5 ms·
Google will stop serving political ads in the EU, including on YouTube
- iLoveOncall 2y agoAfter living in 2 EU countries and the UK for decades, I don't think I've ever seen a political ad on any Google product (and even overall?). It's probably a very minor impact to Google's ad bottom line.
- seumars 2y agoSame here. I also wonder who would even target their political ads at european audiences.
- cj 2y agoEU countries have elections, too.
- PoignardAzur 2y agoI don't know what various countries' norms are, but if people aren't used to political ads and are generally suspicious of the concept, an ad may have negative utility. I know if I saw a paid ad for a candidate that would make me want to vote against them.
- Aardwolf 2y agoPaper flyers in your mailbox, and billboards in people's gardens, are some age-old and very common forms of advertisement during elections I've seen in multiple countries in Europe
- Mashimo 2y agoInteresting. Where are billboards on private property common? I mostly see them on tv, public billboards and light poles.
- hsbauauvhabzb 2y agoAustralia small signs (100cmx50cm size) are common. Billboards you’d see down a commercial street are probably private property and often are political also.
- Aardwolf 2y agoHere's an example: https://img.nieuwsblad.be/vXdqo10D824EJ6p5Ab4IBfARaZs=/960x640/smart/https%3A%2F%2Fstatic.nieuwsblad.be%2FAssets%2FImages_Upload%2F2019%2F05%2F23%2F28ee31b3-8d1f-4099-b563-0b9d49a7733b_web_scale_0.0666667_0.0666667__.jpg https://img.nieuwsblad.be/vXdqo10D824EJ6p5Ab4IBfARaZs=/960x6...
- baud147258 2y agoAt least in France I don't think I've seen either of those. More common are poster stuck on public infrastructure
- PoignardAzur 2y agoThere's a bunch of strictly regulated ad formats. Each party gets one "metal billboard" poster and I think one TV spot and that's it. The most common form of political advertising by volume is probably unauthorized propaganda posters on public infrastructure, yeah. Those are annoying. Also stickers on traffic light poles and similar places.
- gorbypark 2y agoIn Spain we get nicely labeled "Political Propaganda" in the mail around election time. I think by law each party can send you one letter, and it has to have the "Political Propaganda" text on the outside. It's pretty nice in that I can throw it all straight into the recycling bin!
- ben_w 2y agoNot sure about the EU-27, but the UK has rules about election ads, to the extent that Cambridge Analytica was a scandal. Some of that scandal was due to bribery and offering prostitutes, but even the aspects that were purely what is considered "normal" for targeting online advertising was unacceptable by UK political standards. That said, part of the latter being scandalous assumes that they were actually capable of providing the service they claimed, which is something I find myself increasingly unable to believe due to how wildly badly I get categorised by the main advertising platforms — nationality, country of residence, language, gender, all wrong.
- mathverse 2y agoWhat? We mostly get political ads in CEE region as most of the products or services being sold here are not applicable anyway.
- 1oooqooq 2y agoexactly. they already cannot show ads on EU because of regulations... not that they wouldn't, but campaign managers abide to the regulations and don't go to google. so what google does? spin it as a holier than thou campaign to try to offset the dumpster fire that is the very lucrative US campaign ads they do profit handsomely from. "look over here, not over there". so boring. also, their jobs site have tons of lobbyist positions on DC ;)
- carpenecopinum 2y agoIn a roughly two-week window of not having adblock enabled, I have seen a ton of "politics-adjacent" ads in Germany. They'd usually start off with something that will get right-wing nuts excited ("This Green Party politician ruined their career, learn more.") and will then pivot to some crypto-scam. I'm wondering if those will be affected by the new ban as well, or if crypto scams aren't political enough to apply.
- kurayashi 2y agoCloser to an election you will also see ads from actual political parties. I’ve mostly noticed them from CDU and AfD, sometimes the greens.
- delichon 2y agoLess poltical information from fewer sources equals incumbent protection. This is a regression for democracy and an advance for oligarchy.
- datway 2y agoOligarchy actually does great with less regulation too.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoCan't uploaders still post political videos? Based on the political ads I've seen over the years, people are better off hearing from non-paid sources.
