6 ms·
It's ok boys, now you're allowed to pirate all books ever published as long as you don't seed.
by IshKebab 2y ago
It's ok boys, now you're allowed to pirate all books ever published as long as you don't seed.
- phony-account 2y agoAlmost the worst thing about Amazon and this gouging way of renting books is that it ‘legitimizes’ piracy. My partner works in publishing and we know a lot of authors. If you think piracy is going to sustain that industry and give you and your children books to read in the years and decades to come, you’re very mistaken.
- DetroitThrow 2y agoPlenty of books I've tried to purchase epub or PDFs of only have Kindle rental versions. If the publishers of these authors wanted me to let me own a PDF, I'd gladly purchase, but until they actually do that I have several easy alternatives to getting sucked into Amazon's ridiculous ecosystem. And this is a larger subset of books I want to buy than I would want, surprisingly.
- jazz9k 2y agoI say the same thing about GNU licensed software: if the author just gave me my preferred licensing terms, I wouldn't be forced to use it in proprietary software without compenstion.
- OKRainbowKid 2y agoHow is pirating books to read them by myself comparable to proactively selling other people's work?
- drawkward 2y agoNeither belonged to you in the first place.
- OKRainbowKid 2y agoAnd yet, one of these options is much more benign than the other.
- jazz9k 2y agonope.
- OKRainbowKid 2y agoIndeed, it is!
- fc417fc802 2y ago> without compenstion A key point here is that GP expressed a willingness to pay. The analogy would be attempting to license a piece of GPL software that you've decided to integrate into your proprietary stack and being outright refused for ideological reasons. Still illegal but people are probably going to perceive it a bit differently.
- InsideOutSanta 2y agoAs an author, I barely get any money from Amazon. In some cases, with the cut Amazon and the publisher take, I make a few pennies on a $30 book. If you buy my book directly from my publisher's website, I'm extremely grateful. I get a fair amount for that. If you buy it from a local bookstore, at least they benefit. But if you buy it from Amazon, you might as well just get it from Anna's Archive. At least you're not supporting the jungle.
- Flimm 2y agoI would love to buy ebooks directly from publishers, but publishers generally sell ebooks with DRM just as bad as Amazon's DRM, if not worse. If publishers insist on vendor lock-in, then I might as well stick with Kindle where most of my ebook collection already is.
- GolfPopper 2y agoYou can buy a copy of the ebook from the publisher (or whatever source the author tells you is the best for them), and then acquire a useable copy by other means. You get an ebook, the author (and publisher) gets a sale.
- Marsymars 2y agoCan you clarify if you're talking about physical and/or ebooks?
- InsideOutSanta 2y agoBoth.
- llm_trw 2y agoI contacted a well known author about the shit latex rendering of his ebooks on Amazon. He said sorry and send me the a pdf copy he build with my name on all the pages. I really like the fact that I have a book dedicated to me by the author, but why the fuck do we need Amazon in this interaction?
- mystraline 2y agoWhat's that capitalist moniker: adapt or die. When we pay for a good, be it digital or physical, we want possession and ownership of that good. When your class of people demand 'licenses to read' instead of the actual ownership of the book, you can shove it. I would rather pay pirates to get actual non-DRM books than buy the temporary permission to view., especially since the eBook is more expensive. I will buy physical books, drm-free books, and pirate. I'm not paying hard earned money for a temporary license. If your publishers and authors can't understand first sale doctrine and actual ownership, then you can close up shop and quit.
- autobodie 2y agoMoniker or not, I don't see Amazon or Kindle going anywhere anytime soon.
- DennisP 2y agoWe need an AI that produces the text of a book, from a video of it as you flip through its pages. No special hardware, just a phone and a thumb. If a few pages get missed it can ask you to do it again.
- matwood 2y agoI think it’s wrong to pirate books, but making it harder and harder to use the thing someone buys will push people to pirate. The onerous DRM from the likes of publishers and Amazon will eventually back fire on them. They are fighting hard to not have books end up like music, but I feel it’s inevitable.
