7 ms·
OpenRA – Classic strategy games rebuilt for the modern era
- cheeseomlit 2y agoI would absolutely love to see the same sort of project for aoe2. There's OpenAge, but it seems like they're still pretty far from something playable.
- Cristan 2y agoMaybe 0 A.D.? https://play0ad.com/ https://play0ad.com/ Its's closer to AOE1 in terms of historical period, but gameplay should be close enough.
- mtlynch 2y agoI think 0 A.D. is a super cool project, but I found it pretty hard to learn. It made me appreciate how delicate a task it is to teach the player the mechanics of a game like AoE and how good a job AoE did at that. I felt like 0 A.D. isn't approachable in the same way.
- Havoc 2y agoFor those interested in CC games see also upcoming tempest rising game. Doesn’t say as much but it’s clearly a copy. Half CC half Tiberian sun vibes
- nadermx 2y agoI play this often. If you play multi-player these build orders help https://forum.openra.net/viewtopic.php?f=82&t=21563 https://forum.openra.net/viewtopic.php?f=82&t=21563
- tra3 2y agoNice. Me and my son play coop against the bots and can never win. Maybe this will help.
- petercooper 2y agoGreat resource. This is my main problem with the game. It's so formulaic in the early stages and you really have to play to the meta to stand a chance of surviving past about ten minutes. Strategy doesn't really come into it unless you survive beyond a certain point.
- kingo55 2y agoI love how faithful this is to the original games but at the same time they've modernised the gameplay so that it doesn't feel it's age. When you go back and play the originals (even Red Alert remastered) the modernised gameplay added by Open RA becomes very apparent. I can't go back to the originals now.
- goosedragons 2y agoFeel the same way with OpenRCT2. I could have sworn the original games had controls for speeding up and slowing down park time but nope. Going back to Roller Coaster Tycoon 2 I just can't play it at 1x speed anymore. OpenRCT2 just has some nice little fixed.
- bondarchuk 2y agoThat was so nice about the og though, you have to wait so you just spend the time building some technically useless but nice looking stuff. Fast forward kind of ruins that.
- hnlmorg 2y agoTo be honest, I always found Westwood strategy games to be very one dimensional compared to other strategy games even in its own era. I never understood why people loved them so much. Perhaps it was because of their simplicity thus allowing for more mainstream appeal? Im sure I’ll get downvoted by the Red Alert fans with their rose tinted glasses for saying this because a lot of people forget just how basic those games were. But I played a hell of a lot of strategy games back then (it was my favourite genre) and Westwood did some of the most simplistic games in the genre. Where Westwood excelled at was the presentation more than the game play. Great music, FMV in the later games, etc. Anyhow, I might check out this OpenRA project if they’ve tweaked the mechanics.
- intalentive 2y agoC&C Generals is up there with StarCraft in terms of gameplay. And yes the RA music is some of the best ever game music. I still blast Hell March from time to time.
- deadlyllama 2y agoDoes it play the single player mode cutscenes though? My PC was underpowered when I was playing Red Alert. Full screen, full motion video still seemed pretty amazing back then. "Hitler is.. out of ze way"
- dfex 2y agoIf you have the original CDs, then yes, you can import all the cutscene media files (FMV, music etc.) during the install phase and it will play them just like the original, but they aren't included in the download for obvious reasons.
- cpressland 2y agoI’d love a project like this, but for Red Alert 2. It works great on my Steam Deck but often stutters on larger battles. A modern, native, Linux port would be amazing.
- kingo55 2y agoThere have been plans to bring RA2 to OpenRA for some time now. I second this. It'd be nice to also see support for Tiberian Sun and the C&C Remastered collection.
- cpressland 2y agoAny sources? I’d be keen to see if I can help out, even if only financially.
- kingo55 2y agoIt was posted below: https://github.com/OpenRA/ra2 https://github.com/OpenRA/ra2 It works, but it's not an official release yet. Fwiw I haven't played this myself.
- 999900000999 2y agohttps://github.com/OpenRA/ra2 https://github.com/OpenRA/ra2 Works great on Linux
- cpressland 2y agoI have seen this in the past, but I figured it was mostly abandonware given the lack of recent commits. I’ll install it and check it out though, thanks for the suggestion.
