13 ms·
Sal Khan responds to critic
- nadu 14y agoThats the old response to this critique http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/post/khan-academy-the-hype-and-the-reality/2012/07/22/gJQAuw4J3W_blog.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/post/khan-a...
- droithomme 14y agoFrom the article: > Below is Khan’s e-mail to me, which I shared with the author of Monday’s post, Karim Kai Ani, a former middle school teacher and math coach who is the founder of a company called Mathalicious. He said Khan is wrong. So, to summarize, "Khan is wrong, but I won't bother to explain why, he just is, and I have a self-proclaimed expert that says so."
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoMore so, Khan's free model has the potential to interfere with my paid model, so I'm going to sling some FUD around. There were some cogent points in Kai Ani's critique; the biggest one I think Khan would completely agree with: education problems aren't going to go away because of videos on YouTube.
- badclient 14y agoeducation problems aren't going to go away because of videos on YouTube Moot point since the Khan Academy is much more than about YouTube videos now. The videos may have kickstarted it; but to offer the above as a critic to Khan just shows that you are debating on an outdated version of what the Khan Academy is up to.
- jcromartie 14y agoFor any equation in the Cartesian plane, Khan is right. http://mathworld.wolfram.com/Slope.html http://mathworld.wolfram.com/Slope.html http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slope http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slope I cannot stand people who leave things at "just because". I can't remember who said it, but it goes "people who have explanations will explain".
- manicbovine 14y agoThe Cartesian plane does not contain equations. I think what you mean is that a two variable linear equation over the reals describes a line in the Cartesian plane. Try thinking of a line's slope (as you've described it) as just one measure of that line's "steepness" in the Cartesian plane. Thinking like this, we could use any number of measures to describe "steepness" (for example, angle of inclination provides a measure for the "steepness" of any line) So it's sort of a philosophical difference. However, there is a a very subtle elegance at work here.... we have this geometric concept of "steepness" which -- very interestingly -- turns out to be related an algebraic concept. Actually, we can go further. The geometric concept of "steepness" is related to algebra via a simple quotient, which is further related to an analytic concept (rate of change). It seems so trivial, but a good number of mathematicians make a living by finding small connections between geometry, algebra, analysis, etc. (Edited)
- jonhendry 14y agoNo, she presented Karim's argument in another column. This is Khan's response. I don't know if she has a position on Khan herself.
- kstenerud 14y ago"Khan is wrong" is actually Karim's response to the email: "Below is Khan’s e-mail to me, which I shared with the author of Monday’s post, Karim Kai Ani, a former middle school teacher and math coach who is the founder of a company called Mathalicious. He said Khan is wrong."
- MrMatters 14y agoI think it just may be poor paragraph structure. "Below is Khan’s e-mail to me, which I shared with the author of Monday’s post, Karim Kai Ani, a former middle school teacher and math coach who is the founder of a company called Mathalicious. He said Khan is wrong. This won’t be the end of the debate." It was part of the recap, I understood it to mean "Khan responds to this guy who posted the other day who said Khan was wrong" and then "stay tuned for his response to Khan's response" rather than "And then he replies Khan is wrong in his response. Stay tuned."
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ghshephard 14y agoNot to suggest that credentials are everything, but, lacking any other information, they do provide useful signaling indicators, from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khan_Academy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khan_Academy "After earning three degrees from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (a BS in mathematics, a BS in electrical engineering and computer science, and an MS in electrical engineering and computer science), he pursued an MBA from Harvard Business School" One would hope that his education background might have given him some insight into what "slope" was, and how to best explain it to someone in the 8th/9th grade. I can _recall_ when it was introduced to me, and I didn't really grok it until a few years later - "rise over run = slope" was complex enough for my brain back then - I can just imagine if people started yacking about "Ratios of variables" - my head would have exploded.
- Gormo 14y agoHow often do you need signaling indicators, though? If someone has sufficient competence at a given field, they should be able to demonstrate that competence by delivering satisfactory work. The proof should be in the level of understanding of the concept of slope acquired by students using various methods; it doesn't matter at all who is "right" with respect to some formal definition.
