13 ms·
In Jail Without a Lawyer: How a Texas Town Fails Poor Defendants
- jordanpg 2y agoThis sounds just like the kind of thing that the federal government in a robust constitutional democracy could involve themselves with. Oh wait.
- katherineingram 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- josefritzishere 2y agoTexas is not known as a bastion of civil rights.
- jp191919 2y agoDepends on the civil rights in question. Champion of some, not so much on others.
- bsder 2y agoWait until minorities start open carrying lots of guns. That's how California wound up with gun control under Saint Reagan (hack ... spit).
- richwater 2y agoYou know that Reagan hasn't been governor there in like...50 years right? If the democratic trifecta that has run the state for the past few decades actually cared more about civil rights than scary guns, they would repeal the law.
- bsder 2y agoMy point was that Republicans are hypocritical and will happily throw "core" beliefs down the drain if "those nasty other people" start taking advantage of them. I lived in Western Pennsylvania during Reagan's terms of office--I assure you that my beefs with his governance are WAY more substantive than a stupid issue like gun control.
- BeFlatXIII 2y agoAnyone remember why they were so desperate so leave Mexico to go independent and get annexed by the US?
- alabastervlog 2y agoTexas: the only US state that seceded twice to preserve slavery.
- FilosofumRex 2y agoDue process is not civil rights, it's constitutional rights and it applies equally to everyone everywhere in the US, including illegal aliens!
- nadermx 2y ago"Two men were released after The Times asked about them, half a year after their sentences had been completed." Horrific. This egregious human rights violation is something you'd think you read about in a developing nation, not a developed nation.
- kurthr 2y agoSounds really expensive for the municipality. The local jailers are probably doing well, though sticking it to the local rubes who support them.
- CobrastanJorji 2y agoMany people are happy to spend money to hurt members of out-groups.
- thrance 2y agoAnd they don't even care if it hurts them too, as long as the out-group suffers more.
- ceejayoz 2y agoIf you or I did the same thing, we'd be in jail shortly for kidnapping and false imprisonment. Here, at best, it just means the local taxpayers pay a settlement.
- nine_zeros 2y ago[flagged]
- ajsnigrutin 2y agoAs someone who was born in the country that led the third world, don't use us as comparison for stuff like that. Stuff like this is often forgotten: https://i.redd.it/lb2npuvhxobb1.jpg https://i.redd.it/lb2npuvhxobb1.jpg
- exhilaration 2y agoGift link: https://nyti.ms/421I5Ox https://nyti.ms/421I5Ox
- _p2zi 2y agoBetter Link: https://www.texastribune.org/2025/03/25/texas-jail-lawyer-maverick-county/ https://www.texastribune.org/2025/03/25/texas-jail-lawyer-ma...
- dkkergoog 2y ago[dead]
- givemeethekeys 2y agoStanding out in any way in a small, socially conservative community can have some pretty terrible consequences.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Zigurd 2y agoCan confirm. A friend of mine got death threats for reading the constitution aloud on the steps of town hall. This was not in Alabama. It was in the Massachusetts hill towns.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- StefanBatory 2y agoAn American colleague of mine got beat up in Idaho for being gay :<
- skyyler 2y agoI have friends that have been attacked on the street for being trans in San Francisco. America's a rough place to stand out.
- MaxHoppersGhost 2y agoSame as wearing a MAGA hat in San Francisco or New York City.
- givemeethekeys 2y agoEven in SF and NYC, you will find friends by wearing a MAGA hat.
- crooked-v 2y agoMerely "fails"? That sounds like apologetic underemphasis to me, like so many other Times stories. The system described is more like active oppression.
- potato3732842 2y agoHalf of the country will do olympic level mental gymnastics to justify government misdeeds so long as those misdeeds happen from behind a desk and the other half will do the same if those misdeeds happen at the hands of someone with a badge and a gun. Doesn't surprise me that a county that has both problems this exists somewhere.
