15 ms·
Breaking into apartment buildings in five minutes on my phone
- bgirard 2y ago> Hirsch replies stating that these vulnerable systems are not following manufacturers’ recommendations to change the default password These manufacturers’ recommendations are not acceptable. They should mandate a non-default secure password before allowing the system to be used.
- pavel_lishin 2y agoEven my parents & grandparents modems/routers each have a unique password printed on the bottom! There's just no excuse for this.
- nottorp 2y agoOh speaking of which. A lot of places i rented on holidays had internet access with that default unique password. Which is a pain to type on your phone and laptop when you get there. Did anyone think to at least try to add OCR-ing those labels on our phones to automatically enter the wifi password?
- ghaff 2y agoA lot of inns and B&Bs in tiny towns etc. have these complicated passwords that seem like overkill. You're probably right that they're some sort of default. Even if they're not 12345, it seems as if they could be something pretty simple and that would be fine.
- axus 2y agoQR codes?
- nottorp 2y ago> QR codes? How do you change the label on the router that got installed 8 years ago and is working fine? Especially since the owner of the cabin in the woods that you just rented for the weekend is into ... renting cabins in the woods, not geekery. > have these complicated passwords that seem like overkill. You're probably right that they're some sort of default. It is the default. If you find their router you'll find that overkill password printed on a label on the bottom. More enlightened ISPs give you extra stickers with the same info that you can put on the fridge or somewhere like that.
- wrs 2y agoWe used this for our guests at home. https://qifi.org/ https://qifi.org/
- nottorp 2y agoOh pretty. Now I just need to tell all the hosts in my future holidays about those :)
- dghlsakjg 2y agoThere is a wifi credentials QR code standard that can be used to pass the network name, and authentication details. Anyone can generate one, here's a generator app: https://www.qr-code-generator.com/solutions/wifi-qr-code/ https://www.qr-code-generator.com/solutions/wifi-qr-code/ Most modern phones recognize the standard and can be used through the native camera app.
- jajko 2y agoYes I saw it literally few days ago when visiting relative (not even airbnb just her home), so easy to do yet it never occured to me.
- datadrivenangel 2y agoI have a framed wifi QR code in my house. It's great. Looks like a photo on the wall.
- happyopossum 2y ago>Did anyone think to at least try to add OCR-ing those labels on our phones to automatically enter the wifi password? You can do that easily on iOS, I'd be surprised if Android didn't allow it as well... Tap in the password field, tap Autofill from the popup, and tap Scan Text.
- lostlogin 2y agoSlightly off topic, but sharing WiFi passwords on iOS is so very user friendly.
- bildung 2y agoHow does it work in iOS? On Android User A taps on the wifi they are connected to and gets a QR code, and User B taps on the icon for scanning wifi QR codes, so one tap each once you are in your wifi settings.
- arjie 2y agoOn iOS, the guest attempts to connect and anyone with them in their contacts list is prompted to share. The common use case of a friend visiting is very simple. If you want to share a different network, there's a similar flow to the Android one: * Go to Wi-Fi in the Passwords app * Select the Wi-Fi network you want to share * Share Network QR Code
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y agoSo they know when you're trying to access a wifi network?
- mcculley 2y agoIf you are near them, yes.
- gryn 2y agogoogle lenses works for this as an OCR copy & paste
- rbalicki 2y agoYou can generate and print a QR code. It's quite a nice solution
- fragmede 2y agohttps://qifi.org/ https://qifi.org/
- prophesi 2y agoOddly enough, these default unique passwords usually are in the format of word+word+digit+digit+digit. If you look up the model, it won't take long to find the word list they use and can trivially bruteforce it. So even then, I'd recommend changing it, or push for these companies to provide generated passwords with a much larger key space.
- jack_pp 2y agoIdk in Romania routers come with random passwords. https://imgur.com/a/x915ZfO https://imgur.com/a/x915ZfO
- yesthis 2y agofunction generatePassword() { // comply with Romanian regulations return "gaGc52eP" }
- rad_gruchalski 2y agoThis function doesn’t evaluate, something something expected expression of }, premature end of file.
- bongodongobob 2y agoThat's usually the wifi password, not the admin password.
- robbiewxyz 2y agoTheir routers only have this feature because the internet providers who sell those routers pay for bandwidth themselves lol. If residential internet plans sold on a pay-per-byte basis you can bet routers’d still ship with non-unique passwords.
- schnable 2y agoNah, it's to deflect customer support contacts. Which often in the case of ISPs, results in a truck roll which is hugely expensive.
- jonathantf2 2y agoIt's also the law in the EU.
