11 ms·
Learning not to trust the All-In podcast
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Centigonal 2y agoThere was the opendoor ipo, there was Jason Calacanis "sharpening the knives" ahead of the Twitter acquisition, there was what David Sacks did to Zenefits, and there's more. People are going to keep trusting these guys, simply because they have a hard-on for charismatic people with a lot of money, an extremely short memory, and refusal to believe that they will be the next ones to be scammed.
- 27153 2y agoIt's frustratingly impressive how grifters are able to maintain a grift even after it's made evident that they are grifting...
- wrs 2y agoOne of the effects of a successful grift is that contrary facts don’t matter — in fact contrary facts just reinforce the grift by strengthening the us against them dynamic.
- mhluongo 2y agoDavid Sacks*
- Centigonal 2y agothanks, fixed!
- goleary 2y agoDavid *Sucks
- schnable 2y agoI find these guys are pretty insightful when discussing tech and VC news. The politics talk is awful. Chamath is a lightweight who doesn't know anything about how our government works but speaks confidently -- I remember one time he was talking about how raising the debt ceiling will allow the President to spend more money. Sacks is a partisan hack who will spin everything as a positive for Trump and MAGA politics. That's after he was a hack for Desantis.
- winterrx 2y agoI find that I listen to them mainly for the tech and VC discussion as you said. The politics conversations are very drowning and I am gladly looking forward to not having to hear as much of this given the election is over.
- bartread 2y agoI have an imprecise and somewhat tongue in cheek measure of a leader’s quality that suggests it is inversely proportional to the frequency with which they appear in the news. I seem to remember from his last term that Trump is at least a daily fixture even within the British media. I think I’m just going to spend even less time consuming mainstream media.
- astrange 2y agoPeople have short memories, but the last time Trump was in office you had to hear about him all the time. (Of course the real concerning trend is that every recent R administration ends in an economic collapse.)
- fny 2y agoChamath is a fraud. He dumped an unbelievable number of SPACs retail that imploded.[0] The fact that he's part of the All-In crew speaks volumes. [0]: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/chamath-palihapitiya-crumbling-spac-empire-100748788.html?guccounter=1 https://finance.yahoo.com/news/chamath-palihapitiya-crumblin...
- 2y ago
- aerhardt 2y agoI didn't know about any of these incidents, but I could never listen to the podcast because they all sounded like a bunch of douchebags to me. Maybe sometimes there's an evolutionary advantage in prejudice?
- nixosbestos 2y ago> People are going to keep trusting these guys, simply because they have a hard-on for charismatic people with a lot of money, an extremely short memory, and refusal to believe that they will be the next ones to be scammed. What a perfect week for people to read this line and go "well that doesn't mean me, nah!" This thread is literally CHALKED FULL of people being like "but I like the vibes despite the obvious signs of charlatanism".
- talldayo 2y agoHacker News: a website where the founders fight the founders, the investors argue with investors, and engineers look on in complete and abject contempt, wondering who gave all these morons money and how they can get their cut.
- mayhaps 2y agoFormer Zenefits employee, present for both Parker + Sacks eras. I'm with you, and I'd like to add additional color to David Sacks time as CEO. David Sacks was uninspiring and aloof. As Zenefits CEO, he worked remote from his office at Craft Ventures. When he rarely appeared on-site, he was escorted around by handlers. On top of everything Zenefits was going through, it didn't help morale having an absentee leader. In retrospect, the guy lacks charm and charisma, so in a way it was a blessing not having him around. Before the major 2017 layoffs, Sacks held an all-hands announcing a new CEO had been found. His impending departure was explained by repeating that he never intended to be CEO, and only took on the role because he felt obligated. What is more, he admitted he was upset over his long working hours, saying he had been sacrificing time to be at home with his family for quite some time. He even shared that his newborn didn't recognize him or his face, to illustrate how long he had been away. Home for him was roughly 3 miles away. Remarkably pathetic. Couple points in retrospect: 1. Back in 2016, Sacks created "The Offer", an agreement where Zenefits paid a severance to employees to quit voluntarily. About 10% did. It was clear later that Sacks wasn't all-in as CEO or previously COO. Perhaps he should have taken "The Offer" himself? 2. Remote work vs RTO. Given productivity data on remote work, combined with his personal story about his newborn, you'd think Sacks would be an advocate of remote work. Yet he's hardline RTO. He also gets memmed on by other pod hosts who tease him with questions, like if he can remember his kids' names.