- DistractionRect 2y agoIt's amazing how understated some parts are. Like they just casually mention > Like most Texas county judges, he does not have a law degree. I'm sorry, what? Anyone off the street can be a judge? That one line begs soo many questions, and at least some outrage, which is simply glossed over. Doing my own research, I guess I see why it's glossed over, because apparently this isn't uncommon - a quick search says that only 28 states require judges presiding over misdemeanors have a law degree. In 14 of the remaining 22, you can request a new trial from a lawyer-judge if you receive a jail sentence from a non lawyer-judge. I take it for granted, to me it's common sense, that a judge should a law degree. I mean, how can one preside over and act as arbiter in legal matters without knowing the law?
- ranger_danger 2y agoSome lower level judges in Texas are not required to have a law degree. https://www.txcourts.gov/media/1454620/judge-qualifications-and-selection-chart_07262022.pdf https://www.txcourts.gov/media/1454620/judge-qualifications-...
- FilosofumRex 2y agoThe jurors are the fact finders (if it's a jury trial). They don't need to know the law, it will be explained to them by the judge. In a bench trial, the judge is both the fact finder and the law interpreter. The argument in favor of non-lawyer judges is that for misdemeanor cases the facts dominate the law, ie whom do you believe, not what's larceny or drug dealing.
- kelseyfrog 2y ago[flagged]
- IdSayThatllDoIt 2y agoHi we're looking for volunteers to be incarcerated unjustly (without habeas corpus) so that when criminals perform a calculus vis a vis deciding to be poor they will be diverted from crime by the unjustness of your incarceration. Looking forward to hearing from you!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- _DeadFred_ 2y ago"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety” -- Benjamin Franklin
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- psd1 2y agoI heard "deserve neither and will lose both", which has better meter. No idea which is more accurate. I _generally_ agree with the sentiment, but Franklin's neighbours didn't have amplified music.
- selimthegrim 2y agoIt is not uncommon in certain rural Louisiana towns to have the local sheriffs/police make up some traffic offense and have you sit in the local jail for a weekend because the judge isn't going to show up until Monday if they don't like you being around there as an outsider/activist.
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoOr just don't like you and want you to lose your job when you don't show up to work Monday.
- FilosofumRex 2y agoIt's not uncommon in certain urban Massachusetts metropolitan to have the state police make up some phantom hacking & trespassing offenses and lock you up until you post $100K bail. Then have you face 35 years in prison and over a million dollars fine, if they don't like you being around there as insider-activist. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Swartz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Swartz
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mmooss 2y agoMinor traffic offenses are also used in cities to pressure, search, and arrest people that are not liked by those with power, such as minorities.
- AngryData 2y agoAnyone who has ever dealt with the US justice system as just some regular bloke knows it is broken. 90% of it is about extorting the population for funding for the courts and cops. If you can't afford a lawyer, they will provide you with a joke. And if you can afford a lawyer, now its just a question if you are willing to spend more on your lawyer than the state is hoping to extort from you. If you are, you will get off no problem, if you aren't or can't, most courts are going to try and screw you over. Oh whats that, you want to actually fight your charges in court? Now you better not lose because you are on the hook for all of the money the court wants to believe it cost them to prosecute you. Oh you don't want to risk that and just settle for whatever minor fine the law says you might owe? Don't worry, the courts will still fuck you with the addition in mandatory minimum court fees, additional fees and fines not stipulated under the law you broke, inflated "programs" that they get kickbacks from, and an even better excuse for cops in the future to try and screw you over by painting you as some wanton criminal. Just like healthcare, US justice is only for people with money.
- almostgotcaught 2y ago> Anyone who has ever dealt with the US justice system as just some regular bloke knows it is broken. and just like re healthcare, this is the rub of communicating about this: 90% (to pick a random number out of thin air) of hn's target demo has had perfect/sheltered lives and has never come into contact with the "law". so they believe all the political and institutional rhetoric around it. the other 10% know it's a myth but fail to be able to convince the 90% because it would cause deep cognitive dissonance to accept that the US is deeply deeply inequitable and unfair and that it's not accidental but systematic. when i was younger i was in jail a handful of times (not prison thankfully). it's impossible to explain to someone how fucked up it is that's never experienced it. i stopped talking about the "justice system" a long time ago to co-workers/friends/etc and i don't tell anyone about my experience (only my wife knows).
