12 ms·
Firmware update bricks HP printers, makes them unable to use HP cartridges
- hyperman1 2y agoWat's your update strategy today, HN? Main possibilities seem to be 1) The faster, the better I am protected. 2) I wait a few days/weeks. The second mouse gets the cheese.
- bobmcnamara 2y ago0) Don't buy from companies that treat me like a criminal. 1) Manufacture's suggested update schedule.
- JadeNB 2y ago> 0) Don't buy from companies that treat me like a criminal. So don't buy printers, basically? That's sarcasm, but, non-sarcastically, do you know any printer companies that (make decent printers and) have basic respect for their users?
- kstrauser 2y agoI'm still going with Brother. There was a recent claim that they disabled 3rd party toners but there were lots of anecdotal stories of people who had no such trouble with it. If Brother ever truly loses the plot, my next printer will be the local FedEx store. Life's too short to fight hostile hardware.
- llm_nerd 2y agoI have a Brother multifunction colour inkjet (MFC-J995DW). I generally only printed in B&W on the very rare occasion I printed, so when a colour ran out (usually because one of my children errantly printed some giant colour thing) it was perfectly happy to keep printing black content using the giant, very full black cartridge. A recent (as in the past two years) update removed that benefit. Now it fully refuses to function in any capacity if a colour cartridge is out. It won't let me print fully-black content, and it won't even let me scan. So Brother are no longer one of the good guys.
- ndiddy 2y agoBrother laser printers are cheap and extremely reliable if you only need to print in black and white. Because they use toner, there's no ink to dry up so they can go months without printing and not clog. The catch is that Brother started putting chips in their toner cartridges a few years ago to keep track of toner usage (they previously used a mechanical gear system). You can still buy and use third-party toner but most third-party toner cartridges use small batteries on their chips and the toner will stop working if the battery runs out (this is the source of all the rumors about various firmware updates stopping third-party toner from working). However, even if you stick to official toner, the cost per page is still fairly low. If you need to print in color, you can buy an inkjet printer that uses ink tanks instead of cartridges. However, you generally should be printing at least once per week as otherwise you'll need to waste a bunch of ink on head cleaning cycles. The other thing is that all inkjet printers (including ink tanks) clean their heads by spraying ink into a pad called the "waste ink reservoir". After a couple years of use, the pad will become saturated with ink and the printer will refuse to work. Most printers have the pad integrated into the printer, so you have to throw out the printer at this point. Look for a printer with a "maintenance box", which is really the waste ink pad in a user-replaceable plastic cartridge.
- TacticalCoder 2y ago[dead]
- bobmcnamara 2y agoHP LaserJet from the period where they still made atomic clocks. Did need to upgrade the memory and added a network card when my computer no longer had a parallel port. Today, Epson for inkjet and Brother for laser.
- pabs3 2y agoProbably none do, likely all of them are printing tracking dots. https://web.archive.org/web/20190805123707/http://www.seeingyellow.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20190805123707/http://www.seeing... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Printer_tracking_dots https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Printer_tracking_dots
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y agoYou can take different approaches on different things. A browser is probably the most exposed piece of software in your system, so maybe be aggressive with updates on that, but a printer is unlikely to be exposed to untrusted inputs so I would question whether there's any point updating it ever unless you have a specific issue you're trying to fix.
- tart-lemonade 2y agoThe last time I tried updating an HP printer, it locked up and printed half a ream of jibberish before I pulled the plug on it. Now, I just put printers on a firewalled VLAN and call it a day.
- dylan604 2y agoThis is pretty much my take on it. Once I get a printer installed and working, that's the last time I look at the software for it. I'm also not a heavy printer, so my printer tends to be unplugged more than it's actually turned on. My publicly facing servers get patched as soon as I'm aware there are updates available. If it borks anything, I just turn to the previous backup (not that this has ever actually happened).
- smodo 2y ago3) Completely disconnect my printer from the web and live with this small discomfort. HP burned me too many times.
