13 ms·
Ouya: A New Kind of Video Game Console
- eperoumal 14y agoI don't want to be pessimistic, but given the hardware configuration, what kind of games this will be able to run ? I don't really feel like playing Angry Bird HD on my TV forever.
- Tim-Boss 14y agohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lBl-goBrWno http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lBl-goBrWno The Tegra3 quad-core processor doesn't perform awfully, and comes with 1Gb RAM... I'm not sure how much better you can get for $95 (lowest backing point to secure a console)!
- pwny 14y agoI don't know about others but poor (relative to PC and console) game performance on mobile games is only acceptable to me because the machine fits in my pockets. I don't sit in my living room to play iOS/Android games, the fact that the device is hooked to a bigger screen won't change that. Also, they seem to be confusing two target audiences here. People that grew up with games as a central part of their lives are (in my experience) people that STILL play a lot of games and prefer to do so on consoles and a PC, while people who are into social and mobile games are mostly casual people that won't be bothered to sit in front of a big screen to play anyways. I've felt like the console market was ready for some change for a while but envisioned it as a kind of Steam-console more than a big screen phone. That being said, I wish the best of luck to these guys, it's an ambitious and exciting project.
- eperoumal 14y agoTotally agree. BTW, a Steam console would be a total killer provided the games come less expensive than PS3/Xbox games.
- pwny 14y agoThat and a lot of very good indie PC games come with controller support out of the box. For example, I bought Super Meat Boy on Steam, I'd be glad to play it on a Steam Box!
- davedx 14y agoYou mean like the Steam Box [1] Valve is working on? :) [1] http://www.theverge.com/2012/3/2/2840932/exclusive-valve-steam-box-gaming-console http://www.theverge.com/2012/3/2/2840932/exclusive-valve-ste...
- pwny 14y agoGiven the relative free-for-all mentality that seems to be going on at Valve (which is far from a bad thing imo!), I won't take a patent application as a definite sign that Valve (a software company) will be unveiling a console anytime soon. I would buy it in a heartbeat though.
- jerf 14y agoDid you watch the video? I'm not sure what resolution that is pushing, but it clearly beats the Wii hands down and looks to be roughly competitive with the XBox 360/PS3. If that's 1080p it may even have a slight edge on them. (But I'd guess 720p. For the most part on a TV console it's not really worth pushing twice the pixels for such a marginal image quality gain.)
- pwny 14y agoPushing 1080p off a mobile GPU on a console with 1Gb of RAM is cool and all but good luck doing anything else impressive besides... well pushing 1080p. This thing is closer to a phone than a real console.
- jerf 14y agoYou might find it educational to compare the specs of the "real consoles" to your phones, and don't forget to account for the fact that the "real consoles" are running somewhat older CPUs and stuff so the GHz difference isn't necessarily reflected by straight-up division. Also the newer GPUs include quite a few newer tricks and capabilities that the current console gen don't have. Remember, the XBox 360 is now coming up fast on seven years old. By the time this comes out, eight. It's a bit fuzzy when a phone/tablet gets released that completely beats the XBox 360/PS3 due to the inability to easily directly compare the stats, but if it hasn't already happened it'll certainly happen next year, no question. Also, that video was of games, not just video. I mean, how much more concrete a proof do you need that games are possible than... games?
- mtgx 14y agoThe consoles are 7 years old. Mobile games are getting pretty close to their performance. All the new ARM GPU architectures coming out this year and next year will support OpenGL ES 3.0 (OpenGL 3.2 features) and OpenCL 1.1. Next year's hardware should also be 4-5x faster in GPU performance than Tegra 3 (that includes Tegra 4, as well as other chips), and around 300 gigaflops each, which I think already surpasses the Xbox 360 and PS3, or it's around as powerful. If Google and many of their partners would put these chips in $99 set top boxes/consoles, and let them play 3D Android games, it could disrupt the console market, simply by flooding the market with the help of multiple manufacturers, a low price, and a decent gaming platform, that could only grow bigger if it takes off, not unlike how Google dominates the smartphone market through the sheer number of Android devices released by many, many manufacturers. I just hope Google is smart enough to recognize this and actually go for it, instead of focusing solely on their "smart TV" strategy with their Google TV boxes.
