8 ms·
Visual Basic 6 rebuilt in C# – complete with form designer and IDE in browser
- anonzzzies 2y agoVery nicely done, now a Delphi and I can finally be happy about the state of development again. Sourcecode: https://github.com/BAndysc/AvaloniaVisualBasic6 https://github.com/BAndysc/AvaloniaVisualBasic6 Edit: someone information about Lazarus deleted their comment, my answer; I know about Lazarus yes; I use it for my old projects. I would like a modern version that also works in-browser and .NET seems good for that as this shows. Maybe based on this https://pascalabc.net/en/ https://pascalabc.net/en/ . Not kidding; I still enjoy Pascal/Lazarus (and common lisp) programming more than anything current; none of the anxiety and all of the joy and productivity.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- merb 2y agoJust because you can use some technology in .net on the client and inside the browser does not mean you should. Most of the time these frameworks have huge tradeoffs and once you are using it, you will quickly be locked in. I.e it’s way easier to migrate from mvc to mvc than from webforms to blazor/avaloniaui/dotvvm
- EasyMark 2y agoNeeds more Turbo Pascal/C++
- Tistron 2y agoI can't get it to actually do anything, is it supposed to work to run programs in the browser? (mac, chrome)
- Tistron 2y agoturns out I had a typo and it doesn't report errors as far as I can tell
- slfnflctd 2y agoMaybe you need to explicitly capture the errors to view the error number and/or message in a message box or something? I have no idea, just guessing based on some prior VBA work I did.
- bandysc 2y agoSyntax Errors reporting was missing indeed, but I just added it now and it would show a message box (while you write the code)
- Closi 2y agoIt does! Drag some controls onto the form and hit the play button.
- thom 2y agoEvent handlers don't seem to run (I couldn't get the simplest MsgBox to work, at least). Is the actual language implemented?
- jmkni 2y agoThey're working for me Drag a button, double click, MsgBox "hello" in the event handler, hit play
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mrweasel 2y agoSame issue here, I add UI elements just fine, double click and generate the event handlers, but nothing runs.
- bandysc 2y agoHey, author here, only a subset of VB6 language is implemented, I also didn't implement all properties and events, i.e. the Click event on labels. Updated the website with all basic events. Considering how much response this project got, I might improve the VB6 interpreter :)
- PaulRobinson 2y agoSay what you like about Visual Basic (and a lot has been said that is less than complimentary), but for a huge number of people and workplaces this was the tool that moved people from trying to fudge Excel or Access into a workflow and actually trying to write some software. My first language was BASIC on 8-bit machines (actually, it may have technically been Logo on a BBC, but I remember BASIC on a BBC as an 11 year old more clearly), and by the time VB came along I'd moved onto compiled languages like C and interpreted languages like Perl and PHP, and was a bit sniffy about the point and click nature of it all. I had one friend at college who refused to move on from QBASIC - I once saw him write a 3D game engine in that could about 30 frames _an hour_ on a Pentium - and the general atmosphere of being pro-FLOSS/anti-MS, plus a ton of really badly written apps encountered out in the wild when I did some small business IT consultancy made me very averse to VB in general. But you know, it wasn't the fault of the environment or the language. It was powerful, useful and better than the alternatives for a lot of people. Its main contemporary competitor - Delphi - seemed all the rage before it didn't. And I now wish we'd been able to get a little more down the simpler visual programming domain for a while, because the modern equivalents like XCode feel massively confusing to the novice, so the learning curve feels very steep by comparison.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- netdevnet 2y ago> a ton of really badly written apps encountered out in the wild when I did some small business IT consultancy made me very averse to VB in general. A lot of VB has been historically written by people who had no background in writing software. They were jack of all trades, needed some quick and dirty and they learned just enough to have some working code
- PaulRobinson 2y agoThis might be classic "that's not a bug, it's a feature", territory. I love the idea that somebody could just get something working - it is fantastic that was possible, and a shame that we've lost it a bit. The fact that a professional might look at the code produced and die a little inside is where a lot of bad rep comes from, but hey, working software is better than no software, particularly in the days when that software probably is running on a single machine that is not connected to the internet, and when it is, it's only connected a couple of hours a day via dial-up modem.
- newsclues 2y agoI miss VB 6, because it was so easy to teach people how programming works as the visual nature was very intuitive. I have felt for a long time a modern version would be so useful.
