10 ms·
PeerTube mobile app: discover videos while caring for your attention
Android: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.framasoft.peertube https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.framasoft....
iOS: https://apps.apple.com/fr/app/peertube/id6737834858 https://apps.apple.com/fr/app/peertube/id6737834858
Repo: https://framagit.org/framasoft/peertube/mobile-application https://framagit.org/framasoft/peertube/mobile-application
- tosser2084 2y agono way to use from desktop? Absurd.
- do_not_redeem 2y agoHN users are the most demanding group of people I've ever encountered in my short time on this blue sphere. Use a browser.
- echelon 2y agoTo be fair, most people will just bounce. Feedback can be an opportunity to improve. It would be nice if the feedback remembered that there are humans on the other side of the line, but sometimes you take what you can get.
- Zak 2y agoPeertube has existed as web-based software for years; this post is about the addition of a mobile app. The linked project page has a search from the big "browse content" link at the top and a list of servers running Peertube, such as https://fedi.video https://fedi.video. For onboarding a general audience, this project page is not ideal.
- facialwipe 2y agoAt first I thought this was an app to discover content on YouTube. Nope, it’s a platform.
- thal3s 2y agoIt's the Fediverse version of YouTube using the ActivityPub protocol just like Mastodon and Lemmy.
- kuu 2y agoNot a single button to download the app on the landing page. A lot of info about the company who made it, a lot of info about how bad other actors are, and a lot about requesting funding, but not a single video, neither how to explore the platform or download anything. I guess this is not made for users...
- weberer 2y agoThere are buttons for the Play Store and App Store halfway down. Its under the heading: "A very first build, limited by (play & i) stores"
- theandrewbailey 2y agoThat's 2/3rds down a very long page. Most people won't go down that far unless they're quite interested in the material.
- aloisdg 2y agoYou wont install an app if you are not interested in the material
- Goronmon 2y agoNone of the apps I've installed in the past are because I was invested in the developer's marketing materials.
- atomicfiredoll 2y agoThat's an assumption and not necessarily true. Some users may read it, some may skim, some may come to the page already convinced. For those latter groups, having a fast lane/shortcut call-to-action visible someplace like the top gives them a way to get started before they get overwhelmed/distracted and potentially leave.
- herval 2y agothat's the kind of attitude that makes otherwise successful apps/content/etc created by stiff engineer minds to never experience any success: "they didn't want it anyway", when people literally didn't _understand_ what you were trying to sell.
- BadHumans 2y agoI like PeerTube and most of Framasoft's products but like most federated software, I think they have a branding and marketing problem that prevents them from growing any bigger. Mastodon did as well and before they revised a lot of their site, no more "toots" for example. I say this knowing that they say their goal is education not growth but you need growth to reach the people you want to educate.
- kstrauser 2y agoYeah, I had to go into my instance's locale files and fix them to s/post/toot/ to put it back. Some of Mastodon's upstream decisions strike me as "we must be identical to Twitter in the insignificant ways if we want to get users".
- guerrilla 2y agoEven heavy Mastodon users thought the "toot" thing was dumb though. It was the constant butt of jokes and a distraction. I don't think it was about Twitter.
- treyd 2y agoI still don't understand the objection to it. Yes I understand the double entendre. But I'm also an adult and mature enough to move onto more important things than getting up in arms about a little fart joke.
- warkdarrior 2y agoIt is not a double entendre, since there is one common meaning for "toot" and it is about bodily noises. "Toot" has not been about posting on Mastodon up until very recently.
- kstrauser 2y agoDo they not have trumpets where you live? Did "tooting one's own horn" imply breaking wind during the annual performance review? Far and away the most common use of "toot" is playing a note on a horn. At one point, Gargron, the main guy behind Mastodon, even mentioned using a trumpet as the basis of Mastodon's logo branding: https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon/issues/962 https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon/issues/962 "Toot" also has the double entendre. In all my life, I've never heard anyone outside a playground use it to describe flatulence. In my personal experience, it's almost always been about the musical notes. I'm not in a band or otherwise around musicians more than the average person, either.
- weberer 2y agoDoes anyone have any good recommendations of English language tech channels on Peertube? Most of the recommendations I'm getting by default look to be in French.
- loonshi 2y agohttps://videos.lukesmith.xyz/videos/recently-added https://videos.lukesmith.xyz/videos/recently-added
- corobo 2y agoIf we're talking about the app: if you go to settings (top right hamburger, then cog icon) you can set your language preferences I almost tripped over "welp this is all in French, I got nothing to watch" too
- aloisdg 2y agoAwesome. I am glad to see PeerTube growing. One of the most serious alternative to the centralized YouTube hegemony.
