22 ms·
Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real
There are numerous eBay listings for off-brand Korean monitors boasting 27" IPS panels with 2560x1440 display resolutions. These puppies cost less than $400, or roughly half as much as the name-brand alternatives. We've tested one against a 30" Dell, and a few caveats aside, it's nearly as good.
- Xcelerate 14y agoThese monitors a great deal. One thing that always bugs me on forums (or deal websites) where these are discussed is that people are quick to point out that these monitors have A- panels -- the rejects from the Apple and Dell supply. While this is true for a few of the companies, it is not true for all of them. "Korean monitors" isn't one entity. There's a lot of companies selling these things, and a lot of them are A quality panels. (So the lesson is to not just repeat things you hear without finding a primary source first). I believe most rumors point to Apple releasing a 27 or 30 inch super resolution display within the next year. I'll be waiting for these Korean companies to release their own version and then snatch it up for a cheap price.
- pbreit 14y agoSo is there any way to figure out if you're getting an A or an A-?
- Xcelerate 14y agoAsk the group selling the monitors. They'll normally tell you.
- devindotcom 14y agoYeah, I'm hoping to pick up a generic version of whatever high-res monitor they introduce, if they don't clamp down supply too hard. Windows isn't quite ready for that kind of scaling, though...
- josephcooney 14y agore: windows - nonsense. GDI+ has been capable of doing resolution-independent rendering since 2000-ish. I think since vista there have been DPI-settings within easy reach. More recent UI platforms like WPF and silverlight are vector-based and resolution-independent. My primary monitor is 2560x1440 and it looks beautiful.
- wmf 14y agoYou missed the part where almost every Windows app breaks at high DPI.
- kbolino 14y agoIndeed. Windows apps are resolution-independent in theory, but not in practice. Even the OS itself has a bunch of tie-ins to ancient dialog boxes that have only been incrementally improved and break when you change the DPI.
- josephcooney 14y agoSo when you said "Windows isn't quite ready for that kind of scaling" you meant "some windows apps" or "most windows apps"?
- CamperBob2 14y agoThere's also a subtext that makes me a bit nervous. The OEM did not build these monitors as an act of charity. They were ordered by someone, with the intent of selling them at a much higher price. When you see a deal like this -- especially if the monitors are actually of better quality than represented in the ad -- it means that someone at a major PC manufacturer ordered a metric assload too many monitors. Why/how did that happen? Does it signal a larger market collapse?
- excuse-me 14y agoProbably signals a market collapse in the last 2years. Dell and co either ordered, or suppliers thought they would order lots of new big screen monitors, so fab lines were setup, components were bought, screens were made. ... and then the world (or at least those who still had jobs ) ... bought tablets.
- gareim 14y agoOr, you know, the panels just weren't up to the PC manufacturer's standards. Happens all the time.
- eps 14y ago... low price. I don't always nitpick, but when I do, I go after "cheap prices".
- white_devil 14y agoI'm curious, why is "low price" wrong?
- Kudos 14y agoLow price is correct, cheap price is wrong. Price is implied in the word cheap.
- Thrymr 14y ago"Redundant" is not the same as "wrong". (To pick a nit on a nit.)
- freehunter 14y agoI don't regard that as correct. Cheap can mean multiple things. I can say this fabric has a cheap feel to it. This is a reference to quality. The shirt may have cost me $400, but the workmanship and materials that went into it were of low value. When you say you'll give me a full refund for the shirt but then only give me store credit, I could tell you that your words were cheap. Yes, this relates back to price in the end, but having a cheap price means you paid a small amount for it. Having a cheap quality means it's worth a small amount, but you might have paid much more for it. Clarifying with the word price gives a very specific meaning. Cheap doesn't always imply price.
- Xcelerate 14y agoThen that explains the hesitation I felt when I typed that.
- wiwillia 14y agoDo you have a link to one of the eBay listings? Would love to pick one up, but there are dozens of 27" IPS monitors advertised on eBay (would hate to get suckered by a low quality option).
- kevhsu 14y agoI got the Auria EQ276W from Microcenter for 400+tax last week. Fantastic purchase. Includes Displayport, HDMI, DVI-D, and VGA ports. Colors are vivid, and I don't believe I have any dead/stuck pixels. Mine has minor backlight bleed, but probably not more than the $700+ Apple and Dell displays.
