7 ms·
Apple M4 MacBook Air review: I have no notes
- ksec 2y agoNo WiFi 7. I am guessing it will come next year when Apple have their own WIFi Chip going in this year iPhone 17. Hopefully with 320Mhz instead of a crippled 160Mhz. Trackpad slightly too big that causes false positive which was non-existent on older gen MacBook and Keyboard is new scissors that as less Key Travel than old scissors. No 120Hz Screen. Some people want OLED, personally I prefer LCD. But I could see how it could be thinner for lid. Quality Face Camera is not solvable yet though. May be Vapor Cooling Chamber. Still fan less but gives more longer peak workload. May be Silicon Carbon Battery in the future. Other than all these it is about as good as it get. Most of the solution above are ready today if Apple is willing bump the price up. I am thinking if Apple will drop the current M4 MacBook Air to $899 and release the M5 at $999.
- throw0101d 2y ago> No WiFi 7. I am guessing it will come next year when Apple have their own WIFi Chip going in this year iPhone 17. Hopefully with 320Mhz instead of a crippled 160Mhz. What are you transferring such that 320 channels solve a problem that 160 ones do not? At least 6E gives access to 6 Ghz bands, which tend to be more less congested (and have more available channels).
- ksec 2y agoWith 320Mhz you could get about 3Gbps Real world or roughly 300MB/s. Basically max out the 2.5Gbps Ethernet port. It is useful at times when you are transferring between NAS or on a 2.5Gbps Internet. I think it hit the sweet spot of having enough headroom that when I need it, it is there.
- tosh 2y agoI wonder if I'm imagining it but the keyboard on the M4 Air feels better than the one on the M2 Air. Travel feels "better" (I can't pinpoint how to describe it though) and the keys feel less slippery but that might just be how a clean, new keyboard feels. I could not find anything in reviews about the keyboard being improved other than that the M4 Air keyboard has a strike-through on the speaker icon on the F10 key now.
- wiredfool 2y agoMight be a difference, with the M4 marginally crisper, or a bit more haptic feedback. Or it might be that my M2 is on a stand and the M4 is on the desk. Also, the screen is totally clean. No dust or smudges.
- ksec 2y agoInteresting let me try this in Apple Store. The reason why you cant find it in reviews is because not a single reviewer in modern days actually cares about the small details anymore. And even if they do most dont care about keyboard. My instinct would be while the Key travel could remain the same ( IIRC 1mm Key travel ), but actuation force increase as it was previously something ridiculous like 35g. Even if they bring it half way back to New Magic Keyboard used on the Desktop which I believe is 1.3mm Key Travel would have been much better.
- DrillShopper 2y agoHave they removed the stupid globe key from the keyboard (or moved it)? I'm getting pretty annoyed at hitting it when I very clearly mean something else, and the menu it brings up by default is a waste of time.
- bookofjoe 2y agoI love the globe key which I've mapped to emoji
- wiredfool 2y agoMine came yesterday. It's nice enough, and exactly what one would expect from a minor speed bump. Doesn't feel any different than my work M2 Air, though it's faster? It feels a bit snappier than the M1 Air it replaced, and for the same spec it's cheaper these 3+ years later. The subtle blue is nice, it's like a colder sliver look than what it was. I'd still like one in the blue that the series 6 watches came in. I wouldn't have upgraded, except that I'm in need of a hand-me-down for a kid's laptop. Oddly, using Migration assistant -- display and internal/external keyboard settings didn't transfer over, but Apple Intelligence remained off. Chrome reset it's search engine.
- kisamoto 2y agoI am evaluating a new machine to replace my laptop & desktop for coding (Python, Go, React), data exploration, running containers and low resource business day-to-day (Microsoft Suite, Slack, light image editing etc.) - not necessarily all the same time but often.. I travel a medium amount so can't just use a desktop but running both seems cumbersome. The M4 MacBook Airs are very tempting and I think the size & weight of the 15" is not as offputting as it once was. However I agree with the criticism in this article. A lesser quality display and lacking a little power (M4 Pro option would be nice). A 14" MacBook Pro is the current draw. Slightly heavier but option for M4 Pro as well as more memory (up to 48GB) as well as nanotexture for out and about. I love the idea of the Framework 13" machines with Ubuntu. Almost same weight as a 13" Air and with strong upgradeability. Disadvantages (to me) are the battery life on Linux is significantly less than an Apple device (although hard to find exact numbers), and even with the new Ryzen AI Max processors and the DDR5 memory, speed is much lower compared to the M-series soldered on a chip (although I'm open to counter points that this difference in speed is not worth it). The Apple software ecosystem is a soft grab but to be honest there are options to Apple Photos which is the one I use the most.
- a3w 2y agoLacking power? Below buying the very best Intel or AMD CPU which needs a new mainboard and RAM, I seem to never get any PC upgrades in the region of even an M3. For mobile, this kind of performance is insane. I usually am happy if it is not a netbook CPU, since my 4th gen i5 dualcore+HT is still up to anything I want to do with it.
- gessha 2y agoThat’s something that I’m puzzled about. If we take a look at both PC and Mac Geekbench results which use the exact same Intel CPU as a baseline, Macs wipe the floor with any Intel or AMD professor. Am I reading it wrong or? [1] https://browser.geekbench.com/processor-benchmarks https://browser.geekbench.com/processor-benchmarks [2] https://browser.geekbench.com/mac-benchmarks https://browser.geekbench.com/mac-benchmarks
- 2y ago
- CaRDiaK 2y agoWhat I find disappointing about this revision is that the Air is portrayed as Apple's most portable machine, yet it still lacks the nano-texture option. I understand that this distinction between the Air and the Pro is intentional, but it seems somewhat counterintuitive.
