5 ms·
The consensus on Havana Syndrome is cracking
- subliminalpanda 2y agohttps://archive.ph/qb4E2 https://archive.ph/qb4E2
- j_bum 2y agohttp://archive.today/qb4E2 http://archive.today/qb4E2
- Over2Chars 2y agoIt sounds mysteriously like the American medical and health insurance systems: "disabled, struggling with chronic pain, and drowning in medical bills." Maybe the US should inflict it's medical and health insurance systems on foreign adversaries as a "mystery weapon" to inflict disability, pain, and medical bills on them. Just sayin'
- BLKNSLVR 2y agoWWIII was ended when the US dropped the world's first beauracracy bomb on Brussels, followed by an assault of, also unprecedented at the time, regulatory-capture missiles. It's not expected that the Brussels that existed prior to the war will ever be seen again. It is expected that it's populace will continue to decline for the foreseeable future.
- Over2Chars 2y agoIs the US at war with Brussels? Figures, I don't think their sprouts are very popular either.
- zeofig 2y agoIf by adversaries you mean "allies", then they're way ahead of you.
- pstuart 2y agoMy completely unfounded wild ass guess is that its some form of remote monitoring that has the noted side effects (that is, the harm to the personnel affected is unintentional).
- DiscourseFan 2y agoYou mean like mass x-ray scanning? That would be extraordinarily dangerous, but I suppose it might be possible given the right conditions.
- pstuart 2y agoI was thinking something more akin to this: https://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/security/a42575068/scientists-use-wifi-to-see-through-walls/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/security/a425750... But with way more power.
- cmdli 2y agoAs an aside, I’m rather tired of every discussion being implicated as some grand conspiracy or coverup. It’s possible that things simply move from “we have almost no evidence that this happened” to “we have some evidence to support that this happened”. That’s not admitting some grand mistake, that’s just the normal progression of the facts.
- zonkerdonker 2y agoRespectfully, the issue here was not that intelligence agencies were saying "we have no eveidence of this". first few sentences of the article shows the reality, these agencies were vehemently stating that it was not possible that the Havana Syndrome was caused by bad foreign actors, full stop.
- EA-3167 2y agoAre people really surprised that an intelligence agency's first duty isn't to the truth or accurately informing the public? ed: sp
- econ 2y agoThose might be agents too. The narrative might have started with electric fields from the grid stressing people if not causing cancer. Then moved to radio, wifi, the so called biological radio frequency spectrum. Etc It was always an engineered argument between one camp advocating absurdly human fragility vs the other camp pretending we are indestructible supper beings and no form of radiation could harm us - ever! It sets up the perfect climate to prevent a honest objective scientific discussion.
- derektank 2y agoSaying "we have no evidence that directed energy weapons caused this syndrome," is not the same as emphatically saying, "this syndrome was not caused by directed energy weapons," which is what the reporting in this piece indicates was said. The latter is an affirmative statement intended to eliminate doubt and which has the effect of denying the experiences of those affected.
- kennywinker 2y ago“campaign by a U.S. adversary, probably Russia, that left them disabled, struggling with chronic pain, and drowning in medical bills.” Yeah, that last bit’s not an adversary’s fault… What kind of country lets diplomats and civil servants, or really anyone, drown in medal debt when they’re injured on the job???
- dylan604 2y ago> What kind of country lets diplomats and civil servants, or really anyone, drown in medal debt when they’re injured on the job??? ooooh oooh ooh, I know this one. pick me pick me!!! I'm assuming this was rhetorical though
- arisbe__ 2y agoWatch Jack Kruze on Robert Breedlove's podcast (near the end of Pt II will blow your mind blown right out of your skull.) A medical revolution? -- perhaps something much more.
- Izkata 2y agoAs far as I was aware, "mystery weapon" was the consensus, and this reaffirms it in the first two paragraphs. Looks like a clickbait title.
- elicash 2y agoNo, you should read the article. They cite the previous review by seven intelligence agencies. That had been publicly reported, so for folks who had been following it, the consensus was most recently that it wasn't a mystery weapon.