- kirso 2y agoPalmer actually addressed Calacanis really well here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3vjIx3S09gQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3vjIx3S09gQ
- greenie_beans 2y agoI watched their election result livestream last night. They had some notable guests, like Donald Trump Jr. and Steve Bannon. Bannon was excited about the prospect of deporting 15 million people. Jason seemed shocked, as if this wasn't what he's been supporting all along. Does he not realize that he's in bed with fascists? Or he's just a fascist too? They hinted at knowing who will be the secretary of state and treasury secretary, like it was somebody in their circle. Seemed like Elon Musk will be Trump's righthand man, the way they were acting. They were hyper-fixated on DEI and "woke" in politics. They think the government should be run like a CEO, obviously influenced by Moldbug ideas. Sure, they might be very skilled at becoming rich, but these are not the people we want in government.
- kemiller2002 2y agoAnybody who is going to be shocked at what happens as far as aggressive policies aimed at women, minorities, immigrants, the elderly, and the lower income brackets really has no excuse. They haven't been shy in stating their intentions. You can say you made a choice to support it, but don't hide and say you didn't know.
- voisin 2y ago100%. In 2016 it was fair to be shocked that he meant what he said literally rather than figuratively in a crass manner of getting elected. I think everyone expected he would cut to the middle once elected, as he was a New York democrat for his whole life. But in 2024 we now know that when he says something he means it.
- kemiller2002 2y agoI will firmly admit, that in the 2015 primaries I thought he was the lesser of 2 evils between him and Ted Cruz. I will absolutely state that I was foolish and wrong. That's not happening again.
- nerdponx 2y ago
- kemiller2002 2y agoPlease don't beat me up too much on this. Even if their faulty assumption was true, wouldn't that just be a Keynesian approach to solving a recession? I though Keynes approach was that the government should step in a spend more to prevent a recession, essentially equalling what is lost in the free market. Fully admit could be totally wrong on this. Just curious.
- 27153 2y agoGovernment spending is how a Keynesian combats a recession. For perspective, though, look at this chart of government spending as a % of GDP. It has never gotten even close to 85% of GDP (https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=8fX https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=8fX). Chamath claimed it was 85% of GDP growth, which is a different calculation, but looking at [this data](https://www.bea.gov/sites/default/files/2024-10/gdp3q24-adv.pdf https://www.bea.gov/sites/default/files/2024-10/gdp3q24-adv....) from the past couple of years you can see that the claim is still incorrect.
- KK7NIL 2y agoThis is for Q3 of this year, for which the government is saying we're not in a recession. The problem with Keynesian economics is that no one wants to turn off the money printer when the times are good.
- astrange 2y ago> The problem with Keynesian economics is that no one wants to turn off the money printer when the times are good. That's what central bank independence is for. Raising interest rates is effectively the same thing. Besides that it has been turned off for three years: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WM2NS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WM2NS But the US population is getting increasingly older so there will be increasing pressure on welfare for them.
- ilya_m 2y agoAre we in a recession? I don't think so. There was (still is) a possibility of a recession, due to elevated interest rates, but the way fiscal policy works, through Congress's appropriations, it is hopelessly lagging behind monetary policy (the Fed).
- cryptozeus 2y agoIf you make investment decisions based on podcast called all-in then yes you should not watch it. It is a entertainment/ news podcast, treat it as such.
- llamaimperative 2y agoNo, it's actually a bad idea to expose your brain to pathologically dishonest people.
- goldforever 2y ago[dead]
- cryptozeus 2y agoThey make mistake and they also come out and apologize or call it out when they are wrong. No one is 100% correct all the time. You have never made mistake or said something wrong when having discussion with your friends ? They are not running this as a educational channel , its a podcast where 4 friends chit chat.
- lewhoo 2y agoApparently the biggest mistake they made is to criticize Trump for Jan 6. It's ok, they apologized for that.
- throwaway4736 2y agoHa. Imagine believing this. Yeah, please let me know when Chamath corrects the record on the topic in question. These guys are charlatans. These lying idiots have absolutely no shame in misleading you, and you are falling for it. “Oh, it’s just entertainment. Oh, it’s just opinion. Oh, you shouldn’t take them seriously.” No. Absolutely not. I refuse to give them a pass. We have to stop normalizing this behavior. Ethics matter. Character matters. The truth matters.
- cryptozeus 2y ago
- nostrebored 2y agoMisinterpreting data is easy. To be clear -- I think the All In podcast is frequently flagrantly wrong, but basically all podcasts that try to foretell events are. Chamath mistaking 0.85 absolute as 0.85 relative is fairly easy to do. Even the critique's interpretation is very shallow -- things like second order effects, like the fiscal multiplier contribution, aren't considered. But macro is an art more than a science, and what people interpret as 'true' depends immensely on their assumptions about how the world actually works.