- adrianwaj 14y agoBig question is do they use LED or CCFL, and are they the cheaper e-IPS? What is their refresh rate, >10ms ?
- devindotcom 14y agoSays LED on the panel, and they said refresh rate was just fine. Not sure what type of IPS it is, but given the explosion of IPS panels and demand these days I wouldn't be surprised if it was the real thing. $337 isn't cheap, after all.
- hastur 14y agoThe explosion of IPS panels is because LG figured out how to make them really cheaply. And those economic, low-quality variants are called e-IPS and I have absolutely no doubt that we're dealing with one here. (Despite the fact that specs on eBay say S-IPS.) Also, $337 is not only cheap - it's dirt cheap. $300 for 24'' IPS is cheap. Courtesy of e-IPS, of course. A Dell U2412M would be an example. A decent 24'' IPS display, say a Dell U2410, will cost $500. A high-quality 24'' IPS display, say a NEC PA241W, will cost $1000. A high-quality 27'' IPS display, say a NEC PA271W, costs $1400. Welcome to the real world.
- adrianwaj 14y agoI've got my eye on the new NEC P232W: 23", $569 - http://www.necdisplay.com/p/desktop-monitors/p232w-bk http://www.necdisplay.com/p/desktop-monitors/p232w-bk
- mappu 14y agoA friend of mine bought one recently, and it arrived yesterday... his comments were along the lines of 'Build quality is not as good as Dell, but passable, and it's a third of the price'. He found a calibration file and seems very happy with the purchase. The common brands to search for are the Yamakasi Catleap and (to a lesser extent) the Shimian QH270.
- kakuri 14y agoI haven't seen the Yamakasi's or the Achieva Shimian's in person, but I have a Crossover 27Q and the monitor housing is sturdy metal and the stand is sturdy as well. Still overall very lightweight.
- citricsquid 14y agoHmm, I currently have 3 x 24" Samsung monitors and I've been considering the Samsung MD230X6 (6 x 23", 1920 x 1080) but the cost (around $4,000) vs. the $1000 cost of getting 3 x 27" (2560 x 1440) means I'm tempted to try out these "korean" monitors. My main concern is why are they so cheap. The article mentions that they're displays that companies didn't deem fit to sell, does that mean these are displays that were due to be destroyed and someone is just selling them on, or are they purchased in bulk at a big discount and then being resold? I figure all that matters is if they work and is only $1,000 but I would be much more comfortable purchasing if I knew exactly what their story was.
- samstave 14y ago>why are they so cheap Maybe they are made by slaves in North Korea underthe work exchange program they have... EDIT: downvoted, but I was being serious... Maybe they are using labor such as that to make these. I dont know I cant think of another reason they are so cheap - unless they see an opportunity to steal the market by dropping margins and getting these to go in high volume ove rthe next months/year...
- brador 14y agoI'm not the downvoter, but since we can't know either way, is it of significance when making a purchasing decision?
- samstave 14y agoNo, but the question by the OP was "how" are they doing this... I was speculating.
- moonchrome 14y agoHow likely is it that low skilled manual labor is the highest cost factor in high tech manufacturing of things like monitors.
- Lagged2Death 14y ago
- wesbos 14y agoI've been researching these lately as well and I've found the Crossover 27Q LED to be the best build quality and the nicest casing. Quite tempted to snap one of these up before they get popular and drive the price up..
- kakuri 14y agoI've got a 27Q and it is excellent. The housing is metal, the stand is solid (if lacking in adjustment, but other models offer more adjustment - I replaced it with an Ergotron MX arm). It's very basic - just a DVI port. Crossover has multiple models offering different stands and different connectivity options. The major unknown at this point is longevity, but other than that I would recommend this without reservation.
- majorlazer 14y agoI have an Ergotron MX arm (one of the best purchases I ever made) supporting a 23" ViewSonic and I was planning to get one of these 27" monitors. How well do these arms support monitors that big?
- kakuri 14y agoI have the Crossover 27Q and the Ergotron MX works perfectly with it.
