7 ms·
I'm making some big assumptions about Adobe's product ideation process, but: This seems like the "right" way to approach developing AI products: Find a user nee
by ryandrake 2y ago
I'm making some big assumptions about Adobe's product ideation process, but: This seems like the "right" way to approach developing AI products: Find a user need that can't easily be solved with traditional methods and algorithms, decide that AI is appropriate for that thing, and then build an AI system to solve it.
Rather than what many BigTech companies are currently doing: "Wall Street says we need to 'Use AI Somehow'. Let's invest in AI and Find Things To Do with AI. Later, we'll worry about somehow matching these things with user needs."
- ryanmcbride 2y agoYeah I much prefer this approach to the current standard of just putting a chat bot somewhere on the page and calling it a day.
- JohnMakin 2y agoPrecisely. There are many such use cases too! It's disappointing to see the industry go all in on chatbot wrappers.
- jthacker 2y agoThis is certainly a great immediately useful tool but also a relatively small ROI, both the return and the investment. Big tech is aiming for a much bigger return on a clearly bigger investment. That’s going to potentially look like a lot of useless stuff in the meantime. Also, if it wasn’t for big tech and big investments, there wouldn’t even be these tools / models at this level of sophistication for others to be using for applications like this one.
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoWhile the press lumps it all together as "AI", you have to differentiate LLMs (driven by big tech and big money) from unrelated image/video types of generative models and approaches like diffusion, NeRF, Gaussian splatting, etc, which have their roots in academia.
- copperx 2y agoLLMs don't have their roots in academia?
- withinboredom 2y agoNot anymore.
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoNot at all - Transformer was invented by a bunch of former Google employees (while at Google), primarily Jakob Uszkoreit and Noam Shazeer. Of course as with anything it builds on what had gone before, but it's really quite a novel architecture.
- ansk 2y agoThe scientific impact of the transformer paper is large, but in my opinion the novelty is vastly overstated. The primary novelty is adapting the (already existing) dot-product attention mechanism to be multi-headed. And frankly, the single-head -> multi-head evolution wasn't particularly novel -- it's the same trick the computer vision community applied to convolutions 5 years earlier, yielding the widely-adopted grouped convolution. The lasting contribution of the Transformer paper is really just ordering the existing architectural primitives (attention layers, feedforward layers, normalization, residuals) in a nice, reusable block. In my opinion, the most impactful contributions in the lineage of modern attention-based LLMs are the introduction of dot-product attention (Bahdanau et al, 2015) and the first attention-based sequence-to-sequence model (Graves, 2013). Both of these are from academic labs. As a side note, a similar phenomenon occurred with the Adam optimizer, where the ratio of public/scientific attribution to novelty is disproportionately large (the Adam optimizer is very minor modification of the RMSProp + momentum optimization algorithm presented in the same Graves, 2013 paper mentioned above)
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y ago
- eitally 2y agoOn the plus side, for Adobe, is that they have a fairly stable & predictable SaaS revenue stream so as long as their R&D and product hosting costs don't exceed their subscription base, they're ok. This is wildly different from -- for example -- the hyperscalers, who have to build and invest far in advance of a market [for new services especially].
- mihaaly 2y agoIt is the 'make something for the user/client' vs. 'make something to sell' mindset. The latter one is what overwhelmingly more companies (not only BigTech, not at all!) adopted nowadays. And Boeing. ;)
- politelemon 2y agoAnd Boeing?
- bobthepanda 2y agoIf the lore is to be believed, Southwest (a airline that has made its business only the 737) saw the a320 neo and basically told Boeing "give us a new 737 or we go to airbus." they did what the client wanted, to their detriment. "If I asked people what they wanted they would've said faster horses," or whatever Henry Ford is falsely accused of saying.
- renegade-otter 2y agoI don't think it's a Big Tech problem. Big Tech can come up with moronic ideas and be fine because they have unlimited cash. It's the smaller companies that need to count pennies who decide to flush the money down the AI Boondoggle Toilet. "But Google does it. If we do it, we will be like Google".
- reaperducer 2y ago"But Google does it. If we do it, we will be like Google". Were you in my meeting about 40 minutes ago? Because that's almost exactly what was said. If the big tech companies wanted to be really evil, they could invent a nonsense tech that doesn't work, then watch as all the small upstart competitors bankrupt themselves to replicate it.
- notarealllama 2y agoYou mean like React, right? Right?
- coliveira 2y agoIsn't this what AI is all about? Don't kid yourself, most companies, even some big ones, will bankrupt themselves chasing AI and the few remaining will get the spoils.