- 27153 2y agoThe order of magnitude of his mistake makes it damning. Especially considering he began his commentary by noting that "the data can be confusing"
- nerdponx 2y ago"Data is hard, let me interpret it for you" is specifically crafted to get people to trust the speaker ("wow this guy understands data I better listen") and discourage independent corroboration ("I don't want to look at it myself if it's hard and I'm likely to misinterpret, best leave that to an expert").
- xmprt 2y ago> Chamath mistaking 0.85 absolute as 0.85 relative is fairly easy to do. I would disagree. If you're actually looking at the data, then anyone with a high school education should know that you don't take percentages of percentages like this. I still think it's ignorance more than malice, but I can't trust someone who would make a simple mistake like this to prove a point. I need my sources of information to at least be unbiased in how they view facts of data. You can represent those facts differently. For example, he might think that 30% of growth being tied to government spending is high and I can follow his reasoning based on that. However if he claims that the actual figure is 85% then the starting point itself is incorrect.
- alexanderchr 2y agoSure - it's an easy mistake to make if you are dealing with data that don't mean anything to you. But anyone with even a tiny bit of experience reading macroeconomic data should be able to tell that something is very off with that number and question it before parrotting it in a podcast.
- newfocogi 2y agoIn this age of endless expertise, it's easy to be fooled into thinking someone is a true authority until you hear them speak on a topic you know well. There's a certain thrill in getting a glimpse behind the curtain, seeing the man (or woman) behind the rhetoric. While I tell myself that 40% of what they say is just made up or misinterpreted, I can't help but keep listening, captivated by the illusion of insight. Even when we know better, the siren song of perceived wisdom is hard to resist. At the end of the day, true expertise is rarer than we'd like to admit - but the fantasy is always enticing.
- swyx 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gell-Mann_amnesia_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gell-Mann_amnesia_effect
- deskr 2y agoWow, I didn't know this effect had a name. I've experienced it so many times. I've also seen how politicians lie and tell half truths about stuff, where I know the full story like them.
- TApplencourt 2y agoIt was in the article...
- deskr 2y agoShows that it's not safe to assume that a random Besserwisser on HN has read the article. In my defence I did skim through it though.
- musicale 2y agoI consider it the cost of information rather than amnesia. When I read articles about something that I don't know much about, I usually don't have time to fact-check everything individually if it's not obviously wrong and seems to be plausibly presented, so I use it as a base theory until I receive evidence to the contrary - while knowing that it is likely still full of errors.
- dktoao 2y agoThank you so much for this analysis, even as a person with layman's grasp on economics you made the deception in host's apparent off the cuff assertion very obvious. I think a big part of the problem that we have in America (and the rest of the world) right now is that it takes these charismatic individuals (All-in, Joe Rogan, etc.) 10 seconds to confidently make these false claims based on personal bias and vibes. Then it takes 10 minutes (or more) by someone with a background in the underlying maths looking at the issue in-depth to rebut. The information landscape is heavily weighted towards these grifters, and I am not sure how we can fix that.
- piva00 2y agoIf you haven't ever read about and came to this thought independently I'd say Brandolini's law[0] is an interesting one for you to read about. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law
- dktoao 2y agoThanks! I will have a read. Looks very interesting.
- alexashka 2y ago> The information landscape is heavily weighted towards these grifters, and I am not sure how we can fix that. We can start with not alienating the millions of people who enjoy listening to Joe Rogan and like him as a person. What do you even mean by grifter and how is Joe Rogan a grifter? We can go back and forth on here until you are shown to have a very shallow understanding of Joe Rogan and the history of his podcast and yet feel comfortable in calling him a grifter - a derogatory and inflammatory term that is completely unnecessary in a fact based conversation. Assuming you are wrong in calling him a grifter - what gave you the utmost confidence to do so and is that not the exact problem you decry Joe Rogan and these other 'grifters' of being guilty of? Of just saying shit based on personal bias and 'vibes'? Anyhoo :)
- MisterBastahrd 2y ago
- practice9 2y agoOne of those guys needs to be fined for the pump & dump scheme (with SPCE: Virgin Galactic), and the other one should be investigated if he was receiving money from the Russian government or influence agents.
- xrd 2y agoThe irony of people like this misinterpreting government data as they orchestrate and cheer on a change in government.
- red_hare 2y agoIn this past Friday's episode, Saks made some pretty terrifying statements about the FCC selling the VHF/UHF Frequencies. He seemed wildly unclear about how leasing that space by the FCC has worked until now and pitched it as a "fixing the woke media" solution.
