8 ms·
The XB-70 (2019)
- sgt101 2y agoDoes anyone know why they went for six engines rather than four bigger ones? Was there a specific reason for that config?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Syonyk 2y agoThat era of aviation was nuts. I wish I was around for it. Men with slide rules working out the limits of material science, aerodynamics, and everything else, all at once. Because it wasn't enough to just push one limit, you had to push half a dozen others to get things to that first limit. And the rate of advance was just staggering. The XB70 flew in late 1964. Concorde was doing revenue flights in 1976, cruising at Mach 2, with passengers being served luxury food. > The Air Force learned that pushing the technological envelope resulted in plane that was difficult to build, difficult to maintain, difficult to fly, and perhaps even more importantly, was incredibly expensive; the program cost nearly 1.5 billion dollars, or around 11 million dollars per flight. And nothing has changed. Pushing the limits is expensive. Always has been, always will be.
- mandevil 2y agoMy favorite bit of design from this era went something like this: "ooohhh, we need something that can handle high heat. How about if we made it radioactive?" and so Mag-Thor was born (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mag-Thor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mag-Thor): Magnesium plus Thorium. It's creep resistant up to 350C! And it's only mildly radioactive! That's not a problem, right? Actually used on the BOMARC and D-21's ramjet engines- which is why you don't originals of their engines on display anywhere.
- dogma1138 2y agoMag-Thor is interesting it actually has rather poor overall thermal characteristic compared to most metals since its melting point is only circa 650c pretty much the same as magnesium but it basically shrugs any heat upto 350-400c depending on the alloy so it doesn’t changes its dimensions or becomes susceptible to mechanical deformation (it’s basically as hard at 350c at it is at room temp). So it’s useful but only for very specific applications unlike say titanium. And today we have super alloys like inconel which can hold back heat creep up to 650c and it’s annealing starts at almost 900c.
- retrocryptid 2y agoThey tell the most pernicious lies about radiation.
- skhr0680 2y agoFun fact: The real-life inventor of the neutron bomb, Samuel T. Cohen, loved “Repo Man”!
- slow_typist 2y agoThe sheer amount of gas this plane must have carried in order to fulfil its mission…
- Syonyk 2y agoPer Wikipedia, the XB70 carried: 300,000 pounds (140,000 kg) / 46,745 US gal (38,923 imp gal; 176,950 L), on a maximum takeoff weight of 542,000 lb - so about 55% of takeoff weight was fuel. A 747-8I carries up to 63,034 gallons, or about 400k pounds, on a max takeoff weight of 987,000 pounds, or about 42% of takeoff weight. Interestingly, the ranges are about the same. The XB70's combat radius (there and back) is 3,725 nm, for a straight line range of 7450 nm, the 747-8I's range is 7730 nm. High altitude supersonic flight is actually fairly efficient... if you can handle it.
- nocoiner 2y agoWas the XB-70 capable of inflight refueling? On a quick look, I can’t tell if that was the plan, or if it was going to be a one-way trip (optimistically landing in Turkey or something to refuel, but realistically…).
- Syonyk 2y agoI don't believe it was capable of it, which is why it was so massive. The SR-71, which required inflight refueling repeatedly, only held 80k pounds of fuel (about 12k gallons). I don't have any good sense of fuel burn vs speed either, but in general, jets like to run high and fast. The old Lear 23s burned about as much fuel (pounds per hour) idling on the ground as they did at cruise, and I think the SR-71 (which mostly used the turbojets to keep the afterburners lit, at cruise...) fuel economy up high was quite good. Apparently the major problem with performance was keeping it from overspeeding - left to their own devices, the engine (... entire engine assembly, however long it was) was running so efficiently that they just wanted to go.
- mandevil 2y agoThe actually built XB-70's- the two prototypes- did not have a refueling receptacle. Production models would have had a boom receptacle just like the B-47, B-52 and B-58 did. It would have gone in the upper fuselage about where the delta wing starts.
