5 ms·
We're experimenting with advertising
- verdverm 2y agotl;dr people are not inclined to pay for search, so Perplexity's hand was forced?
- nicce 2y agoI believe that many are willing to pay if the results are good enough when compared to free alternatives. However, as many studies show in Youtube/Meta/GoogleSearch ad revenue per user, the subscription price needs to be really high to match the ad profits. If you want to maximize the profits, you include ads.
- dizzydes 2y agoYes, which is fine
- Veen 2y agoI paid for Perplexity Pro for a while. It was somewhat useful for researching technical articles. But I found it got too much wrong in areas I knew about, so I couldn't trust it in areas I didn't. If I have to double check what it tells me, I might as well use a search engine, so I moved that spending to Kagi.
- tomjen3 2y agoI pay and I don't see an excemption for pro accounts. I am already pretty pissed at them for pushing the election widget so hard - you could click on the X, but it would come back on every new search I opened.
- teejmya 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enshittification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enshittification
- ssahoo 2y agoAll the VC money is pumping to make it a profit. Being just an ai agent should be enough to cover with subscription revenue otherwise
- mplewis 2y agoThese LLM companies have never been profitable, and most of them will die before they achieve profitability.
- nicce 2y agoAnd so it begins.
- Rocka24 2y agoThey have to do something especially with the deployment of ChatGPT search.
- llamaimperative 2y agoCrazy idea: charge money.
- papichulo2023 2y agoAnd then, big surprise, still show ads but just call them differently like promotions or partnerships! Can I collect my MBA now?
- rvz 2y agoOriginally, Perplexity advertised itself as being the ad-free alternative to Google search. Now they switch to an ad-based model. Unsurprising. The grift continues.
- bitpush 2y agoEnshittificaiton begins!
- dewey 2y agoSomehow everyone learned about this word in the past two years and now it's been so overused that it's getting boring to always shout it as soon as something changes.
- ThrowawayTestr 2y agoHappens to every new word that becomes popular on the internet.
- canardlaquay 2y agoI understand getting bored of it, but it's only been "overused" because it's the same pattern everywhere since the beginning of this decade. In the last few years, a lot of companies went down the anti-consumer road: shrinkflation, lower quality/reliable parts, and just like Perplexity, forced ads in paid subscriptions for Netflix/Prime Video/etc. So I think it very much applies in this case.
- autoexec 2y ago> now it's been so overused Is it actually overused or are you just tired of being reminded that so many things are constantly getting objectively worse?
- amelius 2y agoWe finally have a word for what capitalism eventually leads to. In a few years economics textbooks will be full of it.
- AlexandrB 2y agoIt's such a common pattern in technology - especially in VC-funded companies - that it's nice to have a single word to be able to discuss it concisely. In a way it's not too different than old-school "dumping" of products at below cost to drive competition out of business only to raise prices once you have control of the market. Though with internet companies the "price" is often the volume of ads you end up getting exposed to.
- evandena 2y agoIs this limited to non-pro accounts?
- freefaler 2y agoThat's the question and since they didn't explicitly mentioned that in the post I assume that it will be shown to the pro accounts too. You pay 20$ for the "pro-search", but not for ad-free experience.
- dizzydes 2y agoWhy are people so negative about ads? Just don't click them, this and tons of other services wouldn't exist without revenue streams... EDIT: Based on the tsunami of responses, perhaps a hybrid offering with a paid ad-free version? Even then they would only be building a single product so directional conflict would still arise..
- conception 2y agoThis seems simple - it makes the experience worse.
- dewey 2y agoPeople don't want to understand that someone has to pay for all that bandwidth and free compute. I'm using Kagi for that reason, just like I'm using Fastmail. I give someone money, they give me a service and support if needed. Seems fair and simple.
- arresin 2y agoWhen the internet started it was weird to pay for something ephemeral like certain bits being delivered to you. But totally normal to pay for magazines. I think that early mindset just continued and became the new default. Electronic media just feels weird to pay for for people.
- dewey 2y ago> Electronic media just feels weird to pay for for people. Most people in the target audience of Perplexity probably pay for at least two streaming services (Spotify, Netflix etc.), so I don't think it's about "eletronic media" but more that search seems like a simple thing from the outside that always has been free and has a very strong player that offers a pretty good service for most people.
- dizhn 2y agoBy the end magazines were mostly ads and almost free to subscribe to.