- sorcerer-mar 2y agoI think the most inconvenient thing is actually that it’s both (largely) accidental and systematic. If you go looking for the source of “evil” breaking these systems, you’ll surely find a few bad folks purposely fucking it up, but removing them is almost certainly not going to fix anything. The vast majority of these systems’ behavior (good or bad) is effectively not driven by individuals whatsoever.
- Avshalom 2y agoThe purpose of a system is what it does.
- npvrite 2y agoYou're telling me the country that illegally spies on all of us online and provides corrupt pi.. cops with qualified immunity doesn't abide by the U.S. Constitution? Say it ain't so..
- mmooss 2y agoCould any attorneys comment on why habeas corpus actions aren't used here. Isn't this sort of thing exactly what habeas is for?
- bdangubic 2y agothis is Texas :)
- praptak 2y agoYou are bringing up chess rules while the opponent flips the table and draws a knife.
- jwsteigerwalt 2y agoNo, as a society we apparently don’t really care about these inmates. The social justice movement has chosen plenty of questionable causes, but neglected ones like this one.
- mmooss 2y agoThe social justice movement has focused on prisoners, and especially on reducing incarceration and allowing former prisoners to transfer back to society successfully. The progressive DAs elected a few years ago prioritized decriminalization and deincarceration, and for formerly incarcerated, movements such as 'ban the box' (prohibiting employers to require info on past inceration) and restoring voting rights have also been priorities. There's also focus on the 13th amendment of the Constitution, which has an exception for incarcerated people to be used for forced (slave) labor.
- mmooss 2y agoAlso, ending the death penalty has been a long-time priority.
- arcbyte 2y agoHabeas corpus applies to illegal detention. After an arrest, you may be detained even without charges for a "reasonable amount of time". In most cases, this will be 48-72 hours depending on the state and your circumstances. After that "reasonable" period has passed without charges, your detention would then be illegal, and habeas corpus would be the perfect remedy. So why isn't it used? The answer is simple and twofold: 1. These people don't know to do that, let alone how. 2. They don't have the money to pay somebody who knows to do that. The final, uncomfortable answer here is that most of these people are actually guilty. If they filed the writ, it would only serve to speed up the actual filing of charges. This could be seen as a good thing, but why would you take the few thousand dollars to file habeas corpus when your family is now suffering because you aren't working anymore - and because you committed the crime you aren't going to be working for some time to come. So might as well wait out the period anyway. Is it fair or good? No, its brutal calculus.
- FilosofumRex 2y agoOf course big corp media like NYT would report on injustices in red states, especially Texas. Next door to NYT in the deep blue state of Massachusetts, two men have been arrested for simple trespass even though they had valid active IDs. Cops simply took the ID and left it out of police report, and never turned it over to the DA or the defense as exculpatory evidence. All with complete impunity and re-arrested them half a dozen times again repeating the same exact way! You'd think where gay marriage was first legalized (and has a lesbian governor), plenty lawyers would take such cases. They've had to go through six lawyers because they refused plea bargain deals so that the dirty cops would have to testify under oath. But the corrupt DA dropped each and every charge on the days of trials, to save the cops from perjury; but not until after nearly two years of fake and phony court hearings to make sure these two lose their jobs or give up their rights. You'll never read their story on the front page of NYT or any other big corp media because it happened right at the heart of Massachusetts in Cambridge/Boston on the precious private property of an elite university.
- BrenBarn 2y agoCan you provide a link to a non-big-corp-media source where we can read about it?
- FilosofumRex 2y agoNo, because cases are very recent , as in 2024-25 and one is still pending. I got it from a local court listener who said they had filed an 800 page lawsuit against alleging various undisclosed connections between major corps, elite universities and the notorious Jeffery Epstein.
- NotYourLawyer 2y agoAn 800 page lawsuit full of conspiracy theories? Sounds legit.
- lynch_autists 2y ago
- jokoon 2y ago[flagged]
- keisborg 2y agoWe do not know why you are in jail, but because you are in jail you must have done something bad. We cannot just let bad people roam freely
- skirge 2y agoUSSR explained in one sentence ;)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AStonesThrow 2y agoI feel that nolo contendre [No Contest] is underrated, and Imma keep leaning on its elegant simplicity.
- sgjohnson 2y agoFunctionally the same as pleading guilty
- sph 2y agoExpressing the wish to adopt a Latin idiom using Gen-Z slang and AAVE. A linguist could write a PhD thesis on your comment alone.