- IG_Semmelweiss 2y agoCan you elaborate on why the FCC openly auctioning VHF / UHF frequencies is terrifying ?
- toephu2 2y agoHe's not wrong?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- alexashka 2y agoAbout as ironic as Linux devs recognizing Windows to be a crock of shit and providing a viable alternative. Yes, Linux has bugs.
- toephu2 2y agoWhat government data did they misinterpret? They correctly stated that the job numbers always get revised down not up. They also correctly stated that the GDP growth in the last quarter was largely driven by government spend, and if you take out the private sector, there was little growth.
- thinkharderdev 2y ago> They also correctly stated that the GDP growth in the last quarter was largely driven by government spend, and if you take out the private sector, there was little growth. The entire article is pointing out quite clearly that this, in fact, not correct. > They correctly stated that the job numbers always get revised down not up. This is also demonstrably false with like 5 minutes of research. This is all a matter of public record https://www.bls.gov/web/empsit/cesnaicsrev.htm https://www.bls.gov/web/empsit/cesnaicsrev.htm
- steeve 2y ago[dead]
- tailspin2019 2y agoAll-In is one of the few podcasts I listen to where I don’t exactly like the hosts and disagree with a high percentage of what they say. But I find them interesting, and their recent shilling for Trump gave me a bit more of a nuanced insight into what they see as Trump’s strengths. I take everything they say with a huge grain of salt. It is incredible how confidently they talk about certain topics where it’s clear even to an uneducated listener that they only have a surface level understanding. Their flip-flopping on AI - from it being the best thing ever to being completely overhyped and underperforming - and then back again - has been amusing. I enjoy their insights on slightly less hyperbolic topics like SaaS business models and other more mundane things. There can be some genuine nuggets of wisdom there. Jason sometimes pushes back on the political stuff and attempts to be a voice of reason (relatively speaking - though I’m revealing my bias there) and that can sometimes prompt some actual interesting debate. I probably wouldn’t be able to bear listening at all without him on it. Mainly though I think it can be good to listen to people you don’t agree with every so often.
- indy 2y agoThat's the best description of the All-In Podcast I've read. It's often infuriating to listen to someone being confidently wrong, but occasionally there are some good insights.
- somethoughts 2y agoAgreed - I find it useful to get unfiltered insight into how ultra high net worth people think about the world and view/approach things and what sources they use to form opinions. I also find it useful to compare/calibrate how much about finance that's not VC specific (i.e. macro economics, interest rates, commodities, etc.) I know relative to ultra high net worth people. It does require active listening to spot the subtle/not subtle bias, errors in logic etc.
- xmprt 2y ago> I think it can be good to listen to people you don’t agree with every so often I 100% agree. However I don't think it's valuable to get information from people who misrepresent data like All-In. In fact it can be counterproductive to listen to people who are misinforming you. If I can't trust my sources then it hurts more than it helps. This goes the other way too - you should fact check the people who are on your side. In my experience though, when I try sampling new content from people who are biased towards Trump, it's easy to find hypocrisies and misinformation.
- Bhilai 2y agoI was by a few right leaning friends that All-In presented neutral perspectives to political issues but after having tried a few different episodes, I felt that they were pretty biased for Trump. I heard several things which I knew were true but Sacks dismissed them or simply ignored them and continued with his circumlocution on the topic.
- alexashka 2y agoIf you understand that these people are professional politicians in the realm of tech - it will all fall into place. They will believe and say whatever accrues power to them. That's their nature. What would change if they take the podcast more seriously and hire fact checkers for every segment that they do? Would that make it all a-okay? Shrugs To me, the fact that they don't feel the need to be accurate is telling. I don't want anyone helping someone that acts in bad faith to do it better. The better bad faith actors get at persuasion, the worse it is for everyone else. Look at Obama.
- senkora 2y agoThe one that I always remember is how they shilled for Solana immediately before it crashed hard. (I have never had any position in any crypto) I feel like their show has an implicit subtext where you’re expected to understand when they are lying. You get to feel smart by recognizing when they’re just talking their book. The tricky question is whether there is any value in the podcast besides understanding their book.
- seattleeng 2y agoI think you’re exactly right, it’s a show for insiders to know what these 4 people think so the next time they directly or indirectly encounter them they are known quantities. Its masked as news & informative media but its principally brand marketing for these 4 people and their funds & companies.