- polshaw 14y agoThese require 2 DVI connectors, right? Is there a similar one with HDMI? [E: ok.. it seems like 1 dual-link DVI, so-- can you simply use a basic HDMI-DVI socket converter as used on many video cards if you want to plug in an HDMI source?] Also appear to be glossy, care to comment on your impressions of that aspect?
- northisup 14y agoWe bought a bunch of them at DISQUS, our current failure rate is about 20-30% failed within the first three months of use. Would not buy again.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoIf they're less than half the price of a comparable Dell, a 30% failure rate seems acceptable. Just buy some spares, right?
- scott_s 14y agoIt depends on how much you value the extra time and effort it takes to replace them. If you buy spares ahead of time to negate that time and effort, then have you really saved money?
- pyre 14y agoThe point is that a 30% failure rate is less than the 50% discount so you only end up saving 20%, with the spares included in the purchase.
- ZachPruckowski 14y agoBut if 20-30% failed in the first few months of an expected 5+ year life cycle, that's indicative of a >50% failure rate in the medium to long term. You'll probably come out a loser in monitor-years/dollar.
- jff 14y agoThat does not necessarily follow. See the "bathtub curve".
- excuse-me 14y agoSee also "time value of money" - if you don't have to buy the spares until they fail, all that extra money is worth something to you. There is a reason Toyota and co don't have 6months of parts on hand - and it isn't due to shortage of shelf space
- rogerbinns 14y agoAnnoyingly they are 16:9 which means you lose some vertical resolution versus 16:10. I'm pretty sure I bought the last two displays with 16:10 in this area. For those who care about colour checkout http://www.hughski.com http://www.hughski.com for a device and http://lwn.net/Articles/499231/ http://lwn.net/Articles/499231/ for details. It turns out that manufacturers do ship displays with completely wrong colour calibration (yes I'm looking at you Lenovo).
- kakuri 14y agoThe dearth of 16:10 monitors available bothers me, but if you're going from 1920x1200 (or less) to 2560x1440, you're still gaining vertical space - you're just gaining more horizontal space. I replaced my 24" 1920x1200 with a Crossover 27Q 27" 2560x1400 and absolutely love it.
- rogerbinns 14y agoNote that you only gain physical vertical space if you also increase the monitor size. eg replacing a 24" with another 24" will lose 11% vertical space even if there are more pixels. Consequently you have to significantly increase the diagonal size in order to get the same (or more) vertical.
- pbreit 14y agoYou pay another $300 for the 160 pixels (but I guess they are larger pixels!). http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_nkw=2560+1600+ips http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_nkw=2560+1600+ips But I agree, I much prefer 16:10 and am frustrated they are so much pricier and in shorter supply.
- rcvassallo 14y agoRight on. I think the proximity to φ says it all: φ = 1.618 16:10 = 1.6 16:9 = 1.777
- Kell 14y ago
- rrmm 14y agoThe guy in the article mentions having trouble figuring out how to change the brightness using the non-OSD controls. As great as LCD monitors are, the one thing I miss about CRT's is having an analogue brightness control. It made it really convenient to adjust the monitor at night. (Also, I miss not having blue LED's and touch-sensitive controls. They really need to force designers to read Don Norman's book).
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoBlue LEDs are an evil scourge upon electronics. Most especially on alarm clocks.
- overworkedasian 14y agothere is alot of good information here on various 27" displays from korea. http://www.overclock.net/f/44/monitors-and-displays http://www.overclock.net/f/44/monitors-and-displays
- theatrus2 14y agoSadly, not a good monitor review (from the likes of say Anandtech). If you're going to do a qualitative review, you need to check color accuracy, tracking, gamut, etc.
- sliverstorm 14y agoI think it can already be taken for granted that if you are concerned about color accuracy, gamut, et al, these are not the panels for you.
- corin_ 14y agoPlenty of people are concerned about specifics when buying any tech product without buying the most expensive product. I'm concerned about specifications and benchmarks when I buy a graphics card, it doesn't mean I want the best possible, it just means I can judge quality vs. cost.