- ggm 2y agoAnother part of this is that these agencies by temperament hedge their answers and were remarkably unequivocal, noting "new evidence could change their mind" -and they have become less unequivocal. This strongly suggests new evidence, but since this is in the secrecy-strategic space, we're not going to know. It could be somebody senior said "change tone of voice" or it could be something new was found. We can't know.
- whycome 2y agoWe’ve really blurred the meaning of: facts, consensus, winning, truth
- sanderjd 2y agoNope! Most people think this is a conspiracy theory. Maybe it is maybe it isn't, but it's interesting for both sides to keep in mind the actual state of play as this continues to develop. For you, who thinks "duh, everyone knows this was a weapon", it's interesting to know that no, your perspective is being skewed somehow, probably by the media you consume. For me, who thinks "duh, everyone knows this was a paranoid conspiracy theory", it's interesting to follow the actual investigation into it, because maybe we're wrong.
- specialist 2y agoYour comment gave me a notion. "Science fantasy" was coined to discern between "hard sci-fi" (The Martian) and make believe (Star Wars), right? How about: Conspiracy - - fact: stuff we know, like nicotine and climate crisis - theory: likely but as yet "unproven", like a RICO case going to trial. - fantasy: ancient civilizations, flat earth, X-Files, QAnon, etc. - bullshit/lies: stuff we know is bullshit, like Holocaust denial - mystery: we just don't know (yet?), like maybe Havana Syndrome Acknowledging that "conspiracy theory" was coined to (successfully) cast "conspiracy fact" as "conspiracy bullshit". Like COINTELPRO. Acknowledging that misuse and abuse of terms is the norm. Like how "hackers" morphed from tinkerers and inventors to criminals. But at least when I say something is "conspiracy bullshit", my people will know what kind of conspiracy I'm talking about, without further explanation.
- yapyap 2y agoI thought it was already confirmed to not be a hoax and be a true thing. (kind of sensationalist but still seems to be informative youtube video about it from about 3 months back: https://youtube.com/watch?v=xqE0ltifQ2M https://youtube.com/watch?v=xqE0ltifQ2M)
- kbelder 2y agoLike a lot of things, it's been definitively confirmed both ways.
- anonu 2y agoWasn't the 60 minutes from a year ago enough info to show this was some sort of targeted weapon?
- nickburns 2y agoThe opposite, actually.
- TheAceOfHearts 2y agoI don't really understand how there can be so much back and forth on this issue. We already know directed-energy weapons are possible [0], what are the challenges in exploring the space until you're able to build an approximate match for what people report having experienced? The most scary thing about these kinds of systems seems to me to be the potential for urban terrorism. If it doesn't leave any trace and it can penetrate walls, it could be used to attack people working for rival organizations as well as general harassment. Imagine a tool that lets you disrupt someone's sleep, using that over months would be enough to drive them insane or at least seriously hamper their productivity and performance. For example: if a rival sports team is visiting and you're able to disrupt their sleep that might be enough to give your team an edge. How far are people really willing to go in order to win? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directed-energy_weapon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directed-energy_weapon
- vkou 2y ago> The most scary thing about these kinds of systems seems to me to be the potential for urban terrorism. A mortar or backpack has a thousand times the potential for urban terrorism.
- richardw 2y agoDepends. A mortar going off once will be an incident, but have a hidden mind ray targeting random 10 people a day in a big city and you’ll get a lot of panic, and it’ll gum up the works. Anytime someone gets a headache they’ll head to an ER. A mortar is a somewhat known danger, and doesn’t trigger imagination and fear as much as a danger you can’t identify.
- portaouflop 2y agoThere are people already imagining this - look up “targeted individuals”
- vkou 2y ago> a hidden mind ray targeting random 10 people a day in a big city and you’ll get a lot of panic, You'll get just as much panic by having friendly press start pretending that this is happening. A significant portion of the population does not have a working bullshit filter, and will believe all sorts of stupid garbage. You don't actually need to build a child trafficking ring in the basement of a pizza shop, you just need to tell people that one exists and tens of millions of people will believe you. And in this case, your side business of selling ubermensch supplements and tinfoil helmets will be cracking.