- wtallis 2y agoIOT devices (including printers) get firewalled to have no access outside my LAN, and I don't let my PCs run the kind of software that would fetch a firmware update and push it to another device without prompting me. The first line of security should always be not connecting it to the Internet unnecessarily. This is especially important when the list of probable attackers starts (and ends) with the manufacturer.
- zubiaur 2y agoAbsolutely. Rarely do I need a device to have access to the internet. Printers, speakers, sensors, vacuum cleaners, dishwasher. Nothing gets to talk to the outside world. They are appliances, and if they work they work. Unless something is broken, I leave them alone. The only exception so far has been the robot lawn mower, that supposedly adapts to weather forecast. But it will be jailed soon, too.
- litoE 2y agoUse parental controls at the router to prevent the printer from accessing anything outside our in-house network. If it acts like a child, treat it like one.
- officeplant 2y agoUpdate OS's regularly for everyday machines / Offline machines you don't want changes to affect. Update Phones regularly. Give work software a 6 month-1 year lead before updating because they will break something (Looking at you Autodesk & Bluebeam). And never buy an HP Printer which should come before any talks of when to update.
- runeofdoom 2y ago3) I use out of date hardware and software as much as possible, being rigorously paranoid to never expose it to anything risky, and keep it locked down as much as possible. (Which means little Internet use... which is arguably a feature of the process.) If the manufacturer doesn't support the software anymore (or better yet, is out of business) the odds of malicious updates go way down.
- doublepg23 2y agoI update somewhat promptly, often using automatic updates and stop buying manufacturers that push bad updates.
- pabs3 2y ago1) Switch to an open source alternative that is security supported. 2) Otherwise, never update it and never allow it to be connected to the network.
- PaulHoule 2y ago... that's one reason I got an Epson ET-8550 https://epson.com/For-Work/Printers/Inkjet/EcoTank-Photo-ET-8550-All-in-One-Wide-format-Supertank-Printer/p/C11CJ21201 https://epson.com/For-Work/Printers/Inkjet/EcoTank-Photo-ET-...
- Animats 2y agoI have an EcoTank printer. It keeps telling me it has a firmware update available, but I won't let it update.
- washadjeffmad 2y agoThere are no cartridges in an EcoTank. Is there something in particular you're afraid of happening?
- Animats 2y agoWho knows what they'd come up with? A requirement for an Epson account? Mandatory approved service replacement of the head cleaning brush?
- simoncion 2y agoIf one's complex paper-handling and mark-delivery robot is working fine, why change the software inside it? In other words; software for robots can have bugs just like software for anything else, so why take the risk if the thing's doing what you need it to and the replacement software doesn't solve any problems you have?
- DecentShoes 2y agoI'm almost at the point where I consider any type of firmware update for anything to be actively hostile and to be avoided if at all possible with the sole exception of patches for specific, significant security bugs. In 2017, Apple put out a new iPhone, and in the same week, made my 1 year old iPhone unusable on purpose overnight to make me buy a new one. My S23 Ultra got a software update that removed features and now I can't use YouTube. I can't just not install updates, because it will nag me constantly and leave a permanent notification at all times that I cannot remove. Sony famously removed OtherOS from existing PS3s. I'm not sure what the solution is but letting companies destroy their old product so you go buy a new one, whether carelessness or malice is unacceptable.
- markus_zhang 2y agoI almost never do firmware update, even for security reasons. You never know what's in the patch, and your data is already sold left and right anyway. I consider myself fully hacked 10 times, and every social media company knows me better than my wife.
- iforgotpassword 2y agoYou also never know what's in the original firmware, so why trust it more than the update, security-wise?
- markus_zhang 2y agoI don't trust it anyway. I just use it.
- brokenmachine 2y agoIn the update notes for my banking app, it listed the changes as "Minor update to keep the app running smoothly". If it's running smoothly, why does it need an update? I guess it's like an engine that needs fresh oil.