- MyOutfitIsVague 2y agoI think it's contextual whether it's even wrong to pirate books. A new book that just came out? Sure. If I want to read a copy of "Titus Groan" by Mervyn Peake, who died in 1968, you'd have to do some marvelous convincing to make me feel bad about pirating it. Piracy would be wrong if the copyright system was reasonable. As is, it's the lesser of two evils compared to following the law as written.
- matwood 2y agoNo argument from me around copyright being too long. My point was mainly saying the publishers are working hard to avoid their Napster moment, but missing that it wasn't only about 'free' music, but convenience. The harder publishers make it to use their content legally, the more people they will push to the pirate sites.
- ClumsyPilot 2y agoWell it does - if the business of Amazon is immoral, buying from them is immoral. Therefore piracy becomes the lesser evil.
- GeoAtreides 2y agowell, patreon definitely sustains the industry people on royalroad make $10K a month, many more make over $1K... and then there's AO3, the monster in the dark with everything for everyone
- EA-3167 2y agoI would at least suggest buying a copy (not from Amazon) first, the author deserves a cut IMO and books tend to be relatively cheap. Kobo's store does have DRM, but it's easily bypassed by Calibre, or you can buy elsewhere (local is always good if possible) and then pirate an ebook copy. I think there's an ethical way to both get free use of what should be yours to use, and also support the people who made it.
- lolinder 2y ago> Kobo's store does have DRM, but it's easily bypassed by Calibre See, but that's not actually the same thing as DRM-free. It's adversarial interop that's temporarily allowed to work, but if said interop becomes popular enough the publishers will force Kobo to fix it. At this point I'm really only interested in spending money on books that I can actually own—either physical copies or (where available) fully and legally DRM-free ebooks. I want my purchases to send the right message to publishers: that DRM-free can work.
- shawn_w 2y agoA fair number of the books I've bought for my Kobo are drm free.
- lolinder 2y agoYeah, and that's great! Where that's an option I'll definitely go for it. I'm just uninterested in spending money on a book that has DRM, regardless of how easy it is to bypass. I think it sends the wrong message.
- teemur 2y agoIs there a way to know beforehand if the e-book from Kobo is DRM or not? I thought they were all DRM free, but the last book I bought suddenly was DRM and haven't yet bothered to research (I have a couple of different size e-readers and just copying the file over has been handy.)
- 2y ago
- InsideOutSanta 2y agoQuod licet Iovi, non licet bovi.
- Y_Y 2y ago> Even if Jupiter is allowed to do it, that doesn't mean a cow is. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quod_licet_Iovi,_non_licet_bovi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quod_licet_Iovi,_non_licet_bov...
- A_D_E_P_T 2y agoVery apt. The average individual downloader-not-seeder wouldn't have 1/10th of the cash required to fight a legal battle in court, whereas large firms seem to be able to just do whatever they want. The average person is put through hell and bankrupted. The large firm, at worst, pays a fine that amounts to some fraction of quarterly profit.
- hnthrowaway0315 2y agoMy strategy is to read a pirated copy for 2-3 chapters and then decide whether I want to buy the book. It's similar to the 90s when I used to read volumes and volumes in a bookstore but only with enough money to buy one or two every quarter. BTW I wish No Starch ships cheaper to Canada. It quickly adds up when I buy more. One of the best publishers out there I think.
- StefanBatory 2y agoI recall seeing a nice sale, I was to get a few books from them, and then the reality of living on the second side of the Atlantic hit hard :( At least one of our publishers did a translation for few of them...
- hnthrowaway0315 2y agoI agree that shipping can cost a lot, especially oversea. Last time I checked, Amazon US is still a lot cheaper than Amazon CA. But Canada doesn't have something that can compete with Amazon.
- avipars 2y agoZuck?
- heroprotagonist 2y agoAnd apparently, as long as you don't read them, if you only need a license to view... I hope the huge new antipiracy push that is coming will require litigators to prove that you're actually viewing the material you pirate. Which would make Plex and friends with their metrics a bad idea to trust with all of your pirated content. Though the antipiracy push is going to focus on the torrent sites themselves.
- llm_trw 2y agoThe torrent sites is how meta and friends get their books. They are safe.
- adamm255 2y agoAmazing how quick that story blew over.