- eperoumal 14y agoSure but truly it doesn't stand a chance vs. the upcoming next gen. consoles if it doesn't come with a killer game.
- mtgx 14y agoThe Nintendo Wii was pretty successful with its much weak graphics for half the price of the other consoles. Actually, it wasn't even half the price of Xbox360, but more like 75%.
- smackfu 14y agoIs a $100 console with $1-5 games really competing with what will be $400 consoles with $50-60 games?
- mtgx 14y agoGames like these: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CtxxbS_qhME http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CtxxbS_qhME http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HpzkCTe76Bc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HpzkCTe76Bc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZJz2UkWYqsA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZJz2UkWYqsA And also all the emulator games up to and including PSX.
- fyolnish 14y agoheh.
- tjader 14y agoWhy does the period in "Hackers welcome." link to https://twitter.com/YourAnonNews/ https://twitter.com/YourAnonNews/?
- aw3c2 14y agoCheap attempt of controversy/publicity I would guess. Fits the presumptuous feeling I got from the kickstarter text quite well.
- nates 14y agoThe real mistake is Free to play...
- Garoof 14y agoBut then the "free to play" part doesn't mean much. From the FAQ: "For gamers, every game will be free to play: what this means is that there will at least be a free demo" So it's free to play in the way that a great number of games not generally considered free to play are free to play. Or in the way the XBLA is a free to play platform or something.
- aw3c2 14y agoa) "8GB of internal flash storage & USB 2.0 (one)" That does not sound like it would be too useful if you want to play more than 2 games (exaggerated). b) Why would I invest into a project where "there are plenty of other people involved, but some of them would get fired if we tell you who they are"?
- mtgx 14y agoWe're talking about Android games here running on an ARM processor. They are a lot smaller than a PC game. I've only seen a couple of games that approach the 500 MB mark on Android, and there may be a few bigger ones I haven't tried. But most 3D Games should only be a few hundred MB at most.
- edintheforth 14y agoI admire them for trying to bring a cheap platform for (indie) gaming and such, but I don't get some points: They are claiming that "all the games will be free-to-play" and then in the FAQ they rectify it by saying that all games will have at least a "free-demo", which is not F2P, but nonetheless it means it will offer both kinds. Now let's see what kind of games they might bring to this platform: most of the F2P games that are available are either MMORPGs or some kind of FPS (ruling out flash games, of course). You don't find these formats on consoles, and why? Keyboard and mouse, which is totally the opposite of what they are trying to offer. Even though there are a lot of FPS games on consoles, there is not a single one the F2P format. The other kind of games (the non-F2P) will be mostly indie games, which is great. But still limited to the use of a controller! There are some amazing ones like Super Meat Boy and Bastion, but not many!
- kevingadd 14y agoFeels like amateur hour. I would honestly be shocked if they can ship a console with even those specs along with a controller and all the assorted bits and pieces you need, to an end user for $99 without eating some hidden costs themselves (which, if their budget is under a million, doesn't seem like something they're going to do). I'm not a manufacturing expert, so maybe I'm missing something enormous here, but given the history of console manufacturers taking a loss to sell bundled software, and the high list price of android devices, I don't see any evidence to support that their target price is remotely realistic. Even worse, the hardware specs are just... short-sighted. 8GB of storage is not remotely enough for a console that has no physical storage medium for games - Microsoft gets away with selling a 4GB XBox 360 because customers can pop a DVD into the drive, but anyone who is actually downloading games off the internet is going to need way more space than 8GB. I've got individual games on my Android phone that are over a gigabyte, and that's ignoring the amount of space used by the android OS itself along with other data (like saved games) - many modern PC games have individual save files that are over 10 megs. That stuff adds up. If you force players to add/remove games from their system in order to fit into 8GB, they're going to spend a ton of time waiting on their internet connections (and you would expect a guy who worked on the OLPC to know that a lot of people out there don't have fast internet yet.) USB2 for external storage means that expansion options will be limited - loading game assets off USB2 would probably have pretty dire performance consequences. There's also other assorted details that just make this feel lazy. The buttons on that controller mockup are only color-coded, which means it will be difficult (if not impossible) to clearly communicate to a color-blind player which button is associated with what action - even worse, they use all four colors, so it will probably affect people with every type of colorblindness. This is a mistake that none of the other console vendors have made: Microsoft, Sony, and Nintendo all made sure that each of their buttons has a distinct shape or letter associated with it so that in-game text and UI can communicate clearly to anyone who plays. Furthermore, they show various games in their mockup material - like Minecraft, and Triple Town, and Shadowgun - but apparently they haven't made deals with all of these developers to show up in the promotional material (let alone use the platform), which makes it seem like they really believe they're just going to ride the Android Market all the way to success. Can they even provide access to the official Android Market without meeting the requirements that Google imposes for shipping the Google Experience apps or whatever they're called? I could also rant about the fact that they think a Tegra 3 and Cortex A9 is adequate for a game console, but honestly I'm not worried about that. People have done amazing things with low-spec hardware before, but it certainly doesn't help if the hardware is poor along with the other poor decisions on display here.
