8 ms·
NASA remains silent on why crew went to hospital after dragon splashdown
- squircle 2y agoAndromeda strain on the one hand; gravity sucks on the other. There must be a psychological/neurological toll, like wearing prismatic glasses that invert your vision until the mind adjusts.
- andrewstuart 2y ago>> Andromeda strain Can't see why it wouldn't be.
- metalman 2y ago[flagged]
- not_a_bot_4sho 2y agoNASA: Space flight is still something we don’t fully understand, we’re finding things that we don’t expect sometimes. This was one of those times, and we’re still piecing things together on this and so to maintain medical privacy and to let our processes go forward in an orderly manner, this is all we’re going to say about that event at this time Gizmodo: fuck their privacy!!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- meowster 2y agoGizmodo used to be owned by Gawker which went bankrupt due to a lawsuit brought on because they didn't care about a famous person's privacy. So this seems par for the course.
- FireBeyond 2y agoGawker went bankrupt, because a public figure who felt that he was outed failed to win a lawsuit against them, so bankrolled someone else's lawsuit, with many questions unanswered. Public figure, because Courts have ruled that billionaires are public figures due to their "outsized influence on government and public policy". Outed by Gawker, despite his social media at the time regularly featuring photos of him shirtless on gay cruises. Good for him, but "outed" was a bit of a stretch. I have many issues, not with Hogan's lawsuit, but Thiel's bankrolling of it: Hogan had already reached a tentative deal with Gawker, including a percentage of profits and partial ownership. When Thiel's paying the bills, and some of attorneys are in his full-time employ, whose interests are actually primary in their mind, versus whose should be? After his lawyers became involved, Hogan then asked for 5,000 times more, including damages that are pretty hard to account for: Economic losses (financial loss, to be clear, NOT "emotional distreess", which they asked for separately) of $50M due to the damage of the videos release being publicized (because Gawker didn't release it, someone else did, and Hogan had settled with them for 1/1000th of what he wanted from Gawker)... Hogan's career earnings were $15M, and his net worth at its highest was $30M, and at the time of the lawsuit, $8M. Wrestlemania would typically pay about $150K. Obviously Hogan has endorsements, but I would love to see how the fifty million number was arrived at... endorsements for hair products, and WWF reruns? The reason I asked about lawyers and motives, because after all this was settled, Hogan/Thiel's lawyers told him to drop just one of the claims, specifically the one that would have had Gawker's insurance pay out... ... in other words, having had a deal for part ownership of the company, Hogan threw that away and asked for far more in questionable damages, and then when awarded them, then dropped the only claim that would actually have allowed him to see any real portion of those damages. I wonder how much Thiel paid Hogan under the table. And I thought a tenet of law / justice was being able to face your accuser, not to have them launch/finance puppet lawsuits against you.
- dotBen 2y agoJD Vance is a protege of Peter Thiel and Peter Thiel his heavily involved behind the scenes in the Donald Trump campaign and presumably administration... Which is how you have Hulk Hogan involved in Trump rallies. It all goes back to Gawker...
- giantg2 2y agoIt's likely they will publish their findings once they figure it out. Probably after a considerable time passes to help obfuscate the individuals involved.
- bpodgursky 2y agoRespectfully, I think it's reasonable that the privilege of being an astronaut — there are a thousand times more applicants than astronauts — comes with the tradeoff losing some of the privacy afforded to private citizens. It costs NASA (and to be blunt about it, taxpayers) an extraordinary amount of money to put each astronaut in space. The fact is, there have been fewer than a thousand people in space in all of history. Each illness, sickness, even basic health vitals is in a sense invaluable taxpayer-funded science, and if you don't want your health to be in the public domain, there are a lot of other jobs available (or, now that we have SpaceX, you could take a private rather than government flight) I'm not saying NASA should be publishing a livestream at the hospital, but I do think there's a reasonable expectation that NASA will release the health issues in a respectful but informative way to the public.
