5 ms·
A lot of people are going to sneer at this because they like seeing rich tech people fail, but I think it’s great that he’s trying something. Results don’t nee
by Aurornis 2y ago
A lot of people are going to sneer at this because they like seeing rich tech people fail, but I think it’s great that he’s trying something.
Results don’t need to be dramatic or come right away. Even failure is a learning experience. Improving agriculture is a worthy goal, even if it’s not immediately successful.
- actionfromafar 2y ago[flagged]
- leovingi 2y agoCan you please post links to some of that cheap farmland available right now because of DOGE?
- duxup 2y agoI think the idea is that farm subsidies potentially being cut would make land available. That would take time.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoIt might not take a long time; many farmers are on a knife's edge in terms of solvency.
- duxup 2y agoMost farmers are petty involved in year to year fluctuations and financing things so hard to know how many would stick it out in hopes of legislation…. Granted this is all a hypothetical.
- mistrial9 2y agoalso a few suicides.. the process does take time
- selectodude 2y ago[dead]
- cjbgkagh 2y agoUSAID spends ~$2B p.a. on food from US farmers, I assume the presumption that without that backdoor subsidiary farms making less money will be cheaper. Though total output value is ~$200 p.a. so that’s %1, but price is set at the margin so actual loss could be greater. I think this loss might already be less than the loss from the effects of ozempic. Edit: looking at total US farm subsidies from taxpayers is around $30B which is ~%15.
- actionfromafar 2y agoWill see if I can scrounge up some links, but farmers are paid (just an example, there are many environmental and other programs) federal money to do stuff like leave strips of land uncultivated to reduce fertilizer run-off from fields. These payments are stopped and farmers are left to foot the bill. Also, technically, if a contract is for 3 years and a farmer is 1 year in but decide to stop because the money isn't coming in, now the farmer is in violation! On a related note: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43162502 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43162502
- bpodgursky 2y ago[flagged]
- mikeyouse 2y agoHe owns an entire 90,000 acre Hawaiian island and multiple mega yachts.. they’re not sneering because he tried, they’re sneering because he’s delusional that he thought that one of the oldest and largest sectors of the economy just needed an untrained rich guy to fly in and save the day.
- bpodgursky 2y agoYes, they are sneering because he didn't buy another mega yacht instead. > one of the oldest and largest sectors of the economy just needed an untrained rich guy to fly in and save the day This is just investing. There are many old moribund sectors of the economy that could use investors not focused on quarterly profits. This is not a controversial statement in any other context, you just don't like it because it's Ellison doing it.
- mikeyouse 2y agoI don’t care one way or another to be honest - he’s free to waste his money however he wants. It’s just amusing after all his proclamations about reinventing farming and changing agriculture that they’re stuck at the level of early 2010s Dutch greenhouses.. It’s a shame that rather than just hire experts and give them access to the unlimited funding to advance the field he attempted to reinvent the wheel with ‘disrupters’ but it is what it is
- jimt1234 2y ago> ...an investment that could improve life for billions of people. This is the problem I have with startups/tech that intend to revolutionize farming: it's rarely to improve life for people, but rather to increase profits. Perhaps Ellison does, indeed, intend to use this farming tech to help bring food to hungry people around the world - and that would be great! But I'm skeptical; Larry's never struck me as an altruistic dude.
- teach 2y agoI agree with this, even if it has a little XKCD "struggle no more; I'm here to solve it with algorithms" energy[0]. I think Bill Gates is much better at finding people with the right expertise who are already solving a problem and just adding more funding and I think the results speak for themselves. [0] https://xkcd.com/1831/ https://xkcd.com/1831/
- davidhunter 2y agoBill Gates also lost money on greenhouses [0][1] [0] https://www.reuters.com/technology/bill-gates-green-tech-fund-bets-silicon-valley-farming-robots-2021-09-22/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/bill-gates-green-tech-fun... [1] https://techcrunch.com/2022/11/03/iron-ox-lays-off-50-amounting-to-nearly-half-its-staff/ https://techcrunch.com/2022/11/03/iron-ox-lays-off-50-amount...
