6 ms·
This is a good way for Ars to generate clicks and a more honest headline probably wouldn't move the needle much, but it's worth being clear for HN that the obje
by tptacek 2y ago
This is a good way for Ars to generate clicks and a more honest headline probably wouldn't move the needle much, but it's worth being clear for HN that the objection here is not that locked phones are good for consumers, but that the subsidization deals locked phones enable are.
- metacritic12 2y agoArs has gone down the ragebait rabbit hole, which is perfectly rational, though they do it with technical stories, which people don't expect so much baiting. Basically the carriers are making the standard libertarian argument, which makes sense. If you block locking, you already know what happens: we already know cell phone prices unlocked. The cell carriers are in essence capital providers and they know how to collect money from their customers.
- sofixa 2y ago> standard libertarian argument, which makes sense It really doesn't. Libertarian arguments only make sense if you don't think about it too much, or are ignorant about the context and details, or you have a vested interest. You can compare phone prices with countries where there is healthy competition and there is no or very limited blocking (France is a good example - you can buy phones outright, or get them on a payment plan that locks you on a more expensive monthly payment compared to the classic 20€ everything included including 20-150GB internet depending on the provider plan; after the initial period is over, you can do whatever you want). If you bother to look into the topic a little bit more than surface level, libertarian arguments usually fall apart easily.
- tptacek 2y agoThe complaint they have isn't that unlocked phones exist; they're asking to be able to sell (or serve) unlocked phones alongside subsidized phones. Most people commenting on HN from the US are probably using unlocked phones on major carriers. I sure am.
- reissbaker 2y agoFrance allows companies to have more onerous locking policies than the U.S. is proposing. French telecom companies are allowed to sell locked phones, require customers to request unlocks (rather than auto-unlocking, like the U.S. proposed rules), and the companies are allowed to take up to 3 months to respond to unlock requests, rather than requiring immediate unlocks after the first 60 days pass. I like unlocked phones, and I buy my phones unlocked. But I agree with the sentiment here that we already know what the prices are for unlocked phones: manufacturers will sell them to you at that price, and telecom operators in the U.S. will universally allow you to bring your own, unlocked device free of charge. What the companies offering locked phones offer is an optional subsidy in exchange for a locked phone; while I'm sure there are reasonable arguments around e-waste that result in wanting some limits to locking, there is an obvious tradeoff in that the value of the subsidy diminishes as the allowed lock time diminishes. Mandating short limits to phone locks raises prices for poor people who can't afford unlocked phones. It's not always bad to do that — sometimes companies are taking advantage of poor people — but it's pretty true that will happen.
- makapuf 2y agoKeep in mind that prices in France are WAY lower than in the US according to this site. https://www.cable.co.uk/mobiles/worldwide-data-pricing/ https://www.cable.co.uk/mobiles/worldwide-data-pricing/ (edit: bad autocorrect)
- pkaye 2y agoAre people paying $6/GB on average in the US?
- reissbaker 2y agoNo, the UK-based website is wrong. There are enormous numbers of plan options in the US, and their sampling methodology was probably bad. You can get reasonably good 5G plans for $1/GB in America; probably cheaper if you're willing to go with smaller/worse providers.
- 2y ago
- IshKebab 2y agoLocked phones don't enable subsidized deals though. We still have subsidized deals in the UK but locking is a thing of the past. In fact they have started explicitly calling it like it is and breaking the price down into payments for the plan and payments for the phone, which stop once you've paid it off.
- tptacek 2y agoThat is a perfectly reasonable argument. My point was that Ars' headline was deliberately misleading. Note that the article doesn't go into any real depth about alternative financing plans.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoIf you really don't like the article, you can always read the FCC statement instead: https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/1017178290200/1 https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/1017178290200/1 But I know linking to a PDF will put some people off. It's a fairly short response this time as well. ---- >handsets that are free or heavily discounted off the manufacturer's suggested retail price. You do it by increasing contract prices and being able to collect a phone if you don't stay with the often 2-year contract for stuff like this. The final price is also much more expensive than buying outright. This is a bit silly in am age where phone tech has plateaued and you can often get last year flagships for half the price at launch. Consumers don't need the newest phone at all. >T-Mobile’s current unlocking policies also help T- Mobile combat handset theft and fraud by sophisticated, international criminal organizations. All androids and iphones have built in find - my - phone features these days, as well as the ability to wipe remotely. Phones are one of the least useful things to try and steal these days as a result, up there with a credit card. You can still get info and pawn off a wiped phone, but I don't see what T-Mobile does to prevent that further. >because the proposal would force providers to reduce the line-up of their most compelling handset offers. T Sprint already was reducing lineups, even before the acquisition. And they don't really subsidize anymore. That's why I started buying my own phones. The T-Mobile store was just the Galaxy/IPhone store, featuring overly expensive otter cases. >T-Mobile maintains that the Commission lacks authority to adopt the proposed rule They really pulling off the Chevron defense (assumedly, it's in another document) with no hesitation, huh? I guess we'll see how that goes. I'm not going to pretend I know the full ramifications of how it will affect the FCC. >however, a provider subject to FCC-imposed asymmetric regulation on handset unlocking seeks to modify its commitments Sounds like a horrible loophole to extend the policy as long as possible. So, no. They don't even provide much of an argument for when and where and what should be modified. ----- Clickbait or not, I'm not really liking the arguments either way.