- adonovan 2y agoThe manual clearly says you need to press the "do not explode" button if you don't want the car to explode. It is conveniently located under the rear seats.
- psobot 2y agoViscount has hilariously bad security. I used to live in a building in Toronto that used Viscount infrared fobs for access control. They were no more secure than TV remotes; no rolling codes, no encryption, nothing. An attacker could easily sit nearby with an IR receiver and collect everyone's fob codes at a distance, allowing access to all floors. Needless to say, I moved.
- ghaff 2y agoI'm not going to especially defend but you have a way more sophisticated model of how most burglars work than is almost certainly the case.
- reaperducer 2y agoExactly. This article should be titled "I figured out a really obtuse way to break into apartment buildings." A rock will get the job done in a fraction of the time. It's like all those nobodies on HN who go through all kinds of software gymnastics to secure their phone against imaginary "threat actors," when a mugger is just going to keep twisting their arm behind their back until they enter their PIN.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- badgersnake 2y agoThis is way better than a rock. It raises no suspicion and leaves no trace. Maybe it doesn’t matter for burglary, as you’re probably going to take things anyway, but if you want access anyone knowing you were there this is gold.
- Neonlicht 2y agoIn fairness I think that these "locked doors" are to keep the homeless/drug users out or kids starting fires not really burglars.
- 2y ago
- pavel_lishin 2y ago> 2025-01-29: Hirsch replies stating that these vulnerable systems are not following manufacturers’ recommendations to change the default password Ah, yes. It's the children who are wrong.
- ihaveone 2y agoHoly freaking crap. ALL OF THESE ARE ONLINE. "It's possible" to log in to the first result with the default password. If anyone wants, perhaps login, change the password and make a new client as the password or something. This is going to get bad FAST.
- azinman2 2y agoI would say this is highly irresponsible of the researcher to expose this publicly. These are people’s homes, along with their PII and locations. The residents didn’t choose this system, their building just uses it. They don’t even know that their info is being leaked, nor that the doors to their places were just rendered neutered. If something bad happens because of this…
- smallerfish 2y agoI flagged it for this reason.
- tiborsaas 2y agoI second this. Just because it feels right to them as "I've reported it, It's not on me anymore...", doesn't mean he should enable bored people to revoke access cards, jam elevators, etc.
- Freak_NL 2y agoThat depends on the individual's weighing of the various factors and their personal moral position. If someone wants to prevent a bunch of easy break-ins where the method of entry won't get noticed in most cases, and they feel that the discomfort of denying access for a bit (impacting hundreds of people perhaps) outweighs the trauma of being robbed (maybe impacting just a few), than doing that might be the only morally defensible position to take. For all we know they actually are planning to hammer the open installations until they get fixed to prevent the bigger harm. Other people will shrug and move on after trying everything they can via the proper channels. And then of course there are the assholes who will just do it because it entertains them.
- michaelt 2y ago> Default credentials that “should” be changed, with no requirement or explanation of how to do so. Surely no building managers ever leave the defaults, right? And even if they did, they’d surely have no reason to expose this thing to the Internet, right? My theory is this is one of the reasons so many internet-of-things devices nowerdays omit any sort of offline/local network control. No default passwords, no ports you can forward without knowing what you're doing, all the credentials sorted out on a cloud server.
- craftkiller 2y agoConsumer routers have had this issue solved for ages: you generate a random password and put it physically on the device.
- ghaff 2y agoI don't want some complicated random password. At least where I live, my router password is a very modest security shim to protect against very random casual access. If I have a visitor who needs WiFi access, I want to give them an easy password to type in.
- craftkiller 2y agoYou can always change the passwords. I was bringing this up as a solution to the default passwords issue. You don't want to have a static default password used by everyone, so you need the initial password to be randomized. People are dumb so you need to print it on the device. There is no need to default to cloud-based authentication to close the default password security hole.
- barbazoo 2y agoWifi password != admin password. The admin password should be random and then you can change it when you take ownership of the device.
- marsovo 2y agoSo change it afterwards. Good defaults are important. If someone doesn't change it, it's important that they be on the right path instead of...this one. (See also: opt-in versus opt-out for retirement plans, organ donation...heck, even this from yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43144611 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43144611)
- thomasjudge 2y agoIsn't logging into any system unauthorized - in practice - a violation of the Computer Fraud & Abuse Act?
- roguecoder 2y agoThe EFF has a good guide about the relevant laws: https://clinic.cyber.harvard.edu/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/Security_Researchers_Guide-2.pdf https://clinic.cyber.harvard.edu/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/...