- codr7 2y agoIt's pretty obvious to me that this is all about profits and public image, it's not like they suddenly started to give a damn about other people.
- MisterTea 2y ago> but I think it’s great that he’s trying something. That something is throwing AI and robots at dirt as if there's some kind of labor and knowledge gap in farming that needs a rich guy to throw tech at it.
- biophysboy 2y agoAgtech is still very much a field: imaging, genomics, etc. Its just a very difficult problem; half a billion is chump change in biology
- arrosenberg 2y ago> A lot of people are going to sneer at this because they like seeing rich tech people fail, but I think it’s great that he’s trying something. Is it? It feels like the same money could be given out to thousands of people who actually understand farming to run little experiments. That's how America is supposed to work. Relying on Larry Ellison to succeed in a field he has no experience or instincts by throwing money at it seems like a terrible strategy.
- diob 2y agoPeople underestimate how much our regressive tax structure and lax antitrust enforcement are holding back innovation. If we didn’t allow such massive wealth concentration, we'd see more competition and breakthroughs.
- tbrownaw 2y agoRight, of course, excessive concentration of wealth is the only thing preventing another Bell Labs or Xerox PARC from bringing us tomorrow's future today.
- citadel_melon 2y agoI don’t understand the sarcasm. More competition in the marketplace would create more innovation: I don’t think this should be controversial.
- nottorp 2y agoEven Bell Labs and Xerox PARC are two different entities. These days Bell and Xerox would maybe merge to "consolidate their market position" and fire half of the researchers to show cost savings at the next board meeting.
- snailmailstare 2y agoI hear a lot about how ahead of their time they were and how everything since is based on them.. But it seems like newer things since then are all being built on the shoulders of a generation of thousands of giants instead of a generation where we can only identify 2.
- sympil 2y agoA lot of people are going to sneer at this because they like seeing rich tech people fail, but I think it’s great that he’s trying something. It is much more efficient for society in the form of its government to fund research. We should not leave it up to rich people to decide whether or not research is conducted.
- pfdietz 2y agoIs it? Is government really structured to do this funding in an efficient manner? Or do we end up with atrociously useless investments that are made as vehicles for delivery of pork barrel spending?
- CalChris 2y agoVastly most of basic research is publicly funded.
- pfdietz 2y agoI wasn't addressing the question of quantity of funding, but rather the efficiency of the funding. Is the research valuable, or is it just pretend-value from spending intended as pork? A lot of government funded research is of that kind. More generally: the market has a way of evaluating research value (did it lead to profit) while the government's actions have no reality check. They depend on the wisdom of officials who inevitably have conflicts of interest.
- CalChris 2y ago> A lot of government funded research is of that kind. A lot of everything is of that kind. Larry's folly is of that kind. Most defense spending is of that kind. Most startups are of that kind. BTW, my brother was one of those officials, judging grants at the NSF in DC. But that was only after a career in physics at Sandia.
- pfdietz 2y ago
- beepbooptheory 2y agoWhatever your commitments, seeing a rich person fail is kinda definitionally humorous. Something is funny often because of juxtaposition, contradiction. It is why it is the emperor who has no clothes, not the poor beggar; or why its "your momma" and not you yourself.
- burnte 2y agoI think how Larry Ellison has decided to run Oracle is both atrocious, and his own choice. I think him experimenting with better agriculture is awesome and even failing in it can lead to progress as now we have ruled somethings out. Few people are truly all bad or all good.
- alexashka 2y agoIt's great if you treat Larry like a toddler. Anything a toddler tries is great. Larry is an adult last I checked :) What people find distasteful in my circles is when rich people do nothing to solve systemic problems within society and instead go about acting as benevolent do-gooders selectively handing out resources to causes they feel an affinity for. When rich folks act this way - we end up with a bored and cruel aristocracy and piss poor working people, like England. I don't think that's good for anyone.
- internet_points 2y ago> Improving agriculture is a worthy goal, even if it’s not immediately successful. That very much depends on the cost. History is littered with tragically failed experiments in improving farming ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dust_Bowl https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dust_Bowl https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_farming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_farming are some of the worst and most well known, but there are many others).