- theatrus2 14y agoThey could be - lots of monitors, and especially IPS panels, do well when calibrated. The review is somewhat akin to saying a computer "boots Windows quickly" without ever mentioning the CPU clock speed or hard drive, but complaining the glossy front picks up finger prints and it doesn't fit under your desk nicely. Those may be important, but they aren't quantitative. This review falls into the same trap: adjusting color via on monitor controls and saying the color is "good" is not in any way a reasonable way to do a monitor review.
- hastur 14y agoOK, so let's bring this hype down to Earth. For this kind of money this can only be an e-IPS monitor. (The specs on e-bay say S-IPS, but it's certainly a lie.) For those who don't differentiate between the different variants of IPS, e-IPS is a relatively new thing introduced around 2 years ago (by LG, I believe) and it's a simplified and much cheaper to manufacture version of IPS. Its characteristics are somewhere between TN and IPS. Apart from the display itself, a monitor's quality is also very much dependent on its electronics. For this kind of money it's obvious they've put the absolute minimum into this thing. (For a little comparison: I have an old, med-quality 19'' NEC 1990FX monitor and a cheap 23'' HP 2310ti touch monitor. The NEC weighs 9kg, the HP 8kg. How can a smaller monitor be heavier? It's all electronics.) Same applies to other aspects: you can have no confidence in the monitor's electromagnetic emissions or reliability. And if the power supply fries for some reason in 3 months, don't count on your warranty. I mean, you didn't believe for a second that a no-name brand that sells in the US purely thru e-bay will honor any kind of warranty, did you?
- w1ntermute 14y ago> if this piece of crap doesn't even have an ability to regulate brightness and contrast Reread the article. You can adjust brightness just fine, he just wasn't pressing the button down for long enough at first.
- hastur 14y agoThank you for pointing that out. Corrected.
- ceol 14y agoIn your defense, it took the author a few pages to even get to that fact.
- CamperBob2 14y agoYeah, that was pretty lame. The author is clearly being paid by the word and/or page view, and the quality of the review suffered substantially because of it. Hastur is being hasty with his FUD, all right, but it's not as if the article was much better.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ori_b 14y agoI wish that they were still making 4:3 LCDs. I like having 3 side by side, and I currently have that setup with 3 20" 1600x1200 monitors, but at some point I'll want to upgrade to something with higher pixel density. My concern is that with new wide screen displays, things will span too wide horizontally to be usable.
- excuse-me 14y agoMe too - I'm buying ex-lease high end Dell 1600x1200 IPS screens because using 3x24" 16:9 is like watching a tennis match - you are constantly twisting your neck from left to right
- im3w1l 14y agoPut three screens in portrait and never look back.
- rhizome 14y agoIt would be nice if sizes could be standardized in some way that I could have one large landscape monitor flanked by a couple of smaller ones in portrait, without looking lame. +-----+------------+-----+ | | | | | | | | | | | | +-----+------------+-----+
- ori_b 14y agoA series paper size inspired aspect ratios would be amazing. For those of you who don't know, the ratio of sides on A-series paper (A4, etc) is 1:sqrt(2), which means that if you put together 2 sheets of A4 with the long edges touching, you get the next size up, which would be A3.
- jrockway 14y agoTwo rotated 19" 1600x900s flanking a 2560x1600 30" monitor looks like your diagram.
- deleted 14y ago
- kitsune_ 14y agoThe last thing I would compromise on with my set up is the monitor. After all, I'll be staring into this thing every day for at least two years if not more. No TN-Panel. No glare. I also refuse to buy a 16:9 monitor.
- kakuri 14y agoI have long felt similarly to you (minus the "no glare" part), but I bought a Crossover 27Q and have been thrilled by it. I spent $800 on a high-quality 24" 1920x1200 BenQ about 5 years ago, and now it's playing 2nd fiddle to my 27". As a programmer, it really bothers me that 16:10 is all but dead. However, when you go from a 1920x1200 to a 2560x1440 monitor, you're not losing vertical space - you're just gaining more horizontal space than vertical. My other huge gripe is anti-glare coating. If you are in control of your lighting, AG coating does not benefit you - it just blurs the picture. A screen with no AG coating gives a crystal clear image. The BenQ FP241W was one of the best rated & reviewed monitors when it was released. I'm thrilled to replace it with a "cheap" Korean monitor, and look forward to replacing it completely by adding a 2nd Crossover next to my current one. The big issue with the new monitor is longevity - my BenQ is still running perfectly, I hope I can say the same for the Crossover in 5+ years.