- tehjoker 2y agowow i hadn't heard that before! https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/artificial-intelligence/meta-staff-torrented-nearly-82tb-of-pirated-books-for-ai-training-court-records-reveal-copyright-violations https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/artificial-intell...
- llm_trw 2y agoTeenage me who wanted information to be free didn't imagine this would be the result. It's like everything I wanted to happen in the 00s did, but from the monkeys paw. The only way I can think of fixing this is by giving rights to flesh and blood people that corporations don't have. GPL? Humans only. Free speech? Humans only.
- prawn 2y ago"Well, it was playing on the TV, but I wasn't actually watching. I was looking at my phone like everyone else." "That sounds quite likely. Case dismissed!"
- spudlyo 2y agoThere are so many incredible works of literature that I’ve yet to read available in glorious DRM free epub on Standard EBooks and Project Gutenberg, I don’t know why I’d deal with this shit for imaginative fiction .
- themadturk 2y agoNo argument, but there are incredible works of literature being created now, by living authors (who want to continue living, so need to eat) as well. We will likely always the classics, but we need living authors to create new classics.
- spudlyo 2y agoIs it still worth the terrible compromises to our digital freedoms we as a society have to make in order "to promote the progress of science and useful arts"? I'd argue that the pendulum has swung so far to the side of IP holders that this trade-off is one I no longer support. IP laws were designed for a different world, and in our current age they are often used to lock down content, control devices, and restrict how we interact with technology.
- themadturk 2y agoI think the idea that things have swung far to the side of the IP holder is a valid argument. But I don't think it's so much that the IP laws were designed for a different world as it is that large and powerful IP holders (Disney is the canonical example, but far from the only one) hijacked the copyright process for their own ends, blind to the way the world works today. The core concern, to my mind, is that creators be compensated fairly for their labor, however we end up defining that. Burning down the current system is likely the only way to find our way out of the mess we're in.
- account42 2y agoIP laws were designed in a world without the means to effectively make infinite copies for free using only hardware that everyone carries on their person at all times. You may say that you think copyright still works for the world we are in today (I don't agree) but that it was designed for a different world is undeniable.
- thayne 2y agoOnly if you have Meta's budget for lawyers.
- lordofgibbons 2y agoOr $5/mo. Just enough for a VPN
- cebert 2y agoA VPN won’t protect you.
- lordofgibbons 2y agoIf they start logging and one of their customers gets sued, their entire business model is finished. So, why do you say it won't protect you for pirating?
- consp 2y agoFingerprinting is pretty effective, no VPN will stop that.
- lordofgibbons 2y agoHow exactly does a bitorrent client fingerprint help anyone track you down?
- fc417fc802 2y agoAre there even any effective device fingerprinting methods for torrent clients? Given that it's a UDP protocol it's probably going to be pretty hard to get much useful information about the device aside from what the client might intentionally provide.
- thayne 2y agoOnly if you don't get caught. It's not really the same thing. A VPN is a way to avoid getting caught. Meta's legal defense is an attempt to avoid getting punished after getting caught.
- jisnsm 2y agoIt’s funny but predictable that the same website that has always said that piracy is a-okay changes its mind as soon as it’s Facebook who’s caught pirating stuff.
- AlexeyBelov 2y agoAre we using the same website? I mostly see fervent anti-piracy and pro-pay-for-everything sentiment. UPD: 17 day old account. I was had.
- j_burner 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thewanderer1983 2y agocombine Meta's statement with the WEF statement "You'll own nothing and you'll be happy". And you'll start to get a feel for the asymmetric "rules based order" the elites envision for the plebs.
- climb_stealth 2y agoPersonally I really don't like the whole downloading-but-not-seeding approach. The whole point of p2p networks is to receive and to give and spread. Back in the day it was the leecher clients that got banned because they were amoral and breaking the system. Buy books from responsible publishers. And please keep seeding the things you torrent that can't be purchased anywhere. And when I'm looking for that classic undubbed Jackie Chan movie and you are the single seeder making it possible to still get it, I salute you from the very bottom of my heart.
- locallost 2y agoQuod licet Iovi, non licet bovi. edit: haha, someone already made the comment further down the thread
- cantrecallmypwd 2y agoSeed from a VPN or VPS in a non-extradition country. Otherwise, you're just a leech.