16 ms·
NSF starts vetting all grants to comply with executive orders
- esalman 2y agoIt's really contradictory that the party of less regulation are introducing more friction and bureaucracy in scientific research process. But then it's also the party of anti-science so I can see why.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoThey are also the anti-government party, so sabotage is another motivating factor.
- tmountain 2y agoIt's only less regulation when it involves allowing big companies to do whatever they want. Rules for thee but not for me.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- beeforpork 2y agoIt is counter-contradictor measures. It is against nay-sayer people who research and find out stuff. Being smart will cost you, because it's not the goal. Less research, and lower levels of education equals more people to fall for simplistic solutions and promisses. The definition of truth is being redefined, and open-minded research and education is in the way of that. And it is always the same pattern.
- mike_hearn 2y agoIt's not a contradiction: wanting a small state implies both wanting a low burden of regulation on the private sector specifically, and also wanting a great deal of care to be taken with how money is spent by the government. It isn't a general argument for allowing arbitrary levels of public sector fraud or waste, and it feels bad faith to conflate these two things as if one implies the other. Nobody in the history of politics has argued on principle for a state that has high taxes yet doesn't enforce any rules on how the money is spent. In this case, the administration believes a lot of the work the NSF funds isn't actually scientific. In that they are correct. The replication crisis has been rolling for 15 years now with no real improvements, largely because the people who distribute the money don't care if it gets used for things that are genuinely scientific or if it gets used for things that merely have the surface level appearance of being scientific. The NSF funds vast amounts of pseudo-science that can be trivially identified and people have been talking about these problems for years with no resolution. Apparently, they need some friction and bureaucracy as otherwise they won't do their jobs correctly. In a free market government intervention isn't required to solve this problem because free actors will just stop funding pseudo-scientific work after a while, but the NSF isn't running a free market, and so the problem just never gets solved. This article focuses on social science but talks a bit about the general problems at the NSF at the end, and although it was written in 2020 thus at the start of the Biden administration the proposals the author makes for fixes are basically what's happening right now: https://fantasticanachronism.com/2020/09/11/whats-wrong-with-social-science-and-how-to-fix-it/ https://fantasticanachronism.com/2020/09/11/whats-wrong-with... Nobody actually benefits from the present state of affairs, but you can't ask isolated individuals to sacrifice their careers for the "greater good": the only viable solutions are top-down, which means either the granting agencies or Congress (or, as Scott Alexander has suggested, a Science Czar). You need a power that sits above the system and has its own incentives in order: this approach has already had success with requirements for pre-registration and publication of clinical trials. Right now I believe the most valuable activity in metascience is not replication or open science initiatives but political lobbying ... An NSF/NIH inquisition that makes sure the published studies match the pre-registration (there's so much """"""""""QRP"""""""""" in this area you wouldn't believe). The SEC has the power to ban people from the financial industry—let's extend that model to academia.21 ... It is difficult to convey just how low the standards are. The marginal researcher is a hack and the marginal paper should not exist. There's a general lack of seriousness hanging over everything—if an undergrad cites a retracted paper in an essay, whatever; but if this is your life's work, surely you ought to treat the matter with some care and respect. Why is the Replication Markets project funded by the Department of Defense? If you look at the NSF's 2019 Performance Highlights, you'll find items such as "Foster a culture of inclusion through change management efforts" (Status: "Achieved") and "Inform applicants whether their proposals have been declined or recommended for funding in a timely manner" (Status: "Not Achieved"). Pusillanimous reports repeat tired clichés about "training", "transparency", and a "culture of openness" while downplaying the scale of the problem and ignoring the incentives. No serious actions have followed from their recommendations. It's not that they're trying and failing—they appear to be completely oblivious. We're talking about an organization with an 8 billion dollar budget that is responsible for a huge part of social science funding, and they can't manage to inform people that their grant was declined! These are the people we must depend on to fix everything.