- skyyler 2y ago>A linguist could write a PhD thesis on your comment alone I have a feeling you're just tickled by someone using language you consider low-brow to express a thought that you consider high-brow. It doesn't seem that deep to me, but maybe I'm missing the fun. Can you help me understand?
- qingcharles 2y agoNot available in all states. Illinois doesn't have it.
- DebtDeflation 2y agoFun fact: In Texas, ALL traffic offenses (except for speeding and open container) are considered arrestable offenses. It's up to the discretion of the officer whether he writes you a ticket or hauls you off to jail.
- e40 2y agoAny statistics on this, say by race? That would be illuminating, I’m sure.
- alabastervlog 2y agoCops do an intentionally-terrible job of collecting statistics, and their unions vigorously resist attempts to make them do a better job. There's a Some More News episode about police car chases (TL;DW they're definitely net-harmful and should be avoided in all but the most extreme circumstances, but the public likes watching them and doesn't realize how bad they are, and police fucking love anything that gives them an excuse to Go Nuts and act like they're in an action movie, so they remain distressingly common in most states) that, as a necessary aside, also discusses how intentionally awful police stats collection is—and you'd think maybe it was just for that one issue, or SMN's researchers suck at their jobs, except you run into the exact same problem any time you look into deep reporting or research on basically any issue connected to US policing. What we have looks really bad, but also we're constantly working from (probably less-bad-looking than the median...) datasets from a few places that manage to actually collect meaningfully-complete statistics.
- throwbo 2y agonow imagine how bad things are for black people
- tehwebguy 2y agoI’m sure this can be solved with voting and protesting lol
- ddtaylor 2y agoWhat is the exact number of hours I need to stand on the side of the street in YouTube videos?
- mmooss 2y agoVoting and protesting obviously have enormous effectiveness and power, as they always have all over the world, even in non-democracies. That's how individuals without power get things done; they unite, organize, and stand together. The question is, why is it important to you to try to make those powers socially outre (which is the point of using ridicule)? What do you gain? And most importantly, cui bono? Who are you serving, intentionally or knowingly or not? I think it's probably the people with most to lose from votes and protests - those in power.
- oldjim69 2y agoAmerica's ability to fail its citizens is truly limitless
- awongh 2y agoGiven all the facts it's crazy that non-urban areas of the US are so backwards and terrible. I feel that there isn't enough of a focus on class issues in the US because that's what this is- a lot of the people involved are non-white democrats, and it's not an issue of improper/racist decisions per se- it's just literal incompetence and lack of care for anyone without resources to stand up for themselves. At least in urban areas there are some (probably upperclass) people willing to work on the most egregious human rights violations in the court system. In some town in Texas no one is around to advocate for your most basic rights.
- juujian 2y agoI'm surprised the article does not mention that there is a privately operated jail in the county.
- bashmelek 2y agoWould anyone know how we, the American public, can push for reform? Illegal immigration and social issue flag waving is in every press release but we need to demand and hold accountable lawmakers and enforcers.
- tombert 2y agoSomething I’ve joked about but also kind of depended on in my life: most, but not all, problems go away if you throw enough money at it. For the last nine years, I’ve aggressively saved money because I don’t ever want to be in a situation where I cannot buy my way out of a problem. Cynical? Absolutely, but I live in the US. I think this is terrible, but just because I don’t like it doesn’t change the fact that this is how it is at least for now.
- iwontberude 2y agoBest part is after amassing all of this wealth I don’t feel any more protected. I don’t trust brokers/banks to allow sufficient withdrawals, FDIC or NCUA to pay out in a timely way, cash to not be inflated, BTC network fees and trouble causing more lost wealth, my physical ability to protect precious metals from government or thieves, etc. The reality is we are naked and pretending otherwise is a prisoners dilemma.