- xhkkffbf 2y agoI hate YouTube's algorithm. It keeps showing me the same videos over and over.
- _ache_ 2y agoMay I recommend tournesol.app ? It's again a French speaking initiative (but from a French-Switzerland research collaboration) about creating a recommendation algorithm with a lot of good properties and that scale (check the research paper on arxiv.org : 2107.07334). It's also a plugin to help then have more data and to be useful for the users (by having an other recommendation algorithm on youtube), a win-win collaboration.
- redserk 2y agoAnd the algorithm seems to prioritize videos that have extraordinarily lame and over-processed preview images and comically dramatic titles. I personally like the boring deep-dive technical videos. The people uploading these videos don't seem to give a damn about the latest hip SEO buzzwords to use (and, frankly, good) but I have to go out of my way to hunt them down. YouTube really, really likes shoving Mr. Beast, LTT, and other channels at me, but I couldn't be any less interested, and filter them out with an add-on. I can't wait for a replacement platform for the boring technical content. Until that platform exists, I recommend looking at DeArrow. It at least fixes titles and preview images.
- subract 2y agoBig fan of what Framasoft is working on here. It’s a shame to see that (edit: iOS) App Store restrictions have prevented browsing any instances not on a pre-blessed list. That all but eliminates its usefulness to me as a self-hoster.
- talldayo 2y agoIt's another (tragic) example of why the App Store cannot persist in a free market. It's sad, but Apple would prefer that you download YouTube from their store instead of a healthy alternative on your own terms. They have no qualms abusing their double-standard for publishing when it hurts the little guy, which is as monopolistic as monopoly abuse gets. Europe got it right. Crush the App Store, and you kill every maligned incentive with it. Only through natural competition will Apple be forced to finally respect their users.
- musicale 2y agoThere are dozens of successful, competitive Android app stores in nearly every country where Google Play is blocked.
- mihular 2y agoWasn't that list optional, though?
- codetrotter 2y ago
- thal3s 2y agoContrast this with another story on the first page this morning: "Google are deliberately breaking YouTube when it detects you're running Firefox" (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42388983 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42388983). Open-source content on the Fediverse will become more critical as corporate oligarchs continue to exert their influence.
- pessimizer 2y agoThat's just a 6 month old reddit post by a random dude. If they're blocking firefox, they're doing it very badly, because I just spent all morning watching football highlight videos running firefox on linux, adblocked, sponsorblocked (https://sponsor.ajay.app/ https://sponsor.ajay.app/), forging my referer, blocking cookies, with userscripts to unlock private and age-restricted videos, without being logged in. With my setup, youtube can be broken for months on end. It's running like silk right now.
- sitkack 2y agoDo you have a guide you could link to?
- benatkin 2y agoHow important is WebTorrent for PeerTube and how important is WebRTC for WebTorrent? I get a feeling that if this takes off browser vendors might try to change how WebRTC works to shut it down. That would be another reason to support more open browsers and more open operating systems. This app would help in that scenario as well, as would a desktop app.
- palata 2y agoI am not convinced that it would be possible. But anyway I don't think they even care because virtually nobody uses peertube.
- boramalper 2y agoPeerTube has removed WebTorrent in 2022: https://github.com/Chocobozzz/PeerTube/issues/5465 https://github.com/Chocobozzz/PeerTube/issues/5465
- ukuina 2y agoThis page desperately needs a TL;DR and links to the apps above the fold.
- ncr100 2y agoOne could make joinpeertube2.org if you wanted to...freedoms and all that. Hmm... WAIT Peer Tube is trademarked. So any add-on or fan domain name would have to disambiguate itself from joinpeertube to something which is clearly unaffiliated. I'm thinking, MacRumors or other sorts of mostly obvious dances around the trademark word. Amusingly I I generated several hypothetical domain names via Chat GPT (another sidetrack: "Chad gpt" ...lol maybe for April Fools) after explaining the situation and you know it cautioned me of course do some follow-up checks but I think these are funny And somewhat interesting: TubeWithPeers.com PeerTubeGuide.com PeerVideoCommunity.com ExplorePeerTube.com UsingPeerTube.com MyPeerTubeTools.com So I think it is possible to invent a domain name which could just cut to the chase and function as a faster better stronger version of https://joinpeertube.org https://joinpeertube.org.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- engineer_22 2y agoHow does PeerTube handle moderation? CSAM, racism, antisemitism, etc
- emaro 2y agoPeerTube is federated and moderation is each server's own responsibility.
- jeffbee 2y agoIt doesn't. It also has no defenses against DoS attacks, intentional or inadvertent. It is the perfect software for people with no experience distributing videos.