- itchingsphynx 2y agoA good book on this syndrome by Bob Baloh, which also reviews psychogenic illnesses. https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-030-40746-9 https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-030-40746-9
- ggm 2y agoA key point I feel, is that psychogenic illnesses are illnesses. People who get them should be treated as ill, and should be entitled to support and respect. Putting it into the "not a real illness" bucket is why people with ME, and Long covid are so deeply unhappy with the state response to their problems.
- slashdave 2y agoWho is denying long COVID? https://recovercovid.org https://recovercovid.org
- ggm 2y agohttps://bmjgroup.com/flawed-body-of-research-indicates-true-long-covid-risk-likely-exaggerated/ https://bmjgroup.com/flawed-body-of-research-indicates-true-... Less so now, I agree. But there has been a denialist tendency just as for ME
- thrance 2y ago> The geopolitical consequences are profound, especially as a new president prepares to take office: If Russia, or any other country, were found culpable for violent attacks on U.S. government personnel, Washington would likely feel compelled to forcefully respond. Seeing how Trump has repeatedly praised Putin and criticized Zalensky, it's doubtful there'd be any consequences if Russia really turned out to be behind all this.
- klibertp 2y agoIt'll just mean that China is behind this, which means the tariffs are actually benign and justified response, not kickstarting a trade war. It'll be the truth, some new kind of Truth (Social.) I don't want to sound apocalyptic, but I think the media and political narratives of the mainstream lost all reality checks in the past few decades (not for the first time - historically, it happens ever-so-often), which means that there's no point trying to reconcile them with facts mentally. It's tiring and pointless - politicians, commentators, and the public allowed their Overton windows to slide way too far from the reasonable. It'll pass - meanwhile, we can only hope the effects won't be as pronounced as if ImageMagick finally broke for good.
- jmyeet 2y agoSo I'm skeptical for two reasons. 1. Just look at the completely made up fears about ODing from fentanyl just by touching it or even just breathing in the fumes. There is absolutely no truth to these dangers [1][2], yet the myth persists. It's so pervasive that cops actually have panic attacks; and 2. US authorities and the intelligence community has a vested interest in exaggerating the risks of foreign actors to get more funding. You see this everywhere, even in domestic affairs: the "crime panic" of recent times that is completely made up, completely overblown fears of looting in the aftermath of the LA fires (while there's little to no attention on the price gouging and profiteering that's going on) and so on. Those domestic manufactured panics are copaganda to justify further militarization and funding for the police. My point is that there is a significant part of the US government gearing up for and wanting an escalation of conflict with China in particular. Cuba of course has been a bogeyman for decades. So my money is still firmly on "Havana Syndrome is completely made up". [1]: https://www.njspotlightnews.org/special-report/fentanyl-myth-police-cry-overdose-facts-prove-otherwise/ https://www.njspotlightnews.org/special-report/fentanyl-myth... [2]: https://healthandjusticejournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40352-021-00163-5 https://healthandjusticejournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/1...
- satvikpendem 2y agoRegarding #2, then why would US intelligence agencies state that these incidents were not caused by foreign state actors? You'd expect the opposite given your hypothesis.
- cool_dude85 2y agoThe main possibility, I'd say, is that organizationally there's a push and pull of wanting to have the fear of secret weapons programs existing (for funding) and not wanting to seem incompetent. For example, if the CIA doesn't come out and deny these weapons, your geriatric boss calls up and says where are our secret sound guns? Why don't we have countermeasures? In general, I think intelligence agencies are not monolithic and probably have many different factions etc. vying for funding, power, and control. It seems reasonable that many in the CIA would benefit from denying this, and many would benefit from exaggerating it.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- laurentpm 2y ago[dead]
- exitb 2y agoDon’t all of these symptoms have really high (>10%) rate of incidence in general population?
- gre 2y agoIt was crickets. https://coe.northeastern.edu/news/crickets-may-be-the-cause-of-havana-syndrome/#:~:text=ECE%2FKhoury%20Professor%20Kevin%20Fu,short%2Dtailed%20West%20Indies%20cricket https://coe.northeastern.edu/news/crickets-may-be-the-cause-....