- HelloUsername 2y agoThis might interest you (RA2 in the webbrowser) https://game.chronodivide.com/ https://game.chronodivide.com/
- 2y ago
- kingo55 2y agoBased on this open source project, modders have created an expanded universe encapsulating RA, RA2, Tiberian Sun, Tiberian Dawn and other lore into Combined Arms mod: https://www.moddb.com/mods/command-conquer-combined-arms https://www.moddb.com/mods/command-conquer-combined-arms Worth a look for a new fan made entry into the C&C universe. The scale of the mod is huge...
- ozarker 2y agoWoah this looks awesome, thanks for sharing!
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoAnd you don’t need the original game to play this, it appears?
- veidelis 2y agoThat's right.
- tetha 2y agoOh that first level caught me off-guard in a good way. Like, at first they fixed that weird error condition how you could detonate the tech lab Einstein is in, which broke a trigger and failed the mission. Now you just blow it up, Einstein is there and you can go from there. And then I continued with the normal motions of this mission and... no, not gonna spoil it. That was a great introduction of new content to the mission. And the second mission does it in a similar way. Hah!
- piyiotisk 2y agoThanks my favourite is tiberian sun and I was looking to find a way to play it on mac. I think with this I might be able to do it
- 1727706962 2y agoI've just finished both campaigns (and moving on to Firestorm!) on my M1 Macbook by running the game through https://www.portingkit.com/ https://www.portingkit.com/ . It guides you through installation and wraps the game in Wine and other layers as its own .Application for running on arm or intel macs. Porting Kit has bespoke configurations for compatible games. Also see https://github.com/Kegworks-App/Kegworks https://github.com/Kegworks-App/Kegworks (formerly Wineskin, the upstream tech leveraged by Porting Kit without the bespoke angle) which i've used for various modern games to great effect.
- scott_w 2y agoIt’s not clear from the website but I’ve always been curious if these engines have community built assets that negate the need for real game assets. It would be really nice to sidestep the need to buy the games altogether (legally of course!)
- ellg 2y agoIn this case, EA released all the classic c&c games for free so its pretty easy to snag all the assets. I think the OpenRA launcher even has an option to download them for you. There are 3rd party mods with their own assets too though, its a pretty neat engine.
- cess11 2y agoYes, it pulls them automatically, which is really nice.
- TuringNYC 2y ago>> In this case, EA released all the classic c&c games for free Bless EA. I was wondering how this happened. I have wonderful memories of playing these games in the early 1990s and it has been doubly wonderful playing them now, with my children, in LAN mode.
- oaththrowaway 2y agoMy favorite RTS game of all time. Love the port. Run my own server for my friends group and it works great
- hypercube33 2y agohave they fixed the awful pathfinding bugs - especially the Tiberian Dawn ones make it play worse than the official dos one imo.
- wink 2y agoI know people (rightfully) loved them for the gameplay (I was more of a WC2 and SC player), but my favourites were the videos in RA3 with Tim Curry et al. It was just the right type of corny
- endlessvoid94 2y agoAnd Lando!
- BrouteMinou 2y agoOne of the best RTS out there. I go there every night to get my ass kicked once or twice before bed. I highly recommend it.
- dfex 2y agoAnd I thought it was just me. I didn't get my first win until I chose Turtle AI with 40% handicap. After many months of "honing" my skills, I am now about 50/50 against Rush AI on equal standings, but I still have to play larger maps so that there is some lag before they can reach my base.
- vanviegen 2y agoJust wait until you try playing online. That'll be an interesting experience.. ;-)
- hagendaasalpine 2y agoI can recommend the RTS OpenHV, built on the OpenRA engine. https://www.openhv.net/ https://www.openhv.net/
- tra3 2y agoI checked the link but I can’t find anything on how it’s different from the base game. What do you like about it?
- paulryanrogers 2y agoFrom what I've read HV originally aimed to add things like supply lines, terrain heights, deformable terrain, and "player created landscapes". Since the original was cancelled and many of its ideas implemented elsewhere, this newer fan effort may not appear as innovative as the OG could've been.
