprised that many seem to be surprised by findings like this one here.
- josephg 2y agoI wish there was an option for “give bogus contacts” which showed the app a list of contacts - but it was all randomly generated junk. Make it so the app can’t tell if the contacts it gets are real or fake. I read a fiction book years ago where there were cameras everywhere. To get privacy, instead of hiding their identities the protagonist paid companies to insert bogus information into the information brokers’ network. So if they tried to figure out where they were on a certain day, 20 records would match. I think this is a much more likely vision of the future.
- 3np 2y agoI guess rather than closing my Google account I should have removed the 2FA and changed the password to a weak one on the HIBP list (:
- wruza 2y agoLook at how many apps require permission to see you contacts. And how many actually need your contacts to function. That is, again, not require but ask for on iphone. I have zero non-functioning apps on my iphone due to denied access to contacts. Even a chinese bluetooth light controller doesn't dare (while refusing to work on android for the same reason). You can hate apple/iphone ecosystem all you want, but let's not sneak false claims into how they actually work.
- hk__2 2y ago> I have zero non-functioning apps on my iphone due to denied access to contacts. You don’t have WhatsApp then.
- knlam 2y agoActually you can via private API, which Apple app use all the time but forbid other app to use https://blog.verichains.io/p/technical-analysis-improper-use-of https://blog.verichains.io/p/technical-analysis-improper-use...
- buyucu 2y agoapple is the worst product for privacy. The entire ecosystem is closed source. You know nothing about what apple is doing.
- sfoley 2y agoIt's a clickbait title that needs to be changed to stop spreading misinformation.
- MBCook 2y agoThey did, long ago. I remember when it was shut down after someone made the problem public, like this. I’m amazed Android still allowed this in 2022.