- qingcharles 2y agoYou can do the exact same thing, with a nearly 100% exact user interface in the latest version of Visual Studio 2022 that came out yesterday. I've been building desktop apps like this for 30 years. I still build them every day and the designer looks no different today.
- newsclues 2y agoI did not know that, thank you. I guess the windows pc I have won’t be exclusively for gaming anymore!
- evrimoztamur 2y agoVB6 is how I got really started off with programming and building games. There were project files you could find online of games made in VB6 of such immense complexity (one was an 'MMORPG' with networking, file save/load and data serialisation via RTF blocks, etc.) that it made my head spin. I don't know if I would have gotten into programming at such a young age otherwise.
- chamakits 2y agoAre you by any chance talking about Mirage online (and it’s many other servers)? I remember loving that game (or the Jerrath Online server anyways) and being amazed by it. I knew enough about computers to know it was programmed in VB 6, but not enough to actually code. But the desire to eventually make something like it definitely had to do with my interest in coding later on.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mavamaarten 2y agoWhoa. VB6 was totally what got me into software development as a kid. A blast from the past I needed today, thanks.
- VBprogrammer 2y agoSame. A pirate copy of VB6 and a download of some website which gave a reasonable introduction of how to do things. I remember doing things like using the Win32 API to get DMA to images so I could do pixel perfect collision detection between sprites etc. Fun times.
- chii 2y ago> A pirate copy of VB6 exactly how i did it as well! But it was a pirated copy of visual studio (6?) and it came in 6 CDs. I had no idea what it actually was, and just installed it and played around. I'm so glad that i bought those pirated CDs off the street - it was a huge stack of disks for like $50 bucks, and it included a bunch of pirated games, pirated encyclopedia (brittanica at the time iirc), various music software (cakewalk pro, not that i ever used it). There would not have been a chance in hell i'd discover these things by myself.
- mobilio 2y ago6 CDs because VS6 comes with 3 CDs and 3CDs for MSDN. But later they switched to new format of MSDN and old IDEs can't use them. And there was some add-on that allow to old IDEs to use new MSDN format.
- acjohnson55 2y agoI have a very similar memory, building a Spacewar-type game and experimenting with low level stuff to try to get things flicker-free
- sph 2y agoSame. But it didn't take me long, with the exuberance of youth, to declare BASIC a worthless language, and then moved to MS Visual C++ 6. C++ and MFC was worse for different reasons, but then I discovered Linux and the rest is history. Still, haven't found anything as powerful as VB6's RAD. These days we lay out UIs by hand or by writing XML, like absolute cavemen.
- codetiger 2y agoThis reminds me of one of the best programming tools at the time. Moving from basic to vs basic was mind blowing. I still miss such tools in the Modern era. There are lot of so called no-code or low-code tools that does things very differently today. I still think the best low-code is what VB did.
- oaiey 2y agoAnd honestly, with the reactive programming approach ... a related UX for IDE should not be that hard either. I think most framework developers unfortunately forget productivity as a key metric. Might be a bit unfair however, the lack of visual tools is disappointing.
- qwertox 2y agoThe issue today is that developers would create their own framework, most likely something TypeScript-based running in Node or Deno or some Rust-based thing like Tauri, which all might be OK, but with their own opinionated UI styleguides and features, where then half of the native OS functionality then won't work. You see a somewhat related degeneration in Redmond, where the new Windows Explorer doesn't have an icon in the address bar which is actually draggable so that a shortcut to the currently open folder can be created on the desktop or anywhere where such a shortcut can be used (think TrueLaunchBar). Now you have to go to the parent folder in order to Alt-Drag the folder to create a shortcut. It's those little things which where smartly developed during the 80s and 90s, which "modern" developers seem not to have noticed and therefore just ignored while re-implementing applications like the Windows Explorer.
- ryandrake 2y agoThere are so many Chesterson's Fences[1] being destroyed with modern UX design. Everyone just wants to change things for change's sake. Or worse, to simply have another piece of unique artwork for one's portfolio. Whenever I've tried to push back on Yet Another Big UI Design, the reasons for doing it are always so vague: Our current product looks "dated." It's not "fresh." Competitors' products look "sleeker." We're using "outdated" design language. So we overhaul the application, throwing years of know-how and bugfixes away in all the refactoring. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Chesterton%27s_fence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Chesterton%27s_fence
- ben_w 2y agoOh, interesting. I should see if I can get my 22 year old coursework running in it. Assuming I can get my source out of the Word document, because it predates git and I don't have the original source files: https://github.com/BenWheatley/A2-coursework https://github.com/BenWheatley/A2-coursework
- throwaway2037 2y agoIt seems like you can write VBA to extract stuff from Microsoft Office files. It might be worth a try. Here is what I found: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/49724/programmatically-extract-macro-vba-code-from-word-2007-docs https://stackoverflow.com/questions/49724/programmatically-e...
