5 ms·
The Begining of the End for ANT+ Wireless
- femiagbabiaka 2y agoWell that sucks. But thankfully all my devices support both ANT+ and BLE.
- wslh 2y agoELI5: Does this mean that, in the future, I will not automatically see my heart beats on a treadmill without doing any kind of device pairing?
- jjtheblunt 2y agoDid you read the very first sentence of the article?
- wslh 2y agoYes, and that is why I was asking for the treadmill. The article was confusing from the point of view of the user: go to the treadmill and see your heartbeat appearing. What will replace ANT+ in the future? How sport machines like treadmills will react to this reality? You need two to tango: health devices are only one side.
- jjtheblunt 2y agoIt looks like they're saying treadmills etc will "balkanize" to build their own protocols. that seems more difficult than something based off bluetooth. i agree that the article gets more vague the longer it got. i guess time will tell.
- nradov 2y agoBluetooth Low Energy will largely replace ANT+. There has been a heart rate profile available for years which most heart rate monitors support. Unfortunately, most treadmills are kind of crap for connectivity. https://www.bluetooth.com/specifications/specs/heart-rate-profile-1-0/ https://www.bluetooth.com/specifications/specs/heart-rate-pr...
- yencabulator 2y agoIsn't that just a BLE broadcast? Wouldn't it have the same fate with this regulation? You only get encryption from pairing, and I don't remember my BLE cadence sensor needing pairing.
- stevekemp 2y agoFrom the site guidelines: > Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. Edit out swipes. > Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that".
- jjtheblunt 2y agoi like "the article mentions that" definitely!
- fuzzy2 2y agoThat was never ANT+ anyway.
- bobmcnamara 2y agoThat was always ANT+
- p_l 2y agoIt was ANT+ for the profile and automatic selection of closest device.
- tonymet 2y agoand a consent popup
- xobs 2y agoThat could be GymLink, which is a simple 5 kHz LF transmission. It’s also used so that it can work while swimming. Here’s a discussion about it: https://www.eevblog.com/forum/rf-microwave/looking-for-a-receiver-for-5-khz/ https://www.eevblog.com/forum/rf-microwave/looking-for-a-rec...
- rcdemski 2y agoSurprisingly well written and just detailed enough to not leaving wanting more or overwhelmed. I never really got in to ANT+ land with cycling but the couple things I tried I appreciated how easily they paired up. Bluetooth feels like the obvious next place but with so much momentum behind ANT+ I wonder how long this transition will take.
- testrun 2y agoIf I read this piece correctly, is that going forward the suppliers are going to develop their own protocols. They find Bluetooth development to onerous.
- philjohn 2y agoIt feels like the fitness brands need to come together and shut out the BT SIG and all fitness profiles should come out of that new consortium - which would be a formalising of what Wahoo did with the Kickr protocol.
- izacus 2y agoIn reality we'll probably end up with a lot of shitty apps on your phone which may or may not successfully sync to your main fitness platform.
- yencabulator 2y agoIt would be a totally EU move to state that fitness gadgets need to support certain common protocols; think USB-C for charging.
- notatoad 2y ago> They are discontinuing membership programs/fees > They are discontinuing certification programs > They are however continuing to ensure ANT+ is available on silicon > All documentation to be made fully available online funny how "the beginning of the end" kind of sounds excellent.
- fer 2y agoYou skipped: > They are ceasing development of new ANT+ Profiles Which kind of ensures a slow death, as new devices potentially would require them.
- notatoad 2y agothe most recent profile they added was an update to the cycling shifter profile. before that, the most recent actual new device type they added was radars in 2016. ant+ is not a protocol that has or needs to have frequent updates. opening it up could have been a lot more significant than stopping the development of new profiles.
- nimish 2y agoGood. It was a pointless standard now that ble exists.
- mtrovo 2y agoI’m crossing my fingers that this EU move nudges Garmin, SRAM, Shimano, etc. to collaborate on an open Bluetooth protocol. Sick of the whole private extensions protocol approach.
- stingrae 2y agoIn the article it mentioned Bluetooth SIG sluggishness being the primary reason that they didn’t shift over.