- andrewjf 2y agoNASAs entire budget is 0.47% of the national budget in 2020. Spare me. Space travel is worth it.
- bpodgursky 2y agoI don't think you really read what I wrote.
- sim7c00 2y agothere are lots of places taxoayer pay for which never see the light of day. i thimk ultimately though, this is not atall about that. they have very lenghty projects to get to root causes of issues. before such a project is fully completed and signed off on, they will not sah a word. before they have all the answers, you will get none. places of science -generally- work like this. no poitin bringing out incomplete information or uncertainties especially in siluch a place which faces a lot of public scruitiny.
- peutetre 2y ago> now that we have SpaceX You don't have SpaceX. It's a private company. Soon you might not have NASA either. As part of his payment for supporting Trump, more and more of NASA and the Department of Defense will be handed to Musk for his profit. Oligarchs always expect to be paid.
- latchkey 2y agoJust a wild guess without anything backing it up and to get the guessing party started... something like decompression sickness? edit: love the answers, but would rather party.
- adastra22 2y agoThere was no decompression.
- danparsonson 2y agoDecompression sickness requires breathing air at higher than atmospheric pressure, which you only need to do if the external pressure is high (i.e. when diving - otherwise your muscles would be unable to overcome the pressure difference and you wouldn't be able to breathe).
- aeternum 2y agoMy wild guess is seasickness. It's not supposed to happen to astronauts due to training and such, thus perhaps the unwillingness to say who. But tight quarters, seas were rough. You get the other astronauts checked out also just in case. I really don't have evidence for this though beyond wild speculation.
- tiahura 2y agoThen why scold SpaceX about safety?
- sandworm101 2y agoThey all get space sick. Training helps with the temporary effects of g but no earthly training can prepare one's inner ear and digestive tract for 24/7 weightlessness. It happens to all of them but, conversely, they all get over it in time.
- nradov 2y agoI've never heard of anyone being hospitalized for motion sickness. Symptoms stop quickly once the patient is back stationary on solid ground.
- Animats 2y agoSome people seem to deal with long-term zero-G better than others. The cosmonaut who spent the longest continuous time in space was Valeri Polyakov, who spent 437 days in zero G in the early 1990s, came back fine, had a good career after returning, and recently died at age 80.
- Rastonbury 2y agoMakes me think of the gravity torture scene of people who grew up in low G from The Expanse
- throe738488 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- perihelions 2y agoCould it be an initially-unnoticed chemical leak in the Crew Dragon? That could explain how it hospitalized four astronauts at once, and also why they're uncharacteristically afraid of media coverage. They were evasive in a similar way when Starliner was first having issues—they're scared of the politics, or of the lawyers. edit to add: These spacecraft all use very toxic fuels, and this one has had issues with fuel leaks before [0]. I'm not sure how or if those could affect the crew. Maybe if there was contamination on an exterior surface, they could have been exposed on landing? IIRC it is or used to be standard procedure to take air samples before opening crewed spacecraft, for this reason. edited again to add: I found it! It Apollo-Soyuz in 1975—the entire Apollo crew were poisoned by fuel when they opened the spacecraft, and were hospitalized with chemical pneumonitis [1,2]. [0] https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/06/nasa-delays-cargo-dragon-flight-due-to-a-propellant-issue/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/06/nasa-delays-cargo-dr... ("NASA and SpaceX stand down on Dragon launch to study hydrazine issue") [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo–Soyuz#Re-entry_and_aftermath https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo–Soyuz#Re-entry_and_afte... [2] https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19770023791 https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19770023791 ("The Apollo-Soyuz Test Project: Medical report") - (wiki) "The only serious problem was during reentry and splashdown of the Apollo craft, during which the crew were accidentally exposed to toxic monomethylhydrazine and nitrogen tetroxide fumes, caused by unignited reaction control system (RCS) hypergolic propellants venting from the spacecraft and reentering a cabin air intake. The RCS was inadvertently left on during descent, and the toxic fumes were sucked into the spacecraft as it drew in outside air. Brand briefly lost consciousness, while Stafford retrieved emergency oxygen masks, put one on Brand, and gave one to Slayton. The three astronauts were hospitalized for two weeks in Honolulu, Hawaii.