- ben_w 2y agoThe code in this case is plain text within the word doc — the hard part is that I don't have a copy of Word from 2002-ish (I don't know the specific Office version my teachers used), and it's spread over 261 pages because I was having too much fun writing it. ChatGPT can probably do it, but my experience is that it starts hallucinating well before you'd expect from the context length.
- gus_massa 2y agoIf you can't open it in a modern Office install, Microsoft used to have the option to download input filters for old and unusual formats.
- boo-ga-ga 2y agoImmediately after seeing the page, got "oh, those were the times" feeling. Really great.
- stef-13013 2y agoWow, really nice !! And very interesting project too... Thanks !
- bdcravens 2y agoAfter going to Help > Avalonia on the Web, the UI stopped responding
- Gys 2y agoPage is not loading in Firefox 132.0.1 on MacOS Intel 15.1? Edit: no, it just takes a loooooong time to load
- mihaaly 2y agoTrue
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ladyanita22 2y agoI see lots of comments about how good VB6 was. I agree it made programming super-easy and practical. However, it is evident to me how the whole thing fell appart by the late 2000's, and now we have much more powerful, yet complex programming environments: - Rust, C, C++: Extremely complex but powerful. - HTML, JS, CSS: You have to learn 3 different technologies and won't be able to leverage the easy, powerful native APIs the OS provides. It's cross-platform though. - .net: Not as easy as VB6 (and C# becomes actually more and more complex, more powerful as well, though). You have to learn XAML as WinForms is still a thing but considered legacy. - Python: Easy (maybe more than VB, but not by much?), but no native, easy GUI toolkit for Windows. There are native bindings for GTK, but Linux is not a big desktop platform, and more so in business, and still GTK is much, much more complex than VB6 + Winforms + COM. So basically, it seems we have traded easy of use and practicality for power/performance and cross-platform compatibility? What do you guys think?
- mft_ 2y agoI often muse over there not being a VB-alike approach for Python. It would surely be reasonably straightforward to automate the creation of the GUI boilerplate code from a form designer, and then within an accompanying IDE hide most of that code from the user, only making the specific parts visible that correlate with different UI interactions?
- dinkblam 2y ago> creation of the GUI boilerplate code from a form designer why? i think the approach of of the form designer generating code instead of generating serialized objects that your code interacts with at runtime is a serious flaw. java got it wrong, cocoa got it right there.
- mft_ 2y agoI guess because that seems the path of least resistance within the existing Python world.
- scrlk 2y ago
- mihaaly 2y agoIs this supposed to work? It does not for me. Probabbly my privacy settings are prohibitive for it? And why is this mania putting everything into the browser that does not belong there? Is the reason putting there is just to have it there? Why not desktop app? Any sensible reason? Is it for pepole not owning a computer and have to fly from borrowed one to borrowed one where only the browser access is stable for them? So many things are particular with browsers for the purpose navigating the web or other source of information that it negatively interferes with usability for generic purpose app if not running the extra miles to get a workaround for it (and most do not care to run the extra miles). Pushing the wrong button in the browser f.s up something and others are cumbersome too, back utton, refresh, context menus, working with files, mixed with anything else in the tabs, even the address bar is in the way, etc. The few sensible web apps were either narrow use trivial ones doing a simple task thing mostly accessing a client service (human client) or put into a thin client (now its a computer) for clarity. Not user friendly at all. But hey, today's computer "engineers" give no fuck for the user but all for the technology, we all must enjoy that! (No)
- worble 2y agoIt's written in Avalonia so you could easily compile a desktop version if you wanted, although the author doesn't package one explicitly https://avaloniaui.net/ https://avaloniaui.net/ https://github.com/BAndysc/AvaloniaVisualBasic6 https://github.com/BAndysc/AvaloniaVisualBasic6
- mikescandy 2y agoYou completely missed the fact that this is built using Avalonia, which means that you can run this on desktop (win, linux, osx), mobile (android or ios) AND browser (using wasm) with almost the same codebase. check https://github.com/BAndysc/AvaloniaVisualBasic6 https://github.com/BAndysc/AvaloniaVisualBasic6, and feel free to try the desktop ones.