- Melting_Harps 2y ago> I think you’re exactly right, it’s a show for insiders to know what these 4 people think so the next time they directly or indirectly encounter them they are known quantities. Its masked as news & informative media but its principally brand marketing for these 4 people and their funds & companies. I use it as a 'weight' of sorts when dealing with topics i know about, mainly Bitcoin and AI since I'm involved both those spaces--they really have a limited grasp about some basic concepts, and when you realize that Chamath (the biggest winner of the 4) has a very limited grasp about bitcoin, and admitadly cannot even grasp basic things like how to self-custody you start to realize why these guys are so scummy and him being called the SPAC-King is not a highly regarded moniker at all. Admittedly, they did call the top on the '22 crypto winter, mainly becauwe I think they had already sold all f thier holdings and were looking for a sale--see Chamath's portfolio where BTC and Grok are his best performers I don't want to to talk about Sacks or Kraft because his proximity to trump will now make him a defacto king-maker and make everything he touches seem like it was a well thoughout plan, as he was the one who ushered the SV/VC crowd to embrace Trump after Theil et al had laid the ground in true Paypal mafia style. They are entertainment, the same way Cramer from MSNBC is, but what it does reveal is the narrative they want to push: what you glean from that is entirely up to you, inverse Cramer made a real killing for a bit on WSB. My real questions is what the depth will these Musk boot-lickers go, and who buys 1k+ tickets in order to go to these events? It's probably teh smae who will lie to your face that Twitter was a wild success despite having lost almost all of it's vaklue when this 'genius' CEO (who is now supposed to be in Government in the Trump cabinet) exposed himself to be the absolute incompetent fraud that he is.
- TwoNineFive 2y agoNote all the comments in this thread about how bad the show is and how they don't trust it... but gee golly it sure is good and you should check it out!
- a3r5 2y agoreal question is what is friedberg doing hanging out with these frauds
- rozap 2y agoProbably also a fraud but just a bit less blatant. A subtle, gentleman's grifter.
- chrishare 2y agoHe seems legit to me.
- TeaBrain 2y agoThis is how baseless rumors start. You're speculating without a hint of evidence.
- rozap 2y agoPoint taken, you're right, and I'm just having a laugh. But he does surround himself with grifters. In any case, I think he'll be fine.
- TeaBrain 2y agoHe does, but I'm kind of glad for it, as if they weren't around then there probably wouldn't be a podcast. Even though he's the only member of the podcast I find likable, I still find the exchanges entertaining.
- _djo_ 2y agoI have bad news for you.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hfourm 2y agoNot shocking.
- MaxfordAndSons 2y agoIncidentally: Chamath plays a fair amount of high stakes poker recreationally, including on various streams and/or filmed poker content. I forget if it was on twitter or a Reddit AMA or what, but he once gave a blurb about what he had learned playing the game for some time, and he said something to the effect of "Poker is a fundamentally defensive game", which is an absurd statement. There is no strategic bias towards offense or defense in poker, there is only EV maximization, which you would think a VC would be able to wrap their head around, but he has managed to fundamentally misunderstand the game.
- gizmo 2y agoWith investing you can make 1000x your money if you bet right. Your returns are determined by your best bets. You can be spewy and it doesn't matter much. Or you can wait for aces and then bet big. It's up to you. With poker it's not like that. Blinds force you to play mediocre hands and make bets when you're weak. Minimizing your losses with correct play is essential, otherwise you'll bleed out. You can only make money in poker when your opponent makes mistakes (good opponents don't make many) but you can lose money in every hand you play. That's why it's a defensive game.
- MaxfordAndSons 2y agoMinimizing your losses is essential; so is maximizing your gains. TBF, in a tournament there is something to be said for biasing towards loss minimization because of the need to preserve your tournament life resulting in chip value being non-linear. But, in cash games (which ironically is what Chamath mostly plays), there is no such bias. Most amateur players arrive incorrectly at that bias over time because frequently miss thin value themselves, and also miss on value when they have the nuts because they don't bluff enough, while also often giving up value incorrectly to better players who are exploiting them, so their experiential bias tells them to err on the side of playing it safe and waiting for a set up in their favor to realize most of their EV, not realizing they are bleeding it away on the margins in countless other spots.
- deleted 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mp05 2y agoAll In is pure entertainment and if you think it constitutes investment advice, you're the problem.
- lxgr 2y agoListening to five minutes of a random episode did the trick for me, personally.
- FigurativeVoid 2y agoWhen the pandemic started, I really enjoyed the podcast. They seemed to have some good insights, and I found them funny. It was a vibe that I sorely missed being home alone. If one them sees this, I hope they take it kindly. The podcast has gone downhill drastically. The level of discourse has dropped considerably. They make all sorts of claims with very little evidence. Recently they have all agreed that voter ID laws "just make sense." But they don't even bring up any of the unpleasant history around IDs. When DeSantis was running, they didn't ever talk about him flying immigrant around as a horrible political stunt. They've been leaning closer and closer to anti vax stances. I still listen.. but I'll probably stop soon. It's becoming a bro podcast. David Friedberg has the best mind for evidence, and he speaks less and less.