- 2y ago
- neilv 2y agoMost recent discussion on printer DRM firmware update jerkiness: Brother accused of locking down third-party printer ink cartridges (tomshardware.com) 536 points by m463 5 days ago | 336 comments | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43261933 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43261933
- rpcope1 2y agoI see Brother is going with the Lexmark strategy. Maybe they'll wake up before they end up in as bad if shape as Lexmark has wound up in.
- ajnin 2y agoTo give a voice to both sides, Brother denies it made any of the alleged firmware changes. Also Louis Rossman's source for his claims is a Reddit post from 2022. Source : https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2025/03/brother-denies-using-firmware-updates-to-brick-printers-with-third-party-ink/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2025/03/brother-denies-using...
- neilv 2y agoI wonder whether HP will get its comeuppance, for years of jerkiness, when an LLM is involved in most printer purchasing decisions, and that LLM will have been trained on Reddit, HN, etc. Or will consumer "AI" services offer "integrated placement" for brands, which also has the effect of neutering valid criticism of the brand?
- g-mork 2y agothe annual LLM subscription came free with the printer
- zoeysmithe 2y agoProbably never. The home printer market I imagine isn't anything anyone new wants to risk money in, and if they did, they'd just end up copying much what HP is doing anyway. Also I doubt anyone is giving some LLM their credit card and all printer brands have bad reputations online. People post when motivated and they're motivated to complain, not praise. In the meantime, I can still buy a Brother brand printer that seems to not have all the HP issues, or less so.
- dylan604 2y agoIf someone created and sold a printer that did not care about the ink that was used, the people of the interwebs would go crazy in the forums when the shitty ink they used did not work correctly in the printer. This is not a defense for DRM'd cartridges, but just an honest look at how people will behave. The support for the company with a open ink policy would be astronomical for the complaints they will receive. Sometimes, people/users are the problem but there's no way to tell that to the customer without you being the dick. "the customer is always right" is such a bullshit fallacy that makes operating a business near impossible.
- spicybright 2y agoI feel like the overlap of people savvy enough to want re-fillable carts and people not understanding what "only fill with high quality ink" means so they jump to blame the company is pretty small.
- runeofdoom 2y agoSeems like the next logical step, really.
- criddell 2y agoHas the meaning of bricks changed? It doesn't sound like these printers are permanently broken.
- SAI_Peregrinus 2y agoYes, years ago. People haven't used it solely to mean permanently broken for a long time, it now also means "temporarily inoperable" or "broken beyond the skill of one particular user to fix it". Much like how "literally" now gets used to mean "figuratively" the use of hyperbole has turned "bricked" into meaning "not actually bricked".
- Gigachad 2y agoNothing is permanently broken though. At some point you can start reflashing chips and replacing internal components. Bricked has always meant the device is inoperable and beyond easy repair.
- tredre3 2y agoWhen the flashing process fails and it leaves the flash corrupted, it's often impossible to do any further flashing attempts. Good products have an immutable factory partition to recover, but not all of them do. So I think it's unfair to claim that those devices aren't bricked just because yes, in theory, you can open the device and reflash the chip over SPI or JTAG.
- blueflow 2y agoYour parent implied that whether a device is bricked depends on the skillset of the user. So if its subjective, there isn't much point in arguing "when" its bricked, right?
- crazygringo 2y agoOn social media, maybe. I would expect HN to maintain the distinction where "brick" means it won't work at all due to a software malfunction, and can't be restored to a working state via a hard reset button or software update via WiFi/USB. Its technical meaning to engineers hasn't changed, and HN is a technical site full of engineers.
- dalemhurley 2y agoAfter years of dodgy HP printers and their very expensive inks, I brought an Epson EcoTank. It cost a lot more but it prints are amazing and the Ink lasts forever. It took 2 years to get through the included ink.