- Validark 2y agoSuch ridiculous laws. The real crime here is that the software vendor lets people use the software without creating a new password. Even that is suspect, since I bet most people's password would be 1234 anyway. So really they should force people to set up passkeys to access the system. Or, cut out the setup, and just send them a couple of USB's which allow them to access the system. This "manufacturer" is not doing its due diligence in any way, shape, or form. They are the ones who should face jail time for not implementing bare minimum security practices. The idea that the guy revealing a complete lack of security is committing a crime is like saying a guy informing someone that they're naked is guilty of forcibly stripping that person. Or that telling someone there's a giant red button that drains the landlord's bank account is guilty of pressing it. Maybe they should remove the giant red button?! Or at least put it in a locked room?
- kube-system 2y agoIt might be harsh, but the general premise is good that we should not blame the victims of unauthorized access to computer systems. We should also, as you point out, require vendors to implement minimum security standards.
- mihaaly 2y agoIt is, like getting into a home with open doors without the consent of the inhabitants. Which is keeping away only the honest and polite persons.
- INGSOCIALITE 2y agoi worked as an engineer in an industry that required on-site access to buildings all over manhattan, some residential. all you have to do is hit a couple random buttons on the intercom and 100% of the time one of them would just buzz the lock
- mvandermeulen 2y agoThis is pretty much all it takes in any western country. Some areas might require a little more effort but nothing substantial. In fairness, the blame for this kind of enabling attitude is mostly attributable to me locking myself out of the building and having to buzz my long suffering neighbours at all kinds of ungodly hours. Proud moments.
- megous 2y agoCould you also lock out specific residents? Or get their daily home arrival patterns for the last few years? Or find unused flats to squat in? IoT still wins. :)
- ecshafer 2y agoMany many many years ago I worked at basically an MSP for telcos on the helpdesk. So customers would call their telco or isp for help and that would be routed to us. Anyways this one small isp with idk 10k customers had deployed their routers to customers with the default username/password and remote authentication enabled. A single script from a bad actor logged into all of the routers, changed credentials, and iirc updated dns settings so they lost internet, phone, tv. Cue 10k people calling as we had to basically walk through everyone one by one on changing the credentials and updating their config.
- myself248 2y agoWas that enough pain to force some sort of change in how the things were deployed thereafter?
- ecshafer 2y agoSort of, they changed it to a different username password that was the same on every box. So it wasn't easily findable from the internet but the same issue could have potentially happened again.
- Agingcoder 2y agoAfter watching a lot of tv series, my non techie wife has come to the conclusion that real life systems are trivial to hack : just click ‘skip password’, or ‘password override’, or just use ‘password’ as a password. It seems she’s almost right !
- assimpleaspossi 2y agoRoad with a guy to visit a friend in a gated community. We didn't know the access code for the gate but the guy I was with is an Amazon delivery driver. "Let's see if I can't get us in," he said. He got out of the car, walked over to the access panel and looked on top, bottom and sides. Then he punched in some numbers and the gate opened. Turns out, so many people in gated communities and apartment complexes order things from Amazon, and other delivery services, and want front door delivery but don't give them any way to get in. Eventually, some frustrated driver who gets the code will write it on the side of the access panel to help everyone out. "Apartments are awful," he said. "College campuses are the bane of our existence. You would think that college kids would be smart about these things but they are the absolute worst."
- _fat_santa 2y agoMy parents live in a very upscale country club community down in Florida and their gate security is laughable. They assign every household a 4 digit code to enter the community. Given how many homes are in this community, entering any 4 digit code > 1000 and < 2000 will work.
- jimt1234 2y agoMy girlfriend lives in an upscale, gated community. Her HOA has done the exact opposite. They change the gate code weekly as way to "protect" themselves from this situation. However, it's kinda had the opposite effect - tailgating has become totally acceptable, even the norm, as people can't keep up with the gate code changes. Amazon drivers usually just sit outside for a minute or two, then tailgate into the neighborhood.
- reaperman 2y agoThe only gated community / apartment complex's I've ever seen where that was not normal are a subset of the ones that have an on-duty guard - specifically the subset with guards who recognize all the occupants and take the information of anyone they don't recognize.
- fortran77 2y agoI just tried it (via Tor) and was able to get into the first 5 that duckduckgo found. Someone had been there before me and (apparently) changed names of things. (I looked but didn't touch.)
- OsrsNeedsf2P 2y ago> fortran77 5 hours ago: > I just tried it (via Tor) [...] Opsec: Failed
- fortran77 2y agoWell, I still have plausible deniability if other people tried it via Tor, too.