- jmull 2y agoThe nano-texture isn't really that useful in my experience... not really much better than the anti-reflective screen and you still end up adjusting angles. The best reason to get it is just because you prefer it.
- kubb 2y agoI just wish they could run Windows games. Many games could comfortably run on this hardware, they just don't for software nonsense reasons. For example Octopath Traveler 2 - a game which isn't graphics intensive at all. It runs on Windows and Linux via SteamOS, so why can't I have it on my MacBook.
- wklauss 2y agoIf it runs on Linux, it should be fairly easy to run it on MacOS through the Game Porting Toolkit. Crossover (or Porting Kit if you don't want to pay for Crossover) should handle it.
- Gazoche 2y agoRunning modern games on Linux requires Vulkan, which has iffy support in MacOS at best (and MacOS isn’t officially supported by Valve’s compatibility tools).
- wklauss 2y agoIt is iffy but serviceable. In this case, seems like Octopath Traveller 2 Windows version works well with GPTK. I haven't tried but Whisky, or Porting Kit should be able to handle it. Reddit has some people running it at good fps.
- p_ing 2y agoWindows and Linux are running OT2 in the application's native instruction set, for one. But if you want to try, you can use Whiskey. https://getwhisky.app/ https://getwhisky.app/
- akyuu 2y agoI agree. But regarding this specific game, it seems to work through Crossover (emulation) and Parallels (virtualization). You can also try Whisky and VMware Fusion as free alternatives. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iysOgfeWz1M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iysOgfeWz1M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZzzPtHcw6k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZzzPtHcw6k
- someperson 2y agoI wish they'd add a USB C port on the right-hand side of the Air. Even moving one of the two on the left would be nice.
- sangeeth96 2y agoThis has been my one wish as well, even if they stubbornly refuse to improve it in many other ways.
- karmakaze 2y agoThat might be my top inconvenience as well. I wanted the larger screen but didn't want the weight of the MacBook Pro so got the M3 Air. The other thing the article doesn't mention is the sound of the speakers. They might be ok compared to PC laptops but isn't close compared to those in the MacBook Pros--I miss it more than any other difference. I knew this going in so I'm fine with it and just tend to use earphones more.
- whitepoplar 2y agoPersonal wish list: - Right-side USB-C - Slightly brighter display - Slightly wider hinge angle - Option for nano-texture display, just like the MBP - WiFi 7
- nanook 2y agoApparently the M4 Air has a slightly wider hinge angle than the M3 Air
- wiredfool 2y agoHuh. Definitely wider than the M2.
- whitepoplar 2y agoTIL! Any link to this?
- asplake 2y agoDedicated HDMI port
- martijn_himself 2y agoI owned a M1 MacBook Air and I was similarly impressed by everything mentioned in this review. MacOS coming from Windows, not so much. A menu bar 'orphaned' from the application window? A 'File Explorer' (Finder) lacking basic functionality. Dragging a file download onto the Applications folder to install software (what?). Plugging in a 2K monitor to find it is unable to display at native resolution without installing third party apps. MacOS feels like it is some relic from the past. EDIT: judging from the comments here, I accept it may be part unfamiliarity. Maybe I should give it another go. What resources would you recommend for someone new to MacOS?
- postexitus 2y agoMenu bar "orphaned" from application window is a feature - not a bug. It's intentionally in a fixed location on the screen so you can find it every time you look for it. (I am an original Amigan - Workbench had the same approach, but only visible when you right click - oh I miss my Amiga) While Windows approach of attaching the menu bar to application window was popular for a while, I am now crying just looking at Chrome window and seeing no menu at all. I don't even mention Ribbon blasphemy.
- p_ing 2y ago> It's intentionally in a fixed location on the screen so you can find it every time you look for it. Which is a disadvantage when working with multiple applications as it forces an application switch before you can access the menu, rather than in windows where if you have your app windows staggered, you can immediately click into the other application's menu.
- WillAdams 2y agoIsn't Windows click-to-focus? AFAICT, it's not possible to directly access the menu, so it's still two steps: - switch to the second app to bring it to the fore/make it active - activate the menu I find this faster on a Mac since the menu target is larger.
- api 2y agoI'd like a 64GiB RAM and a 4-8TiB SSD option, but that might actually be problematic in the Air form factor. I'm sure board space is limited. Also increases power consumption a bit since that's more hot silicon.
- sgarland 2y agoIt would also cut into MBP sales, I’d think. They’re always going to want to maintain product differentiation.
- api 2y agoFor MBP give me one with 128GiB or even 192GiB RAM that I can run big local LLMs on. I have an M1 Max MBP with 64GiB and I can run decently sized local models but 128GiB or more would run more serious ones.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoWhile you could run larger models with 128GB, I feel like 64GB is just the amount needed to run models at a reasonable speed with a M Max (I have an M3 Max 64GB).
- api 2y agoThat's kinda why I'd like a 64GiB M4 Air. 64 is the magic number for local LLMs of any reasonable capability. Example: deepseek-coder can do unit tests, gemma3 can summarize PDFs and stuff pretty well, etc. You can't do much with LLMs with only 32GiB, just run baby ones.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoM4 is going to be too weak on GPU, even an M4 pro is probably not going to get you far. If you go with an M4, 16 or 32 is fine. An M1/M2/M3/M4 Max is probably what you need minimum to run quantized 72b models, where 64GB is needed.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]