- ghshephard 14y agoTotally agree with you that what matters is whether the students eventually grasp the material. What I like about Khan, is he is fundamentally interested in teaching students so they _understand_ the material. He doesn't get caught up in theories of pedagogy or mathematical models or precise correctness - he sees his job is to communicate a concept in a way that the student says, "Oh, I get it." Now, with that said - there _is_ a danger in that model of teaching, in which the student gets lured into a zone of comfort. So there _absolutely_ is a place in teaching for instructors who are going to challenge, upset, and disturb the student - resulting in a form of stress that pushes to the student to new heights. This can be a very uncomfortable (and, indeed, upsetting/stressful) learning environment - but it does give students deeper, and sometimes much more meaningful insight into topics. But that's not what Khan's about. He is the guy you go to when you just want to get over some hurdle about a topic that has frustrated you.
- mikemarotti 14y ago"As math was not my subject in school, I don't know who is right but would love to hear from mathematicians out there." Go find a professor, you sorry excuse for a "journalist".
- saraid216 14y agoYou mean the two who are sitting there disagreeing?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- dinkumthinkum 14y agoWhich ones are the "professors?" I'm not trying to be flip but I don't think it's unreasonable to ask for the blogger or whatever it is to go find an expert. It's not like this debate is occurring between Einstein and Feynman.
- steveplace 14y agoNo need for inflammatory language here.
- mikemarotti 14y agoThis kinda stuff gets me fired up. Do your job, blogger! Anyways, edited.
- saraid216 14y agoI wasn't aware that KA was a non-profit. Where do they get their money? Entirely donation-driven?
- unimpressive 14y agoBill Gates. Among others.
- smashing 14y agoJust ask KA for a current IRS Form 990. It will show you just about everything. Here's an example from 2010 - http://dynamodata.fdncenter.org/990_pdf_archive/261/261544963/261544963_201012_990.pdf http://dynamodata.fdncenter.org/990_pdf_archive/261/26154496...
- Evbn 14y agoRule 1: Don't feed the trolls. Khan should keep taking his message to the public, not flattering attention on "critics", people who just want to sit in his coattails and stab him.
- spinchange 14y agoCan anyone weigh in on their differing arguments regarding the definition of slope? I am not a maths expert by any means, but am genuinely curious who is correct here. Or is this a matter of one being technically correct versus the other being correct in practice? (Cross posted from the original thread because I genuinely would like an opinion more informed than my own and the totally unhelpful "conclusion" provided by Valerie Strauss.) *Edit, I missed that he (Khan) posted a video defending his definition http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TNaQJjLAhkI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TNaQJjLAhkI
- nessus42 14y agoI'm not a math expert either, but rise over run sounds like a perfectly good definition of slope to me, at least for the purposes of an introduction to high school algebra. It is certainly how I was taught about slope, and I went on to graduate from MIT, so whatever nuance this definition allegedly didn't catch did me no harm. Once you get to calculus, things get a little more complicated, as the slope at a given point is defined using derivatives, but I'm pretty sure that ends up being the same as the rise over the run of a tangent line. In any case, anyone who would make such a lame criticism, should just STFU. If that's the best criticism they can come up with, they surely can't have much of value to say. Also, when teaching something like algebra, it's more important to make the material approachable and comprehensible, rather than define everything to a level of rigor that would make Russell and Whitehead happy.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pflats 14y ago>It is certainly how I was taught about slope, and I went on to graduate from MIT, so whatever nuance this definition allegedly didn't catch did me no harm. In that case, this debate really isn't about you. You were probably an exceptional student, who saw the connections between mathematical concepts easily, regardless of instruction. You probably found yourself predicting the next concept a teacher would introduce, because it just "makes sense." Not all students are that way. Most are not. The two people involved here are fighting over two different ideas. Sal is being pedantic, but is right, slope is defined as ∆x/∆y. What the other guy was saying is that slope represents rate of change, which is a much more important concept to early algebra, and the underpinning of why you actually care about slope in physics and calculus. You probably made the connection effortlessly. I assure you, many students do not. I teach high school mathematics to both honors and special needs students, and it's important to keep in mind that the instruction is very different between the two populations.