[22] Brand took responsibility for the mishap; because of high noise levels in the cabin during reentry, he believed he was unable to hear Stafford call off one item of the reentry checklist, the closure of two switches which would have automatically shut off the RCS and begun drogue parachute deployment. These procedures were manually performed later than usual, allowing the ingestion of the propellant fumes through the ventilation system.[23]"
- jp_nc 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- MilnerRoute 2y agoOnly one astronaut "experienced a medical issue." The other crew members were also evaluated -- and soon released -- "out of an abundance of caution." (Only one spent the night in the hospital.) https://blogs.nasa.gov/commercialcrew/2024/10/25/nasa-provides-update-on-agencys-spacex-crew-8-health/ https://blogs.nasa.gov/commercialcrew/2024/10/25/nasa-provid... The next day NASA announced "The crew member is in good health and will resume normal post-flight reconditioning with other crew members." https://blogs.nasa.gov/spacestation/2024/10/26/nasas-spacex-crew-8-astronaut-returns-to-houston/ https://blogs.nasa.gov/spacestation/2024/10/26/nasas-spacex-...
- efitz 2y agoMaybe it was an STI and they are embarrassed.
- junon 2y agoThen another member would have to have been tested. They don't just materialize out of thin air. They're also tested for them before they go up, IIRC.
- poundtown 2y agoseems like a normal thing after that long in space. am i missing something?
- wmf 2y agoNo, you're not missing anything. This whole thread is an embarrassment. Space is hard on the body and one of the astronauts wasn't feeling 100% when they came back.
- TechDebtDevin 2y agoThe Russians have literally been saying the guy lost his mind up there months ago...
- henearkr 2y agoMy take is that it could be the excessive vibrations and shocks inside the Dragon ship. Iirc, some Dragon passengers already "semi-complained" about that in the past. Now the NASA probably has agreements with SpaceX discouraging them to speak about that kind of problems.
- cwiz 2y agoPlot twist (thriller/sci-fi) astronauts sent to psychiatric asylum after a) confessing that earth is flat after landing. b) confessing that they landed of different version of Earth they originally departed from c) suggesting that whole time they were in simulation and spacex is fancy alien vr tech d) a new kind of virus affecting gravity particle / waves borked physics in thir legs and they can't walk normally
- throwaway888abc 2y agoThey are here ? Sputnik https://www.imdb.com/title/tt11905962/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt11905962/
- wtcactus 2y agoThey were 8 months in space close to 0G and they just returned to our normal gravity environment. Just think for a moment how hard that is on the human body. I would expect them to go to the hospital right away
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pavlov 2y agoThis is exactly the kind of headline that would appear 20 minutes into a B-rate sci-fi movie. As we approach Act II, an intrepid young journalist rushes to the hospital to find out what’s really going on… But wait, who is in the black car trailing her?
- christophilus 2y agoI’d watch that one. Also, I miss the x-files.
- wozer 2y agoReminds me of the Apple TV show "Constellation".
- inkyoto 2y agoI am inclined to believe that they had clearly encountered the protomolecule, and – of course – the government is now trying to cover it up. Because, you know, too prevent another Eros.
- Neil44 2y agoSounds like the start of a Michael Chrichton novel
- evoke4908 2y agoPretty much the opening plot to Stranger in A Strange Land
- pavlov 2y agoSeems like the link on HN was changed from the original which had a more movie-worthy headline.