- fn-mote 2y agoFrom the article: >> For academic scientists, the list of banned activities could include efforts to increase diversity in the scientific workforce, collaborations with foreign scientists, and research on more environmentally friendly technologies. These are not the "vast amounts of pseudo-science" that your comment refers to. I have nothing against the ideas suggested in the 2020 blog post that you cite... it's just that is not what is happening because of the executive order. The executive orders do not address bad science. So overall, I agree with most ideas in your comment but I do not think it is relevant to the current situation. The administration is not trying to fix bad science.
- esalman 2y ago+1. I'd even say they are promoting bad science by putting up people like RFJ Jr for cabinet positions.
- esalman 2y agoRiddle me this, what has the Republican party done to alleviate replication crisis in scientific research?
- mike_hearn 2y agoHow about this move that we're discussing? Getting rid of openly ideological research grants will help the replication rate quite a bit, as that stuff is riddled with basic replication problems, much worse than the median paper. It's just too easy to take some grant money then publish something pseudo-scientific which sounds good to left wing ears, knowing that nobody will double check because they want it to be true. As an example, a lot of research into "misinformation" is like that. It's not replicable out of the gate because the papers don't describe their procedure for deciding whether a claim is true or false. They just present random lists of things that conservatives tend to believe, assert that none of them are true / they're conspiracy theories, then do a survey and use the results to conclude that conservatives are dumb / Russian bots. That's it, that's the entire field. There's no methodology, no theories, nothing to be refined or refuted. There are thousands of papers like this, it's astonishing to witness. I've been writing for years on the topic of bad science, and the fact that universities/granting bodies claim to care about science whilst simultaneously funding and celebrating this stuff is why their reputation has gone down the drain. The consequences were absolutely predictable. Nobody can claim they didn't see it coming. Right now, there's just a grant freeze combined with a review to find the really nakedly partisan DEI stuff. That's nothing. Much more intense stuff is well within the Overton Window of possibilities by this point, like ramped up prosecutions or large scale defunding.
- rsynnott 2y agoLess regulation for _companies_, more regulation for _people_.
- baggachipz 2y agoI was told that corporations are people, my friend.
- ludwik 2y agoThey are considered people only when it comes to rights, but not when it comes to restrictions and consequences.
- easytiger 2y agoIt really shouldn't be easy for ideologues to spend other peoples money. There are entire parallel structures in government, academia and now in business not contributing one iota of effort towards whatever the directed goal of their organisations are principally for. https://new.nsf.gov/funding/opportunities/dcl-social-behavioral-science-bias-prejudice-discrimination-bpd/nsf24-052 https://new.nsf.gov/funding/opportunities/dcl-social-behavio...
- ahmeneeroe-v2 2y agothis is pretzel logic.
- gtirloni 2y agoIf you couldn't see the anti-China rhetoric was a smoke screen, now it should be pretty obvious, with the US going down a similar road (eg. vetting projects that goes against the government's ideology... which is ironically what most far right politicians say they are against: ideology).
- brookst 2y agoIt’s the classic authoritarian doublespeak: they are 100% supportive of your rights, freedom, and obligation to believe what they tell you to believe.
- figassis 2y agoThis should make it clear. There is no such thing as being for or against ideology. If you exist, there are things you weakly believe in, and things you strongly believe in. The thing someone else strongly believes in, that we weakly believe in, we call ideology. So it's always been about fighting "their" ideology, not ideology. Always be skeptical when someone defends only the things they strongly believe in. That goes both ways, for the left and right.
- intermerda 2y ago[flagged]
- tome 2y ago> > Conservatism consists of exactly one proposition, to wit: > > There must be in-groups whom the law protectes but does not bind, alongside out-groups whom the law binds but does not protect. But this is completely false. The credulousness with which it gets repeated is telling.
- deeg 2y agoBefore the rise of Trump I might have agreed with you but now I think it's true for trumpers. Look at Musk, Mr. Free Speech until he doesn't like it. The quote above describes him exactly.
- omgJustTest 2y agoThey need arbitrary criteria on which to assess that money goes to the “right” group of people. Competitive awards already had a lot of arbitrary factors, this is yet another person to add to this, with a uniquely political perspective. Also if they don’t have to award the money it is likely they don’t.
- flanked-evergl 2y ago[flagged]
- tmountain 2y ago[flagged]
- rbanffy 2y agoLet's not allow a minority to drag what can be a civil and objective discussion into a shouting match.
