4 ms·
Are at-home genetic tests worth it? As an oncologist, here's my advice.
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/lCvqt https://archive.ph/lCvqt
- mylons 2y agothe real mvp.
- mylons 2y agoi’ve worked in R&D for DNA sequencer companies for over a decade. this is a pretty good TLDR on why genetic testing is a “complicated” test. you kind of need continuous testing over your lifetime to see what’s changing due to cell division errors. those are the true monsters that cause cancer. one study i worked on showed that on average every 12th cigarette you smoked created a mutation in your DNA. usually benign but that’s another path for how it starts.
- _yb2s 2y agoThe mutations will just be in single cells a few cells- you’d have to be liquified in order to sequence your whole body for cancer mutations. Leukemia would be an exception though, as you could find that from a blood sample.
- mylons 2y agoright. single cell analysis is a big thing people are hoping to achieve. the cigarette study i mentioned was looking at cells in the lungs and tumor samples iirc.
- adamredwoods 2y agoAnd I hope we get there. My wife died because her cancer mutated in such a way to evade chemo. Why? How could we have discovered this sooner? Do we have the tools to accelerate this and stay ahead of cancer mutations?
- mylons 2y agoI am so sorry for your loss. I’m sadly a CS guy living in a biology world and don’t have the foresight to predict anything like that.
- _yb2s 2y agoYou’re not understanding what I am saying- there is no way to identify which single cell has a mutation until it is already growing a tumor. There is no way to do what you are proposing -using sequencing to detect cancer mutations early before they turn into cancer- on a living person, even in principle. Single cell sequencing is for individual cells in a liquid culture- not living organisms- and the cells are destroyed to sequence them.
- bpodgursky 2y agoThis is about germline variants for BRCA etc, not somatic mutations.
- SoftTalker 2y agoPeople should not try to be their own doctors, like they should not try to be their own lawyers. Your self-interest will work against your objectivity, most likely to your detriment.
- ipaddr 2y agoYou should try to be able to provide as much of a level of care for yourself as possible. Learning more should be encourage. On a basic level being in the woods it's a positive benefit that someone can provide first aid. Doing research on a medical issue the health system doesn't have answers and making decisions for yourself is okay. Being able to read and understand legal text helps you in common areas like agreeing to terms when signing up for cable. Be your own lawyer or doctor but accept the level of skill and education you currently have and call one when you are over your head.
- throwaway98797 2y agoleave to the experts they say but are we experts at choosing experts? life is such is that we have to muddle through when we barely know anything live or die by your own choices you got only this one
- Dalewyn 2y agoIf there's one thing that 2016 (really 2015) onwards has taught me, it's to give absolutely zero of my damns to "experts". Unless I am paying them cold hard cash or some other incentive to work for me, and even then I will still be wary. Anecdata, my mother's cancer diagnosis (which she passed from a year later) took longer than it should have because her general physician was a piece of crap and kept insisting it was just bad constipation.
- fakedang 2y agoI mean you're still paying them a bunch of cash, yet most of them are still morons. Take a first, second, third, whatever opinion always. And best not to show previous diagnosis reports to the next guy, as that tends to bias them. Had a "reputed" doctor-professor at an Indian medical school who barely looked at my endoscopy and colonoscopy reports and insisted I was simply suffering from stress and diet issues, when it was actually the signs of Crohn's disease, which was correctly diagnosed by NHS doctors.
- heroprotagonist 2y ago[flagged]
- Dalewyn 2y ago[flagged]
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoEvery thread getting littered with complaints about the titles has become more annoying than the titles ever were.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y ago> Every thread getting littered with complaints about the titles has become more annoying than the titles ever were. Glob yes. And it just makes HN Bingo predictable.
- heroprotagonist 2y agoI bet it's even more annoying when you participate with those complaints and give them your attention. Then you can get really mad at them for stealing your attention instead of just moving on.
- eppp 2y agoIve watched people die of cancer. I do not want to die of cancer. Early detection and treatment increases the chances of a better outcome. What is a normal person supposed to do exactly to avoid this terrible fate when doctors say nothing works and you should just yolo it?
- daveguy 2y agoFollow the currently recommended standard of preventative care. They check for the most likely indications of the most likely cancers. An indication from your DNA is valid when it informs a new course of care. We don't know many of those markers, and family history can tell if those should be checked.
- nradov 2y agoEverybody has to die of something. If you don't die of something else first then you'll eventually die of cancer. There is good medical evidence to support colorectal cancer screening so go ahead and get that (along with other recommended preventive care services) if you meet the criteria. https://www.healthcare.gov/preventive-care-adults/ https://www.healthcare.gov/preventive-care-adults/ Obesity and insulin resistance (type-2 diabetes) greatly increase the risk of many types of cancer. Don't overeat, don't get fat, and exercise enough to keep your metabolism working well.
- adamredwoods 2y agoYour DNA is not guaranteed to mutate into something cancerous that spreads and mutates. I do think there are things humans can do to avoid carcinogens, but remember, bananas give off radionuclides.
- Retric 2y agoBananas don’t actually linearly increase your radiation risks because the body maintains homogeneous with relation to potassium. Banana equivalent dose is a misleading analogy not medical advice. Critically, risks are cumulative so the chances of cancer depend not on individual events taken in isolation but multiple events combined, and many of them are under your control.