- netcan 14y agoSounds like a great idea with lots of potential for spinoffs. Basically any Android TV device with a dedicated appstore connected to your credit card has lots of potential. Its a continuations of the entertainment merge (radio, tv, video, games, etc, social web) and thats the correct general direction. Being based on Android also opens up the possibilities for local variations. In Ireland for example, a great/cheap TV solution is SoarView (6 free-to-air terrestrial Irish TV channels) + FreeSat (UK free-to-air satellite channels) + Netflix (7 euro a month currently). That's not very common though because the hardware is crap and you need someone to come in and set it all up for you. You'll probably have 2 boxes & 3 remotes and need to press lots of buttons to get to everything. "Cable" companies wil spread out the cost, manage the hardware and get Irish & British TV into the same remote. A box that can pleasantly handle it all and "ephemeralize" it (thus doing all the stuff we haven't thought of yet) would be excellent. Add in some gaming that appeals to wii people and some that appeals to facebook scrabble people and you've got a bomb. Gaming is probably the best angle and any angle will do. Once you are shipping something that people connect to their tv, there are all sorts of things you can do. I'm glad to see experimentation going on here. I'm also glad to see that its getting to be in the reach of small companies.
- DanBC 14y ago"The entire first production run of consoles will have YOUR USERNAME and BACKER NUMBER ENGRAVED INTO IT" Well, at $10,000 that's an expensive barrier but I hope they're carefully checking those usernames.
- nik_0_0 14y agoIn the FAQ, they define free to play as "every game will be free to play: what this means is that there will at least be a free demo, or you’ll be able to play the entirety of the game for free but may have access to additional items, upgrades, or other features that come at a cost." I do believe that the first part is unequivocally not free to play... Xbox Live doesn't get to call itself free to play because it offers demos for almost every game. The 2nd part is certainly the freemium model that has been heavily used (and quite successful in my eyes). But I think it is important to clarify that the system does not only feature free-to-play games, but there are paid games that offer demos. They do mention that by all games being "free" they mean that developers will be forced to include some playable content for the user, but I just do not agree with that wording, it could be much clearer. Having said that, this looks cool :)
- ricardobeat 14y agoThat FTP part really curbed my enthusiasm. I very much prefer paying some reasonable price for a game I liked, think is cool or just admire the developer than feeling compelled to "unlock" stuff. That's true even if I end up not playing it at all later. Unlocking/going pro/etc still has a scammy feeling to it.
- wmf 14y agoDo you feel that way about demos?
- bitwize 14y agoGaming on android is a sad, laggy affair. There's too much input and audio latency for it to be a serious gaming platform.
- rrreese 14y agoWill that not change with Jelly Bean and Project butter?
- byproxy 14y agoThey're doing triple-buffering and vsync with Project Butter, which, if I recall correctly, increases input lag.
- Garoof 14y agoHmm? I might not know excactly what you're referring to and so on, but... I guess you increase input lag if you're doing vsync and double buffering and your drawing things can't keep up with the refresh rate (so framerate gets halved and that). With vsync and triple buffering, compared to vsync off, you should only (potentially) miss out on stuff like "I could have drawn the bottom third of this new screen I've rendered one frame earlier".
- RutZap 14y agoIt already reached 200K! WOW! Looking forward to this one...