- flanked-evergl 2y agoI was not thinking about immigrating to the US, but this is making me reconsider. EU is circling the drain and the writing is on the wall. The project failed.
- MrBuddyCasino 2y ago[flagged]
- matthewdgreen 2y agoAs context, the NSF requires grant writers to include a “broader impacts” section [1] in every grant proposal. This includes things like improving education, national security, economic competitiveness, and also inclusion - for example, ideas to attract more talent from underrepresented groups. So every NSF proposer works hard to satisfy the NSF on this requirement. I happen to think that these are worthwhile goals (we shouldn’t be wasting our limited talent due to historical crankiness) and simultaneously I believe the sections ends up being a bit performative. If the NSF were to change its criteria for grants going forward I might disagree with that approach but it would be consistent with what I’ve heard from these folks, ie they think “DEI” is getting in the way of science. However: the current approach is just destructive: if involves asking researchers to augment their proposals with these goals, and then retroactively refuses to pay already-awarded grant recipients who did what they were asked to. I will leave the question of whether this is constitutional to other folks. I will even leave aside the question of whether we can afford to defund science in our current crazy geopolitical environment. The real point here is that this is just plain wrong. [1] https://new.nsf.gov/funding/learn/broader-impacts https://new.nsf.gov/funding/learn/broader-impacts
- sega_sai 2y agoI think broader impact section is good. Whether it should be weighted as high as it was is up to debate. I personally think it was becoming too important for the success of the proposal. But obviously the new administration is not interested in any sort of nuanced debate, but rather ideological purge.
- anon946 2y agoI agree that the goals are worthwhile, and also feel that requiring every proposal to include this is not efficient and/or very effective. They should take all the funds and time spent on this every year as part of every award, and just fund programs specifically designed to attract inner-city kids to science, or funnel talented, low-income, high school students to be mentored, taught advanced classes, etc. I would be happy to spend time mentoring URM, etc. But it'd work a lot better if others managed such a program, thought about how to attract them, etc. Specialization is good.
- ANewFormation 2y agoThis seems great. It's increasingly apparent that the government was spending countless billions of dollars to push ideology in plainly weird ways. Why should somebody researching e.g. fusion for the Department of Energy also need to create a Promoting Inclusive and Equitable Research (PIER) plan, to even apply? This should greatly reduce the overall bureaucratic nonsense in science and help get back to science simply being science without imposing ideological conformity tests.
- taurknaut 2y ago> It's increasingly apparent that the government was spending countless billions of dollars to push ideology in plainly weird ways. Did you miss the last 80 years of anti-communist, pro-capitalist, free-market propaganda? The american government has been the most powerful ideological force in the world for basically all of living memory.
- rbanffy 2y ago[flagged]
- ANewFormation 2y agoYou're definitely right and I also do not agree with that stuff either, but it was mostly done "appropriately" in that it was through avenues, like the State Department or CIA, who have propaganda as part of their mission. In this case you had things like the Department of Energy requiring Promoting Inclusive and Equitable Research plans to even apply for funding. The two big differences I see is that that is a wholly inappropriate avenue for ideological enforcement, and that it's also exceptionally divisive. Things are changing in modern times but historically free markets, capitalism, and so on were very widely shared values. The contemporary equality of outcome (versus opportunity) stuff is extremely new and extremely divisive. The government pushing it, and frequently in very inappropriate ways (the military also comes to mind) is just very weird.