- jgrahamc 14y agoHaving the debate framed as 'Sal Khan is the future of education' and 'No, he isn't, teachers are' is bogus. It's a ridiculous dichotomy. It does a disservice to both Khan and teachers to debate this in that way. There will be many teachers who will use Khan's videos in their teaching (or to augment it), and I imagine that over time Khan will change the way he does things based on his own education about education. It's self evident that the 'sitting in front of a machine watching videos' isn't the solution to the education. If it were the multimedia revolution wouldn't have petered out as it did. Children (and adults) need a variety of approaches. Khan's is just one.
- boca 14y agoNot sure if there's a reason you mention it that way but his last name is Khan, not Kahn.
- jgrahamc 14y agoMy mistake.
- irahul 14y ago> There will be many teachers who will use Kahn's videos in their teaching (or to augment it), and I imagine that over time Kahn will change the way he does things based on his own education about education. Sal Khan(it' khan, not kahn) himself mentioned he is not looking to replace classrooms. He wants to invert the classroom. Traditional classroom has passive lectures followed up with problem solving which is to be done at home. He says it's better if people can do the passive things at home at their own pace, and use the classroom for problem solving. The problem with passive lectures in classroom is many a times students are sitting through lectures they don't follow because they don't know the prerequisites; and often times students by themselves aren't able to figure out if they can't make heads and tails of probability problems, what is it that they need to know so that they can understand it. In his talk, Khan demonstrated the software(I haven't used; I might be off) which can track your deficiencies. For example, you are struggling at basic probability. The framework will drop you down to permutation/combination problems. You still are struggling; introduce fundamental principle of counting. You are doing fine now. So explain permutations based on counting principle. Lacking the prerequisites is one of the problems. We have people who learn at different rate, people who aren't fluent in the language the lecture is delivered in, people who are shy/under-confident to speak up, people who are smart and are bored and feel left out, people who aren't very smart(lack the fundamentals, slow learners...) and are lost and feel left out. If Khan Academy, or any other self-paced learning resource can solve these problems; coupled with classroom guided problem solving and projects, that will make a huge difference.
- tomkin 14y agoWhat's missing from this argument is that traditional education dogma has the same plight. Is anyone ready to state, on record, that any educational platform is perfect and free from error? Khan deserves/requires criticism, but let's not forget that these criticisms apply across the board.
- zeteo 14y agoFrankly the response only addresses a small part of the criticism (the definition of slope) and then launches an attack on the critic's motivation. The main point in the original article [1] was that Khan's preparation for his lectures is deficient ("I don’t know what I’m going to say half the time") and often resumes to "two minutes of research on Google". [1] http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/post/khan-academy-the-hype-and-the-reality/2012/07/22/gJQAuw4J3W_blog.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/post/khan-a...
- gorbachev 14y agoI found Mr. Khan's response really odd for the same reason. He's addressing an EXAMPLE the critics used to illustrate their actual point, and fails to completely address the bigger issue. I thought the critics' points were completely valid, and raise pretty serious issues about the quality and usefulness of the Khan Academy material.
- dkkarthik 14y agoI find this line of discussion dubious. What you want to know is _not_ if he has spent hours preparing but if what he is saying is correct/the best way to explain something. He might be so gifted that everything just comes to him. Or he might be the person that might suck at math even with hours of preparation. Just because he said "I dont prepare for my lessons" (paraphrased) does not mean what he's teaching is no good. There is a reason why the videos have been watched as many times as they have. The thing that annoys me about Karim's argument is 1. There is no constructive criticism. He does not tell Sal (or me the reader) how one can make SA better 2. He has a competing for-profit venture that is a direct conflict of interest with SA and leads me to question his motives 3. He is a self-proclaimed expert with no proof of his own expertise 4. From his rant, I don't get that there is something structurally wrong with SA videos in general as his claims make them out to be
- ghshephard 14y agoHow many of Khan's videos have you watched? I've gone through about 100+ of them, and the material has been universally excellent, and certainly met, (and in most cases exceeded) the lecture material that was presented to me at High School/Simon Fraser University. "Quality and Usefulness of Khan Academy Material?" - you must have gone to an incredible school if you find his material lacking.