- jere 14y agoI find it interesting that when someone gets a chance to build a controller from scratch in 2012, it ends up looking essentially no different than one from 1997: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual_Analog_Controller http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual_Analog_Controller On a completely separate note, this might be a great reason to target android... if it works.
- GuiA 14y agoThe human hands are notoriously hard to design for; controllers are a very hard to improve design, much like computer mice.
- sigkill 14y agoI wonder how comfortable it'd be if the controllers were split in the center and the resultant looked like dual nunchucks. You could join them by a cable and add motion detection too. Since the left and right hands are essentially now independent to move, the developers have a lot more creative freedom with movement controls.
- GuiA 14y agoAre you thinking about this? :) http://i.imgur.com/lpDqH.jpg http://i.imgur.com/lpDqH.jpg
- sigkill 14y agoWell not EXACTLY that, but close :D Just imagine taking your normal 360 controller and split it along the center. Now add gyroscope/accelerometer and two tracking cameras/LEDs (just like the WiiMotes).
- shadowmint 14y agoI was really excited about this until I saw the specs; they seem singularly unremarkable. 1 gig of ram, and a say what, a T33 maybe? Am I completely off the deep end here or is that like an order of magnitude less powerful (abit with more ram) than say, an xbox. So its cheap. Big deal, so is the Pi and say, http://www.androidauthority.com/remember-the-74-android-pc-now-it-has-a-53-little-brother-95354/ http://www.androidauthority.com/remember-the-74-android-pc-n... I'm kind of dubious about the value proposition of something that wants to be a full blown console, but is basically just a slight lower spec'd version of my phone. If you want to get me excited, stick 8 GB of ram on that thing and an intel based 3.2 Ghz cpu with a gpu that can run say, UT. That would effectively !!!! all over the state of the art for android devices AND consoles. This? It'll be obsolete by the time it even exists.
- mtgx 14y agoNo, it's not an order of magnitude less powerful. Tegra 3 games look almost console-like. And you can play a lot of older emulator games on this, too. Next year's ARM hardware should all but match the Xbox 360 hardware performance.
- sixbrx 14y agoXbox will probably be refreshed next year, though.
- mtgx 14y agoSure, but it will cost a few hundred dollars more. And many people might not want these just for games, but for media stuff, and they would find the $99 price a lot more attractive than $300-$400 for such tasks.
- heretohelp 14y agoSo it'll become a glorified Netflix player. Wonderful? This sort of our point, it's not useful for anything it purports to be useful for...like gaming.
- gcb 14y agoEverything sounds fine, except being Android based. Worst platform ever. Also good luck getting most of the hardware like game developers do with java.
- learc83 14y agoAndroid has an NDK that allows you to write native code in C\C++. Most of the resource intensive code for Android games is native. That's why you can't play most of the games if you have an android phone with a MIPS processor (they're all compiled for ARM).
- mtgx 14y agoWhat else should it be based on? Linux? At least Android has games, and they can also leverage 400 million users, and a platform growing at 1 million new users per month. Why does this matter? Because even if game devs are not interested to make games specifically for Ouya, they will make them for Android, and then it should be very easy to just port them to Ouya.
- cooldeal 14y agoThe UI seems have a lot of similarity to the XBox 360 Metro UI, Windows 8 and Zune, even the fonts. http://cdn2.sbnation.com/entry_photo_images/4547820/ouya2_gallery_post.jpg http://cdn2.sbnation.com/entry_photo_images/4547820/ouya2_ga...
- Sunlis 14y agoPersonally, I really like the new Xbox360 dashboard. Once I got the hang of it, I found it very easy to move around and get to what I want quickly. Using triggers for "tab" navigation makes a lot of sense. If that's (partially, at least) what they're basing their UI off of, then I'm all for it.
- nemo1618 14y ago>We get it – smartphones and tablets are getting all the new titles – they're "what's hot.” The console market is pushing developers away. We’ve seen a brain drain: some of the best, most creative gamemakers are focused on mobile and social games because those platforms are more developer-friendly. And the ones who remain focused on console games can’t be as creative as they’d like. Weird...I've this appeal many times before, but always with s/smartphone/console and s/console/pc. The whole "Deep down, you know your best gaming memories happened in the living room" bit reminds me of "Don't reduce big screen movies to a household TV" and "Surf the Internet, swim in magazines" campaigns. Can you imagine if this was coming from a bigger name like Sony or Nintendo? Sorry, just thinking out loud.