- idle_zealot 2y ago> requiring Promoting Inclusive and Equitable Research plans > equality of outcome (versus opportunity) stuff is extremely new and extremely divisive Equality of outcome, in the sense that we should hire unqualified people for research positions, is thankfully an incredibly rare and frankly insane position that almost nobody holds. Also thankfully, that's not what these required plans were. The requirement was that groups applying for grants have a specific and actionable plan for making sure that equality of opportunity was ensured. In fact, advantaging one group over another, such as with quotas, would directly violate DEI policy[1]. Typically, a plan would reference existing enrollment/acceptance policies of the company/university/department making an application, which are designed to make sure employees/students are not advantaged or disadvantaged by immutable or protected characteristics. Common examples would be: - Make sure that your hiring panel is diverse to avoid bias towards whatever groups are over-represented at your company already. It's a well-studied phenomena that people are inclined to like others who are similar to themselves. Without any other factors in play (skill is randomly distributed in applicants, all of your employees are free of sexual/racial bias), if your company consists of, say, 80% men and 20% women, and you pick your interviewers totally at random, you will continue to hire more men than women. If you use a 50/50 split on your interview panel then your hiring becomes more meritocratic by virtue of factoring out self-similarity biases. - Implement structured interviews and standardized qualifications-based hiring, rather than relying on interviewer preference. - Learning about potential subconscious biases helps people account for them. Incorporating bias training can mitigate (though not eliminate) hiring biases. Of course, as you have no doubt experienced, these training courses tend to be pretty boring and patronizing, but that's true of most employee training, so /shrug. - Diversifying applicant sourcing. If you only look for applicants via one platform, adding some more that tend to be used by different groups to your sourcing strategy. You have bought into the oft-repeated lie that DEI is some Harrison Bergeron-esque attempt to cripple institutions. You were probably pointed to one or two extremely poor implementations of such policies that were genuinely unfair. The broader movement, and most implementations of it, are about equality of opportunity. The intentional destruction of public perception of these policies and subsequent removal only guarantees that existing self-perpetuating gaps in opportunity will persist. [1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20241222222206/https://science.osti.gov/SWI/DOE-Diversity-Equity-and-Inclusion-Policies/Q-and-As https://web.archive.org/web/20241222222206/https://science.o... Archive link, because of course the new admin took down the page.
- aaron695 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sevensor 2y agoThe evil genius of this move is that it gets everybody arguing about DEI, and we’re letting the continued expansion of absolute executive power centered in the president go unchecked. It’s not even about party; this started with FDR or even earlier, massively expanded under LBJ and again under W and Obama, and now here we are. The president feels no obligation at all to execute what the Congress authorized him to. Instead the limits of power are whatever the president can get away with. We have a constitutional problem where the Congress is unwilling or unable to legislate effectively and the executive gets to make policy unilaterally. This is not the balance of powers from the U.S. constitution. This is something else.
- throw7474847 2y ago[flagged]
- pjc50 2y ago> We have a constitutional problem where the Congress is unwilling or unable to legislate effectively and the executive gets to make policy unilaterally. This is not the balance of powers from the U.S. constitution The Republican party controls both houses and the presidency, having already stacked the supreme court, so they get to do whatever they want and there is no balance of powers. Inevitable consequence of a two-party system with first past the post voting.
- FredPret 2y agoThere is still a very clear balance of power. All Republicans and all Democrats don’t act and think as one. Take any collection of humans, of any size, and their opinions will be spread across a spectrum. There are, and always will be, some members in either house and of any party that find it’s in their political interest to debate and pull new laws left or right. This is especially true under FPTP because each member has to answer to an area, and different areas of a country have baked-in differences in their ideal political outcomes and points of view.
- noobermin 2y ago
- wanderingmind 2y ago@dang this is turning into flame throwing. Can we please kill the thread as there is nothing intellectually curious being discussed here.
- davidmurdoch 2y agoThis. There are like 3 or 4 comments that are worth reading right now.
- rbanffy 2y agoOP here. Can we instead limit the visibility of the flamethrowers?
- seydor 2y agothe overton window has a new view. According to the old direction, these subjects are 'not to be discussed in professional society', i.e. they are to be decided by government and are considered intellectually dirty. Under the new rules, anything goes and needs to be publicly debated in order to remove the previous biases. Curious to see whether HN is also following suit in changing its window, like every other online medium seems to be doing.
- pjc50 2y agoI hope not; you can often see rightwing nonsense in threads, and lord knows I argue with them often enough, but it's not reached the Twitter point of total unusability yet and still manages to have interesting discussions sometimes.