- caminante 2y agoThis isn't a joke. At one point, the narrative (2021) landed on this native insect whose frequency was so loud that you could "hear it from inside a car while driving [40+] mph down the highway" (paraphrased). Was this debunked or just another conspiracy™? edit: > The heavily redacted report notes that “many” of those reporting symptoms described hearing “unusual sounds” but states that in only one instance someone experienced medical symptoms immediately after hearing the sounds. The report goes on to say that JASON could identify “no plausible single source of energy (neither radio/microwaves nor sonic) [that] can produce both the recorded audio/video signals and the reported medical effects.” Instead, the scientists wrote that the most likely source of the sound heard in the recordings is the Indies short-tailed cricket, whose call, it says, “matches, in nuanced detail, the spectral properties of the recordings from Cuba.” Still, the report hedges, saying that “other hypotheses are plausible,” including that the sounds were created by a mechanical device or “structure-borne vibrations.” [0] [0] https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/havana-syndrome-crickets-not-microwaves-report-1235163/ https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/havana-s...
- ggm 2y agoAnyone remember the "yellow rain of poison" in the Haig years which turned out to be insect shit on leaves? If you weren't there: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellow_rain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellow_rain These kinds of things are why people are skeptical when "official sources" tell us things from intelligence sources they can't discuss in public.
- selimthegrim 2y agoI think the Hmong are still mad about being made out to look like idiots
- harry8 2y agoThe Atlantic is simply not a credible source for anything involving Russian influence on the USA. Anything they print on the topic you think is plausible should be corroborated relatively deeply. The Alfa Bank BS is amazing. Putin sucks.
- ggm 2y agoWhile I think you may be right, I wish you could find a way to say it which is evidence based, and something we can look at more deeply. Because right now, what you said carries the preface: "In my personal opinion" I read the atlantic precisely because I am sure it doesn't align with my non-US, world view. I want to understand what vaguely rightist, middle-of-the-road corporates and old school william buckley types think. I don't mind reading things I may disagree with. I'm tired of reading things grounded in fantasy which is what Fox sells. At least the atlantic is grounded in a version of ground-truth I can usually get behind, and is clear when its opinions, or reflecting opinionated sources.
- WillPostForFood 2y agoI want to understand what vaguely rightist, middle-of-the-road corporates and old school william buckley types think. Wow, that's wild. I don't think you are reading the right magazine for that. Atlantic is vaguely left of center, middle of the road oligarchic old school Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr. ish. It's a good read! But will tell you nothing about the right. If you want that, just read National Review, or The Dispatch for something a little more modern.
- ggm 2y agoIf its "left" I'm a dutchman. It's as middle-of-the-road as it can be, and for me, thats right of center. National Review is foaming at the mouth. Remember I said I'm not an american, I don't regard "liberal" as a slur of the right against the left, in Australia the "liberal" party are the rightists.
- WillPostForFood 2y ago
- lawrenceyan 2y agoNeurowarfare is the next frontier (*we’ve reached a ceiling in the realm of kinetic weaponry imo). But the only reliable defense for that is gaining enlightenment, which is both very difficult to scale and somewhat ironic given the context.
- macinjosh 2y ago[flagged]
- ggm 2y agoI have had a theory this is a "blowback" effect of counter-intel functions inside US diplomatic and related facilities. The amount of RF, sound and other burdens inside the suspended secure communications facility, and the ubiquity of these facilities inside US state functions operated in potentially adverse economies. Like EMP, you protect to the level you can afford, and demonstrate inside your own testing it's operationally feasible to prevent, not the actual scale an attacker can elect to deploy. It's a variant of the 'look for your lost keys under the lamppost because you can see' problem: to protect secure communications you need to do work, in the radio and sound spectrum, at least as energetic as the attacks you have hypothesised, and you probably wind up injecting TWICE the effective energy overall, if an attack happens: their energy, and your mitigation. If these defences are purely passive, I'd be deeply wrong. I doubt if anyone who knows what active defences are deployed would be able to say so. edit: if this is potentially caused by US counter-intel efforts, they'd probably seek to deny it, but that heads to a conspiracy theory place. A lot of Iraq veterans can testify to how much the forces seek to minimise the damages of service, I would be totally unsurprised if state department and foreign affairs doesn't want a multi-million dollar health claim on their books. No matter what, they have one, but for now it's without associated damages. If they admit to it being their own fault the class action lawyers will have a field day.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 2y agoI also think that some sort of embassy-operated anti-eavesdropping emitters being the cause is the most plausible explanation. Embassies are typically espionage stations, i.e. they're almost certainly full of equipment that monitors every measurable aspect of the EM spectrum and probably various other things too. Covertly deploying any kind of electromagnetic weapon near an embassy sounds like an impossibility to me. But if the embassy's own security hardware caused it, it's very likely that it would be kept secret (also to protect the secrecy around such hardware). It would also explain why it happened in multiple locations.