- mikeleeorg 14y agoWhat Khan is doing is great. For some students, it is very effective. For other students, not effective whatsoever. Thankfully, dozens of similar offerings have appeared (40 by one count), as well as tools to help teachers create their own video lessons (ie. Educreations). And that's not even mentioning all the other students for whom video is not the best way to learn these topics. The real problem is the media. And by that overarching term, I mean the rhetoric that various journalists, bloggers, and others have let themselves use for whatever purpose (ie. sensationalism, pageviews, linkbait, etc). It's understandable that there's been a backlash to Khan. He got overhyped. The pendulum swung too much one way. Now it's naturally swinging the other way. In the end, this is going to turn out better for students. As critics lash out in both directions (supporters and detractors both have gotten pretty vicious in this debate), there are a bunch of for-profit and non-profit efforts that are creating alternatives. Khan has a smart team too. I'm sure they're steadily improving their offerings.
- Cushman 14y agoThe way I've understood it, Khan isn't trying to disrupt the idea of teachers or schools per se, only alter it. Basically, the traditional schooling model consists of "lectures" in class, where the teacher presents you with information for an hour, and homework, where you work on problems relating to that content alone in your own time. Khan says, that's cocked up-- we should let students consume the raw informational content on their own time, where they can pause, rewind, and go over it as many times as they need to in order to understand it without disrupting anyone else, and then do "homework" in the classroom, where there's a focused environment that encourages exploration and somebody who can help each student with their individual difficulties. Which has always struck me as a pretty straightforward, good-common-sense approach to at least try. Why is this concept so opaque to so many people?
- Strallus 14y agoThat approach (students working at their own pace) isn't very novel when you consider the fact that home-schooling has been around for a while.
- Cushman 14y agoAnd unless I'm mistaken, home-schooled children tend to consistently outperform their public-schooled peers in testing, yes?
- praxulus 14y agoI'm sure if you had that kind of student-teacher ratio in normal schools students would perform better anyway.
- michaels0620 14y agoA big part of a child's success in school has to do with parental involvement. Home schooled children, almost by definition, have highly involved parents. It would be interesting to compare home schooled children with regular children whose parents are actively involved in their education to see how that matched up.
- delinka 14y agoMy son has been watching Sal give lessons for the last year. Sal makes mistakes sometimes. My son usually notices and asks for clarification. We end up with a nice discussion about the topic at hand and arrive at a correct answer. If it's math related, I've got it covered. If it's not, we do some research. Classroom teachers make mistakes. Textbooks make mistakes. But the system is set up to disallow question of these two authorities. Example: Math class is the first class of the day; teacher follows textbook and textbook is wrong; child questions and is waved off; is that kid gonna remember at the end of the day that she needed to ask mom about this problem? No. I much prefer when Sal makes a mistake because it makes for a learning experience. What's nice is when my son comes back some time later and tells me that Sal's video has been corrected.
- SudarshanP 14y agoYou are one awesome mom :)
- delinka 14y agoThanks for the compliment! (you assumed incorrectly on the gender, but I'm accustomed to that with the nick :-)
- dinkumthinkum 14y agoNo, I think that's great. Is it really like that though. I always feel like this is kind of a caricature: "The teacher would not dare let me question the authority of the textbook." That doesn't seem very serious. I'm sure, and this may sound mean, that this goes on some very bad rural or inner city schools but it's just such a ridiculous thing to say that I find it hard to believe it occurs in more reasonable scholastic settings. But people always bring it up ...
- delinka 14y agoIt seems to be a matter of convenience. It shouldn't be, but that what it looks like. It disrupts the flow of the teacher's classroom. It's viewed as yet another disruption, but the worst kind of disruption: the legitimate kind that gives the rest of the class an opening to continue disrupting the class. And that could affect perceptions about how this teacher handles a class. No, can't have that so just sit down and shut up. A good teacher can handle the book being wrong. A good teacher will tell the students that the book has a mistakes on this problem well before they have the chance to discover it themselves. A good teacher will have gone over the material in advance and know what's correct. Instead, we have teachers thrust into roles that aren't near their specialty; teachers that can get a degree and qualify for a paycheck because they can work the system, not because they know how to teach students. And interfering with that teacher's conveniences is not a good thing for a student to attempt.