- rbanffy 2y agoI hope we can still hold discussions on "dirty" subjects in a dispassionate and objective way. Sadly, I see a lot of those typical short snarky comments now common in other online spaces. Also, this IS an important discussion, for it's creating social transformation that might hinder our species' ability to solve the difficult challenges ahead.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rsfern 2y agoLots of politically charged comments on this discussion. If you disagree with NSF’s merit and broader impact review criteria, that’s fine and it’s important to have a healthy conversation about it, but I think it’s important to take a step back and thoughtfully address concrete ideas that are actually contained in the proposal review criteria. These are the kinds of issues at stake in terms of the broader impacts criteria: - Is it good that NSF promotes applications that include historically minority-serving institutions (as opposed to just the same few R1 universities)? - should NSF prioritize proposals with strong scientific outreach activities aimed at boosting engagement and opportunities in under-represented demographics? Keep in mind that NSF funding is extremely competitive. It’s not like subpar research is ubiquitously getting funded over better research with lower “broader impacts” scores. Successful proposals excel on both fronts.
- Gabriel54 2y ago1. There are thousands of universities in the US that are neither R1/R2 nor "historically minority serving". What about those universities? 2. Where did you get the idea that outreach is not still an important priority? The issue is what is euphemistically called "under-represented demographics" which we understand excludes many Americans on the basis of their race.
- legolas2412 2y ago> It’s not like subpar research is ubiquitously getting funded over better research with lower “broader impacts” scores. Yeah I don't buy that. I've seen equity directives in universities explicitly asking to hire only underrepresented minorities, or give one third of a candidate's score based on race and gender characteristics (the other two thirds were resume and interview). I've heard equity hiring quotas given to execs in tech industry. I've heard of pressure to hire/promote minorities. I've seen what affirmative action did to University admissions. The admissions office reduced Asian Americans score on "likeability". As a result they needed a higher sat score than any other group for admissions. The hiring office essentially said that they did not like Asians. So sorry, I do not buy the argument that equity initiatives just choose a minority representation from equally qualified samples. Because from what you say, Asian americans wouldn't have been discriminated against.
- Gabriel54 2y agoI'm genuinely puzzled by people's reaction to DEI measures. In my experience, they have in many cases been explicitly exclusionary (e.g. a conference only for certain minorities, specific support preferences). I have never heard anyone criticize "outreach" in general. The problem starts when outreach means only targeting specific minorities.
- WesolyKubeczek 2y agoIt's the first time I'm seeing accessibility put under the same umbrella as DEI. Is "DEIA" in the executive order, or is NSF overreacting, or... is being disabled and wanting to have some quality of life "woke" now?
- Steuard 2y agoAccessibility has always been part of DEI. (Certainly it's been a repeated topic of conversation in my campus's Diversity and Inclusion Advisory Board.) And yes, any effort that involves spending time or money to make sure that every person gets to "have some quality of life" falls under this same umbrella. That is literally what people are referring to when they call things "woke".
- WesolyKubeczek 2y agoThere is still a difference between actually doing hard work to help disadvantaged and marginalized folks and thinking that “being annoying about one’s pronouns” or “making lists of coworkers who are not woke enough” (both examples are quotes from self-proclaimed social justice activists) solves any problems. However, thinking that this crop of politicians would take a nuanced stance on anything at all is idiocy at its purest.
- Steuard 2y agoSure! There are always people out there who obsess over linguistic and behavioral purity, and they tend to be very loud. I'm not certain that I've ever met one of them in person. (I've certainly met people who might say (e.g.) "Here's why I've started including pronouns in my email sig," but I think that's not what you're talking about.) If the current "anti-woke" movement were just about shutting down those obnoxious purists, I think it would be a lot less controversial. But from what I've seen, the political rhetoric (and the associated policy positions now being implemented) strikes just as hard or harder at the folks actually trying to do the hard work.
- 2y ago
- noobermin 2y agoJust a note, this isn't just about DEI, it's about all things trump doesn't like it looks like. May be even solar power and windmills (that cause cancer, according to him).
- niemandhier 2y agoDirect presidential decrees within control by the parliament were how Weimar fell. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_48_(Weimar_Constitution) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_48_(Weimar_Constitutio...
