9 ms·
> that means the average person can emit about 5.4tCO2/person/year from here on out. This is what emissions look like currently Using a world average target nu
by Aurornis 2y ago
> that means the average person can emit about 5.4tCO2/person/year from here on out. This is what emissions look like currently
Using a world average target number and then presenting a list that leads with world outliers is misleading. This is the kind of statistical sleight of hand that climate skeptics seize upon to dismiss arguments.
The world average is currently under the target number:
> World average 4.7t
I think you meant to imply that the CO2 emissions of poor countries were going to catch up to other countries, but I don’t think it’s that simple. The global rollout of solar power, battery storage, and cheap EVs is exceeding expectations, for example.
I don’t want to downplay the severity of the situation, but I don’t think this type of fatalistic doomerism is helping. In my experience with people from different walks of life, it’s this type of doomerism that turns them off of the topic entirely.
- lotsofpulp 2y ago>it’s this type of doomerism that turns them off of the topic entirely. In my experience, it’s the prospect of having to give up expected or dreamed about large homes, large vehicles, non seasonal/local fruits and vegetables, cheap electronics, and vacations involving flights.
- exe34 2y agotry suggesting that people should eat more vegetables and less meat - they see red and shout down any chance of reasoning.
- dgfitz 2y ago75% of the US is overweight or obese. You’re trying to make a partisan issue out of a not-partisan issue. Please stop.
- exe34 2y agoI would suggest that you are the one who just made it partisan. I'm in the UK personally, but I can immediately tell which side of the political spectrum you are, given the reflexive defence.
- iechoz6H 2y agoUnless they're a vegetarian presumably? I guess 'people' here means North Americans?
- exe34 2y agowell quite. I'm in the UK myself.
- mjamesaustin 2y agoOne person's individual change is a drop of water in the ocean when compared to the vast amount of emissions and pollution and waste produced at scale by corporations. Arguing to your neighbor why they should recycle their plastic water bottle can at most make an infinitesimal difference. Creating a legal responsibility for Coca Cola to clean up the billions of plastic bottles it produces annually, on the other hand, could change the world.
- antisthenes 2y ago> Creating a legal responsibility for Coca Cola to clean up the billions of plastic bottles it produces annually, on the other hand, could change the world. It would change the world in a sense of Coca Cola either going bankrupt, or shrinking to the point of irrelevance, succumbing to competitive pressure of corporations that aren't forced to do such cleanups. Edit: Do better, HN. Explain why you disagree. This argument is a delusional meme, as if people were not the primary consumers of corporations' products. Corporations are reactionary at best and believing there's 0% responsibility on the consumer is a 5 year old child mentality.
- sumeno 2y agoIf they aren't profitable when taking into account their negative externalities than the owners are stealing from the rest of the world and they should go bankrupt. They'd probably figure out a better way to do business instead though
- tsunagatta 2y agoThe incoming government in America loves the idea of tariffs; why not frame it as part of a trade war in a theoretical government set on ending climate change? Place heavy tariffs on any goods that do not have the same cleanup obligations.
- consteval 2y agoI don't understand why enacting a 20% tariff on all imports makes sense, but enacting a 20% carbon tax on every company in order to pay off the damage of pollution is literally unthinkable and would cause every company to go under. The days of letting companies do whatever the fuck they want and doing nothing to steer their incentives in the right direction are gone. It doesn't work, end of. We need to nudge them to do the right thing, and the only thing humans care about is money.
- roamerz 2y agoAfter reading this comment I wonder how much making Ozempic free for all would affect global CO2 emissions.
- ben_w 2y agoMy guess would be 3%: 1) I have no reason to think the carbon intensity per calorie would change 2) it doesn't take much overeating per day to build up, so I'd assume semaglutide based weight reduction reduces calorie intake by about 25% per day unless someone gives me a study (can't find myself as search results biased to news not science) and 3) all agriculture combined is about 12% of emissions multiply together and that would be about 3% of global emissions, which is a start, but not sufficient — we need to target 99.9% for long term sustainability
- Ekaros 2y agoSimilar thing happens when you suggest about living in cages and not single family houses... Or banning cars altogether...
- ben_w 2y ago> Similar thing happens when you suggest about living in cages Cages? Who is even suggesting that?
- jfengel 2y agoI believe the causation runs the other way. The IPCC was founded in 1988, when CO2 emissions were 22 gigatons per year. Nearly four decades later it's 40 gt/y, and continuing to rise. Doomerism is the reaction to our utter failure to even pretend to try. It did not cause that failure. Nor are people looking at the data and going, "yeah, I ought to do something, but people on Hacker News were gloomy so I'm going to buy a bigger SUV instead." EVs and solar and suchlike are much, much, much too little and much, much, much too late. Doomerism doesn't help, except in the extremely limited sense of helping someone express their frustration. But it also isn't hurting because we'd be doing exactly the same nothing if they were cheerful.