- runjake 2y agoAs someone who once worked on B-52s, I find it amusing how many "successors" it has outlasted. And I know why, because I worked on many of those, too. It has taught me to be skeptical of unproven claims and promises, especially when someone is particularly passionate about them. Also that simplicity is king. Complexity is the enemy. I have great respect for the XB-70. It's the only strategic bomber I haven't worked on or even seen in person, and it holds a certain "alternate reality" mystique for me.
- Enginerrrd 2y ago> Also that simplicity is king. Complexity is the enemy. As someone that has managed engineering teams for large projects, I 100% agree. One of the issues with computers IMO is that it has made bad engineering easier. Back when you had to check everything with a slide-rule, you had a real appreciation for the skill and engineering prowess and experience to make things absolutely dead simple.
- bdamm 2y agoTrue, but also modeling and iteration does lead you to unexpected solutions that can in turn solve complex problems that you couldn't have imagined could be solved. Landing rockets being an easy one, but that kind of iterative approach has been put to work in all kinds of fields.
- colechristensen 2y agoOne of the sources of this, which is now over, was the exponential increase in computing power. You could add complexity and your code would always run faster anyway, one of the popular benchmarks saw worse results on average than last year which never happened before. There are a lot of reasons for it some more speculative than others, and clearly computers will get faster in the future. But still. No longer can software engineers arbitrarily add bloat and just get away with it. https://www.tomsguide.com/computing/cpus/new-benchmark-shows-cpus-are-getting-slower-for-the-first-time-in-history-what-is-going-on https://www.tomsguide.com/computing/cpus/new-benchmark-shows...
- Zeetah 2y ago
- ge96 2y agoA beautiful plane, shame those 6 engines in line is unreal to see. Similar vibe would be the B1-lancer for engine although in 2s
- bediger4000 2y agoThe Wings Over the Rockies museum on the east side of Denver CO has a B-1A (!!!) on display. Landing gear is really tall, you can walk under the wings to see the engines.
- ge96 2y agoI watched a really cool walk around video of it on YT It's crazy it can carry as much payload as a B-52 if I recall right
- bpoyner 2y agoThe have a XB-70 at the Wright-Patterson USAF Museum in Dayton. I was blown away looking at the engines. Highly recommended museum if you're into aviation, it's huge so give yourself plenty of time.
- ben7799 2y agoI have a love/hate relationship with this plane. In 2014 I got to visit the AF Museum in Dayton, OH. With all the exceptional exhibits there it is completely obvious the XB-70 is THE crown jewel in that museum. And it snowed while we were visiting and they shut down the hangar with the XB-70 because it required a shuttle ride. So now I still have on my bucket list to see it.
- yabones 2y agoGo back, it's so worth it. I stood under those six massive turbojets and looked up in absolute awe. It's a miracle that they didn't cut it up for scrap and left a really fabulous museum piece when the project ended.
- pinewurst 2y agoBecause we're not the British or Canadians who felt they had to make their military R&D decisions irreversible by destroying all the evidence (e.g. TSR2, Avro Arrow, etc).
- dangermouse 2y agoIn fact there is a TSR-2 at the Imperial War Museum Duxford.
- pinewurst 2y agoIt was a violation of orders as all airframes were explicitly ordered to be destroyed and burned.
- lizknope 2y agoI went in 2010. Took the bus onto the air base to the experimental plane hangar. We only had 1 hour. I could have easily spent 3 hours there. I mainly wanted to see the YF-23 but here's a pic I took with a fisheye lens of the back of the YF-23 with the XB-70 above. I think they have since moved the planes to a different hangar. https://imgur.com/a/yf-23-xb-70-above-GFZDaYy https://imgur.com/a/yf-23-xb-70-above-GFZDaYy
- ferguess_k 2y agoThe Cold War era was the dream of engineers of all participant countries, I figured. Are we close to another one? Just wanna make sure it doesn't turn into a hot one.
- retrocryptid 2y agoyup, there was just so much money flowing around. it was like the dot com era for aeronautical engineers and machinists.
- tqi 2y ago"got a job with the Flight Propulsion Division of General Electric in Evendale (just outside of Cincinnati), initially working night shift in the Controls and Accessories department... the engine required the efforts of hundreds of engineers to design everything from a new turbofan and compressor, to new fire-suppression systems, to a special high-temperature fuel. Exactly what part my dad worked on is unclear; I always thought it was an oil pan, but my older brother was sure it was an oil pump." This small detail peaked my curiosity - did GE have white collar workers on the night shift? If so, that is super interesting to me.