- mihaaly 2y agoThe second part was an adjacent complain about the generic trend of putting things to the web too much. As it is obvious. It wasn't about this very project (the "putting everything" =/= 'putting Avalonia based Visual Basic 6', obviously, even the 'everything' is a rhetoric expression here used widespread in generic discussions and not a literal 100%, obviously). Please review it carefully this time, thanks.
- hexo 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- JawsOfALion 2y agoLol, that's amazing, as soon as it loaded up i was laughing at how accurate it was . So many memories from simpler times coding as a kid.
- zerr 2y agoVisual FoxPro as well, please :)
- lawgimenez 2y agoMy college thesis was writing complete inventory management using VB6, then making sure the program works inside the company. Good times!
- worble 2y agoPerusing the authors Github, it looks like they also maintain the UI library for the classic Win9x look and feel: https://github.com/BAndysc/Classic.Avalonia https://github.com/BAndysc/Classic.Avalonia I love it, I might have to try making my own app using it
- jeroenhd 2y agoIMO that library is worth a submission as much as the VB6 recreation! The attention to detail is excellent, it makes me want to dive into Avalonia again.
- bandysc 2y agoAuthor of the demo and library here, thank you for kind words, this was my goal to achieve almost pixel perfect recreation of the original GUI (which is sometimes not very easy as some components look slightly different in different programs, I meant small differences in buttons sizes, paddings, etc.).
- stavros 2y agoA piece of feedback: The maximized MDI windows did not keep their border, AFAIK.
- pcdoodle 2y agoVB6 was the best IDE by far for people that get things done right now. I was installing PC based CCTV systems for a living back in mid 2000s, I had a restaurant customer have their mind blown by pandoras music service while demoing the PC. They asked "can I hear this over the restaurant speakers?". Yeah, I got 3.5mm to RCA to BNC in the car which I can run to your AMP. Now he was really happy, felt like he got launched into the 21st century. "Can I pause the music and make an announcement to my customers?". I made him a shortcut on the desktop to sndvol32.exe aka sound mixer so he can talk over the speakers and then resume the music and he was again floored. "I want my staff to be able to do this but not here in my office but at the front counter". Easy. "Give me a paper clip and 30 minutes". Went to the car to grab some stranded Cat 5 and an old beige two button IBM mouse. Ran the cables from the office to the reception area, soldered a cat-5 pair to the left mouse clicker, drove a sheetrock screw threw the mouse body to mount it on the wall like a taxidermied deer head. Back in the office I soldered the leads to the paper clip so I could have a solid connection to the LPT port on the PC (I didn't carry DB-25 back then). It was easy from there: googled "VB6 Volume Mixer". Download that, open the checkbox for mute stereo mix, copy one liner into a timer, set interval for 100ms, check if the pins on the LPT are shorted, if so mute stereo mix, unmute the mic. This was written in the field without any pre planning. I still have this customer to this day. What a great tool for us "jacks of all trades".
- meowster 2y agoI'm pretty sure I read a reddit comment a few years ago where someone said they were a customer in a resturant, and they saw resturant employees click on a mouse attached to the wall to make an announcements (I think notify that an order was ready). It sounds like a very unique setup, so it was probably this one!
- rapind 2y agoI love VB6 too, but what you've described is only 10% VB6 and 90% MacGyver. The Phoenix Foundation needs you.
- CRConrad 2y ago> VB6 was the best IDE by far for people that get things done right now. No, it was second-best. The best was Delphi. (And now possibly Lazarus.)
- tester756 2y agoWow.
- dxroshan 2y agoSo cooool!
- gramakri2 2y agoOh the memories. How does this work? Is it built using an emulator of old VB6 code ? (didn't realize it was opensource) . Or is everything built from scratch?
- v1ne 2y agoOMG, this is how I started programming. I was so happy creating small helpers with this toolchain, e.g. something like Spotlight to launch programs with with a hotkey + the name of the program, on Windows 98.
- stavros 2y agoThis is amazing. I love the nostalgia, it made my day.
- netsharc 2y agoHaha, it hit me with a tinge of pain that I probably saw the screen (the original one) a lot, thinking "Today is the day I learn VB6!", but I never got proficient with VB6. Oh well, I still managed to have a career in IT, so...