- onlyrealcuzzo 2y agoWe were asleep at the wheel for maybe 20 years too long on renewables, but the pace over the last 10+ years has been mind-boggling, and especially the pace the last 4 years. Nothing is going to turn that tide meaningfully. I'd like to know how anyone with an ounce of reality thinks we're going to reduce emissions substantially faster than we already are. Rome wasn't built in a day.
- silver_silver 2y agoIn my mind the only realistic solution left is to make up the difference with solar radiation management, and I would bet it’s what will end up happening
- rwyinuse 2y agoYes, global geoengineering will be probably deployed to buy us some time to get off fossil fuels.
- idunnoman1222 2y agoYou won’t be able to stop poor countries from spraying aerosol into the stratosphere if it gets too hot on the ground
- cogman10 2y ago
- abdullahkhalids 2y agoI don't think I am presenting outliers (though I have edited the list to add some context). US+China+Europe+Australia have cumulatively emitted 70% of all historical emissions. They are still 3x the world average and the estimated target. That's why they are on the list. China is there because it is a common villain in these discussion. The low-(middle)-income countries are, in my opinion, never going to emit much more than they do now. They will never contribute to the problem but will feel all the effects.
- returningfory2 2y agoIf you follow your argument logically, it says there's nothing to do and we're in a good place. You said we need to have 5.4tCO2/person/year on average across the world. You then presented a table that shows that we are in fact _under_ this target (4.7t). In your follow-up comment you claim that the lower-income countries are "never going to emit much more than they do now". So by your argument the world average will probably stay below the 5.4t goal and we're on target.
- willsmith72 2y agoYou're missing the core of the argument: "If we assume that we get to net zero by 2050,"...
- abdullahkhalids 2y agoThe target of 5.4tCO2/person/year is assuming we take a linear path down from 2023 emissions to zero emissions in 2050. It is the halfway point on that line. Real world reductions (or increases) won't follow a linear path. Global population is also increasing. The number is just a rough estimate to show which countries are dropping the ball.
- tzs 2y agoI think the point is that unless we can make a good case that some people have some sort of natural or divine right to a bigger share of the world's total CO2 emissions budget then other do, we have a lot of countries that are over budget. It's hard to tell the poorer countries that they should stay poor so as to keep the world under budget, but using fossil fuels for many of them is the only to become not poor in a reasonable timeframe with their existing resources. Just considering the welfare of their own citizens and their own resources their best path will often be a rapid increase in fossil fuels to get to a reasonable level of wealth and then start emphasizing renewables. Since it is unlikely that the existing wealthy countries can reduce emissions enough to keep the world under budget as the developing countries follow the aforementioned path, we probably need the wealthy countries to help out the poorer countries to try to speed things up so they go through the fossil fuel phase faster.
- nradov 2y agoSounds good, but who counts as poor? If you mean countries like Honduras then sure, let's help them out as long as they have effective financial controls to prevent corruption. But China is the largest emitter, and while they still have a huge number of poor people they also have nuclear weapons aimed at us. There's no possible political scenario where US taxpayers agree to subsidize China.
- dclowd9901 2y agoDo you think there’s ever a point where we say “guys, if we don’t do something now, we’re all Dead”?
- code_runner 2y agoExactly. “It’s bad and you should feel bad and it can’t be fixed” Well… ok I guess I won’t stress about it too much since I can’t change it? I was already powerless but now effort is futile. I’d like a real straw I guess
- taeric 2y agoI'll add my voice to the complaints on doomerism. Frustrating how much of the discourse is on blame and shame. Ignoring that we have done rather well compared to the bad targets for quite a while.
- consteval 2y agoWhen our incoming president proposes to appoint a climate change denier as the head of the Department of Energy and also plans to raise oil subsidies while dissolving subsidies for clean energy, I think perhaps enough shame has not been handed out. We've let blatant lies and science denial get way too far. We currently have people completely detached from reality running our nation states, and we have droves of people who will believe them when they say the sky is green. From a sociopolitical perspective, it's bad.
- taeric 2y agoI voted against this administration, and I still think shame is the wrong choice. Agreed we have allowed blatant lies too much leeway. But progress can be had without shame. I think back to when better lights were hitting the market. People would regularly scold folks for having their current lights on too long. "Just turn your lights out to save energy" was a common view. It was comically misguided, though. Modern lights use a laughably low amount of energy. Same goes for a lot. People love to complain that things don't last as long. Ignoring that energy use is plummeting on things. It is still largely valid that you should not replace a car on a whim. I think justifying my 2000 truck is getting harder every year. Granted, to your point, seeing Buttigieg have to defend encouraging electric vehicles was frustrating. To that end, I'll push it is less shame that is needed, but more accountability. Especially at the leadership level.