- aaron695 2y agoSuni Williams who is still in orbit, has lost a lot of weight. I wonder if it's related to that. Trying to find a commonality. This quote was interesting, not sure exactly how true it is - "Due to changes in metabolism, astronauts consume twice as many calories as an ordinary person: just to maintain their current weight, it takes about 4 thousand calories per day. Williams, doctors suggest, will need about 5 thousand calories."
- cranberryturkey 2y ago[flagged]
- parterone 2y agoI heard it's space worms
- cranberryturkey 2y ago[flagged]
- mc32 2y agoNah, it was space herpes.
- cranberryturkey 2y agoahh so that's why they want an all-female crew going to Mars.
- ck2 2y agoWe already know that low-gravity causes all kinds of bone and muscle weakness and even messes with eyesight in a dramatic manner. The scary part is while the bones/muscles can be healed over time, the eyesight problems persist and appear to be irreversible. They have to solve this before trips to Mars will be possible, unless they are going to simulate gravity by constantly (slowly) accelerating half-way there and then slowly decelerating. It's technically plausible but a million other little problems have to be solved too. Won't happen in the lifetime of anyone alive right now.
- wileydragonfly 2y agoNASA always manipulates news coverage… I recall the days 20 years ago whenever a politician got serious about cutting their budget, NASA would run a “water on the Moon!” story. If it comes out that long term space travel is going to cause brain damage (my guess here) their golden goose is cooked.
- johnchristopher 2y agoBut long term, that's good: we have only one spaceship (earth) in the end, that's the one we have to take extreme care of.
- kebaman 2y agoNASA is more than manned space travel with lots of unmanned missions to other planets and moons. If space travel causes brain damage, it's more like Elon will have problems.
- exe34 2y agoso he'll be fine then?
- throwanem 2y agoA constant-acceleration flight profile would also be a lot faster for interplanetary travel, but is impractical for any known or currently plausible reaction engine: the rocket equation strikes again. Ion or Hall-effect thrusters require only electrical power and so can more or less continuously accelerate, but they produce far too little thrust to provide meaningful pseudogravity. Classically, the way to mitigate the medical problems of long microgravity exposure is by giving the spacecraft a rotating section, which produces enough centrifugal "down" to mostly satisfy human physiology. I understand the engineering problem involved there to be fairly severe in its own right, but most likely soluble given an established orbital manufacturing industry amply supplied by heavy lift from Earthside. Another option might be to cable a pair of spacecraft together and spin them about their common barycenter, as I believe has been done with satellites in a few cases. Perhaps this will serve to improve the economics of Martian convict labor by increasing survival rates of transportees, while the English travel first class aboard luxury liners with spin gravity and nightly zero-G cabaret.
- FollowingTheDao 2y agoIt’s either because they don’t want us to freak out that we’re not gonna be able to escape the climate change hell on earth to go to Mars or that there is some reality behind all these new UFO disclosures.
- maxerickson 2y agoThere's lots of simpler explanations. Like maybe one of them had a "gastrointestinal event" during the landing, potentially exposing the others to something infectious.
- mort96 2y agoWe're not going to be able to escape climate change hell on earth by going to mars. You're not transferring 8 billion people to mars this century. The extremely optimistic scenario is that a small group of select rich people and explorers will be able to go to mars and live there self-sufficiently this century, but "we", as in 99.99% of humans, will have to deal with conditions on earth as they are.
- maxerickson 2y agoYou need a huge group of people to even vaguely approach self sufficiency, or multiple generational advances in manufacturing. For example, if you are importing microchips, you are not self sufficient.
- mort96 2y agoOh I 100% agree. The very optimistic scenario is that a colony on mars is formed with a few people who depend on regular shipments from earth. The realistic scenario is that a colony on mars is not made this century. The extremely, wildly, super-optimistic, not gonna happen style scenario is that a few thousand people live there self-sufficiently; and my point is that, however unlikely such a scenario is, even that is nowhere close to enough, because the vast, vast majority of people would still have to deal with climate change. Moving to mars is not, and has never been, "a solution" on foreseeable time horizons.