- ForOldHack 2y agoHP brings a broad new meaning to Dodgy. Shotty and shabby. Its wholly unethical how hey manage their affairs, but now to hear they are disabling their own printers, oh my how unfortunate, and I shall decline the gift of any, and inform potential buyers of their ... unwholesomeness. I was going to limit myself to brothers, but I hear they are now on the 'short term profits over everything.' type of CRM. Customer Relation Managment: Screw you.
- genewitch 2y agoI tell people not to buy HP and to buy a brother, but what did they change? Mine works fine, even with third party cartridges. Printer ink has always been hilariously overpriced. A gallon of IBM check sorting machine ink was $25. And that's magnetic ink. Extract as much value from your users as possible I guess. If some subset of users figure out how to at least lube up, first, disable their hardware.
- codr7 2y agoMost of this world is firmly on the 'short term profits over everything' bandwagon by now.
- ajnin 2y agoFWIW Brother denies it made any of the customer-hostile firmware updates Louis Rossman recently accused them of, according to this other Ars Technica article: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2025/03/brother-denies-using-firmware-updates-to-brick-printers-with-third-party-ink/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2025/03/brother-denies-using...
- sedatk 2y agoMy local Costco always has Epson EcoTanks on sale, FWIW.
- paulydavis 2y agoSo what if I update the device without asking?
- anonymousiam 2y agoHP has always (after the Compaq merger) had unethical people running the company. I stopped buying their printers after LaserJet4. I did however have one of their DDS4 tape drives that I had paid over $1k for, about 25 years ago. I stupidly updated the firmware shortly after the warranty period was over, and then immediately noticed a new loud pinging sound whenever it loaded or ejected the cartridge. It died within a few days of the upgrade, and I always suspected that HP had deliberately killed it. I bought a refurbished unit from them for another big chunk of money, because I was locked into the media platform. I haven't bought an HP product since.
- seoulbigchris 2y agoI had a LaserJet III that lasted forever, like over ten years. It just wouldn't die.
- einr 2y agoI took a LaserJet 4050 (introduced 1997, I think ours might have been made in 1999) out of service (active, networked office use) just a couple of years ago. Not because it stopped working, because it still printed like nobody's business, but just because it was surplus to requirements. I believe this was just about the last generation of LaserJet that was Actually Good.
- seoulbigchris 2y agoI also just remembered, these things had option slots. Which I had to use on my III, because I needed more memory to print many kinds of documents / images (I vaguely remember it may have been for printing from AutoCAD). Can't remember a modern printer having add-on circuit boards these days.
- skipps 2y agoWe should all be using a community-designed open-source printer using environmentally safe ink or toner. I blame us for our laziness. Let HP be HP.
- BrenBarn 2y agoRelated: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43298106 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43298106
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sushidev 2y agoI think mine is broke as well. Where to join the class action lawsuit?
- atoav 2y agoLet's hope HP didn't donate to your political leadership.
- 1oooqooq 2y agocan't wait for a smart lawyer realize they can use the millennium digital act to create very profitable class action lawsuits. "have you or your loved ones been harmed by a firmware, installed on a computer system you own and didn't authorized access to the manufacturer? click the link on the video"
- nosioptar 2y agoIt'd be fun to see a prosecutor with the balls to charge a company under the CFAA.
- tacker2000 2y agoI stopped buying and recommending HP stuff years ago, back when their driver EXE swelled to 300 MBs and included all sorts of crapware...
- b3lvedere 2y agoMost printers work great using their basic PCL 5 or 6 drivers. When customers ask printer advice it kina depends on the importance and priority, but usually leasing laser MFPs is the most hassle free option for companies since it reduces the hassle immensly.
- JohnFen 2y agoYou actually install printer manufacturer drivers? You're a braver person than I.
- grishka 2y agoRelatedly, I remember reading that it's unrealistic to build an open-source 2D printer because of how much research and very specific manufacturing that requires. But, what if someone designs an open-source replacement motherboard for some popular commercially available printer model? How much of the "secret sauce" is in the firmware, if any? How easy would that be to replicate independently?