- TeaBrain 2y agoI actually was of the impression that David Friedberg got a decent amount of speaking time in the last few episodes, especially in that recent one that he moderated, which I enjoyed since he's the most level headed, least partisan and most evidence based as you said of the bunch.
- WillPostForFood 2y agoRecently they have all agreed that voter ID laws "just make sense." But they don't even bring up any of the unpleasant history around IDs. This year is the 80th anniversary of the passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, do they really need to go through the history of IDs? We need to rebuild confidence in the integrity of elections, Voter ID, which most democratic countries require, seems like an incredibly modest step. The states that historically had the worst race issues all have voter id anyway, it is the Northeast and West coast that are refusing.
- goldforever 2y ago[dead]
- patrickhogan1 2y agoOne really good source I’ve found is Steve Ballmer’s* USA Facts and YouTube videos Just The Facts https://usafacts.org/answers/how-much-does-the-us-federal-government-spend/country/united-states/ https://usafacts.org/answers/how-much-does-the-us-federal-go... *What he did to open source while CEO at Microsoft is atrocious - but he’s putting his money to some good content and I’m all for that
- somethoughts 2y ago"But I know that I won’t be tuning in for the next episode of All-In to find out. I will not fall prey to Gell-Mann Amnesia." Not sure if the author - Michael Bateman - will ever see this but if he does - just a thought - it could be an interesting and fertile genre/substack niche to do follow analysis of their claims/discussions in more detail regularly as a counterpoint to their podcast. I found his analysis compelling and it could be popular among HNers.
- 27153 2y agoAppreciate the comment. This is the author here. Unfortunately, due to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law as pointed out by another comment, there is an asymmetry of effort in making vs finding/disproving false claims. I was just lucky to have been recently primed with the information to notice this mistake. My usual niche is writing about climbing and skiing, but if I'll be sure to share future thoughts in this realm.
- the_optimist 2y agoLeading off the article with Yglesias shows the guy has little idea what he’s proposing to discuss. Imports can reduce GDP because the import is imported and not domestically produced. The formula identifies specifically: that which is consumed domestically but not produced domestically is not part of domestic production. There is no inconsistency here at all with revised trade policy increasing GDP. It should be totally obvious and intuitive that if the same good is consumed domestically, producing it domestically rather than importing it will increase GDP, all other externalities and second-order impacts aside.
- TeaBrain 2y agoYglesias has no business commenting on macro finance. He just as good at being confidently incorrect as Chamath. An entertaining example of this was his confidently incorrect tirade about basis points. https://www.cnbc.com/2023/01/13/matt-yglesias-got-confused-about-basis-points-heres-what-to-know.html https://www.cnbc.com/2023/01/13/matt-yglesias-got-confused-a...
- astrange 2y agoImports don't /reduce/ GDP. They don't affect GDP because they are not produced domestically. What you're proposing is import substitution (tariffs), which is bad because 1. domestically imported goods can have imported inputs. 2. reduced competition from the external good means the internal ones will be worse. > It should be totally obvious and intuitive that if the same good is consumed domestically, producing it domestically rather than importing it will increase GDP, all other externalities and second-order impacts aside. There's no situation where those can be put aside, and since GDP is an artificial formula you shouldn't Goodhart it like that.
- the_optimist 2y ago“Bad” is merely the inverse of the characterization you seek to avoid. There is no basis for assuming Pareto improvement in offshoring, particularly in an intellectual-property-flat world.
- thinkharderdev 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jimmydoe 2y agoInfotainment is entertainment after all. All In podcast, President talks about people eating pets, they are just same type of garbage.
- sailfast 2y agoIt's probably best not to trust _any_ podcast until you do a bit of investigation. That way you won't run into the "learning not to trust" problem and you can write a "why I trust the X podcast" article. That said - this was a great breakdown - thanks to the author!
- briantakita 2y agoI have news for you. Don't trust anyone with data. Mistakes are made. Biases are confirmed. Reproducibility & criteria for falsifiability are not proven. Unknown unknowns exist. There are different ways of categorizing & counting things. Abstraction is a lie (the map is not the territory). There are only two hard things in Computer Science: cache invalidation, naming things, and off by one errors...