- Auracle 2y agoIt seems that’s just the way things go with disruptive technologies. It’s a gold rush and you don’t want to be left behind.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- oarsinsync 2y agoSounds a bit like trying to roll and support your own k8s platform
- emmanueloga_ 2y agoI think you're being a bit too generous with Adobe here :-). I shared this before, but it's worth resharing [1]. It covers the experience of a professional artist using Adobe tools. The gist is that once a company has a captive audience with no alternatives, investors come first. Flashy (no pun intended :-p), cool features to impress investors become more important than the everyday user experience—and this feature does look super cool! -- 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lthVYUB8JLs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lthVYUB8JLs
- mesh 2y agoYou can have both! Cool features that excite users (and that they ultimately end of using), and that get investors excited. (i.e. Adobe mentioned in the day 1 keynote that Generative Fill, released last year and powered by Adobe Firefly is not one of the top 5 used features in Photoshop). The features we make, and how we use gen ai is based on a lot of discussions and back and forth with the community (both public and private) I guess Adobe could make features that look cool, but no one wants to use, but that doesn't seem to really make any sense. (I work for Adobe)
- derefr 2y ago> is not one of the top 5 used features in Photoshop I mean, is there any Photoshop feature that’s come to dominate people’s workflows so quickly? People (e.g. photographers) who use Photoshop “in anger” for professional use-cases, and who already know how to fix a flaw in an image region without generative fill, aren’t necessarily going to adopt it right out of the gate. They’re going to tinker with it a bit, but time-box that tinkering, otherwise sticking with what they can guarantee from experience will get a “satisfactory” result, even if it takes longer and might not have as high a ceiling for how perfectly the image is altered. And that’d just people who repair flaws in images. Which I’m guessing aren’t even the majority of Photoshop users. Is the clone brush even in the top 5 Photoshop features by usage?
- bythreads 2y agoYou're super wrong. Pro here working with this stuff for decades. There was a brief moment in time where freehand was just a better and faster drawing tool than illustrator (which is whats is shown here) but from there on psp, ill & indesign have pretty much killed all competition out there. The formats they use are sigularly stupid and arcane for legacy reasons, they are all mem hogs and inefficient to the extreme - but nothing beats that unholy trifecta and it is used it or die. Now to get the point: generative fill is one of the absolute killer features of psp - in an instant it does what could take multiple hours to do previously with 5-10 sec of watching a loader. There are many mor gamechangers and this really looks like another
- MiddleEndian 2y agoMy company has decided to update its hr page to use AI for reasons unknown. So instead of the old workflow: "visit HR page" → "click link that for whatever reason doesn't give you a permanent link you can bookmark for later" it's now: "visit HR page" → "do AI search for the same link which is suggested as the first option" → "wait 10-60 seconds for it to finally return something" → "click link that for whatever reason doesn't give you a permanent link you can bookmark for later"
- mstipetic 2y agoSomebody's putting "AI expert" on their resume
- coliveira 2y agoNvidia needs to continue selling chips like crazy, all companies in the US need to do their fair share to contribute!...
- Oarch 2y agoBubbles require constant maintenance
- karmonhardan 2y agoYou joke, but it's literally in the interest of many companies to prop up the SP500 et al. by wasting money on M7 products, isn't it?
- rightbyte 2y ago"click link that for whatever reason doesn't give you a permanent link you can bookmark for later" Sounds like engagement hacking?
- Macha 2y agoI think this is a weird SAML pattern I've seen before where e.g. Okta generates a URL that's like https://somevendor.com/SAML/somesignedbase64payload https://somevendor.com/SAML/somesignedbase64payload to do SSO, which is sort of the inverse of the more common approach of the page you're logging into sending you to the Auth provider after seeing your email domain.
- crazygringo 2y agoThis feels extremely ungenerous to the Big Tech companies. What's wrong with trying out 100 different AI features across your product suite, and then seeing which ones "stick"? You figure out the 10 that users find really valuable, another 10 that will be super-valuable with improvement, and eventually drop the other 80. Especially when if Microsoft tries something and Google doesn't, that suddenly gives Microsoft a huge lead in a particular product, and Google is left behind because they didn't experiment enough. Because you're right -- Google investors wouldn't like that, and would be totally justified. The fact is, it's often hard to tell which features users will find valuable in advance. And when being 6 or 12 months late to the party can be the difference between your product maintaining its competitive lead vs. going the way of WordPerfect or Lotus 123 -- then the smart, rational, strategic thing to do is to build as many features as possible around the technology, and then see what works. I would suggest that if Adobe is being slower with rolling out AI features, it might be more because of their extreme monopoly position in a lot of their products, thanks to the stickiness of their file formats. That they simply don't need to compete as much, which is bad.
- blep-arsh 2y agoForce-feeding 100s of different AI features (90% of which are useless at best) to users is what's wrong with the approach.
- crazygringo 2y agoWhy? It's not "force-feeding". You usually get a little popup highlighting the new feature that you close and never see again. It's not that hard to ignore a new "magic wand" button in the toolbar or something. I personally hardly use any of the features, but neither do I feel "force-fed" in the slightest. Aside from the introductory popups (which are interesting), they don't get in my way at all.