- frankphilips 14y agoLooks to me like a feeble attempt by Karim Kai Ani of Mathalicious to generate some PR for his for-profit website. What better way to drive traffic then to "build up some controversy" by hating on Khan? Sal's noble efforts have allowed countless people obtain a first-class education at virtually no cost. Shame on The Washington Post for promoting this hidden agenda. Seems like they also have an agenda of their own. 1) Post a controversial guest article bashing a guy whose actually trying to do something good in the world. 2) Act like the neutral party so they don't have to take any blame. Allow Karim to be the scapegoat. 3) Sit back and enjoy while traffic explodes to their site. I see you Washington Post. You ain't fooling me!
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mrobataille 14y agoWow, nailed it. I totally missed the Washington Post incentive angle.
- kamens 14y agoDisclaimer: I'm part of Khan Academy. Not going to chime in w/ my deeper disagreement w/ the original critic and the other article on the frontpage. I would like to correct a persistent misconception or two. Persistent misconception: "...we suggest that Khan Academy desperately needs voices of teaching experience. Khan could tap into any number of existing networks..." Truth: We have four ex-teachers as full-time employees. We have two high school math teachers as consultants. One Harvard Doctoral candidate in Education and one post-doc in neuroscience at Stanford are in residence. One UPenn Professor is also likely to begin a sabbatical with us. We have a 3 person team dedicated to working with and getting feedback from our 50 pilot classrooms and the 15,000 teachers actively using KA in classrooms. Persistent misconception: "...it certainly requires more than just “two minutes of research on Google,” which is how Khan describes his own pre-lesson routine." Truth: Go read Sal's AMA response (includes the sentence "When I did organic chemistry, I spent 2 weeks immersing myself in the subject before making the first video") before taking one of these "two minute" snipped quotes at face value: http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/ntsco/i_am_salman_khan_founder_of_khan_academyama/c3bv5hv http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/ntsco/i_am_salman_khan.... I've seen Sal's face light up when he gets an unwieldy new shipment of textbooks to start studying in preparation for his videos. Does he dive right into some videos? Absolutely. Is claiming that his "pre-lesson routine" can always be dismissed as two minutes of Googling disingenuous and patently false? Absolutely.
- tokenizer 14y agoIt's good to know that you guys are a non for profit and that you're just looking at improving in any way possible the current education system, whether as a supplement, or as a self learning tool. I personally think that Khan's response was one of tact and class, as is your comment. Keep up the good work.
- SiVal 14y agoI agree that Sal is a class act. I'm glad he's doing what he's doing. I suspect we'll see some (more) great things from Khan Academy. I can say that and still believe that it might be a good idea for him to treat these videos as version 1 and consider upgrading them to version 2. In particular, if there are resources for creating more videos, some of those resources might better be spent on upgrading the existing videos. I've tutored math in Korea, observed the schools in Japan and Singapore, was observing math class in Shanghai most recently, and have used curricular materials from Singapore, Japan, and China to homeschool my own kids in math. What I observe in the Asian programs I've seen that differs starkly from the vastly inferior curriculum here in my own country (US) is meticulous care put in to the development of: 1) a strategically-ordered, cohesive sequence of topics, 2) explicit list of the ideas that need to be mastered in each topic before moving on, and 3) rigorously field-tested teaching techniques, examples, assignments, and assessments for each idea. The whole sequence is constantly being experimented with, tested, and optimized like a Japanese industrial, or Apple consumer, product. In contrast to this meticulously crafted approach to incremental mastery, our US approach is one of each teacher throwing her own bowl of math spaghetti at kids and whatever sticks sticks. Whatever doesn't stick today, well, don't worry, we'll be doing something different tomorrow. Maybe you'll do better with that. And someone else will throw the whole bowl at you again next year, and the year after that. If you run out of years and a lot of things still haven't stuck, well, we did all we could. You're just not a "mathy type" (claim the teachers who couldn't solve a Singaporean 5th grade word problem if their lives depended on it.) What Sal has produced in version 1 reminds me more of the American way than the Asian way, but that's no surprise. It started off as an act of personal generosity, not a NASA space project. If it stays the way it is, I'll be grateful for the moral equivalent of free pizza. I'll gladly eat some, and I won't fuss that my free pizza doesn't have my favorite toppings. But if he's planning to go forward, I think the next step might be to back off a bit on the quantity of videos and consider upgrading some of the old ones to a more deliberately designed, cohesive video sequence.