- knowitnone 2y agoopenHV is such a horrible game. your units default to doing nothing when attacked. You barely know what is being attacked. This game is from the 80s and should just stay there.
- HelloUsername 2y agoPrevious discussions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28511076 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28511076 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37553193 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37553193 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31197091 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31197091 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7730555 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7730555 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26533422 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26533422 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42823667 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42823667 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23120677 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23120677 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23342320 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23342320 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14065021 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14065021
- dang 2y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: OpenRA – Classic strategy games rebuilt for the modern era - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37553193 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37553193 - Sept 2023 (169 comments) OpenRA: Open-source RTS game engine for games such as Command and Conquer - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31197091 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31197091 - April 2022 (80 comments) OpenRA: Red Alert, Command and Conquer, Dune 2000, Rebuilt for the Modern Era - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28511076 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28511076 - Sept 2021 (199 comments) OpenRA Release 20210321 (and new website) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26533422 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26533422 - March 2021 (10 comments) OpenRA: An open, cross platform and expandable implementation of Command&Conquer - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23342320 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23342320 - May 2020 (3 comments) OpenRA: AI Development Guidelines (2018) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23120677 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23120677 - May 2020 (4 comments) OpenRA: Classic strategy games, rebuilt for the modern era, open source - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14065021 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14065021 - April 2017 (1 comment) Show HN: OpenRA – RTS project that recreates Command and Conquer games - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7730555 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7730555 - May 2014 (40 comments)
- Ygg2 2y agoHeh. I still see they are using my localization library. Not much, but it does give me a small heart warming tug.
- veunes 2y agoThat’s awesome! It is such a great feeling.
- cess11 2y agoTo me multiplayer RA is like the Quake 1 of RTS, it's fast, chaotic and exciting, and OpenRA makes it trivial to get running, with some balancing and quality of life adjustments compared to the original. It would be awesome if someone managed to figure out something similar for Populous: The Beginning, which is a fantastic solo RTS and arguably even more chaotic than RA so multiplayer isn't as cleanly skill based as is common in the RTS genre. I can run it through Wine but it's always a bit messy to install on a new machine.
- sapphicsnail 2y agoAre there any newish RTSs that are active? It seems like there's way more users for older ones.
- timidger 2y agoBeyond All Reason
- mdaniel 2y agosomeone submitted it <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42826983 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42826983> if anyone wants to discuss it separately
- killerstorm 2y agoBest RTS for me, by far. 10x more playable than SC2.
- bloomingkales 2y agoWhy? SC2 is too physically exhausting for me. I like strategy, but I don’t like how it makes me micro at all.
- killerstorm 2y agoYeah, in SC2 I could not micro units at all. In BAR micro feels quite good: * the game pace is overall a bit slower * projectile weapons actually take time to land * many quality of life features, in particular, ability to give a whole group of units an order to get to specific positions by 'drawing' where you want them to be * a lot more options for static defense play * different options - surround, ranged attacks, kiting, AoE weapons vs evasion
- Kerbiter 2y agoRusted Warfare Sanctuary Tempest Rising
- 2y ago
- warthog 2y agoThe site gets blocked by Phantom wallet extension for your information
- m4thfr34k 2y agoFirst time I've ever seen this. Came to the comments to see if anyone else experienced that. I don't see openra in the blocklist but perhaps I need to look again. https://github.com/phantom/blocklist https://github.com/phantom/blocklist
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- readyplayernull 2y agoI've been playing Open X-Com + The X-Com Files, pretty addicting.
- Kerbiter 2y agoI thought constant reposts of the same thing are not allowed on HN.
- andrewstuart 2y agoI loved the Command and Conquer games and played them for vast amounts of time. Don’t seem to be able to play or replay any such real time strategy games now. Don’t know what changed.
- nprateem 2y agoYou did I expect. I find it so much more difficult to play games now I know i won't live forever and times a-wasting.
- ZYbCRq22HbJ2y7 2y agoIf I remember correctly, people used to mod RA and other C&C games to have custom models, like Tanya nude and such. I wonder if this was born from that.
- The28thDuck 2y agoThis looks cool but intimidating - is this something that is accessible to beginners?
- self_awareness 2y ago"Learning" is always accessible for beginners.