- ignoramous 2y ago> ... we want to highlight our guiding principle: the content of the answers you receive on Perplexity will not be influenced by advertisers ... Ads will appear in the US to start and will be formatted as sponsored follow-up questions and paid media positioned to the side of an answer. Isn't masquerading sponsored follow-up question a loophole around the "guiding principle" of not wanting to influence the user here? I must say though, there's no easy way out for pplx since ads, by definition, compete for user's attention (and an unrelated / unobtrusive sponsor link / question / reference would be no good for the sponsor; which is to say, the sponsor is pplx's customer, not the end-user).
- whakim 2y agoI don't see how this won't eventually converge towards some kind of AI-optimized SEO; presumably there's some algorithm which surfaces sponsored follow-up questions for a given query?
- nerdponx 2y agoThis is what Google did. Even if you technically don't manipulate the search results around sponsorships, you can devote more and more real estate to the sponsored results, and gradually make the distinction between sponsored and normal results less visually apparent. Google search has essentially been eaten by its own ad-based funding model, but I'm sure they made a ton of money on it up to this point.
- pennybanks 2y agoevery business is trying to sell you something. or make money off you somehow. doesnt necessarily mean its a bad thing, in fact you could think of it like a service we want and willingly pay for.
- nerdponx 2y agoBut not every business finds it usefulness gradually eroded by its revenue model.
- 2y ago
- mcdow 2y agoI started using Perplexity as my primary information-finding tool because of the progressive worsening of Google search results. Philosophically Kagi resonated with me, but Perplexity just gave me better results and it won out. This move into an ad-driven-revenue model may tip the scales back in Kagi's favor. For those that aren't aware, (part of)the Kagi hypothesis is ad-driven-revenue ultimately leads to enshittification, and that the solution is a subscription model. I don't question the first part of this hypothesis(ads -> enshit.). But the second depends on many factors. In this particular case, how long does the enshittification take? What if we just move to a world where every 10-20 years, there is a new VC-subsidized but ultimately ad-funded organization that kills the previous incumbent? And we just jump from ship to ship, never realizing the cycle we are in because it takes 10-20 years for the ad model to rot at the core of the product.
- int_19h 2y agoTo be fair, that first part is not just a Kagi hypothesis - they literally quote Brin & Page on this: "The goals of the advertising business model do not always correspond to providing quality search to users... advertising funded search engines will be inherently biased towards the advertisers and away from the needs of the consumers." — The Anatomy of a Large-Scale Hypertextual Web Search Engine, Sergey Brin and Lawrence Page, 1998 As far as the model, I think the problem is that once ads are shown to be profitable, they become pervasive in anything mainstream, because, well, why would VCs back a startup that is not willing to take money that's on the table? There's a niche in catering to people who really, really hate the notion of targeted ads and the associated infringement of their privacy, which makes Kagi viable, but I don't see any major ad-free competition in this space. So I doubt that it can work as a cycle. We might get a competitor that works better than Google - it's not exactly a high bar these days! - to replace them eventually, but I'm pretty sure it'll also be ad-ridden. And with LLMs especially, the potential for replacing in-your-face ads with subtle but persistent bias in the desired direction can make it all much worse.
- iammru 2y agoI'm highly skeptical they'll step away from this approach once it becomes a core part of their business metrics. With VCs pushing for higher growth, resources and new outside hires will inevitably be directed to fuel it. Eventually, growth through ads will become embedded in their culture.
- pennybanks 2y agotheyve already partnered with aws. i mean every online company works through ads if not direct purchase/subscription. its just the only revenue model that works. unless every user purchases pro how else would they make money? sell perplex t-shirts? its obviously a costy product to maintain. and if your not going to pay cash for a product then whats the only other revenue system that you will tolerate? its ads. everyone is fine with it in actuality but act like they arent. thats the funny part. vote with wallet, they will comply
- arresin 2y ago(We want money)
- sanex 2y agoThey're not running a charity
- amelius 2y agoWe don't want to pay with our attention.
- what 2y agoThen pay with your wallet.
- amelius 2y agoThat's not always an accepted payment method.
- handfuloflight 2y agoIt is here: https://www.perplexity.ai/hub/faq/what-is-perplexity-pro https://www.perplexity.ai/hub/faq/what-is-perplexity-pro
- amelius 2y agoIt doesn't say there are no ads.
- dev1ycan 2y agoGod it's so obvious how they're running out of money with nothing really to show for it, these are gigantic red warning signs of the bubble getting close to bursting, another is how Microsoft released Warcraft 3 reforged 2.0 with literally every asset upressed by AI, they're trying to justify the amount of money thrown into the dumpster to AI by doing these things.
- dumbmrblah 2y agoI've subscribed to Perplexity for the past 2 years. ChatGPT search is on par if not better in some respect but I use Perplexity enough to justify the $240 a year still (and inertia). However, if they start pushing ads on Pros subscribers I'm out. The service has really taken a worse in the past couple of months. Bugs are creeping up more and more, suggestions from the community are getting ignored, removing popular models (e.g. Claude Opus), the interface has stagnated etc.