- infinitex 14y agoThis is a storm in a tea cup.
- themonk 14y agoMathalicious is doing this just to get popular, I never knew they exists before this debate. Google might improve page rank of mathalicious.com as well due to back links.
- andyl 14y agoFirst they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.
- derleth 14y agoThen you get to shove mind-control worms into their ears.
- theoretick 14y agoI found quite a bit in the original article that seemed to point to a misunderstanding of the site for someone who hasn't used it. Karim doesn't even mention one of the most valuable areas: the practice area. It isn't just about watching videos, and maybe I'm alone, but I use the practice first and the videos as supplements. Furthermore, the actual videos seem to often feature explanations in a clear way that does not merely point to following a series of steps (see "why division by zero is undefined")
- bherms 14y agoThe original critical piece was written by someone with a vested interest in defaming Khan, as he runs a company that is (in a way) a direct competitor. That alone should be enough to dismiss his critique.
- brockhand 14y agoI disagree that critiques from those with vested interests should be dismissed out of hand. I do believe that their points should be reviewed more carefully, though.
- bherms 14y agoMy comment was a bit sensationalist... I agree with you 100%, I just stated it a little more black and white than I should have.
- robomartin 14y agoFrankly, I don't know why he even bothered to respond. What KA is doing might not be perfect but it is one serious attempt to move education forward in some form. They deserve nothing less than admiration and support. I am sure that they welcome and encourage constructive criticism. Aside from that, the only way the "(highly unionized) teachers do it better" argument can hold water is if the (highly unionized) teachers start producing students that actually place in a reasonable range in international comparisons.
- jere 14y ago>An effective math teacher will point out that “rise over run” isn’t the definition of slope at all but merely a way to calculate it. In fact, slope is a rate that describes how two variables change in relation to one another: What a dumb thing to argue about. I'm not a historian (or a mathematician), but the term "slope" seems pretty obviously adopted from a physical slope/incline/hill. Why? Because it's the easiest visual analogy for us apes to grok. It doesn't come from an earlier term meaning strictly "a rate that describes how two variables change in relation to one another." If you're trying to teach someone a complex concept, are you going to use a phrasing that has zero significance to them? Rate? Variable? What? The people learning about slope aren't programmers or engineers. Give me a break. Why not use a visual analogy that makes perfect sense and is still a valid definition: rise over run on a section of a hill, road, roller coaster, etc. I hope whoever is teaching this is relating it to a real world object. Just talking about a line on paper isn't going to help much, but neither is an overly complex definition.
- chris_wot 14y agoWait till they start learning Calculus - by this point it would be extremely useful to have understood that slope is a rate that describes how two variables change in relation to one another!
- bicknergseng 14y agoFrom the article that sparked Khan's response: >Take Khan’s explanation of slope, which he defines as “rise over run.” An effective math teacher will point out that “rise over run” isn’t the definition of slope at all but merely a way to calculate it. In fact, slope is a rate that describes how two variables change in relation to one another: how a car’s distance changes over time (miles per additional hour); how the price of an iPod changes as you buy more memory (dollars per additional gigabyte). Followed by this in her response to his letter: >As math was not my subject in school, I don't know who is right but would love to hear from mathematicians out there. I had to reread all 3 articles multiple times. Then I lamented the sad state of journalism as well as the complete willingness of our society to tolerate the "I'm just not good at math so I won't bother to understand it because I don't think it's worthy"-attitude. What angers me about the first article is not that it went by some editor without the editor saying, hey, this seems suspect, but rather the fact that the journalist decided to write about something she had little knowledge about with a tone that suggests that she thinks she knows knows more than Sal or someone else educated on the subject. An unapologetic combination of ignorance and condescension.