- huang_chung 2y agoInteresting story but a CVE for this is a bit melodramatic and why no one takes security folk seriously (cry wolf too many times). OpenWRT ships with no password at all (!) with full root access on default install. The situation is the same: they politely suggest you change it from the default (blank) password but do not force you to do so. By this logic every OpenWRT install (and many other softwares) dating back many years should be subject to CVE.
- NRv9tR 2y agoI assume you have to be on that network to access the login. I'm 95% sure it the UI/admin is not accessible to the internet by default... but also, yes that shit should be way better. Even Comcast and other ISPs have done better than this for a decade or more now.
- huang_chung 2y ago[flagged]
- anilakar 2y agoYup, worth a CWE but not a CVE.
- Neonlicht 2y agoYou can get in the building with a bit of social engineering. I live in an apartment complex. Put on a DHL or Dominos cap and nobody cares. It's your front door lock that is the real barrier.
- paxys 2y agoNowadays you don't even need that. Just carry a brown paper bag. Every mid-large sized building gets a food delivery every 5 minutes, and no one looks twice.
- stevage 2y agoJesus. The whole system seems to have been designed to maximise the damage that can be caused with minimal effort. Why are these admin pages web findable? Why is there a public database of them? Why have they tried so hard to make it so accessible? Why is there no security? Arrrrrgggh.
- bluedino 2y agoLove this stuff, reminds me of old 2600 articles
- kingkulk 2y agoExposing a loophole in the best way. Great job
- malaya_zemlya 2y agoThere was a time where somebody in SF has figured admin access code to older apartment intercoms (I believe they were manufactured by Linear and maybe other companies too). These intercoms would call the programmed in phone number whenever you type in the apartment access code at the door. So what they did is add a new fake tenant with a premium 1-900 number and used the intercom to call it, earning themseleves a bit of cash. Naturally, landlords had to foot the bill.
- gosub100 2y agoI did something similar to my highschool in the 90s. They had a free student phone in the office. It had long distance blocked on it, but I learned you could circumvent the block using those 1010-321 and other long distance prefixes. Some of them had $5 access fees, billed once, in addition to the per minute rate. I called several of these and prided myself on getting the phone removed from the office for a few months.
- fourteenrhinos 2y agoCan you elaborate on why having the phone removed was itself a source of pride? I do appreciate the hacking around aspect, particularly with respect to old phone systems, but having a free student phone removed seems like it would be a bad thing for everyone, no?
- BizarroLand 2y agoBreaking the rules so bad that the ability to even interact with the thing the rule was made for was taken away?
- gosub100 2y agoI was a rebellious teen. I'm not proud of it now.
- miki123211 2y agoThe Polish spin on this were unsecured office landlines that used radio for some reason, I don't remember if that was for cordless handsets or just an access technology. People would walk around big cities, usually on Friday evenings, radio scanner out, trying to find one of these. They would then dial a premium-rate number, preferably on more than one line. In most cases nobody would realize that something was up until Monday morning, and if they had a way to disconnect the calls before then, not until the bill came. You could do similar shenanigans with unsecured PBXs or insecure answering machines that had a "call my mobile if somebody leaves a message" feature.
- teddyh 2y agoThat sounds complicated and too much work. I’d prefer <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rctzi66kCX4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rctzi66kCX4>
- MBCook 2y agoI’ve always wondered: how do all these things end up in Google? What’s submitting the link, or public thing links to it?
- userbinator 2y agoGoogle's own browser phones home with the URLs you put in it, presumably for malware scanning or some other "security"-excuse reason. I don't remember if there was a setting to stop that from happening, or if there was, whether the setting may still exist today, but that would be a good way for them to get otherwise-private URLs.
- MBCook 2y agoThat’s all I can think of. That or perhaps emails (in gmail or another web mailed viewed by Chrome) that contained the links.
- aqueueaqueue 2y agoThe sinister part is you get a log of everyone's keyswipes. You can plan a burglary, stalk someone, construct or destroy an alibi and so on.
- 0xbadcafebee 2y agoThis is the kind of thing where responsible disclosure is really very important. Let's say you're a woman. A woman who lives in one of these apartment complexes. A woman with a stalker. A stalker who has threatened to kill you, multiple times. Who has shown up at your apartment, but was rebuffed by the building security. One day you wake up and find out that a "security researcher" found a way that anyone in the world can get into the building at any time, in addition to looking up who lives at each address. And it turns out the security researcher waited only two months (including over christmas break) to try to resolve the issue in a way that would not leave the existing buildings exposed. If I were that woman, and something happened to me as a result of this disclosure, and assuming I was still alive, I would, at a minimum, sue the shit out of that security researcher.