- cbsmith 14y agoI like my vertical pixels as much as the next guy, but unless you are doing a lot of drawing work (and therefore really need a circle to look like a circle), I have a hard time seeing why one would not give a little on this. You've got $300. You can either get a 1920x1200 display, or you can get a 2560x1440 display. If somehow there was another choice with a 2560x1600, I'm going to be strongly tempted to go with the 2560x1400 display unless it has some annoying display quality issues. Even if you have more money, it'd be tempting to consider getting 2 of the 2560x1400 instead of one 2560x1600.
- yardie 14y agoBasing your display decisions by the price is like basing your car buying decisions on the monthly payment. Displays are some of the sturdiest, longest lasting piece of the system, and it's the part of the computer you most interact with, unless you are blind. My single 27" LG is 6 years old and has gone through 3.5 computers in that time. In that regard, you've got $300 right now for a monitor, in 2 months you'll have $500. If it's possible to get a good monitor right now for $300 then I'd go for it. If I can't find anything that fits me (IPS, 16:10 are critical) I'd rather wait.
- Scene_Cast2 14y agoAnyone looking for a high-quality review of the panel, check out http://www.tftcentral.co.uk/reviews/dgm_ips-2701wph.htm http://www.tftcentral.co.uk/reviews/dgm_ips-2701wph.htm. The Pro/Con conclusion is at the very bottom of the page. I cannot recommend tftcentral enough as a monitor review site.
- jfb 14y agoI rock the Cinema Display, but would seriously consider one or two of these as secondary displays. Of course, it the mooted third party Thunderbolt breakout boxes actually show up (and work), the economics change for me.
- kristofferR 14y agoI've heard some great things about the Yamasaki Catleap, another cheap 27". I might be ordering one of them soon. The vast majority of the receivers have received perfect screens and been really happy with their purchase it seems, check out the reports in the table here: http://www.overclock.net/t/1225919/yamakasi-catleap-monitor-club http://www.overclock.net/t/1225919/yamakasi-catleap-monitor-...
- jaytaylor 14y agoI've been loving mine! My co-worker also enjoys this same monitor as well.
- eliasmacpherson 14y agothe HDCP complaint he lists seems like a feature, not a bug.
- josephlord 14y agoWhy? An HDCP capable display can show content without HDCP or with HDCP so in what way is one that only supports non HDCP inputs better? The only benefit is if only a small minority of people have HDCP displays then it makes no commercial sense to mandate HDCP for content. And in my view it is too late for that. Edit: Note that it wouldn't be a show stopper for me with a product like this but I would regard HDCP support in a monitor to be a benefit. Edit2: Added missing word to second sentence.
- josephlord 14y agoJust wanted to add another item which is that HDCP is completely broken now anyway. The remaining security is mostly the fact that it is bloody hard to handle the massive datarate of the the uncompressed video without custom hardware. And why bother; almost everything is available in the compressed form (e.g. Blu-ray) more easily accessible if you are trying to access the content.
- riobard 14y agoHmmm, LG panels... These panels were available since a few years ago on Taobao.com (China's eBay if that helps) in small quantities, and there were lots of excitement to make your own “Cinema Display” at 1/3 the price. As a big screen lover, I was also intrigued. So I did some research. Here's the background story I heard a year or two ago from an anonymous guy claiming he's working in LG's factories in China. I didn't verify if it's true (unless I saw LG's contract with Apple, which means impossible), but it makes a lot of sense to me anyway. You have to judge by yourselves. These 27" S-IPS (yes, not e-IPS) panels were indeed manufactured for Apple's iMacs and Cinema/Thunderbolt Displays. Apparently Apple has pretty high and tight standard (which they do, if you've ever used authentic ones) about these panels. Once in a while a production run will not meet Apple's expectation for some reason (e.g. color/brightness/contrast uniformity). So Apple rejects the faulty batch, and LG has to find some creative ways to deal with the rejects without losing too much (these are expensive panels) AND not breaking the contract with Apple. Turned out Apple forbids LG to resell rejected 27" panels to any well-known brands in meaningful quantity. The restriction makes a lot of business sense: you don't want a major brand suddenly floods the market with comparable displays but at less than half of the price of iMacs and Cinema/Thunderbolt Displays. Especially so when you had spent a lot of money to secure the supply of such giant panels. So what does LG do in the end? They first sort the faulty batch into two categories: the better ones that can be salvaged by LG itself, and the worse ones that have to go somewhere else. LG re-cuts the slightly better ones into smaller panels (24" and below), and re-sells these to its partners as high grade IPS panels, as this is not forbidden by the contract with Apple (only 27" ones are forbidden). And worse ones? They go to various unknown brands in small quantities (again, this is not forbidden by the contract). My bet is that these Korean panels are from the second category.