- szundi 2y agoAlien microbes slowly consume them
- maxerickson 2y agoApparently this is based on their post flight press conference, where they basically said "we aren't going to say anything today": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2dldvKAn2Ns https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2dldvKAn2Ns
- yawpitch 2y agoSpace Herpes. Definitely Space Herpes. I swear I can’t be the only one who has seen Ice Pirates (1984).
- gcanyon 2y agoThere are dozens of us! DOZENS!
- yawpitch 2y agoOh thank the gods… I was worried I was the only one with persistent nightmares about castration engines.
- baerrie 2y agoThank you for this, I never knew its title lol
- yawpitch 2y agoDOZENS + 1! Excellent! You’re welcome, a classic of “bad” science fiction filmmaking, and well worth the knee jerk downvotes.
- kunley 2y agoReminds the Belters from The Expanse
- ncr100 2y agoSci-fi is useful that way, extending a platform of base familiarity upon which the readers may then more quickly comprehend new advances and novel events. Love the stuff
- jensgk 2y agoAstronauts have privacy too
- JCharante 2y agoI suppose you're right. As long as there ends up being some form of public discloser either through a journal or press conference in a timely manner (e.g. not 50 years from now) then humanity can still benefit.
- krisoft 2y agoYes. That is absolutely true. The conflict of course is that the point of sending astronauts to space is to learn about the medical effects of the space environment on human bodies. Basically they are participating in a very expensive publicly funded medical trial. So the goals of that need to be balanced against their privacy. I’m not advocating that NASA should publish high resolution pictures of astronauts with puke stained shirts. But they could say “one of the astronauts experienced symptomps commonly associated with intense motion sickness which started after disembarking the vehicle” or “one of the astronauts had intense headaches” or whatever describes the situation. If the astronauts are not okay with that level of transparency they should pay for their flight with their own money. Is my opinion.
- ruthmarx 2y agoThe info will be made public eventually. There is no reason it need be public immediately.
- jgalt212 2y agoUnless they are hoping the public forgets to follow up. Sort of like when the president's press secretary says to a reporter when faced with a difficult question, "I'll have to get back to you on that."
- b3ing 2y agoJust like they got back to us on those pipelines that were blown up in the sea, they never said who really did it
- mywacaday 2y agoAny chance it's a defection?
- jacknews 2y ago100-mile high club consequences?
- sombragris 2y agoApply Occam's Razor. It could have been something as trivial (?) and embarrassing as a STD.
- PorterBHall 2y agoPlot twist: STDs are endemic in the space station. Turns out low earth orbit is a powerful aphrodisiac, and space agencies have hid this from the general public for years. Now we know more about why billionaires are racing so urgently to get to Mars.
- rbanffy 2y ago> space agencies have hid this from the general public for years Nonsense. If that were the case, they'd be shouting it to everyone and NASA would never again be underfunded.
- natroniks 2y agoDoes anyone know: If deep sea divers need to come back to the surface slowly so their bodies can reacclimate to standard pressure, do astronauts undergo a similar reacclimation process as it pertains to gravity?
- kelnos 2y agoThe issue with divers is that the extra pressure forces nitrogen bubbles deep into their tissues. If they then come up to surface pressure too quickly, the nitrogen bubbles will essentially "explode" out of their tissues and damage them. So no, this is an entirely different problem.
- natroniks 2y agoI can see how it has nothing to do with nitrogen bubbles exploding. But why are you so quick to dismiss the concept? If gravity affects how liquids flow, bone density, and various aspects of human physiology, it stands to reason that a sudden return to earth's gravity could cause internal issues. No?
- TechDebtDevin 2y agoThe Russians were saying the dude lost his mind months ago and that NASA blamed the whole ordeal on the voeing capsule. Who knows
- ebi-moussa 2y ago[dead]