- eurleif 14y agoThe original article criticizing Khan wasn't written by the person who wrote this response.
- bicknergseng 14y ago"A guest post I published Monday critiquing the Khan Academy..."
- eurleif 14y agoRight. She published it as a guest post, but it wasn't written by her. She didn't "write about something she had little knowledge about"
- bicknergseng 14y ago
- reso 14y agoThe author of the criticism is the founder of a for-profit start-up competing with Khan Academy. Khan Academy itself is a non-profit. These incentives should frame everything we hear about this exchange.
- caycep 14y agothis also is reminiscent of this nytimes op ed: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/20/opinion/the-trouble-with-online-education.html/?_r=1 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/20/opinion/the-trouble-with-o... that conveniently forgets to mention all the collaborative/interactive components built into coursera - the community TA's, the forums, chatrooms, etc etc etc. moral: don't criticize unless you've actually read the book/seen the movie/etc. or maybe beware of hidden agendas.
- cs702 14y agoThis article is emblematic of the hardest challenge Khan Academy faces, IMO, as it tries to change the educational system from the current 'lecture at school, practice at home' approach used by virtually all schools today, to the 'learn at home, tinker and interact at school' championed by Khan Academy. The hardest challenge is this: disrupting the educational experience requires buy-in from teachers, administrators, regulators, academics, and existing service providers, but all these parties are nearly always resistant to change and well-entrenched in their positions, making large-scale change very, very, very slow and difficult. The optimist in me wishes Sal Khan and his team only success as they take on, and attempt to co-opt, the educational establishment. The realist in me thinks they face a long, tough battle.
- dpatru 14y agoThe educational establishment won't "buy in" it Khan, just like the traditional encyclopedia establishment didn't "buy in" to Wikipedia. But change will happen regardless because the users of education, the parents and students, will ask themselves the same question that the users of encyclopedias asked themselves: "Why are we continuing to pay for the same old product when a much better product is available for free?"
- justin_vanw 14y agoEither the people who watch Khan's video's find them useful, and can do things they couldn't do, or understand things better than they did, or not. Most public school teachers are awful. They have degrees in education, and most university programs in the teacher pipeline are intentionally easier and less demanding than the equivalent 'real' degree in a given subject. 'Math-ed' is a very undemanding degree compared to 'Mathematics'. If high-school teachers were placed under this kind of scrutiny we would be forced to completely re-evaluate how teachers are credentialed and licensed. They aren't put under this or really any scrutiny at all, and probably they never will be. Teacher unions fight as hard as they possibly can to prevent any measurement or evaluation of teacher performance. Students will continue to try to fill in the gaps in their understanding of these topics, and if there are free resources available to them to do so, even better!
- dinkumthinkum 14y agoThe problem is partly economic. Most people very advanced in mathematics, I don't think would choose low salaries teaching kids Algebra or "AP Calc" in the inner city. Sure, there are the "heroes" out there but it's a reality.
- coolpin5 14y agoI never understood why Sal Khan does all the videos himself. Shouldn't they get the best Linear Algebra teacher that they can find for the Linear Algebra series, the best Calculus teacher for the Calculus series, the best Marine Biology teacher for Marine Biology, and so on? Maybe even get two sets of teacher with different lecture styles for each subject? I've had dozens of amazing teachers throughout my education, all of which were excellent at gripping my attention, having a passion for their subject, and a knack for explaining it extremely well. If I thought my teachers were this good, can you imagine how good the best in the country would be? And what it could do for education to makes those lessons available for the entire world? It's a shame he does it entirely himself. It's not for lack of funding, that's for sure. Maybe it's an ego thing?
- thirsteh 14y agoThe critique was written by a competitor. Isn't the motive obvious?