- balch 2y agoI'm worried a move to bluetooth will lead to a mess of propritary protocols that stops devices from one manufacturer working with another
- blacklion 2y agoAll my equipment (except Tempe) is dual-standard now and my phone see my heartrate, cadence, bike speed (I don't how powermeters, though) in generic OSMAnd navigator application. Looks like there ARE BLE profiles for these already.
- WD-42 2y agoUnfortunately that requires work that these relatively small companies don’t or don’t want to put the resources into.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chabons 2y agoGarmin has a market cap of ~40B USD. Inflation adjusted, that's where NVIDIA was <10yr ago. It's not missing resources to do the work IMO, but it's missing the market dominance to singlehanded set the standard for the industry.
- 2y ago
- thebruce87m 2y agoSlightly off-topic but can anyone recommend a cheap viewer for the Garmin Varia Radars? It’s ANT+ but I can bring myself to pay hundreds for a bike computer when all I need is an LED and a beeping noise to indicate a car behind me. Cheapest I can find is a Bryton Rider 420. I bought a mount for my phone but then discovered that vibrations can kill the autofocus/stabilisation, even with a damper.
- tguvot 2y agoif you can find used/new varia vision.
- geor9e 2y agoSo a phone app does everything, but you're just worried about your expensive phone? Get another. Search "android prepaid phone" they're mostly around $30.
- misnome 2y agoI think they meant that the vibrations mean the app doesn’t work because with the vibrations of the camera the picture is useless, not that it damages the phone.
- thebruce87m 2y agoNo, it’s the damage I was talking about: https://www.reddit.com/r/cycling/comments/14s9fwm/comment/k5o5zie/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button https://www.reddit.com/r/cycling/comments/14s9fwm/comment/k5...
- geor9e 2y agovaria is a radar you put on your back to get alerted when a car is closing in on you. the alerts can go to a phone or dedicated receiver
- aucisson_masque 2y agoThere are downside with using your phone. First of them is the battery. road cycling you go for 5 to 8 hours in bright sunlight with the screen at 100%, that battery is going to die very very quickly.
- blacklion 2y agoAnd there is still no BLE replacement for Garmin "Tempe" sensor: no ultra-small rugged temperature sensor on the market (or I cannot find one! If you could point me to one, I will be very grateful!) On the other hand, all Android phones dropped ANT+ support after approximately Android 9. My old Xiaomi Mi A1 supported ANT+ till some major update, my next phone (Samsung A72) didn't support it from the beginning, my current Pixel 8 Pro doesn't support it too. You need true "head unit" and cannot use phone as one. Hardware is here, but drivers are not installed and cannot be installed from Playstore. It is pity.
- teruakohatu 2y agoThis is a real shame. BLE and ANT+ are fundamentally different, the latter being a broadcast protocol. You can have any number of devices connected/logging the broadcast of an ANT+ device, while BLE is usually limited to one or two devices. I am sure is not a fundamental limitation of BLE but is the reality for the currently available chipsets. The fact that it is unencrypted is completely irrelevant. My heart rate data over a short period of time is not useful to anyone but myself, and that is the only personal data any of my ANT+ devices broadcast. Unless you consider cadence to be personal information but that is also broadcasted to the world visually and is no more secret than the colour of my running or cycling shorts. The rest of my devices broadcast mechanical, device status and/or environmental data.
- WD-42 2y agoMaybe encryption isn't important for you, but it is for some people, especially professional athletes. Imagine a Tour De France rider or their follow car being able to read the heart rate of their competitor - this could easily inform their strategy.
- stonogo 2y agoWe're really going to screw things up for everyone else because of a couple dozen professional bike racers? This deal sucks
- bkls 2y agoWould be funny if Apple was pushing this regulation
- canucker2016 2y agoSo it begins - CES 2025 started and Garmin released the HRM 200 which operates by default in open mode, but one can switch to a secured pair mode over Bluetooth. see https://www.dcrainmaker.com/2025/01/garmin-hrm-depth-review.html https://www.dcrainmaker.com/2025/01/garmin-hrm-depth-review.... Another tweak to the Garmin HRM design is conforming to laws in Australia and USA for requiring a tool to access coin cell battery compartments. But the required tool is built into the HRM strap.