- yk 2y agoLast week we have seen ai CEOs calling for sanctions because the Chinese publish open weights models and research, while the American companies don't. Then this naked politicization of science (which is also done pretty incompetently). This really feels like a paradigm shift.
- systemstops 2y agoI'm confused - was the decision to "shut everything down" made by the Trump admin, or by NSF on their own? If it's the latter, is it actually necessary or are they overreacting on purpose?
- bix6 2y agoIt is wild to pull already granted money. I meet so many scientists who just need $X to continue pursuing their research and it’s generally not a large sum. So this is incredibly disappointing for the research ecosystem which feeds the startup ecosystem. This hurts our competitiveness on the global stage and decreases our future quality of life.
- rsanek 2y agoanother great reminder that if the money isn't in an account in your name that you fully control, you shouldn't count on it. have had to learn this the hard way myself.
- elashri 2y agoWithout going into the discussion about polarized points. I have some observations 1- NSF budget is about 10 billions, I always had in mind that it is much more. That's about 0.17% of the total federal budget. If we include DOE R&D funding and NIH we will get to 1%. This is the funding for most of research in science in the US. Seems like not a great area to achieve huge reduction in deficit. 2- Even if we ignore the whole point of DEI and say that we need to end support for some of the projects. You do take your time and evaluate projects that needs to take action. You don't stop all the funding and pause critical support for projects and cause huge problems on medium and long term. And it also hurt the reputation of the country and its competitiveness. 3- The current NSF director was actually appointed by the current setting president in his first term.
- flanked-evergl 2y agoThis does not hurt the reputation of the US.
- greentxt 2y agoThe media coverage of it does.
- flanked-evergl 2y agoIn whose eyes? Iran's? Russia's? China's?
- intended 2y agoGermany, France, Canada, Japan, Taiwan, India. China looks at America and shows its citizens what an alternative fate could be, and it works.
- flanked-evergl 2y agoEurope is circling the drain, Taiwan is inconsequential and becoming less so by the day, and China does not respects it's citizens, they treat them like cattle. But okay sure, India's opinion is super important, especially as they are profiting off the Ukraine war.
- tbrownaw 2y agoSo everything has to get reviewed, and people are speculating about what that might mean?
- throw7474847 2y ago[dead]
- insane_dreamer 2y agoI can’t sort of understand an EO stopping grants with “gender ideology” or “woke ideology (whatever that means, still unclear), but “green new deal”?!? So we a halt all research into clean energy or climate change and just hope co2 emissions drop by themselves? Fing idiots who are sacrificing our children’s future for the oil and gas lobbyists. This makes me very angry.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoFor those of you who haven’t lived under an authoritarian regime, this is what it looks like (though it gets worse).
- bigstrat2003 2y agoThis is not, by any stretch of the imagination, an authoritarian regime. Hysterical rhetoric doesn't help anything, it simply inflames tensions and perpetuates the cycle of politicians trying to hurt each other. We should all attempt to avoid it as much as possible.
- Ylpertnodi 2y agoOn the other hand....
- insane_dreamer 2y agoThe whole "loyalty purge" is very much a hallmark of an authoritarian regime, and Congress is just standing by. Sure, it's not Russia or China, but it's certainly no model democracy. We're definitely heading down the path of authoritarianism / fascism. Don't forget that 4 years ago there was an armed attempt to overturn the results of an election, spurred on by the losing president who also pressured officials to overturn the results. And then the same politician was given immunity by the justices who he appointed (if it had been any other court they would have been forced to recuse themselves from the case), leading to him being re-elected and then promptly pardoning those who attempted a coup. That's arguably the most anti-democracy event in the history of the US (or at least the last 100 years). Then when that politician gets in power he starts an loyalty and ideological purge. That's exactly what authoritarian leaders do (and Xi in China did). So yes, we still have checks and balances and our system is not authoritarian, but Trump certainly is and is trying his hardest to centralize as much power and authority as possible in himself, which is again exactly what authoritarian leaders do. Lets call a spade a spade.