- siilats 2y agoWell he doesn't know how to divide. If private sector does 2% and government does 1% then government is 50% not 33%. Similarly he displays the level of government spending, not the change. If government is 30% of GDP, then automatically its 30% of GDP growth no matter what. And again 30% is really 50% of the private sector. Now if the government grows from 30% to 35% like it shows on that chart, in addition to few quarters of 50%, thats how you get to government being 100% of the growth. Just use $, the % is clearly too hard for HN. Economy was 100. Government 30, private sector 70. Economy grew to 105, government 35, private sector 70. So 100% of the growth was government. I hope the author reads this comment, HN is being a weird echo chamber. Bayesian probability people, what is the chance that All In is actually wrong based on a random blog post.
- starwin1159 2y agoWhat other podcasts are worth listening to?
- avs733 2y agoI really enjoy knowledgefight. Although I’m not sure I can continue listening after this week.
- 27153 2y agoEzra Klein
- tacitusarc 2y agoI have listened to a lot of Ezra Klein over the years- like, a LOT. And I believe he is one of the scummiest people in journalism. There are very, very few people I think are genuinely malicious and entirely self interested, but he is one.
- prng2021 2y agoI’m glad this author wrote this up. The guys in All-In really need to be called out for all their bs. Here’s episode 191 Aug 9, 2024 where Chamath is talking about a Google breakup possibility: “The big O outcome though is more if you go back to the Ma Bell kind of thing where the company gets broken up. I think that the odds of that are extremely unlikely. I think the big O outcome is probably something that you can pretty safely take off the table.” And here’s episode 199 Oct 11, 2024 where the host rewrites history: “We have an update on the DOJ's antitrust suit with Google. It looks like they're going for the break up as Chamath predicted” What??
- TeaBrain 2y agoI think Chamath is guilty of this to a degree that far exceeds the others. Chamath regularly states misconceptions about economic data, but with extreme confidence as if he's a macro econ subject matter expert. I think Friedberg should get some credit for often calling him out on what Chamath is confidently mouthing off about. In a recent episode, I think Friedberg just started laughing after he realized breaking through to Chamath would be impossible.
- bob_theslob646 2y agoHow is Chamath not in jail for his pumping and dumping of spacs? https://www.marketwatch.com/story/secs-coates-tells-investors-to-ignore-billionaire-spac-investors-legal-advice-11617909564 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/secs-coates-tells-investor...
- 9cb14c1ec0 2y agoOne person made a mistake once, so everything they ever say is useless. Got it. Now I can discredit and ignore anyone I want to, because everyone has made a mistake at some point.
- TwoNineFive 2y agoThat show is 95% hyperbolic con-man BS that angsty tech tweens lap up as truth. I listen to because I want to know what the hype machine is pushing, and they tell me. It's great for following the techniques of grifter speech and influencing, but it's not a source of good information.
- metabagel 2y agoThe mistake which this podcast made was to misinform their listeners. Given that informing their listeners is their core mission, it's a pretty unforgivable mistake. Better to listen to another podcast which takes their mission more seriously.
- 9cb14c1ec0 2y agoAny podcast that has "informing their listeners" as a core mission will make mistakes now and then. It happens because we are all humans and not Gods. All I'm trying to do here is push back against the suggestion of the article that you write off people based on a single mistake. A world in which I can never make a mistake is not a world I want to live in.
- Analemma_ 2y agoThere’s an obvious difference between a one-off mistake and one which is part of a pattern of continuous deception meant to bias the audience in one particular political direction; the mistake mentioned in the article is clearly the latter. It does not deserve the benefit of the doubt you’re giving it, as a genuine one-off would (particularly if they mentioned, corrected, and apologized for the mistake, which I predict with high confidence they will not do).
- 2y ago
- nfw2 2y agoI think part of All-In's success is that it has the vibe of a group of friends sitting around and shooting the breeze. It's way less academic than something like the Ezra Klein Show, but that's the point. Is there bloviating involved? All the time, especially from Chamath. Are there bad takes? Certainly. But it's entertaining.
- nerdponx 2y agoBeing confidently wrong about matters of public policy in front of a large audience is more than just an incidental bad take. It pollutes the public well of information and thereby does a disservice to society. You do not have a right to entertain yourself with something that damages the ability of society to make decisions and govern itself.
- braza 2y agoPeople in this “large audience” are listening voluntarily to a bunch of guys talking about similar interest points. Some of those points they will have credibility others no; and that’s the beauty of to live in an almost free information society. The problem with the “something that damages the ability of society to make decisions” it’s with who establishes that and what’s the self correct mechanism those institutions that establishes that has.