- x3ro 2y agoInteresting, why do you think so? I feel like paid, targeted ads on platforms everyone uses are extremely insidous, because an incumbent or major political party will always have more funds than an e.g. an upstart party, and targeting is generally bad as it's easy to play into people's preconceived notions that way, instead of presenting your position or the change you advocate for. Edit: replaced "incumbent" with "incumebt or major political party"
- spacebanana7 2y agoWinning at targeted ads is more of a skill game. You typically only need a few thousand well placed votes to win an election, and even 100k impressions at $10 CPM is pretty inexpensive.
- piva00 2y ago> You typically only need a few thousand well placed votes to win an election, and even 100k impressions at $10 CPM is pretty inexpensive. In the context of the EU this isn't true though, no political system in any EU member state relies on a tiny minority of votes from some states/provinces to completely tip an election.
- h1fra 2y agoI wonder if recent propaganda around war is part of this block?
- Agingcoder 2y agoI don’t think so, this is not new. At least in France there are rules regarding political spending and advertising. The basic idea is that even with an unlimited amount of money, you are not allowed to buy significantly more tv time than your opponents, campaign spending is capped etc. Since 2021 that’s what google does for France : no ads about a debate of general interest three months before an election. On tv it’s manageable : there are not many channels, and everything is declared, at worse just have a bunch of people watch and report. I understand that google can’t deal with this automatically. I am not saying it necessarily works well in practice, just that it’s not a new idea.
- xena 2y agoYouTube creators are going to be upset by this, political ads in election years have a CPM of upwards of $5. It makes up a lot of their income.
- anonzzzies 2y agoSure, but feeding impressionable people garbage which then gets them to vote squarely against their own interests is worse than creators making a bit less.
- ReptileMan 2y ago[flagged]
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoDid you forget a "/s" or is that your genuine belief / political stance?
- ReptileMan 2y agoThat is the fun part - you have to decide yourself.
- skyyler 2y agoI don’t think this is the right website for that sort of rhetoric. Do you have any sincere beliefs that you’d like to earnestly discuss with other people with curiosity?
- ReptileMan 2y agoA particle or a wave. Choose one. Cannot be both. It's travesty against nature. Is a belief that universal franchise is stupid, but since we are playing that stupid game we should enjoy it's stupid prizes and not cry disinformation every time the voters have the audacity to vote against the preferences of the pseudo intellectual elite that controversial?
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y agoI wish they'd stop serving scams too. I keep seeing shit like "make 75,000 using Ethereum and ChatGPT"
- cjrp 2y agoIt might not be a scam, maybe the rest of the sentence is "...by spending 150,000"
- ahartmetz 2y agoAnd "a propos of nothing, would you like to see this political fringe/crank/"angle"/plain lies content?" Since YouTube started to take disabled tracking seriously, I guess I see what it tends to suggest to Joe Shmoe, and it's not good - not for Joe and for sure not for social cohesion.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoI was sure there was EU laws as well as big tech policies against misinformation / fake news nowadays, maybe I was wrong, maybe there's no oversight, or maybe money trumps principles/laws. I'm disappointed, given that it's no secret that foreign interests (e.g. Russia) are funding / pushing these divisive misinformation campaigns. Ironically, me saying it's Russia pushing divisive campaigns is in itself a divisive statement to make, therefore, mission successful?
- ahartmetz 2y agoI'm also fairly surprised that such crap is still happening. I think I remember details about one time that it happened, it was in the context of a video where some US dude tries all kinds of flammable liquids as fuel in a combustion engine. It was like YouTube decided "Oh, redneck content! That guy is gonna love himself some right-wing cringe shit." No, YouTube. That guy doesn't like it and that guy doesn't like YouTube serving divisive garbage to others.
- christkv 2y agoMy current YouTube is full of self help gurus, ads for funeral insurance, tampons and ground to air anti aircraft missile systems.
- NeuroCoder 2y agoArticle says this has been done other places already. Has this specifically been campaign ads or does it also involve things that are considered politically motivated messaging? For example, is there danger of vaccination PSAs getting banned because some politicians say bizarre things about them?
- account42 2y agoI would hope so. The government paying private companies to spread its propaganda is bad for many reasons.