- pkkkzip 2y agothis would be a major hinderance to widespread adoption. DoS attacks aside the fact that it has no legal liability offset for video hoster (which anybody watching the video ends up sort of like bitorrent)
- stiltzkin 2y agoIt works like forums, you need to look for an instance with the culture and moderation of your liking.
- yreg 2y agoIs there a specific App Store rule that prevents them to let users add custom streams? It sounds functionally the same as adding instances to a Mastodon client or RSS feeds into a Podcast app. What's the catch?
- mrbombastic 2y ago[flagged]
- sitkack 2y agoAll the words on the site should be explained IN A VIDEO. Every page should HAVE VIDEO ON IT.
- skratlo 2y agoThis will never take off with that awful logo and mascot, and general silliness. With the "developed by Framasoft", like who the f* cares. It's noise, it looks awful, it repels potential users. Get some serious marketing person in.
- TibbityFlanders 2y ago[dead]
- tpoacher 2y agoI have some feedback if anyone from PeerTube is reading. The https://joinpeertube.org/instances https://joinpeertube.org/instances page should have some more useful sorting for the instances it shows. (not to mention the ability to sort by something useful) E.g. in my page as I see it, there's a random channel with 20 videos appearing as the second instance result, and then the 6th result is Freediverse.com with 741 subscriptions and 465,094 videos. Surely the latter should be on top.
- minroot 2y agoUsing Revanced YouTube greatly improved yt experience, and for some reason yt is suggesting a lot of small channel with great videos
- kouru225 2y agoSo downloading the app and adding my interests my first 10 recommendations are: 1) An educational video about peertube itself by peertube 2) the same educational video about peertube by peertube with English subtitles 3) a slideshow presentation about Framadate in French by framadate 4) an educational video about the fediverse by peertube 5) another educational video about peertube by peertube but this time in French 6) a French video about the pyramids I think? 7) the same educational video about peertube by peertube with Spanish subtitles 8) an educational video about mastodon 9) an educational video about alternative medicine 10) and educational video about TILvids by TILvids I don’t speak French fyi. Also it doesn’t change what videos I see when I filter by my interests. Methinks this is not a viable competitor to YouTube.
- m348e912 2y agoIt seems like the streaming tech is solid, no issues loading and playing videos. Curation on the other hand seems to be abysmal. I even tried their cutely branded search engine SepiaSearch with similar non-relevant or not so interesting results. I am also curious how moderation works. How do they prevent inappropriate or illegal content from being shared?
- quinncom 2y agoI get exactly the same list of videos when sorting by Most Views. It seems the algo doesn’t consider interests.
- iLoveOncall 2y ago> Methinks this is not a viable competitor to YouTube. It is not. I'm French and I have known about the different FramaSoft software for years now. They are all terrible alternatives. Their approach is completely wrong, they think that being "libre" (free) is enough to acquire market share, and they completely ignore the user experience, feature parity, and innovation. All of their tools are therefore terrible, to the point of being unusable. They are a paragon of oblivious French mediocrity. PeerTube specifically has existed for almost a decade and has never been used by anybody. It is an empty shell of a website kept alive just to burn public money.
- sschueller 2y agoI created a Peertube client for android a few years ago. It was removed by Google in September and is still pending appeal: https://github.com/sschueller/peertube-android/issues/302 https://github.com/sschueller/peertube-android/issues/302 I hope this version doesn't receive the same fate as mine did.
- stavros 2y agoThere are many more options than the Play store for Android. F-droid, Obtainium, etc. Could you list in some of those? EDIT: Oh, you do, nice!
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThe US needs to clamp down on the App Store monopolies to stop this abuse
- 71bw 2y agoWhat monopolies? There's various other options you can use on Android.
- eafkuor 2y agoSerious question, why would I use this? I searched for a topic I'm interested in, in English, and got barely related results in various languages (Swedish, Spanish). On YouTube, the first result for the same search is an amazing playlist, in English, on the exact topic I searched for.
- vfclists 2y agoPeertube is fine. It just needs more AI, the solution for all software and platform problems du jour
- stevage 2y ago> We cannot stress enough how their stores are not ready for independent solidarity-oriented networks. For exemple, a small "support us" donation link in our website footer or even on one of the allowed platforms triggered a "nope" from Apple. Ugh, wow.
- danlitt 2y agoDeleting YouTube and replacing it with this. I hope it pans out!
- Amira465485 2y ago[flagged]
- scirob 2y agoTried to type in something as simple as "funny videos" but got zero relevant funny cats or dogs. I wonder if they need an initiative to build content pipelines to bring move r some video.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoI wonder how a new platform can seed content to compete with YouTube
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoWhere's all the porn?
- petabyt 2y agoObligatory mention of grayjay: https://grayjay.app/ https://grayjay.app/
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 66yatman 2y agoAnother Utube?