- theappsecguy 2y agoInsane to pay that amount from what I seen. I had a free 6 months trial and got almost no value from it tbh
- mplewis 2y agoAre they still charging 5x per click compared to the real search engines?
- alangibson 2y agoDear Perplexity, We've seen this all before. We know what VC funding inevitably leads to, and we know what Enshittification is. You're just too late to the game.
- rednafi 2y agoEnshittification begins.
- ryandvm 2y agoFucking gross. The industrial advertising complex needs to die. Advertising supported business models are the root of so many of our problems. It's turned news into ragebait political bubble machines. It's why we have an epidemic of screen addiction and social isolation. They spy on us and sell our weaknesses to the highest bidder. Drug companies literally spend more on advertising than actually developing drugs. Billboards clutter up the landscapes and digital ads litter all our screens. It is a blight on humanity and future generations are going to look back on us with the deepest pity on how we voluntarily did this to ourselves just to not pay for anything (directly).
- thfuran 2y agoIt's not going anywhere without being legally banished, and of the two major parties in the US, one is fairly pro-corporate and the other is anti-regulation. I don't think there's going to be improvement here in the US in the near future. But I do think advertising should be almost entirely disallowed.
- lancesells 2y ago> It's why we have an epidemic of screen addiction and social isolation. Advertising isn't why this happens. Massive greed, immoral behavior, and natural human behavior to be entertained and distracted is why you get screen addiction. Netflix changing it's model to ads based is because they make more money that way, not because viewers get more addicted from ads. Meta makes an absurd profit every quarter but two years from now they'll inject more ads into your feed to make more profit. Corporations have record profits and record stock prices, and then fire thousands of people only to get rewarded with their stock price going up. The entire system is just set up wrong. And IMO Perplexity is fucking gross way more than advertising.
- AlexandrB 2y agoAds kind of are the reason though. Algorithmic feeds are found in every social media product because they create nearly infinite ad space "inventory". If your feed was limited to stuff people you know post you could spend an hour, read it all, and be done for a while. But if you're not "engaged" you're not viewing ads. Metrics like "eyeballs" and "engagement" are important to social media products because they're proxies for the quality and quantity of ad space inventory you can sell to advertisers.
- MisterBiggs 2y agoThe incentive to sell something completely undermines the ability to give you the best information. Floating sponsored links to the top is one thing but telling an AI this is the link the user should click is going to ruin the whole thing.
- contagiousflow 2y agoJust wait until we have AI agents finding optimizing for click through rates.
- euroderf 2y agoThat will free up the best technical minds of our generation to apply themselves to some _other_ socially useless application.
- nicce 2y agoIt is already happening outside of LLMs. It is just so sophisticated that we don't notice it. Actually, you can already notice it in many news sites. The either provide different titles for different userbases/ or change it globally few times for everyone and then they settle for the title which got the most clicks. I am confident that the title content is not managed by the human anymore. Just reviewed.
- shwouchk 2y agowe have that. it’s called ads
- DataDaemon 2y ago1. Rewrite someone's copyright content. 2. Put Ads. 3. Profit.
- sourcepluck 2y agoI call time-out, exodus, boycott, I mean, when do we stop following these companies down the garden path. "We weren't making enough money, so we have to destroy any good in the service we were providing and hope that enough people are apathetic enough to accept that shit and that we make more profit?" -- that's not your only option! Anyway, this is hot air, the problem stems from the structure of the internet, and the answer is in new types of networks with different rules. GNUnet, Freenet, IPFS, Autonomi, something else, there's loads of effort going into it. I hope something compelling emerges soon.
- AlexandrB 2y agoWell, here we go. Will be interesting to see how "enshittification" of AI products plays out compared to Web 2.0.
- openrisk 2y agoIf one of the most important innovations in tech in recent times cannot support itself without ads what is the future of tech (and why?)
- anonzzzies 2y agoThat's why I do want everything open ; in the end these companies will end up like all of them. Pay per month, still get ads, service declining and that until they disappear. It seems with Qwen en Llama and cheap storage, we can build similar experiences already/soon.
- ahaucnx 2y agoAsking for feedback from the community but not directly indicating how this feedback can be submitted sounds to me insincere and probably just PR speech.
- qbantek 2y agoAnd that's how it all starts...
- nojvek 2y agoHa! That’s what Google said to themselves when they were getting started with ads. It’s a way for us to sustain our business but not compromise on our principles. Give it a few more years, every company needs to show ARR growth. How are you going to show that growth without resorting to ads in search results?