- Aloha 2y agoYes, there is often manufacturing engineers on duty 24/7 and of course, line management.
- 0xffff2 2y agoAt that point in the story, the dad didn't have a degree yet. I know _a lot_ fewer people did back then, but it's not entirely clear to me that he was working a white-collar job at that point.
- retrocryptid 2y agoI remember seeing this beast at the Air Force 25th anniversary in '72 at wright pat. Pretty sure the one I saw didn't ever fly again.
- agloe_dreams 2y agoThe one you saw was the only one left after the insane accident that destroyed the other. It is still on display in Dayton.
- ellisd 2y agoThe ejection capsule design for the XB-70 is some next level engineering. Your seat would move backward into a capsule before ejection to survive the cruising altitudes of 70k feet / Mach 3. https://www.generalstaff.org/CDA/Air/B-70/XB-70_Escape_System_Paper_FEB-1963.pdf https://www.generalstaff.org/CDA/Air/B-70/XB-70_Escape_Syste...
- BonoboIO 2y agoThat is a really good explanation and reference. I like those old documents.
- low_tech_love 2y ago“…Eisenhower, the newly-elected president, was working on something a little bigger: a national security policy to counter the growing Soviet military threat in Europe.” The good old days.
- FpUser 2y agoI normally do not read blogs. Yours is different. I loved your stories. Salut to your dad. Life well lived. Also thanks for pointing to Vivian Della Chiesa. Listened few songs on Youtube - great artist.
- geoffeg 2y agoI've seen the XB-70 at the Dayton Air Force Museum and each time it seems both massive and relatively svelte. Like some kind of shape that I can't quite fully understand. Really cool plane to see, especially among all the other aircraft from that era of aviation.
- rayiner 2y agoThe 1960s airplanes sometimes seem anachronistic. Both the XB-70 and SR71 were mach 3+ airplanes that flew in 1964. That was five years before the 747.
- hollerith 2y agoWe no longer needed the XB-70 when ICBMs got good (basically when they changed from liquid fuel to solid fuel). We no longer needed the SR71 when reconnaissance satellites got good.
- mandevil 2y agoWhat ended the XB-70 was SAM's, not ICBM's so much. It was much easier for the Soviets to build and deploy the SA-5 Gammon (aka the S-200 Angara, basically a perfect a B-70 killer) than it would be to build and operate a significant fleet of B-70's. This was actually so clear to the USAF that about five years after the B-70 was canceled (about the time the first XB-70 took flight), when the Soviets actually started to deploy thousands of SA-5 across the Soviet Union, the USAF was convinced it must have ABM capabilities. It wouldn't make sense for the Soviets to use ~10% of their annual concrete production to defend against a threat that the US had already canceled, so they thought that the SA-5 had to be a super-useful national ABM capability (they had already evaluated that the ABM-1 system under construction around Moscow, the so called Triad system, as overmatched by the existing Minuteman I deployments, but thousands of missiles required more even more thousands of warheads to exhaust). In response, the USAF suddenly expressed significant interest in MIRV technology, and the Minuteman III program began, and ICBM warhead numbers started to get really insane. Cite: https://www.thespacereview.com/article/3677/1 https://www.thespacereview.com/article/3677/1
- taylorius 2y agoBeautiful! Both the story, and the aircraft.
- curtisszmania 2y ago[dead]
- rsynnott 2y agoThis, if anything, understates how weird the XB-70 was; in particular it skims right over https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zip_fuel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zip_fuel
- fooblaster 2y agoDissatisfied with the progress, though, just weeks later the Pentagon canceled the HEF-3-powered J93 engine program and limited the Valkyrie program to the use of JP-4 fuel only. Testimony by USAF scientists before Congressional committees revealed that the technical hurdles and the operating cost of using HEF-3 as a jet fuel were prohibitive given the defense budget of the day.
- alpaccount 2y agoGot chills seeing the first pic. What a beautiful piece of machinery.