- nothercastle 2y agoThey aren’t though. Subsidized phones are like monthly car payments drive up costs and are targeted at people bad at math. If consumers paid out of pocket for their phones then they would be more picky about upgrading and plan prices. It would also make upselling shitty plan features harder so the carriers would loose a lot of money.
- christophilus 2y agoMonthly car payments can be good, though, as opposed to paying cash, assuming you can get a reasonable rate of return by conservatively investing the cash in a fairly liquid investment.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoThey type of people they target don't even have money saved for an emergency. Let alone money to invest.
- ryandrake 2y agoCurrent (risk free) 5 year TIPS real yield is 1.65%... Not sure if there are many car loans offered at a lower rate. If you were thinking a different investment, you'd of course need to adjust it for risk, inflation, and liquidity before comparing to the car loan.
- i80and 2y agoThere are economic environments where this is true, but I think they tend to be the exception, not the rule. Car loan rates right now are quite steep.
- cmeacham98 2y agoI would agree with you (financing small purchases like a phone is a bad idea and causes people to spend money they shouldn't), but that doesn't make the clickbait acceptable. Ars Technica should accurately report the claims of the telco industry.
- 2y ago
- marinmania 2y agoI don't think that is a more accurate headline. The potential regulation is about the government making phones unlock automatically after two months of purchase. The regulation isn't about banning discounts or sales.
- crazygringo 2y agoIf unlocking is made mandatory, the phone subsidies will end. People will be forced to pay full price up front, or else effectively pay more as interest (even if that interest is effectively "hidden" in the overall increased price). So yes, this regulation is exactly about that.
- stevesimmons 2y agoOr they buy the phone with a credit contract, as happens in the rest of the world. If the major telcos only offer exorbitant interest rates, some other player will step in and offer the credit at better rates that fairly price the risk.
- skybrian 2y agoThe interest rate on a credit contract will depend on the default rate. Arguably, a phone company can offer loans on a locked phone for lower interest rates than anyone else could, because they can cut off service if the loan isn't paid, which is an incentive to actually pay it. I'm not all sure this is a good thing, but I can see the argument for why it might result in lower interest rates on phones. None of this is going to matter to people with good credit.
- ryukoposting 2y ago...alternatively, the cell companies will just sell unlocked phones with the subsidies, since you're still locked into the same 1-or-2-year contract that was paying for the locked phones. This won't stop them from making those precious fractions of a cent from bundled shitware. They'll still make their money.
- marinmania 2y ago
- gjsman-1000 2y agoArs Technica has been downhill ever since Condé Nast bought them. So has Wired - sometimes the stupidity is just unreadable.
- michaelmrose 2y agoThey can still lock the user in with early termination fees
- roymurdock 2y agothanks for creating a meaningful dialogue here, wish ars would try to do the same
- 627467 2y agoWhy do you need to lock the phones for this? If the point is to lock customer to a subsidizing contract just do that: use the contract to enforce the lockin. What do they care if I use another sim card on the phone if I'm paying the monthly service for the duration of the contract?
- aeternum 2y agoIt often comes down to enforcement. Cellphone debt is near impossible to collect, I believe statute of limitations is only 2 years in many states. The contract is likely near worthless if sent to collections.
- markdown 2y agoDon't you have credit bureaus that serve as deterrents? ie. Nobody wants to get a horrible credit score over a phone.
- mr_toad 2y agoI doubt they unlock the phone after the subsidy expires.
- gruez 2y agoI thought FCC regulations require that phones be unlocked after 60 days? At least with straight talk it auto unlocks in 60 days https://www.tfwunlockpolicy.com/wps/portal/home https://www.tfwunlockpolicy.com/wps/portal/home
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- EasyMark 2y agoI'm fine with other people buying $1200 phones and then selling them to me a couple of years later for 1/2 to 2/3 the priceunlocked and ready for my consumption. The last new phone I bought was iPhone 12 and that was because 5G was the first really tech jump in a while on phones.
- EasyMark 2y agoI'm fine with other people buying $1200 phones and then selling them to me a couple of years later for 1/2 to 2/3 the priceunlocked and ready for my consumption. The last new phone I bought was iPhone 12 and that was because 5G was the first really "worth buying into" tech jump in a while on phones.