- gus_massa 2y agoNice! Small bug report: I added a button and double clicked it to open the code window. I added something simple like MsgBox "Hello" and clicked the x on the top right of the code window. The code was not saved. You have to "Save" the project or "Run" the project for the code to be updated. This is a difference with the old VB IDE that remembers everything you type.
- woodylondon 2y agoI started in Visual Basic 3 and then moved to Delphi. My first job at 18 was working for one of the large ActiveX component libraries, providing technical support to many developers when I wasn't one myself yet! On my first day, I found a book on my desk—"Learn Visual Basic 3 in 21 Days"—along with a brand new 486DX250 and a 14" monitor. I learned a lot quickly! We answered support queries by fax back then. I never fully understood why this programming paradigm died off. Building business apps beyond Access or Excel was so straightforward. It was great to get an .EXE that you could package up with InstallShield or Wise Solutions and send to anyone. I guess the web came soon after, and trying to do WYSIWYG for HTML and CSS has never gone well—even today. FrontPage came out but died soon after, and mixing desktop apps with web apps was never great. Today, I feel .NET is overly complex and much harder for beginners compared to the old days. Sometimes, I think there are only so many ways to control the appearance of business apps. I'd constrain visuals but provide the most straightforward visual builder possible. The No-Code world is fascinating, and the best I've seen in this space is https://retool.com/ https://retool.com/, but it's expensive and locks you into their ecosystem. Even today, small businesses need to build out simple apps that were simple to do back in the Visual Basic days—a stock control system, a basic support system, sales tools, etc. Today, it's a minefield of options that can quickly get expensive. I'd love to have a visual builder that creates code you can host yourself — something like retool.com but with open source and self-hosting, or maybe I'm just too old for this now! :)
- InsideOutSanta 2y agoI think one aspect is that business requirements for many of these apps became more complex, which is why we now often use process management or case management tools instead of smaller local programs.
- woodylondon 2y agoAgreed, a fair point - companies are a lot more aware of what is possible beyond a spreadsheet! :)
- 2y ago
- rqtwteye 2y agoI remember in the 90s a lot of small companies ran on VB and Access. It really enabled a lot of non programmers. Wish we had something similar for the web. Some low code solutions are superficially similar but what made VB different was that you could grow into full blown apps without changing. I am always amazed how complex today's web CRUD apps are to develop and deploy.
- api 2y agoThe web is a really terrible platform for apps. It's so popular for two reasons: (1) No installation, and no need to deal with OS packaging because all our OSes are horrible. (2) SaaS is DRM -- host software in the cloud and it can't be pirated and you can easily charge monthly rent. A third I guess is that it makes collaborative features easier to build, but that only applies to some software.
- scarface_74 2y ago(3) you can’t run a Windows app on your phone. (4) The world isn’t Windows only anymore.
- anthk 2y agoCheck Androwish for something being able to run under Android and PC. A quick example: https://jxself.org/git/?p=inform.git;a=summary https://jxself.org/git/?p=inform.git;a=summary You can create an APK if you head to the AndroWish home page and read the instructions.
- scarface_74 2y agoThat doesn’t help when 70% of phones in the US are iPhones and even a higher percentage of upper income earners are iPhones. It also doesn’t help with Macs
- datavirtue 2y agoPowerApps. Built into Office365.
- mysterydip 2y agoI was so productive in VB5/6 back in the late 90s/early 00s. I made tons of utility apps to solve all kinds of little problems. It was just so easy to put things together. I tried to make the transition to vb.net but it was not the same thing.
- iask 2y agoIt was rad!
- EasyMark 2y agoI know the feeling, I was the go to VB6 guy in college for writing test automation on equipment over GPIB, UART, RS422, etc. I made bank as a grad student from the EE department, I quit my TA position and they replaced me as instrumentation guy :) . Paid for my masters for the most part.
- qingcharles 2y agoThe VB6 Winforms builder here is almost 100% identical to the Winforms builder in the latest release of Visual Studio 2022 that came out today. I use it for hours every day to just drag and drop a few components onto a form and add some logic and have a little desktop app up and running in a few minutes. I (sadly) code in C# since 2021, because the support is better, but I honestly believe VB.NET was superior because of the increased readability of the code.
