5 ms·
Hertz desperate to unload Tesla inventory, asking customers to buy rentals
- ianferrel 2y ago>Tesla has an 8-year, 100,000 mile warranty on its battery packs, and there’s still a good bit of that battery warranty remaining on this particular car, assuming Tesla will honor it on a used rental car. This feels like a load-bearing assumption that makes or breaks the thesis of the article that deserves more than being an assumption. The model 3 warranty on Tesla's website does say that it covers ownership transfer, but who knows what language is in the Hertz purchase agreement.
- sbuttgereit 2y agoWell... the article goes on to say pretty much at the end... "For what it’s worth, there are a ton of used Teslas on the Hertz Car Sales site, but anything priced this cheaply shows well over six digits on the odometer, and isn’t nearly as appealing. It’s unclear if this Redditor just got a particularly good deal, or if Hertz is just trying to sell everything not nailed down before the end of the calendar year." I mean, if this is what the article is predicated on... seems weakly reported, lets just say.
- jsjohnst 2y agoIt’s Jalopnik, it’s basically guaranteed to be poorly sourced and usually not supported with more evidence than a single tweet or Reddit post. Half the article is a ramble about the author never actually trying a Tesla.
- antisthenes 2y agoThere are only 9 Teslas on the Hertz Car Sales website as of today. Compared to over 7,000 Toyotas. And the Teslas aren't particularly aggressively priced. Which makes me question the validity of this entire article.
- solaarphunk 2y agoI'm always unbelievably pissed off when I reserve a premium tier of car at SFO for a business trip, and Hertz tries to stick me with a Tesla, as if it is a premium car (horrible interior build quality), and with the assumption I have time to install apps and figure out how to use car charging infrastructure.
- jvanderbot 2y agoThe Tesla is not the kind of car I'd like to just jump into for a two day trip, but the neither the car charger or key card entry requires an app, or is particularly weird. You touch the key card to the door column to open or lock, and you plug the charger in. But the interior build and the touchpad interface mean it'll never be a top choice. It's just awful.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 7e 2y agoNo CarPlay is a deal-breaker, as are the hours long queues to supercharge in California.
- ghaff 2y agoMaybe I want the novelty of trying out an electric car on a business trip. But far more likely I just want a bog ordinary car that I can drive from point A to point B.
- MBCook 2y agoIt’s reasonable to have a few for that. Hertz has their premium stuff where you can rent all sorts of interesting cars. I think they were just too early in trying to put a lot of them in the standard rotation.
- ghaff 2y agoMaybe. The problem with a mass market rental outfit is that you end up passing out vehicles on a take it or leave it basis. But I agree with the basic idea that specialty vehicles need to be in a separate category.
- sebastien_b 2y ago[dead]
- jsjohnst 2y agoThe Hertz situation is in my opinion more their own fault vs Tesla. I’ve rented Teslas from them every time they were available when traveling in like 10-12 cities and all of them were poorly handled by local staff imho. As a Tesla owner from back when there was long wait lists (aka before the price cuts), I do sympathize with the insane depreciation aspect though.
- MBCook 2y agoFirst, I think they were just too far ahead of the market. I don’t think there are enough EV owners out there for this to work well. I wouldn’t mind renting an EV, I’ve done it. But that’s because I’m an owner. I wouldn’t expect any random ICE owner to be ready to just accept one. But from talking to my local Hertz (I asked him about this when I had to rent from them last year) basically no one in my area wants them. I assume very few of their customers are existing owners. On top of that I know that they’ve had big problems because even though they’re saving a ton of normal maintenance the cost of scratch and dent/fender bender stuff is way higher than expected since only Tesla sells Tesla parts. Makes me think going with another brand would’ve been smarter on this specific point. There’s of course anti anti-EV sentiment out there combined with anti-Musk stuff now. There’s no way that’s helping. I think renting EVs is a good idea. I understand they chose Tesla both because they have the volume and the charging network. But I think that bit them on repairs and sentiment. Mostly I think they were just a couple years too early. I think they thought the market would move faster than it has. I thought it would. Once more drivers are used to EVs a lot of the problems go away. Then all your left with is charging and repair costs, both fully solvable.
- jsjohnst 2y ago> First, I think they were just too far ahead of the market. I don’t think there are enough EV owners out there for this to work well. This is exactly the problem. They do zero education of substance to help a non-EV driver get used to the experience. If I wasn’t already an experienced EV driver (or intentionally using the rental as an extended test drive), I’d be super pissed personally as they really leave you hanging.
- jgalt212 2y agoYet, TSLA is trading at an all time high and 127 PE. https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/TSLA/ https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/TSLA/
- pstuart 2y agoPriced on the promises of Musk rather than the reality of the market.
- chgs 2y agoThe market is anticipating large amounts of corruption Remember when Jimmy Carter had to sell his peanut farm?
- freen 2y agoKleptocracy is a word for a very real reason.