- inetknght 2y agoI'm disappointed you're downvoted. I know a woman who is the exact situation you describe (sans hacker); their ex-husband has made threats to her life and has made attempts to act on those threats. She's extremely privacy sensitive as a result. You are right. But remember you can be sued for anything, and further remember that suing someone doesn't mean you have good cause to win. For corollaries, see good samaritan laws [0]: (specifically about Texas) https://www.uslawshield.com/can-get-sued-good-samaritan-laws-texas/ https://www.uslawshield.com/can-get-sued-good-samaritan-laws... [1]: https://www.themirror.com/news/weird-news/i-cpr-crash-victim-saved-352724 https://www.themirror.com/news/weird-news/i-cpr-crash-victim... [2]: (More generally) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_Samaritan_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_Samaritan_law So it stands to reason that a white hat hacker who, in good faith, publicly releases information in an attempt to get things fixed shouldn't face negative repercussion.
- 0xbadcafebee 2y agoBut they should face consequences if they were irresponsible, regardless of intention. If you found the nuclear launch codes, and you're pretty sure nobody else has found them, should you wait a week and then release them, because you had a good faith interest in exposing this hole? No, of course not, that'd be insane. What one should do in that situation is wait, and try to get the codes changed. You shouldn't wait forever, because someone else might find them. But you also should wait for as long as you reasonably can, because of how severe the risk of releasing is. This risk analysis is the calculus of responsible disclosure. Any ethical security researcher should err on the side of avoiding harm, making every effort to ensure the disclosure doesn't harm unnecessarily. For most researchers, that means waiting more than 2 months over a holiday season, even if it was just a bug in a javascript library or something. Knowingly exposing the privacy and security of thousands of people is pretty fucked up, imo. I'm pretty sure they could have come up with a half dozen different ways to try and get the issue resolved, if not through the company directly, then through individual apartment complexes, law enforcement, etc. Looking at this closer, it's actually worse than I originally thought. You can see what time everyone comes home every day, what their weekly routines are. So you know when they're gone, so you can rob their house. Or you know when they come home, so you know when you can attack them. This is fucking chilling.
- paxys 2y agoBreaking into an apartment building in 30 seconds without a phone: Carry a brown paper (food delivery) bag. Stand by the intercom pretending to press buttons. When someone comes in or out, tailgate behind them and say "thanks". 9 out of 10 times they'll even hold the door open for you.
- albert_e 2y agoWe laugh at hollwood movies where the protagonist calls his hacker sidekick and says "get me into this building. quick." and the friend goes "one sec. done." and click! the door opens.
- mrweasel 2y agoTry going to YouTube and look for The Lock Picking Lawyer or McNally. Both are really skilled lock pickers, but the majority of the locks they review and demos does not require anything near their skills level to break. Half of all padlocks seems to be susceptible to comb picking, which require zero skill. It was apparently never difficult to break into buildings, physical security has always been pretty poor. Unless you have an armed guard patrolling your property, there's no real reason to believe it secured beyond the fact that most people weren't going to break in anyway, or simply can't be bothered.
- userbinator 2y agoIf I'm reading this correctly, is this just the "public" areas of apartments, and not the doors to the actual suites themselves? There's a huge difference between getting access to those two.
- levocardia 2y agoEven with just the public area, you can still: - Steal packages - Access storage areas and bike lockers - Walk down the hall and check which doors aren't locked - Smash the coin-operated laundry machines and steal the money - Just wait for someone to open their door (All of which happened in an apartment building I lived in a few years ago)
- nutthugger 2y agofinally some actual hacking on this site
- lenerdenator 2y agoThe more I look at electronic access systems for buildings, the more I appreciate a manual lock that takes multiple minutes to pick and makes the intruder create a large noise or light signature while doing so.
- schnable 2y agoI suspect putting these on the internet is recommended so they can push firmware updates, and perhaps it's even required to make the thing work.
- gz5 2y agofrom the timeline: >2025-01-29: Hirsch replies stating that these vulnerable systems are not following manufacturers’ recommendations to change the default password this is why i like the 'secure by design' or 'secure by default' responsibility being put on connected product providers, e.g. EU CRA and implied in US M-22-09. i am always fearful of unintended consequences of regulation like this, but it does seem necessary in today's world.
- hackburg 2y ago[dead]
- Elizabeth13 2y ago[flagged]
- Elizabeth13 2y ago[flagged]
- hackburg 2y ago[dead]