- Arainach 2y agoIt's popups. It's emails. It's constant nudges towards changes in workflows. Most importantly, it's accelerated the slurping of data and aggressive terms of service by an order of magnitude. Sure, in theory everyone wanted your data before, but now everyone wants all your data all the time. They want to upload it to their servers. They want to train products on it. And they want to ban you from using their product if you don't agree.
- tiffanyh 2y agoFocusing on solving customer problems, not buzz words, typically is the right path.
- lofaszvanitt 2y agoYeah but sometimes, they just f it up. Like the PS crop tool was aok then they introduced the move the background instead of the crop rectangle way of cropping which is still to this day a terrible experience. Also, Lightroom is one of the worst camera tools out there. It's only known because ADOBE...
- dmurray 2y agoI would interpret it that they're getting the same push from Wall Street and the same investor-hype-driven product leadership as every other tech firm, but this time they have the good fortune to specialize in one of the few verticals (image editing) where generative AI currently has superhuman performance. This is a testable claim: where were Adobe in previous hype cycles? Googles "Adobe Blockchain"...looks like they were all about blockchains in 2018 [0], then NFTs and "more sustainable blockchains" in 2022 [1]. [0] https://blog.adobe.com/en/publish/2018/09/27/blockchain-and-the-digital-trust-economy https://blog.adobe.com/en/publish/2018/09/27/blockchain-and-... [1] https://www.ledgerinsights.com/adobe-moves-to-sustainable-blockchains/ https://www.ledgerinsights.com/adobe-moves-to-sustainable-bl...
- TheOtherHobbes 2y agoThe article says clearly there's no guarantee this feature will be released. Which I'm reading as "Demo-ready, but far from production-ready." Somewhat relevant: my experience with Photoshop's Generative Fill has been underwhelming. Sometimes it's wrong, often it's comically wrong. I haven't had many easy wins with it. IMO this is a company that doodles with code for its own entertainment, not a company that innovates robust and highly useful production-ready features for the benefit of users. So we'll see if Mr Spinny Dragon makes it to production, and is as useful as billed in the demo.
- DowagerDave 2y agoyou don't need to release to production for real value. I'm under intense pressure to scope out frothy AI features because just discussing them with prospects has a material impact on the costs of the sales funnel.
- BlueTemplar 2y agoThis sounds closer to fake value.
- DaiPlusPlus 2y ago> just discussing them with prospects [...] sales funnel I'll admit I have no idea what % of Adobe licensees/subscribers are individuals and small visual/graphic design firms (who choose Adobe for personal reasons) compared to larger companies (news agencies, web-design body-shops, etc) where employees use the tools given to them despite any personal preferences for rivals like Procreate, etc - and the rest: students, hobbyist photographers, etc. ...but none of the aforementioned market-segments seem like they'd make "AI" (whatever that means) any part of their purchasing-decision. Buzzwords only help sales when the audience is ignorant and/or impressionable; and when your audience are well-informed, seasoned (and cynical) professionals then buzzwords have the opposite effect and damage a company's credibility. ...so I'm not sure who, exactly, Adobe is trying to message with their press-copy for Adobe Firefly (their "generative AI for business" product); perhaps it's just a charade meant only for their shareholders? I'm glad they aren't copying Microsoft and shoving AI branding where it really doesn't belong and compromising the user-experience (...at least not so the same extent).
- mkrishnan 2y ago[dead]
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoMore like "ship some half baked bullshit wrapper for ChatGPT or llama and call it revolutionary."
- kenjackson 2y agoThat approach makes sense for very specific domain-tethered technologies. But for AI I think letting it loose and allowing people to find their own use cases is an appropriate way to go. I've found valuable use cases with ChatGPT in the first months of its public release that I honestly think we still wouldn't have if it went through a traditional product cycle.
- yalogin 2y agoCounterpoint, the pandering to the market has better stock price appreciation :) Also I am sure Adobe is doing both. They released an OpenAI competitor recently
- johnnyanmac 2y agoBeen doing both. Just look at their asset store as of late. Complete mess if you work professionally. At the same time, apparently their generative autofill is top notch. It's just a shame the industry decided to mix together ML tools with generative art, so that it's hard to tell which from which on a casual glance
- bryanrasmussen 2y ago>Rather than what many BigTech companies are currently doing this BigTech strategy or perhaps also Big money strategy is a common feature of all hype bubbles, see XML as an example. Perhaps caused by the people with the big money not knowing anything about the technology but having a feeling that this will produce some valuable things, therefore throw a bunch of money at everything, those things that survive will reward us, the other stuff we write off.
- chucke1992 2y agoAdobe has a powerful moat. That's why companies like MSFT can find better way to integrate AI into workflows rather than just AI companies without any moat.