- MSFT_Edging 2y agoI don't know this for sure(conjecture based on other knowledge), but due to security functions mandated in printers(dot fingerprinting, preventing currency recreation, etc), I would assume other components besides ink cartridges are cryptographically paired. I'd love for this to not be the case though. If this isn't the case, then it would still be a large effort to both design the control software that controls the intricate mechanical parts, as well as providing drivers. I think it would be totally doable for a single printer or a family of like printers in the scope of an opensource project with enough motivated contributors, but 2D printers are some of the least sexy pieces of technology out there so the allure would be missing. I for one love 2D printers. Anything that brings the digital world into our plane, so maybe I should look into this.....
- yencabulator 2y agoLast I looked, you can fully avoid the security stuff by being monochrome instead of color, so that's an easy way out. There's also no public mention of the logic being mandatory to implement -- literally, find me a law that requires it -- so you can probably start doing business without it just fine, and in fact the mechanism is patented so you can't just implement it on your own! At some point, some anti-forging governmental department or business lobby will contact you, and that likely won't happen until after you've already succeeded. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EURion_constellation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EURion_constellation
- jmptable 2y agoI think it's unrealistic to build a cost-competitive open-source 2D printer. But it's relatively easy to just build your own printer. The parts that have the most R&D tied up in them (and so are unlikely to be replicated from scratch easily) are the inkjet heads and the ink's composition. If you can get those off the shelf then you can easily DIY everything else. There is a large existing industrial market for inkjet heads and ink. Many industrial inkjet heads are very easy to drive and have freely available data sheets. But they cost >$500 to a few $1k each and you probably want 4 for CMYK. I just built a custom printer in a few weeks for an art project with some of these (specifically, one called the Xaar128) driven by an RP2040. The experience definitely gave me a sense of awe and resigned respect for my humble desktop printer.
- curtisszmania 2y ago[dead]
- phkahler 2y agoFor those who don't want to apply firmware updates like this, you might want to use Linux. No printer company is going to work with your distro to automatically install their firmware updates. If your printer works today it's going to work tomorrow.
- aendruk 2y agoThe general infrastructure for this is already in place and widely used: https://fwupd.org/lvfs/vendors/ https://fwupd.org/lvfs/vendors/ HP already uses this for firmware updates to keyboards and mice. Of course distros typically acquire consent before applying them.
- pabs3 2y agoWhat do the updates for keyboards and mice do?!
- yencabulator 2y agoIntegrate LLM? (I wish I was kidding. https://www.logitech.com/en-us/software/logi-ai-prompt-builder.html https://www.logitech.com/en-us/software/logi-ai-prompt-build...)
- pabs3 2y agoThat stuff would run under Windows, not the mouse/keyboard firmware right?
- yencabulator 2y agoThe gimmick appears to be in some sort of spyware that wants to sniff all keyboard input and record the screen, bundled as a mouse driver.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- fcpk 2y agoMy old inkjet recently gave me so much trouble with dried up expensive cartridges that when a super good HP offer came late at night from my next day delivery online shop for a newer generation laser at a ridiculously low price and I jumped on it. I instantly regretted after printing 100 pages and discovered the evil move: they deliver the laser printer with "introductory" toners that print 1/2 of the normal toner, and 1/4th of the big capacity. A quick google search revealed that while I got the printer with a nice rebate for 140USD... the toners will cost 280USD for a whole set(1500 pages version), and 480USD for the XL(3000 pages) version which is quite insane. It's sad because the quality of print of this laser outperforms most I've used in the past(the color printing is fabulous), and the software seems to run really smoothly on it. It prints fast and well, it just happens to have an extremely customer hostile company behind it. Thankfully apparently there is now a technique to extract chips from your existing toners in order to transfer them to a new set of generic toners... and one can only hope that the "terrajet" chips will soon be RE'ed by someone so we can get normal generics. For reference, the printer is a LaserJet Pro 3302FDW, that uses 219/219X terrajet toners.
- mass_and_energy 2y agoIs there a strong reason people still support HP's printers after so many horror stories?