- NoBeardMarch 2y ago> The problem with the “something that damages the ability of society to make decisions” it’s with who establishes that and what’s the self correct mechanism those institutions that establishes that has. You seem to imply that this is some metaphysical discussion on the nature of "truth" itself or who gets to be the arbiter of that - but I feel this is a dishonest digression here. Yes, truth can never be truly established - but both you and I know that Chamath's take on All-In for this particular claim was clearly false. I agree with the poster you replied to. I guess you have a point in that there is no law that can tell Chamath to shut up and only open his mouth when he is talking about something with high confidence - but when you are speaking to a large audience on matters of economic policy with some implications as to what people believe then YES - you have a responsibility! The punishment to which breaking it should be (for people with a huge outreach like Chamath) being shamed online for it. People should learn the fact that Chamath is a man who chronically opines constantly about things he has no basis for having an opinion on. He is a chronic borderline liar.
- jreddy 2y agoyou're just learning that? after all this time?
- tacitusarc 2y ago“ In my first and only 15 minutes of watching, Chamath’s confidence in making this false claim, coupled with his co-hosts’ complete lack of critical pushback, suggests to me that these kinds of mistakes happen often enough to where these guys’ content isn’t worth consuming.” This is what I call “anti-credibility.” Where credibility increases the likelihood of belief in subsequent claims, anti-credibility increases the belief that subsequent claims are false. This is subtly distinct from decreasing the likelihood of belief, which would merely result in more skepticism: You say “A is true”, so folks think “A might not be true.” Anti-credibility means if you state “A is true” people think, “oh, A is false.” This phenomenon has played a large role in politics and social movements over the past several years.
- nerdponx 2y agoIt makes more sense if you notice that the direction of wrongness is consistent, in which case an adjustment across the board in the other direction makes sense. Works great for politicians of all kinds, and their supporters, as we see here.
- gaia 2y agoWait, it gets worse: https://x.com/laurenbalik/status/1853850363004063977 https://x.com/laurenbalik/status/1853850363004063977 -David Sacks bankrolled a company called Done Global. The "CEO" Ruthia He is a Chinese national with absolutely no medical experience. Very quickly, this turned into prescriptions for dead people, medspas doling out Adderall, the Chinese sharing health data about Americans as the whole back office was in China. Plenty of these narcotics ended up on the street, which was always the goal. The CEO and several others are awaiting trial. They caught David Sacks-backed Ruthia He trying to flee to China about a month ago, and now she's back in jail. -David Sacks had a whole money laundering operation set up around Eaze. His guy Keith McCarty left Eaze to found a payments system company (to support Eaze) and they have Keith McCarty with crack cocaine, prostitutes, and firearms rooming with a guy named Hamid Arkhavan involved in the Wirecard fraud, running up transactions to facilitate money laundering through porn sites. Eaze was a big advertiser on these sites to clear money laundering transactions. -Earlier this year, conservative influencer Dave Rubin was caught up in a money laundering racket after he and his people were receiving payments from Russian assets, and the Russian fled the US overnight. Dave Rubin is another David Sacks-backed founder. Rubin was co-founder of the company Locals, which is extremely crappy Web 1.0 software used to facilitate payments to influencers. David Sacks sold this Locals plus his other company Callin, to Rumble $RUM and took a Board seat at Rumble. There. Right there you have 3 David Sacks-backed founders all directly tied to money laundering and/or drug trafficking. Ruthia He. Keith McCarty. Dave Rubin. Those are just the main ones with some amount of legal/media coverage on them, but there are more. You still think Sacks is "just" a VC? The VC stuff is a front. This isn't tech. This is the Mafia. Sacks just throws the word "software" over it to obfuscate it, but too many people have figured this out now. He got too cocky after he and Lonsdale "lost" a bunch of foreign money with Hyperloop. His prancing around is like watching an animal in a cage. He's got to negotiate his way out of this regardless.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nojvek 2y agoAll-in podcast is very pro Trump and Elon. I listened to their conference series. Some made sense, some didn’t. But kudos to Trump. He painted himself as the progressive. Embracing crypto and AI. He got the tech bros vouching for him in big numbers. Even my hairdresser said he listened to All-in podcast and brought some Trump coins. It’s gonna go up he said. He voted so his coins go up.
- happymounth 2y agoUnfortunately I don’t think you can trust any particular podcast or news source to be completely perfect. The author did a great job of self investigation which is what we should all do before forming strong opinions about anything.
- science4sail 2y agoThe All-In podcast should not be listened to as a reliable source of news, but rather as a data point providing insight into the perspectives and attitudes of Silicon Valley's leadership class. If one finds their views to be objectionable/incorrect, then that means that the hosts' peers are likely also holding objectionable/incorrect views of a similar form.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]