- Kiro 14y agoWhy was the title changed from OUYA to Ouya? OUYA is the name.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mtgx 14y agoWhy isn't Google making every single Google TV set top box like a mini-Android console? It's not like they would have to change a whole lot about it. Just make sure it has a high-end ARM chip, 2 controllers included, and they actually try to give incentives to developers to port their games for it, which should be a minimal amount of coding if they already have an Android game.
- formatjam 14y agoGood Question. I think the majority issue is: 1. Gaming in Android isn't that impressive yet. 2. They are def. working on it. But they don't want to make so many enemies (Sony) before they have a chance. For them, it is not a huge profitable item. Getting the Google TV into the living room is more important. But I can see Google TV eventually will become a console and OuYA will die out.
- mtgx 14y agoIt doesn't need to die out. They can continue to make the hardware, and adopt the new software. Not sure about the whole free-games thing, though.
- formatjam 14y agoInteresting. I thought about this. I think they will have their own market and not open to the official android market so that they will the cut of profit that games generated.
- ezy 14y agoOh look, AndroidTV. Prediction: Sidelined by the AppleTV in 6 months. EDIT: More detail: What do you think will happen when Apple comes out with an SDK for AppleTV, folks? I suppose the only thing missing is the controller. :-)
- Danieru 14y agoApple is not going to let the AppleTV run iOS apps. If only because the mess of resolutions and aspect ratios you find in everyday TVs. Thus without the iOS ecosystem Apple would be competing on specs and marketing. They could do it but they would be giving OUYA a run for its money. Besides, 6 months is a long time in mobile land.
- smackfu 14y agoI sure wish the Apple TV would have apps, but Apple seems totally uninterested in it. So I'll look elsewhere, instead of hoping "this time they'll announce it."
- jiggy2011 14y agoI want this to succeed and it's high time somebody tried something like this. I see 2 problems though, firstly the price. It's simply too cheap and this is reflected in the hardware specs, if they wanted enthusiasts they really need to bump up the hardware. A console with a small SSD and a desktop class nVidia/ATI GPU would be way more exciting. The other problem will be getting "killer apps" which is a huge part of console marketing, would the Xbox have been so successful without HALO? the wii without "wii sports"? This is where having a more "open" console provides disadvantages because they are in a weak position to score exclusivity deals since MS , Sony or Nintendo could simply see which are the most popular titles on the platform and strike deals with the developers to port them over to their platforms.
- learc83 14y ago>if they wanted enthusiasts they really need to bump up the hardware. It looks like this thing is aimed squarely at indie game developers, and the type of people who play indie pc games. Indie gamers aren't really known for their craving for top of the line graphics. Using android saves them a lot of time and putting it on an arm platform allows it to easily run all of the popular android games. There isn't a commodity SOC that comes with a desktop class GPU, so I don't see anyway they could realistically do that--it would require a whole lot more than a million bucks to develop it. >...most popular titles on the platform and strike deals with the developers to port them over to their platforms. This would a lot of time. Since these games are written for android a port will probably be a complete rewrite (see minecraft for x-box), and take a year at least. Why wait a year to play a game when you can get access for only $99? Sure eventually console makers might make tools and processes to make it easier for indie developers to get android games onto their consoles, but that would be fantastic (and would accomplish the goals of this project anyway).
- jiggy2011 14y agoIt looks like this thing is aimed squarely at indie game developers, and the type of people who play indie pc games. Indie gamers aren't really known for their craving for top of the line graphics. I'm not sure there is much of a demographic of people who are "indie gamers" , most people who play indie games also play AAA games, so a console for Indie games only doesn't seem like it would have a huge target market. Using android saves them a lot of time and putting it on an arm platform allows it to easily run all of the popular android games. Android stuff is mainly Java, so I can't imagine that porting would be that huge a deal especially considering there are also ports of android for x86. You must also keep in mind that most android games are designed around touchscreens, so it's not like they are suddenly going to have a big library of games that are playable with a controller without significant redesign. There isn't a commodity SOC that comes with a desktop class GPU, so I don't see anyway they could realistically do that--it would require a whole lot more than a million bucks to develop it. Couldn't this be mostly done by using a motherboard from a laptop or similar? Since it's a console, space and weight are less of a factor than with a tablet etc. This would a lot of time. Since these games are written for android a port will probably be a complete rewrite (see minecraft for x-box), and take a year at least. This is basically a chicken/egg problem. Indie developers are unlikely to develop around a platform that does not already have significant user base. Most of the popular indie titles, supermeatboy , braid etc were developed around the 360 first because it already had a significant market.