- somelamer567 2y agoI seem to remember that Russia has significant expertise in building powerful and compact microwave sources to control and heat plasma in tokamaks. Nizhny Novgorod is a known centre of expertise in such technology. It wouldn’t be such a stretch to imagine that Putin’s thugs have commandeered it to build a crude, nasty means of messing with their perceived enemies in a deniable way.
- applied_heat 2y agoI read it was caused by pesticides that were being applied extra heavily in the areas around the embassy, inside the embassy, and even in the “victim’s” homes due to concerns about zika virus which were hyped at the time The link below includes results from a study which included brain imaging and comparing the results with other victims of neurotoxicity poisons https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/havana-syndrome-neurotoxin-enqu%C3%AAte-1.5288609 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/havana-syndrome-neurotoxin-en...
- DoctorOetker 2y agoI believe it was hydrogen cyanide, and I believe it was Iran. > Starting about a decade ago, a small number of Americans, mostly federal employees and many of them working in intelligence, reported similar experiences in Havana. In an instant, they heard a painful ringing in their ears, followed by intense pressure on their head and disorienting vertigo, which was often followed by nausea. Some of the victims developed long-term problems with fatigue or mobility. Other officials later reported similar symptoms while in Russia and other foreign countries, and many concluded that they had been the victim of a deliberate attack with some kind of acoustic weapon. ototoxic, vertigo, nausea, brain damage A close inspection of the video evidence released by the morality police concerning Mahsa Amini is quite damning. It appears the morality police allowed some intelligence branch to operate / exercise on their premises but refused to be the scapegoat once things went south. So they released video of her walking healthily into the building, of her searching a seat, but not before quickly glancing back (presumably in response to her name, called out for target lock-on by a trainer / observer "O"). This scene as she selects a seat is also important because the girls are being processing FIFO. Compare the women who are seated right before Mahsa sits down, with the women who are seated as Mahsa stands up. Except for the observer "O", all the women who sat down earlier have been processed and are no longer there, and all the women sitting down as she stands up again were not there before. Except this observer sitting in the midst of the arrested women of course. Pay close attention to unnecessarily early starts or unnecessarily late endings of the segments: what is it that morality police is showing and why? They are threatening the higher-ups that they have already shared the evidence (minus the explanations) to implicate higher branches of government. An unnecessarily early start is when before Mahsa stands up (presumably there is a number display). She seems scared and impatient: instead of a morality police officer coming for her, 2 such morality police officers "Bossy" and "Postpony" are seen in discussion. Certain arm movements are seen (extending one arm, while hiding the other hand, presumably to hide a trigger / squeezing bulb). Annoyed "Bossy" is seen demonstrating the things-to-be-done presumably for the umpteenth time (she is clearly impatient with Postpony's stalling behavior). It looks like this would have gone on for quite a while more, were it not for Mahsa spontaneously arriving. I believe she was afraid of the hypothetical situation where she patiently waited until her number was explicitly called out, out of fear that if the morality police accidentally skips her processing, that she might end up in deeper trouble than she already is: they might accuse her of fleeing the morality police to avoid processing. Apparently Postpony was stalling, now that the target has arrived we will quickly see that when thrown in the water Postpony didn't need further instructions to swim. Some quick admonishing of clothing follows, during which suddenly the same arm movements we saw being demonstrated before are executed. Right after the hand or wrist passed close to Mahsa's face. Mahsa has a pain reaction (presumably the eye irritant intentionally added to hydrogen cyanide intended for disinfecting ships/factories/... which usually serves to warn