- impact_sy 2y ago[dead]
- gatane 2y agoThe OST of this game is amazing. Make sure to download the official CD data from the freeware release, they are a blast.
- ghostpepper 2y agoNow do generals
- shabgzer 2y agoGreat effort, love to see that the game preserved in this way. However, for me, the nostalgia wore off quickly. I no longer have the feeling of immersion I used to have when I was younger; I've become numb to the magic. What I see is pathfinding, a graphics engine, a sound player...
- tomw1808 2y agoIt's because you need more tesla coils, brrzzing. Jokes aside, after reading a few of the official tounament strategies, its where the magic disappeared for me - its so much weight towards rushing over the enemy that wins every time, it kinda lost its bliss. Still, sometimes its fun to just play with some like-minded friends in a multiplayer game
- MortyWaves 2y agoI really wish they’d use the HD graphics from the remastered version on Steam.
- Therapist1911 2y agoThere is a version of Tiberian Dawn HD. Red Alert will take more work as there are unique assets in OpenRA Red Alert that don't exist in the original Red Alert. Including vehicles and infantry units that were put in place for balance/fun reasons.
- bloomingkales 2y agoCan I suggest something? Integrate this with some TTS and LLM so I can say “send my tanks north”, that rough command should translate. I’m not a game dev, so it’ll take me forever to even figure out where in the code to do this interception, but it’s a dream of mine.
- worldsayshi 2y agoShouldn't be too hard to implement. The only hurdle would be that you need the user to host or pay for the TTS and LLM usage. So you need to ask the users for API key or add some payment solution.
- bzzzt 2y agoWould you really need a complicated LLM just to bark some instructions to a game? There is a finite way of expressing instructions to the game, you don't want to get into a discussion about what 'my tanks' means in the middle of the action. Siri could do this in 2011 and later versions work fine on device without connectivity.
- hirako2000 2y agoMechanics in real time strategy games are integral parts of it though.
- worldsayshi 2y agoI would love to see the code of an on device implementation that could accomplish a similar task. Pre LLM I have never seen an app that can take a variety of voice commands and execute on them with a good user experience. Are there any good open source implementations that can run without depending on proprietary calls to the device? In fact I still haven't seen speech-to-command being implemented well in an end user app regardless of technology. Maybe I have looked at the wrong apps. I haven't used Siri to any large extent. Google home seems very gimmicky. I recently tried doing a small bit of STT and I was underwhelmed by the quality I get on device. I used Whisper. It was bad enough that I concluded that I'd probably need to call to a hosted service instead. And even if the TTS works really well, for most use cases you'll need to have an LLM reinterpret what your saying into commands.
- iamsanteri 2y agoI‘ve been playing OpenRA for over a year now. After all the hardcore triple-A games this is the one I‘ve settled on. Maybe because I played it as a kid when it came out. It‘s pretty balanced and the community is awesome. Despite it being very unforgiving at start, as you get up to speed it becomes amazingly deep and competitive. So much fun!
- tomw1808 2y agoI love this. Not that I play it often, however, I guess its the memories. I remember when RA was released and I was glued to my screen, at home or at lan parties. Multi player or Skirmish, always fantastic way to kill some time with quality game play. This and blobby volley :) I love that they fixed so many of the shortcomings of the original gameplay in OpenRA. It's really fun to play.
- bobheadmaker 2y agoAhh... that's nostalgia coming back
- pylua 2y agoThanks for sharing this. I’m really excited to see scrin here!
- nprateem 2y agoSomething about the RA aesthetic always looked a bit cartoonish to me. All the other titles had better graphics. I was never sure what it was...
- Aardwolf 2y ago> Updated gameplay designed around modern features like attack-move, unit veterancy, and the fog of war Modern features: aren't those features as old as RTS's? E.g. fog of war was present as early as Warcraft II :)
- sholladay 2y agoI would pay a lot of money to have an Apple Silicon native install of Star Trek: Armada. Amazingly, it still runs on recent versions of Windows, though Windows itself has become a lot more annoying over the years.
- Gormo 2y agoWhy not just run it with Qemu or Box86?
- OliverJames 2y ago[dead]
- OliverJames 2y agoThat is Great. I like this.
- OliverJames 2y ago[dead]