- autarch 14y agoI figure for $99 this is a fun experiment. If it sucks, I backed an interesting idea and I'm not out much money. If it doesn't suck, I have a neat new toy to play with. At the very least, it might let me drop my XBox Live Gold subscription, which I only have so I can stream Netflix.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- lukifer 14y agoI'm surprised they're not also pursuing media center features, either baked-in or through third parties. Netflix clearly wants to live on every box in the universe, and the open-ish stack lends itself well to Flex, XMBC, etc. It increases the value prop while the game library is still being built up (how many people bought a PS3 because it doubled as a Blu-Ray?) Also: how the heck is Ouya pronounced? Feels a little awkward to say, like the first year of the Wii. It's important that people are able to talk (and brag!) about your product.
- sigkill 14y agoThis is a good point. Also since it's running Android, I'd expect it to be fully compatible with the market place apps. Which means, I can run a webserver from this box if I care. Or more sanely, I could connect to my DLNA enabled media server and stream content from there (assuming this thing is going to have WiFi/Ethernet which I'm sure it will).
- blahedo 14y ago> Also: how the heck is Ouya pronounced? From the FAQ: OOO-yah. Apparently it doesn't have the most pleasant meaning in Swahili.
- Wingman4l7 14y agoAnyone know what the meaning is? I'm curious to know. They don't say, Google Translate doesn't have a clue, and a quick Google didn't turn up anything...
- pbhjpbhj 14y agoI think its 4 symbols to use for button identification.
- primitur 14y agoIf you're looking for a new kind of video game console, and haven't already heard of it, then you need to know about the Open Pandora: http://openpandora.org/ http://openpandora.org/ This device is, really, amazing. I have two. I will tell you whats so amazing about this GAMES machine: it has everything you need to build games, already onboard. Both of my machines are set up with their own on-board development environments - full C/C++ compiler, and so on. I have been able to port a metric tarball-tons' worth of games - and other - applications with the device itself and nothing else. You can use things like LOAD81 (http://github.com/antirez/load81/ http://github.com/antirez/load81/) on the Pandora http://repo.openpandora.org/?page=detail&app=LOAD81 http://repo.openpandora.org/?page=detail&app=LOAD81, and it really rocks. You can put python (or rather, upgrade the existing python), ruby, haskell, &etc. on it. With great ease. Also, you can play a hell of a lot of nice games, too. The free (in all meanings of the word) spirited community has constructed its own a-massing collection of titles: http://repo.openpandora.org/ http://repo.openpandora.org/ Emulators? There are very, very few emulators that are not already running on the Pandora; - I have 27 different 'retired architectures' software archives on one of my Pandoras. New-school games? Well, they're out there, and happening. The Pandora may not have an Android App Stores' worth of apps, yet, but most everything thats in the existing repo, is quality. There are some true gems .. just check the public repo top-10 list at repo.openpandora.org, to see what I mean. (EDIT: Actually, the Pandora can run Android just fine: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hHPxE9om3Hc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hHPxE9om3Hc) Did I mention: 11 hours battery life, and it fits in my coat pocket? Oh, it has two nice little analog nubs, a workable keyboard, and a decent touchscreen. The next generation Pandora might be an almighty beast worth looking at, but the Ouya, well .. it has some serious catching up to do.
- slantyyz 14y agoComparing a 440 Euro handheld device (arguably targeted mostly towards people interested in emulating bootleg roms) to a $99 console is really comparing apples to oranges.
- tatsuke95 14y agohttp://www.gp2x.de/shop/product_info.php/products_id/223?osCsid=b863faffac07b98a020289c53e6a08bd http://www.gp2x.de/shop/product_info.php/products_id/223?osC... Sort of neat, but... That thing is $750, plus shipping. Every gaming system I can think of is cheaper than that, including decent desktop systems. Almost everything you describe can be achieved on a low end laptop, which has more utility, for half the price. Outside of "fitting in my pocket", I can't see any practical reason to own a gadget like that. Am I missing something?
