8 ms·
Candy Crush, Tinder, MyFitnessPal: Apps hijacked to spy on location
- toomuchtodo 2y agoRelated: See the Thousands of Apps Hijacked to Spy on Your Location - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42651087 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42651087 - Jan 2025
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dang 2y agoWe'll merge those comments hither. Thanks!
- gnabgib 2y agoRelated FTC takes action against Gravy Analytics, Venntel for selling location data (194 points, 158 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42309429 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42309429
- xnx 2y ago> Candy Crush, Tinder, MyFitnessPal: See the Thousands of Apps Hijacked to Spy on Your Location This seems like a very misleading headline. These apps were (often for no user-beneficial reason) collecting location data. This code was put there deliberately by the app authors. The app authors are accomplices in leaking this data , they are not victims.
- zoul 2y agoAs I understand it, the story is not the advertising network getting the private data — we have all known that for a long time. The news is that even the unsuccessful real-time auction bidders can get a lot of this data.
- cadamsdotcom 2y agoActually, location tracking was added on purpose.. It is capitalism that has been hacked.
- dylan604 2y agoCapitalism hasn't been hacked, it's working as designed. If there's a way to make money, it will be monetized. Decency and morality does not matter if it gets in the way of making more money.
- neonate 2y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20250109211053/https://www.wired.com/story/gravy-location-data-app-leak-rtb/ https://web.archive.org/web/20250109211053/https://www.wired... https://archive.ph/Danyk https://archive.ph/Danyk
- cookiengineer 2y agoThe two app lists from the article: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ukgd0gIWd9gpV6bOx2pcSHsVO6yIUqbjnlM4ewjO6Cs/htmlview https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ukgd0gIWd9gpV6bOx2pc... https://gist.github.com/fs0c131y/f498b21cba9ee23956fc7d7629262e9d https://gist.github.com/fs0c131y/f498b21cba9ee23956fc7d76292...
- bluechair 2y agoDo I understand correctly that these apps are able to bypass OS permissions of whether to allow location data?
- tveita 2y ago"a significant amount of this geolocation dataset appears to be inferred by IP address to geolocation lookups, meaning the vendor or their source is deriving the user's geolocation by checking their IP address rather than by using GNSS [Global Navigation Satellite System]/GPS data. That would suggest that the data is not being sourced entirely from a location data SDK." Probably it would use the location if the permission was enabled, otherwise fall back to IP geolocation Real-time bidding is a privacy nightmare - basically spraying your actions in real-time to every ad provider, with a pinky promise that they won't abuse it.
- unyttigfjelltol 2y agoPinky promises from scoundrels. Pretty much with that group asking the pinky promise is to provoke abuse of it.
- redserk 2y agoI wonder if apps are abusing background app refresh to do this on iOS. My understanding is that it isn't difficult to create a background task that can periodically make network requests. Just have a background task make a HTTP request including some unique identifier to some ad network server, then have the server handle IP geolocation. While the accuracy won't be great on a lot of mobile networks, you can get pretty granular on wifi as some ISPs have their IPs as granular as a neighborhood. I disable background app refresh for almost all apps in anticipation of this and haven't had a degredation in app experience. I noticed something when using 1Blocker on iOS, which creates a dummy on-device VPN to block tracker IP requests. After I turned off background app refresh, I noticed that the number of blocked requests went down a lot. While some were innocuous diagnostics, like Sentry, the vast majority were not. I'd appreciate if someone familiar with iOS development could weigh in on if this would be practical or not, given the all of the execution limits of background tasks.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- drawkward 2y agoAdvertising is a virus that will infect every ecosystem
- alganet 2y agoIt's more like the ideal vector for some nasty stuff. There's nothing inherently wrong with it but folks doing evil stuff love it.
- jazzyjackson 2y agoWatch "the economics of happiness" if you think there's nothing wrong with advertising. Sure, maybe it can be done without manipulating people's self-image into thinking they're not good enough, not beautiful enough, not wealthy enough, but if you're into maximizing revenue you're not going to simply advertise "here's our invention, take it or leave it" https://m.imdb.com/title/tt1687905/ https://m.imdb.com/title/tt1687905/
- alganet 2y agoI believe there's nothing _inherently_ wrong with advertising. > but if you're into maximizing revenue In the space of ideas, there is a way for advertisement to exist without revenue. Even without money! > manipulating people's self-image into thinking they're not good enough, not beautiful enough, not wealthy enough You can do all of that _without_ advertising.
- SllX 2y ago> You can do all of that _without_ advertising. I want to double-emphasize this. Most advertising sucks, but the effect it has on people is not unique to advertising. Given your five senses, you are being consistently and constantly blasted with information people want to put in front of you in the hopes of effecting your future behavior in a way that makes you think that you’ve talked yourself into it. But given a non-intrusive ad that isn’t trying to also surveil you and isn’t making demands on your attention, they can be informative. The problem is that non-intrusive ads that don’t make demands on your time and attention don’t support advertising-reliant companies with market caps as big as TV broadcasters, and if you want to also be as big as Google or Facebook, you also need the surveillance aspect of it, so if we ever get our shit together as a society and do something about that and they haven’t diversified their revenue streams sufficiently, they’re in for a very bad time.
- smarx007 2y agocomm -12 <(cat gravy_app_list\ -\ count.csv| uvx --from csvkit csvcut -c 2 | rg '\.' | sort) <(adb shell pm list packages -3 | cut -f 2 -d ":" | sort) where the CSV is downloaded from https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ukgd0gIWd9gpV6bOx2pcSHsVO6yIUqbjnlM4ewjO6Cs/edit?gid=1257088277#gid=1257088277 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ukgd0gIWd9gpV6bOx2pc... in order to check the apps on your phone for any match. Two questions from looking at my list: 1. What do you replace PodcastAddict with? Will all ads traffic (not just the display of the ads on the screen) cease on a paid version? 2. How would MS Outlook get on the list in the first place?