- dshep 14y agoWas interested until I got to: "glossy anti-glare coating". I think I'd have just said it was glossy.
- serialx 14y agoTake a look at this: http://www.danawa.com/product/list.html?defSite=DISPLAY&cate1=860&cate2=13735&cate3=14883&cate4=15045 http://www.danawa.com/product/list.html?defSite=DISPLAY&... Simply take 3 zeros in the price tag to match dollars. There's even 220 dollar display!
- sachingulaya 14y agoAs an owner of one I'll toss in my 0.02. I purchased the Achieva Shimian 27" off of eBay for $290 a few weeks ago. It arrived within 5 days of purchase from Korea. There are no dead pixels or other defects. I hook it up to my macbook pro using: http://www.amazon.com/Monoprice-DisplayPort-Thunderbolt-Dual-Link-Adaptor/dp/B004C4SEH6 http://www.amazon.com/Monoprice-DisplayPort-Thunderbolt-Dual... This monitor only accepts dual-DVI input. You can buy the HDMI version for $350 if you want. Other variations include "pixel perfect" displays. Pixel perfect means they opened the box and there were no dead pixels. 80% of people on hardocp reported no dead pixels. The stand is definitely a bit wobbly. For $290--it can't be beat.
- nicholassmith 14y agoI was just thinking about what I'd need for a MBA to do this, so thanks for the link!
- sachingulaya 14y agoTo clarify--80% of people who did not order pixel perfect displays received displays with no dead pixels. "Pixel perfect" displays are ~$50 more.
- brilyient 14y agoI can't wait for "tablets" to be sold as "portable displays" that we can plug into small, low-power general purpose computers. We'll get the resolution of the Apple iPad butwe can use a real keyboard, a better, open-source kernel and we can do real programming without the Apple-style lockdown nonsense. The title is a little misleading. The "non-budget" diplays are often made in the same place (Asia, not the U.S.), from the same parts, maybe even the same factories, by the same workers.
- duncans 14y agoJeff Atwood got some, doesn't look like it worked out well: "two of the 27" Korean $350 s-ips monitors arrived. They are amazing panels, but lack of hardware brightness control may be a showstopper." https://twitter.com/codinghorror/status/224213213649190913 https://twitter.com/codinghorror/status/224213213649190913 "beautiful S-IPS panels but no hardware LED backlight brightness control times 3 is untenable. Oh well, experiment over." https://twitter.com/codinghorror/status/224217599746117632 https://twitter.com/codinghorror/status/224217599746117632
- vitalysh 14y agoArticle mentions that on 3rd page: http://techreport.com/articles.x/23291/3 http://techreport.com/articles.x/23291/3 tl;dr; buttons work, just no OSD. "Armed with a sense of how the buttons worked, I was soon adjusting the display brightness up and down, as well. I was able to dim the display to an acceptable level for the cave-like Damage Labs, and it wasn't even at the lowest possible setting."
- luigip 14y agoSome more discussion of these monitors here: http://www.tftcentral.co.uk/news_archive/26.htm#korean_ips27 http://www.tftcentral.co.uk/news_archive/26.htm#korean_ips27
- fersho311 14y agoJust got it! Dead on Arrival, does not work at all. $337 junk. The only thing that woks on this is the piece of shit built in monitor speakers.