- alttab 14y agoI don't understand all the negativity in this thread. Sure, nit-pick it to death for this and that. But if this was executed correctly it would change the gaming world and collapse multiple console markets within the timeframe of one console generation. I learned to program by making games... so this is exciting to see!
- wtracy 14y agoI wonder how hard it will be to write an Android app that's compatible with both the OUYA controller, and the Xperia Play keypad?
- makepanic 14y agoI'm wondering how they try to solve the problem of getting a touch optimized game to work fine with a analog controller. I know that they said something about a touchscreen, but havn't shown some sort of concept for it.
- meej 14y agoThis reminds me of one of the problems with the never-released Infinium Labs Phantom console -- making PC games designed with a 2ft UI playable at a distance of 10 feet in the living room. This project's goals strike me as quite similar to the Phantom's, actually, but with mobile games instead of PC games. And inverse problems -- Infinium had the UI problem but their controls were pretty well figured out, while OUYA's UI situation seems fine but the controls may present a challenge.
- JVIDEL 14y agoI love the idea and I have talked about the possibility of an ARM-based console for the past 2 years, but the Ouya is one of those cases where the execution doesn't seems right. There's a lack of differentiation, it has no exclusives like big consoles have which can be critical to move units. The GTA series alone moved more PS2s than any other games in that console, and it had tons of great titles. By the time GTA3 made it to the Xbox the PS2 was getting the blockbuster San Andreas 8 months before any other platform did. In comparison most of the games on display for the Ouya are phone/tablet games. The anti-console crowd argues that people wont buy consoles anymore despite the fact that big consoles like the X360 have exclusive games not even available on PC. Simply put, why should I buy a Ouya if I can get the exact same games on my phone or tablet? I don't really understand the whole "hackers can modify the hardware"-part, wasn't the fragmentation of the Android ecosystem due to multiple hardware variations the reason why many developers stick to iOS? Wouldn't homogeneous hardware like that of the Kindle Fire make more sense in this situation? Since it's a console and not a handheld portable device I don't see why it couldn't have a HDD for storage instead of the paltry 8GB it has. It could easily pack 500GB in a 2.5 drive, leaving tons of space to store games, but with just 8GB less than 10 1GB games will use up all of the storage space, so users will have to delete those games and then redownload them every time they want to play, and waiting for a 1GB download is way slower than DVD loading times on consoles, let alone HDD times.
- slantyyz 14y agoI get the impression that the Ouya's bread and butter will be coming from casual gaming. Hardcore gamers will always want to stick to a beefier console anyways. Someone wanting to play Tetris, Canabalt or other low-time-investment game is probably plenty satisfied with something like the Ouya.
- JVIDEL 14y agoThat's even worst: a casual's only reason to buy a console is to get the games that they cannot get on their phones and tablets Why buy additional hardware like the ouya if it's the same exact same experience?
- blahedo 14y agoI read the Kickstarter page, then read the HN comments, and then went back and refreshed the Kickstarter page, and in perhaps twenty minutes, it had jumped almost a thousand pledges and over $100,000. That's... impressive. EDIT: Another hour, another couple thousand pledges, another couple hundred thousand dollars, and it's funded. (And they bumped up the $99 pledge point from 5K to 10K.) That was fast.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jeremyarussell 14y agoIt's funny, earlier I read the comments and they were mostly all about what a stupid idea this was, not a powerful enough system, can't force free, doomed to fail kind of stuff. I pledged this morning thinking how unique games are really going to flourish. How the simple graphic games can come out to be awesome, I mean we all played the classics right? Those 8-bit marathon games that gave us hours of joy, then hours more when they remade those games on the new system with the same old graphics, barely a remake in fact just a future port. And, I've sat as a gamer and watched all my friends buy those classic games over and over again, same graphics, same sound, same awesome gameplay. So now we have this chance to get a lesser powered system out to nearly everyone, people that can't afford to game but wouldn't mind the hours of time and boredom that is swept away by even the most casual of games. (heard of Zuma? Plants v zombies? etc.) I remember this morning seeing all the negative comments. It's 1:55 PM my time now,and OUYA is at 938,733 dollars. Clearly minutes away from being fully funded, with another 29 days they'll go over their asking by three to five times (if any of the kickstarters I've watched grow like this act as a valid indicator, which they should). So I'm left wondering, how many people will be eating the words they said today? I don't think it'll be OUYA, or any of the people that have backed the project already, waiting for the day that this console fills in a niche that the big console makers never even considered needing filled. I for one can't wait. As of finishing this post, the project is fully funded at $953,325.