- talldayo 2y agoWith a username like jgalt you'd better have knocked on wood when you clicked that "add comment" button.
- srslack 2y agoFrom the perspective of the market, TSLA is not a car company. It sells carbon offsets/credits. That is their business.
- shiroiushi 2y agoSounds like a good way to go to jail, when Hertz sells you the car and then reports it as stolen to the police. Hertz does this very, very frequently to paying customers.
- a12k 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tzs 2y agoWasn't that Hertz reporting rental cars as stolen, because Hertz lost track of them and assumed that the last renter had never returned them? This would be Hertz selling cars. Even if they later mistakenly reported them as stolen the buyer should not be at risk of jail because the car would be registered to the buyer in the state's records.
- shiroiushi 2y agoIf Hertz can't handle a simple rental transaction correctly without calling the police and resulting in a false arrest, I'm certainly not going to trust them to handle a car sale correctly.
- tzs 2y agoThe big difference is that with a sale there is paperwork filed with the state showing that the car is yours. If Hertz gets confused and still reports the car stolen that shoukd clear things up with police and prosecutors. If Hertz botches it so badly that the state paperwork cannot be correctly filed you will find that out shortly after buying the car and can get it corrected.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- joecot 2y agoI bought a used Nissan Versa from Hertz and regretted it immensely. Not only did the CVT transmission go on me (it took a while for my year's class action lawsuit, but they did offer me ... $1k on a new Nissan. No thanks), but Hertz is terrible at their maintenance and uses the cheapest parts possible. The only good thing about Teslas from Hertz is that there aren't any third party parts to cheap out on, but I still wouldn't trust a Tesla that was maintained by Hertz.
- mixdup 2y agoThey've owned them for such a short period of time, and the maintenance on an EV is so much less, that may not be a big issue
- nunez 2y agoThey've been doing that since forever; not a Tesla thing. Enterprise and Avis do it too.
- mikhailfranco 2y agoSo Tesla is operating at 1 kilaHertz?
- nunez 2y agoSo I only rent EVs when I travel. I specifically seek out Teslas, as I love driving them (I have two), but any EV works for me. Besides the Tesla business model being, essentially, a huge flex from previous leadership that Elon and team were happy to enable, there were always numerous problems with renting Teslas at scale: 1. The experience of using a Tesla is unlike any other car out there. No other car lacks an engine/HVDC start button, for example. This hurt Hertz in both directions: time-stressed business travelers (many of whom don't have EVs at home) get fed up with trying to get them out of the parking lot (where a surprisingly high number of accidents involving Teslas have occurred), and leisure travelers who _do_ have time struggle to operate the car during their trip. 2. Charging. Everything about charging frustrates renters. Finding superchargers. Waiting 20+ minutes to charge, regardless of what's in the vicinity. (Many superchargers, especially in small markets, are behind malls.) Dealing with non-Tesla networks. (You don't need an app and an account to gas up an ICE vehicle.) Charging at scale is much better than it was when Hertz doubled down on this in 2022 but just isn't there yet. 2b. Many Hertz centers (including airport-attached ones!) didn't have charging infrastructure of their own. This was extremely problematic when a time-stressed renter decides to one-way their car to some other center with this predicament. Those EVs are either taken out of rotation for the day, which is extremely suboptimal, or, worse, are rented out at whatever state of charge they have. I've been assigned cars with a 2% SoC before. This is no big deal for me if there's a charging center nearby, but a renter who is IDGAF about their car (many/most business travelers) will take that sucker out of the lot and be calling roadside in an hour because their car died. This would never happen with a n ICE (since most people know how gas gauges work). 3. Repairing Teslas at the speeds that rental car companies require isn't possible without extra staff and a Tesla Service Center nearby. Tesla is Apple-like in their parts inventory. IIRC, You need to be a Tesla-approved service center to order parts from them. Once you do get the parts, (1) of my list applies again. EVs from legacy OEMs don't have this problem, but you still need techs who are certified in handling HV and EV drivetrains to work on them. That costs money, and car rental companies operate on razor thin margins. The saddest thing about all of this is that Tesla wrote a really cool adapter for their car key auth flow that enabled Hertz renters to add the car to the Tesla app during their rental. The card key wasn't required when this was done. This was ONLY added to Hertz vehicles. I don't think Tesla intends on extending this to the rest of the fleet. I primarily rent with Avis (who, unlike Hertz, still has a reasonably sized EV fleet). Having to use the card key for everything is annoying, especially in cold weather climates. Which brings me to my last point. Hertz is divesting ALL of their EVs, not just their Tesla ones. It used to be stupidly easy to rent an EV with Hertz. These days, you'll be lucky to rent an EV with them at even their largest centers. That said, assuming this next administration at least tries to continue subsidizing national charging networks and EV production (unlikely, especially if their EV or bust by 2030 mandate is rolled back), I hope that Hertz and others revisit EVs at scale in the future.