- outside1234 2y ago[flagged]
- sega_sai 2y agoNot only that. I've seen that some NSF-funded billion-sized projects are closing DEI channels in slack. The idiocy of the government is really limitless here.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thrwawy1234 2y agoI will not miss the “DEI” components of NSF proposals (or the PIER part of the DOE ones), especially having been on the review panel side about 5 times now. It’s not that I disagree with their intent, but the fact that after you’ve read a few you realize that proposers know exactly what they are expected to write there, so they write that there. Those sections are basically a useless going-through-the-motions exercise, and everyone knows it. I’ve never seen a proposal win or lose, or even change positions in a tie break, based on that content. More or less we just look to see that it exists, indicate that existence in the review form, and concentrate on the actual content. It’s a performative waste of everyone’s time.
- floor2 2y ago> I’ve never seen a proposal win or lose, or even change positions in a tie break, based on that content This is an absolutely wild statement, because my experience has been the complete opposite. I've seen a zillion times where a straight white guy was passed over specifically to achieve DEI goals. I don't think the pro-DEI crowd understands how discriminatory DEI initiatives became in many institutions and how that's the root of the anti-DEI backlash. I've lost count of the number of times I've seen the best X (candidate, project, company, whatever) get rejected because they were unacceptably white and male, so that the job/grant/contract could go to a DEI candidate instead. Heck, I was on an interview committee where the recruiters and hiring manager openly admitted they weren't interviewing male candidates, and we spent 3 months interviewing 100% of female candidates who applied while hundreds of male applicants got ghosted. That one was more explicit than most, but the same phenomenon has been happening for years at every layer of academia, business and government.
- Cumpiler69 2y ago[flagged]
- vkou 2y ago[flagged]
- UltraSane 2y agoI hate Trump as much as is humanly possible but DEI feels like using racism to fight racism.
- infamouscow 2y agoBecause it is. It's amusing how much Democrats bitch and moan when Republicans finally put an end to their racist policies. First time was with Abraham Lincoln. Now this. Nothing ever changes.
- UltraSane 2y agoAbraham Lincoln would be utterly appalled at the current GOP and how they follow the script they are given like little robots and despise Trump for his stupidity and lack of integrity. Don't pretend like the GOP isn't racist AF.
- deeg 2y agoSo how do you propose to make things better? White men dominate the power and wealth structures in the US. A long history of crushing racism has left a massive gap between white men and minorities. How do we make sure that minorities and women get the same fair chance at NSF grants as white men, when white men are making most of the decisions? How do we make sure we're funding science that helps everyone, not just those who make the highest decisions?
- UltraSane 2y agoThe real struggle in the US is with the rich hogging all the money and money is power as we see with Trump's billionaire cabinet and Musk. The rich have stolen tens of trillions of dollars from everyone else over the last 40 years by causing wages to grow slower than productivity and hogging all the gains from equity. I propose we have a national dividend were some percentage of all company profit and or revenue is equally distributed to all citizens and an estate tax of 100% of anything over $10 million with this indexed to inflation with half the proceeds equally distributed amongst all citizens who didn't pay the tax and the other half going to the federal government. Taxing people after they are dead is the fairest possible time to tax them. Minimum wage would be set at some percentage of the GDP per hour of labor, which is about $82/hour for the US. 20% to 30% would be reasonable.
- strangeloops85 2y agoWhile everyone is focusing on the so-called 'DEI' part, please note that per this article they are also targeting "environmentally friendly technologies". This is incredibly broad and could de-fund a broad array of fundamental research that has, as potential long-term impacts, reducing carbon emissions, PFAS remediation, desalination, etc. etc. Given that proposals were written years ago, researchers did not know that in the new regime certain words would become verboten and may have framed the eventual impact of their work in entirely reasonable ways that are now considered ideologically unacceptable. If they do choose to issue stop work orders on already funded grants that will certainly cause chaos across engineering and science in this country. And frankly, it will cede leadership on many topics to China (which is already dominating fields like materials science).
- wiskinator 2y agoThe NsF shouldn’t be rolling over to do what this new dictator in the US wants. This goes way beyond DEI; that’s just the trap to get insecure white men to agree with it. The NSF is “reviewing anything that goes against the stated national interest”. What does that even mean.