- fuzztester 2y agosounds cool. can you give a few examples of such apps that you created? i have used VB in the past too, v4 and 5, and even a free v2 copy that I got from the net long back. but mainly did business apps with them. see the History section here: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visual_Basic_(classic) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visual_Basic_(classic)
- andrea76 2y agoI miss those times. Every IDE had a line by line debugger. Now those Angular/React applications, even after years, do not have one; and they still have a confusing syntax.
- skydhash 2y agoWhat is written and what is actually running is so different that it’s better to think of SPAs as a different language. Firefox have a decent debugger for javascript which works well when the build tool output sourcemaps.
- robertlagrant 2y agoI hadn't thought about it like this, but you're right. React has decent browser plug-in tools, but it is still painful to get things back to the IDE.
- jeroenhd 2y agoMy experience with IntelliJ + a bunch of JS frameworks is that IDE-based browser debugging works quite well. Unfortunately, Firefox' remote debugging capabilities broke for me at some point, but adding a Chromium debug target in my IDE seems to work most of the time. As long as the Rube Goldberg machine that does JS transpilation includes a source map, frameworks just seem to work out of the box (as does raw JS, but that's not so common anymore). That even includes debugging some languages compiled to WASM, like C#, interestingly enough.
- a1o 2y agoSite doesn't load for me other than the powdered by avalonia message, on Safari.
- nekitamo 2y agoIt takes a while to load on a slow connection, but then it works fine on my iPhone (IOS 18). This is an incredibly impressive demo of what Avalonia is capable of.
- wg0 2y agoThis is amazing... I am much away from .NET world so can someone elaborate how does it get from C# to browser? All I see is this main.js[0] and everything is drawn on a canvas! (probably explains why text is not as sharp as I remember back in the day) [0]. https://bandysc.github.io/AvaloniaVisualBasic6/main.js https://bandysc.github.io/AvaloniaVisualBasic6/main.js
- af78 2y agoThey seem to be using this framework: https://github.com/AvaloniaUI/Avalonia https://github.com/AvaloniaUI/Avalonia Avalonia aims at compatibility with Windows Presentation Framework (WPF) XAML. The web platform is explicitly supported: https://avaloniaui.net/platforms#wasm https://avaloniaui.net/platforms#wasm. The VB Form model must be implemented on top of this. This is for the UI part. Now for the code part, the dotnet toolchain has supported WebAssembly (wasm) generation for some time: https://devblogs.microsoft.com/dotnet/extending-web-assembly-to-the-cloud/ https://devblogs.microsoft.com/dotnet/extending-web-assembly... I suppose the C# code is translated to MSIL then wasm.
- pjc50 2y agoThere's a bootstrap loader at https://bandysc.github.io/AvaloniaVisualBasic6/_framework/dotnet.js https://bandysc.github.io/AvaloniaVisualBasic6/_framework/do... which downloads the application, which has been compiled to WASM, and the dotnet runtime. Which is why it takes so many seconds to first page view. The Avalonia framework is a third party UI toolkit.
- jeroenhd 2y ago> Which is why it takes so many seconds to first page view I'm seeing a long load time in Firefox but in Chromium, loading takes maybe a second. Loading the entire .NET runtime isn't exactly lightweight, but it seems there's also some kind of browser engine problem in my Firefox setup that slows this page down artificially. I must say I'm impressed that this approach even works with only 16MiB of data transferred over the line (though that 16MiB decompresses to about 50MiB).
- Thorrez 2y ago
- DeathArrow 2y agoI miss RAD tools. I never played with Visual Basic but I enjoyed Borland C++ builder.
- dark-star 2y agoThis is at most something lat "looks like" Visual Basic 6. Most of the actual functionality is not there. - ActiveX and custom controls? Not available - Debugging/Single-Stepping? Nope - Add-Ins? negative - Also, many of the menu items just don't do anything when clicked on, or they open a dialog where everything is greyed-out I mean, yeah, it's cute for someone who has never seen how VB6 looked like... But calling it "rebuilt in c#" is stretching it a bit...
- XajniN 2y agoYou must be fun at parties
- major505 2y agois 2024 and I still maintain a VB6 project. A client of mine (a aluminiun metalurgic compoany from sweeden) have all his machines controled but a central program in vb6. Since the machines are all old, they have integrations using windows COM+ protocol. Its a offline application, that connects to SAP exchanging text files, so they have no reason to update so something more modern.
- eppp 2y agoNot being able to replace hardware easily seems like a disaster in waiting.
- EvanAnderson 2y agoRunning old versions of Windows in emulation or virtualization is really easy.