end-users that they need to ventilate the closed space longer before entering). Immediately when Mahsa has the pain reaction and tries to cover her face with her hands, Bossy and Postpony turn their back long before she collapses, and they also take some steps away from any hydrogen cyanide cloud diluting in the air. This is not the body language of authoritarianism. It illustrates Bossy and Postpony knew exactly what could or would happen after administering the dose. Replay that scene and look at the behavior of observer "O". The hospital reported the girl was brain-dead, and the father responded weird pink spots on her skin (just like observed during the holocaust). I suspect at least observer "O" works in a different branch (aking to Iran's equivalent to CIA training or possibly a chemical weapons scientist, gathering data for dosage setting). It's unclear if Bossy and Postpony are real morality police employees, working under direction of "O", or if they are from the same branch as "O", and pretending to be morality police, who would in that case have been instructed to let the 3 work freely using the facility as a training ground, with Bossy and Postpony pretending to be morality police. The cochlear amplifier (the cochlea is a mechanical amplifier) is extremely sensitive to drugs. A lot of substances are ototoxic. Imagine unknowingly suffering a non-lethal dose of brain damage, involving ototoxic tinnitus. A cluster of victims emerging above the spontaneous incidence background could share many symptoms, and in the absence of help could erroneously conclude an "acoustic directed energy weapon". Then this is cross-referenced with the symptoms of known directed energy weapons, and promptly considered to be mass hysteria. During WWI the British developed hydrogen cyanide bombs to launch at German positions. Clearly some chemists in the British army didn't want to be involved in chemical warfare and chose a lighter than air poison gas, so that it would quickly evaporate and diffuse, as opposed to the other trench war chemical weapons. Hydrogen cyanide may not be effective in trench wars, it seems Iran still considers it effective for assassination, debilitation.
- suraci 2y agoBe careful, the Communist sound wave is poisoning our precious bodily fluids
- rapjr9 2y agoOsha's web page about the health effects of radio and microwave radiation: https://www.osha.gov/radiofrequency-and-microwave-radiation/health-effects https://www.osha.gov/radiofrequency-and-microwave-radiation/... Jet fighter AESA radars can output a highly directional 8KW beam of microwave radiation: https://autojournalism.com/top-10-most-powerful-fighter-jet-radar-system/ https://autojournalism.com/top-10-most-powerful-fighter-jet-... Maybe someone can tell us what safety precautions are necessary when working around jet fighter radar systems?: https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/65274/are-there-any-safety-hazards-when-testing-the-f-16s-fire-control-radar-on-the-g https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/65274/are-there...
- tehjoker 2y agoyou don't have to listen to anything these agencies say. they don't provide proof of anything so you can ignore them.
- SaintSeiya 2y agoOnly wishful thinkers GenZ, pro cubans Biden's functionaries will rule out Russia's or Chinese directed attack with the authorization of Castro's dictatorship. They are explicit enemies of the U.S, allways conspiring and spying against it. In Cuba if you fart, the CDR, UJC, PCC, MTT, FMC and several other communist organizations to control the people will know and assign spies to you. The USA embassy in Cuba is the main target of the Cuban intelligence and has spies all around the buildings and where the functionaries live, what they ate, who they talk to, what they poop, everything!. They are constantly been watched by the cuban government. Do you really think this will go on unnoticed?
- Havoc 2y agoComments here are an apt reflection of said cracking consensus
- tim333 2y agoI'm skeptical there ever was much of a consensus. From the start there have been first hand witnesses say there seems to be some sort of attack and government bureaucracies, not on the ground saying they are probably just imagining it, so we don't have to do anything about it. I wouldn't really say that was a great consensus. Maybe a consensus amongst the bureaucracies that they'd rather ignore everything? But it's only a consensus if you exclude everyone who's a witness.