- EternalFury 14y agoIn a way, I want to invest in this. Yet, something in the back of my mind tells me it would not be an investment, but a transfer of cash from me to them...with no product at the end of the bargain.
- wmf 14y agoThat's just how Kickstarter works. Everyone should understand that before putting down any money.
- EternalFury 14y ago2 years from now, it's going to be interesting to see what percentage of projects actually delivered on their promises. In this particular case, time to market is going to be super critical. They must get to market within the next 9 months or these hardware specifications will be laughable and Android 5+ will already be out there.
- vibrunazo 14y agoKicktraq, which calculates estimates for how much a project will make extrapolating from the current rate. Are estimating that OUYA will reach $39m if they can keep this pace. http://www.kicktraq.com/projects/ouya/ouya-a-new-kind-of-video-game-console http://www.kicktraq.com/projects/ouya/ouya-a-new-kind-of-vid...
- modarts 14y agoKind of curious as to why they'd use a linear extrapolation.
- bostonvaulter2 14y agoIt's a shame they only collect stats once a day, it would look so much nicer if they collected data multiple times per day.
- ricardobeat 14y agoNow tending to $58 million.
- BHSPitMonkey 14y ago"if they can keep this pace" being the qualifying phrase, of course. This project has gone super-viral -- $2mil within its first day. Because word is spreading so quickly, its entire target market will have learned about it in, what, 4 days, tops? It's not like the insane growth will continue after that happens.
- Tichy 14y agoWhy not just wait for Google TV?
- mtgx 14y agoI don't think Google has even made Google TV open source yet, probably because it's still based on Honeycomb. Also, unfortunately, Google doesn't seem interested to want to promote their Google TV set top boxes as mini-consoles, other perhaps than mentioning it in the bullet list *run Play Store games.
- 9999 14y agoIn spite of the pronunciation guide to the name of this console, I choose to pronounce it OOHHHHH YEEEEEAAAH in Macho Man Randy Savage's voice. Cheap hardware, open platform, and a decent looking controller. I would buy one, and I know a dozen other people who will too. OOHHHHH YEEEEEAAAH!
- agentultra 14y agoWell if I backed the $700 level and got a pre-release version of this thing, I'd have to sell a game at $5 to 140 people in order to make my money back on the hardware. Considering there are already (as I am writing this) > 15k backers I think it's fairly safe to assume that with the promised promotion that I could at least make that money back. If I don't get paid for all the time and effort I put into making the game... oh well. I like making games so it's not time wasted even if I don't ultimately get paid for it. Sounds like a cool hobby project at least. And what if it does take off? For a growing population of gamers there is no need for highly optimized hardware designed for crunching polygons and shaders. Not everyone wants to play CoD: Modern Hate Machine 5 Extreme. It would seem that this project is hedging its bets that this population of gamers is large enough to support building a specialized hardware platform for these types of games that they like. Seems pretty reasonable to me. I think I side with @notch (https://twitter.com/notch/status/220971663003623427 https://twitter.com/notch/status/220971663003623427): it would be awesome if this console does well. I think having a low-barrier development platform with wide adoption and a captive audience would be great. As it stands I can't just make a game for XBLA -- I have to suffer in obscurity in the indie store or create a real corporation with funding and a history of decent games and pitch my idea. Neither option is very attractive. I can't even imagine what developing for the PS3 would be like (as I haven't done any, but I'd imagine it would not be very fun). So I hope this project does do well. I think it will open a lot of doors and create new markets. That isn't really a bad thing for anyone.
- kayoone 14y agocurrent android smartphones have similar specs and plug into TVs via mini-HDMI and can connect to PS3 controllers for example. But i still like the concept :)