- eppp 2y agoActivating it isnt. I havent found a way to make the old version worth without installing some hacked fix that I have no idea if I can trust or not.
- EvanAnderson 2y agoWindows 2000 was the sweet spot for that, for sure. A volume license version of Windows XP will activate without any "mothership" to talk to, as well.
- major505 2y agoThey use an old offline machine with winxp to run stuff in factory. But they are replacing for virtualmachines now that the old hardware is dying. other than that, it runs really well. Sometimes, months without rebooting.
- benguild 2y agoThis is the kind of content I am here for
- jillesvangurp 2y agoBasically this is what Figma could be if you could add behavior to the UI. Somehow the web has been running backwards for years now. We lost flash in favor of HTML 5, which sort of fizzled out in terms of creative people actually doing a lot with it. We used to have simple application builders in IDEs like Visual Basic, Delphi, Borland JBuilder. Even Eclipse had a simple swing UI builder thing for a while. For the web we had dream weaver, frontpage, etc. I'm not saying those tools were perfect; because they weren't. But we never really got good substitutes for them. We now have people "designing" stuff in Figma and then handing over for implementation to some developer team that essentially then recreates the whole thing pretty much from scratch. There's something deeply stupid/wasteful about needing to do that.
- itslennysfault 2y ago> I'm not saying those tools were perfect Bite your tongue. Flash was perfect.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- robertlagrant 2y ago> We now have people "designing" stuff in Figma and then handing over for implementation to some developer team that essentially then recreates the whole thing pretty much from scratch. There's something deeply stupid/wasteful about needing to do that. I'm not sure how wasteful it is really. There is some overlap, but not loads in my experience. Most of the time spent on frontend is the stuff behind the components: behaviour; device interaction; security; API calls.
- ben_w 2y agoI've had a weirdly large fraction of my career spent on making UI rather than business logic. That said, the business logic in apps is, half the time, a needlessly complex shim on what is ultimately "here's a REST API you can do in one or two lines via `Codable` etc. except we're anticipating needing to support several API providers… oh no the money ran out".
- nirav72 2y agoI feel like the complexity around current day .Net is more due to Microsoft’s pathetic attempt at naming and branding and the confusion around their development products. One example is their desktop development frameworks. As someone that is in and out of Microsoft centric development stacks - I can't even keep up with it anymore.
- gotstad 2y agoI owe my whole fascination with programming from childhood to Visual Basic 6. I was 11 and I could hardly read English, yet VB6 with the WYSIWYG-editor and an introductory book by my side was intuitive and rewarding enough for me to learn the basics of programming.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- zubairq 2y agoAs someone building a JS type low code tool (yazz.com) which is also open source I am very impressed. Well done!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- robertlagrant 2y agoMy first bit of paid programming work was a VB6 project in 2001. Such happy times!
- vlugovsky 2y agoThis reminds me of Bindows framework. Seeing Windows interface in browser is hard to forget.
- ninalanyon 2y agoWhat I really want is a form designer that would let me create a UI for any language instead of every language reinventing it.
- SaintSeiya 2y agoOne nice side effect of having GUI builders in the IDE was standarized, optimized and "follow best practices" GUIs. No wonder we reached peak UI in the 90's-2000. Then came the web and everyone and their mom had an opinion on how a button should look (for games that's fine) and we ended up here.
- rcarmo 2y agoI want a desktop version of this that runs on Mac and Linux.
- bandysc 2y agoIt runs on Mac and Linux! https://github.com/BAndysc/AvaloniaVisualBasic6 https://github.com/BAndysc/AvaloniaVisualBasic6 It even supports dotnet's NativeAOT, meaning you can get a native x64/arm64 binary!
- rcarmo 2y agoI sometimes wonder if something like this using Lua wouldn’t be a great way to quickly build native desktop apps.
- _0xdd 2y agoAhhh... first programming language I ever played with was VB3 and VB4 writing 'proggies' to knock other AOL users offline. Good times!
- hnthrowaway0328 2y agoI actually think QT is not too bad for small applications too. I wrote a Quake launcher over a few days because I was so tired of finding my Quake executable and setting the same configurations every time I load a mod. I knew zero about QT back then so someone could write it in an afternoon. I think it definitely can be used equally easy for something bigger, e.g. a frontend of a lc-3 VM.
- msephton 2y agoReally cool! Makes me weep that most web apps today have a mere fraction of this kind of depth and functionality.