- NeuroCoder 2y agoIt's already an uphill battle to fix misinformation concerning vaccines without calling it political.
- account42 2y agoIf you need psychological manipulation (ads) to "fix misinformation" then there is a good chance it isn't misinformation in the first place.
- roenxi 2y agoIt is a remarkably complex issue to take a stance on, because most voters don't seem to do any particular research, don't have any understanding of cause-and-effect between policies and outcomes and are easily swayed by lies. Does allowing ad spending on Google push that messy equilibrium towards a better result or a worse result? I contend it is impossible to say with certainty but political ads are likely a net win for voters. They're going to be misinformed by political ads, but also by silence. At least with paid candidate messages they know what the candidates think is popular. But this is a good outcome for the EU nonetheless because Google is a US company and the EU is based in Europe [0]. EU and US interests don't always align, examples like Nord Stream stick out. Or the trade and tariff battles. Putting US companies in charge of EU political communication seems like insanity. [0] My alter ego is Captain Obvious
- Agingcoder 2y agoThe problem is not so much paid political ads as imbalance in spending and tracking the real person behind the ad ? ( which is what you’re pointing at I think )
- drcongo 2y agoConsidering how much of YouTube's "content" is right wing conspiracy nonsense, can't see how this is going to move the needle much.
- andybak 2y agoI genuinely don't see any. What are you doing to get the algorithm to feed you content like that? Or if this isn't in your feed - what are you basing your estimate on? I don't doubt there's a ton of it - but I'm curious how you know there's a ton of it.
- gorbypark 2y agoIt doesn't take much. We recently had large floods where I live and I decided that for next time I was going to have some supplies ready, just in case. A few seemingly benign searches for "preparedness" later and my feed is full of conspiracy theorists, guns and Jeeps. I guess the "prepper" crowd correlates strongly with some other categories.
- akimbostrawman 2y agoThe fact you have to go out of your way to find this supposed "right wing conspiracy nonsense" should be a good indicator of your own bias. I wonder if you had the same opinion of being prepared with cars and guns if you lived in ukraine or gaza
- drcongo 2y agoHe didn't go out of his way, he literally just explained that he searched for something and got served the crackpot stuff. Searching for something on YouTube isn't going "out of your way", it's using it as intended. Maybe read it again.
- akimbostrawman 2y agoHe searched for "preparedness" it's like complaining you get security related videos when searching for VPNs
- rbanffy 2y agoPlotting where the line falls is an interesting problem. Is anti-vaccine misinformation political? Is it greenwashing oil political? Attacking EV incentives? Is correctly informing people about climate change political?
- morkalork 2y agoClimate change shouldn't be but is, but hey, there's a great joke about video games only have 2 gender options now: Male and political.
- aunty_helen 2y ago“Hey guys, I’d like to go ahead and give a big shout out to todays sponsor…”
- seydor 2y agoThe european commission and EP are already the top political advertising spender for Facebook in most EU countries. This will be an unexpected boost to their ad revenue
- dathinab 2y ago> Meta cuts the price of its ad-free plan by 40 percent in a bid to sate EU regulators (the second article bundled with the first article, at least for me) I'm sooooo feed up with platforms and news sites/papers knowingly starkly misrepresent the relationship of ADs and GDPR to mislead consumers and enforcement just accepting it. I.e. they represent it as if the choice is "no-pay+ad+tracking" or "pay+no-ad+no-tracking" but that is _not_ what GDPR is about. It's only about tracking and requires not tracking to be as easy as with tracking i.e. "no-pay+ad+tracking" vs. "no-pay+ad+no-tracking". If you want to also have a payed no-ad plan, sure go ahead, but that isn't required by GDPR nor is it _fulfilling the requirements GDPR it gives you_. But most especially news sides require you to pay to not be spied on and also happen to then no longer show ads, which really isn't what GDPR is meant to enforce, privacy is recognized by the EU as a fundamental human right, not a luxury good you need to pay for.
- rgreekguy 2y agoGreat news, if some years too late... The one time I tried to turn off the ad-block on YouTube, I gave up because of political ads. Now I'm not going back for other reasons, too. Also some tracking parameters were added on the URL. Not sure if it's from Hacker News, or from rejecting cookies, or what.