- simpaticoder 2y agoLife is always a prisoner's dilemma. The real societal "choice" is which equilibrium we pick. There are only two, and one of them is significantly better. The problem, of course, is that indicidual defectors gain advantage in the cooperate-cooperate equilibrium. If they aren't dealt with quickly and meaningfully, then society quickly devolves into the other equilibrium. So really the "choice" is distributed across institutional leadership as a combination of rules and enforcement. It can tolerate some unethical choices, but not many, and not over a long period of time. I wish leaders would understand (or care about) the "environmental damage" their unethical decisions do to society at large. Personally, I blame Citizens United for doing the most damage. Because of that horrendous decision, our information space has been flooded with paid-for advocacy and sophistry of the most pernicious sort. It's like we live in an always-on disgusting court battle between two cynical, unethical lawyers willing to say or do anything to "get" the other side. There isn't sufficient reputational damage attached to this behavior, and the result is an increasingly cynical, unethical public convinced that's the only reality there is. It is utterly tragic what we have lost in so short a time.
- piokoch 2y agoThis is interesting, from the article it seems that authorities broken the law multiple times "[...] people regularly spend months behind bars without charges filed against them, much longer than state law allows." In such a litigious society like the one in the USA, what stops convicts from hiring the lawyer and suing authorities, there are many lawyers who would gladly work for success fee, if indeed the law was broken and they can expect an easy win for a huge amount that people get in US courts because, say, they spilled hot coffee on their laps and it turned out the coffee is hot?
- nemomarx 2y agoyou only get those kind of pay outs if the coffee burns you badly enough to need surgery or etc. suing usually needs you to prove a serious damage to get the jury to want to give you money a month in jail has some concrete damage but it's still going to be harder than pointing at a medical bill, right?
- linuxftw 2y ago> there are many lawyers who would gladly work for success fee For personal injuries? Absolutely. For federal civil rights violation cases? Few and far between.
- h3half 2y agoDo you expect coffee from fast food restaurants to be hot enough to send you into shock? That whole incident is a great example of a story confirming peoples' assumptions (frivolous lawsuits are everywhere) despite not being an example of that assumption
- dongkyun 2y agoI'm genuinely shocked at how "tort reform" (read: corporations trying to reduce liability as much as possible) propaganda has permeated the general consciousness. - Liebeck initially only requested McDonald's cover the medical fees from going into shock and having 3rd degree burns over her lower body (including genitalia), which McDonald's refused and only offered $800. - McDonald's had received hundreds of reports of the coffee scalding people. - Liebeck didn't get the multi-million dollar payout because the judge reduced it 640k, trebled the compensatory damages, which is incredibly normal for punitives.
- 6stringmerc 2y agoTarrant County is just as bad and Sheriff Bill Waybourn takes pride in an attitude of sadism coated under a veneer of Christianity…it’s a fatal place for some…part of my series on my first hand experience being charged with a felony I didn’t commit to satisfy Sheriff Bill’s ego: https://samhenrycliff.medium.com/tarrant-county-sheriff-bill-waybourn-wants-to-brainwash-inmates-into-christianity-d71990f134d4 https://samhenrycliff.medium.com/tarrant-county-sheriff-bill...
- hermannj314 2y agoWe are just a bit over 200 years old, give them a bit more time, the lawyers are tirelessly working to make the court system faster, cheaper, and have better outcomes they just need a bit more time. Any day now...any day...
- anon291 2y agoThere's a major bias by outlets like the NYT to paint red states in a bad light. In reality, the worst state in the country for lacking public defenders is Oregon.
- tetromino_ 2y agoLack of public defenders is the least of the problems pointed out in the article. The presence of a public defender should not be the only thing keeping the system from losing track of who has been imprisoned, why, and for how long. The presence of a public defender should not be the only thing preventing judges and prosecutors from violating the state's sentencing guidelines. The system described in the article is irredeemably fucked.
- anon291 2y agoBy no means am I excusing Texas, I'm just pointing out I've never seen any national expose on Oregon's lack of public defenders, and the fact that they end up freeing repeat offenders since they can't prosecute.
- throwawayqqq11 2y agoThe fact that you didnt see blue states mentioned is reason enough to comment something about "biased NYT". Do you see the irony?
- _p2zi 2y agoBetter non-profit source without paywalls and tracking free: https://www.texastribune.org/2025/03/25/texas-jail-lawyer-maverick-county/ https://www.texastribune.org/2025/03/25/texas-jail-lawyer-ma...
- gahhsbbs 2y ago[flagged]