- oAlbe 2y ago> 1. What do you replace PodcastAddict with? Will all ads traffic (not just the display of the ads on the screen) cease on a paid version? AntennaPod
- LordShredda 2y agoI love AntennaPod. One app that does its job perfectly
- gruez 2y agoThis list is suspect. PodcastAddict doesn't even request location permissions[1]. How can it possibly get access to your location? If you read the article carefully, it caveats that the location might not even be sourced from gravy apps. At best, it's getting your ip location, which you're broadcasting to every website you visit anyways. >Although this dataset came from an apparent hack of Gravy, it is not clear whether Gravy collected this location data itself or sourced it from another company, or which location company ultimately owns it or is licensed to use it. [1] https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.bambuna.podcastaddict https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.bambuna.po...
- dceddia 2y agoCan it get the wifi SSID? Is that a permissioned property on Android/iOS? I believe there are companies that build databases of SSIDs and their locations by driving around, so if an app can get wifi info it could be pinpointed to a pretty specific location.
- supriyo-biswas 2y agoOne point I do not see addressed in the article is how the location is collected. It'd be a little bit of a stretch to call IP geolocation as collecting location data as it is usually no more accurate than just procuring the geolocation yourself, so there's no need to get it from a broker. However, on an Android for example, both ACCESS_COARSE_LOCATION and ACCESS_FINE_LOCATION require permission dialogs, so how does it exactly work?
- ajsnigrutin 2y agoTinder is location based, so probably through that. Not sure about other apps.
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoIt's a stretch to call out a game for tracking every IP use use and trying to location track you using that? A game should not be trying to track my location at all, not get a pass because technically it's not very accurate.
- mikeiz404 2y agoAt least some, if not the majority, is likely derived from the IP address used in the ad bidding process. > Franaszek also says that “a significant amount of this geolocation dataset appears to be inferred by IP address to geolocation lookups, meaning the vendor or their source is deriving the user's geolocation by checking their IP address rather than by using GNSS [Global Navigation Satellite System]/GPS data. That would suggest that the data is not being sourced entirely from a location data SDK.”
- hollow-moe 2y agoThese ad spaces are using the GMS services which is a default system app on every Google Android this app has virtually all access on your device including position and such. https://developers.google.com/android/reference/com/google/android/gms/ads/package-summary https://developers.google.com/android/reference/com/google/a...
- notyourwork 2y ago
- janalsncm 2y agoEvery time you see a little banner ad at the bottom of an app, there’s an instantaneous auction to show you that ad space. Google forwards info to bidders, who calculate how much they will spend to show you the ad. This means even the losers of the auction get a firehose of data. There are companies set up right now whose purpose is to lose that auction but collect the data anyways. It should not surprise you to learn, then, that In-Q-Tel (the non classified investment arm of the CIA) has invested in some of these analytics (read: digital surveillance) companies.
- jillyboel 2y agoHow does one sign up for such a firehose? I was naively under the impression google did this bidding internally.
- rvnx 2y agoYou need to get your ad platform technically certified and a very good reason to join (several millions in marketing budget will do the job), and a very good contact at Google, once this is done, this is what you have access to in real-time: https://developers.google.com/authorized-buyers/rtb/downloads/realtime-bidding-proto https://developers.google.com/authorized-buyers/rtb/download... otherwise you can go through intermediaries like BidSwitch which are essentially resellers, it's much easier but you get less information
- add-sub-mul-div 2y ago> There are companies set up right now whose purpose is to lose that auction but collect the data anyways. Which is against Google's terms, but of course they don't police it because it's their way of selling user data without explicitly selling user data.
- divbzero 2y agoIf I understand this right, Google isn’t actually selling user data to auction losers because auction losers are collecting the data without spending any money.
- p3rls 2y agoPersonally I can't wait until tinder is hit by the government, absolutely ridiculous the sort of monopoly power their amalgamation of dating apps has. People bitch and moan about negative externalities on society from the rise of the internet but for me it's hard to imagine few variables more imperative to a state's success over the longterm.
- notyourwork 2y agoWhat about tinder exactly is the problem? Asking as someone who has never used it but assume it’s Facebook for sex basically. Is it any worse than Metas properties?
- udev4096 2y agoThe truth is, majority of the population doesn't care. Telling people to value their privacy is exhausting because of a stupid argument of "I have nothing to hide". You deserve your data to be up for sale (let's also not forget data breaches) if you are too reckless to calculate the consequences of using these apps
- gradientsrneat 2y agoA few notes: Not sure how effective, but for certain suspicious Android apps, I configure them to not run in the background, and disable networking when using them. However, since Google's ad platform is involved, I can't rule out that there exists location tracking at the device level, let alone the telcos. Interesting that Grindr allegedly stopped selling location data the same year they were divested from Chinese ownership. Article seems to imply the current FTC doesn't like these companies misusing location data. Possibly this data gathered from the Snowflake leaks attributed to UNC5537, or some similar method?
- moore1112 2y agoIf you're wondering how to #track or #spy your boyfriend's phone, look no further. With the rates of #cheating higher than ever, and men being prone to cheat, it's no wonder you want to learn how to track your partner's phone. kindly message her to spy on your boyfriends or anyone Email: infocyberrecoveryinc@gmail.com
- moore1112 2y agoYou don't need to search much more to find out how to spy or track your boyfriend's phone. Given that males are more likely than women to cheat and that cheating rates are higher than ever, it makes sense that you would want to understand how to track your partner's phone. To spy on your lovers or anybody else, please mail her. Infocyberrecoveryinc@gmail.com