6 ms·
Scientists successfully breed corals to improve their heat tolerance
- mike_hearn 2y agoHere's the latest data from AIMS, the Australian government agency that monitors the Great Barrier Reef [1]. There are three periods in these graphs: 1. 1985-2013. Climatologists report global warming during this period, but it had no impact on the corals. This fact is already a major problem for the claim that corals are hurt by global warming - if it were true, there should have been declines in this period. 2. 2010-2017. A big drop. This triggered lots of stories about how humanity is killing the corals. In 2019 they were saying the outlook had moved from "poor" to "very poor". [2] 3. 2020-2024. Robust growth to the highest levels ever seen, more than a third larger than the prior stable period. This time series is incompatible with the idea of a link between CO2 and coral health. Whatever caused this set of changes is unlikely to be human driven, given that the huge growth spurt caught self-proclaimed coral experts completely off guard and they still lack any explanation for what drives these changes. But we can safely say that corals are already heat tolerant. They exist in a wide range of temperatures across the world, which vary by far wider ranges than climate change is predicted to generate, and they have existed throughout history in which natural climate change has created vastly greater differences than seen in the last 100 years. Unfortunately AIMS don't seem interested in a true understanding of the corals. They are only interested in coral doom. Doom = a call to action = money and social status, whereas corals doing fine reduces them to mere observation of natural cycles, which doesn't have much potential for career growth. From the peak of "the Great Barrier Reef is going from poor to very poor" now they are reduced to saying "recent increases in hard coral cover can be quickly undone" and "The high coral cover reported this year is good news but does not mean all is fine". Their reports give the strong impression that they really wish the corals would do badly, but nature is feeling uncooperative right now. Their next best strategy is apparently to just ignore it and pretend scientists have to save the day anyway. [1] https://www.aims.gov.au/monitoring-great-barrier-reef/gbr-condition-summary-2023-24 https://www.aims.gov.au/monitoring-great-barrier-reef/gbr-co... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/aug/30/great-barrier-reef-outlook-now-very-poor-australian-government-review-says https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/aug/30/great-ba...
- theultdev 2y agoIt would be nice if people responded to you instead of downvoting silently. Thank you for the information. It's also worth noting the Great Barrier Reef is fairly new (6-8k years old). It came to be from the sea rise of the Last Glacial Maximum 20k years ago.
- digging 2y agoInformation is fine, overconfident denialist commentary earns a downvote. When you see a comment to the effect of "The self-proclaimed experts are wrong! I know the truth," you should heavily discount the conclusions it draws. Just because the mechanism of resurgence is unknown does not mean that all previous science on the topic is invalidated. It can simultaneously be true that ocean warming is devastating the Great Barrier Reef corals and that the GBR has the ability to rebound on its own. Here's a question the parent comment didn't address: Are we seeing the same species in this resurgence that we saw before mass bleaching, or is biodiversity reduced?
- theultdev 2y agoYour last sentence would have been a fine reply to the GP without any meta level commenting. And GP's main point was that the data from the experts monitoring the reef did not line up with the climate change predictions of the reef. He didn't say HE knew the truth, he's saying the truth from scientific reports are not matching the predictions. If anything, he's pointing out the real "experts" data. The opposite of what you are accusing him of.
- digging 2y ago> Your last sentence would have been a fine reply to the GP without any meta level commenting. I get that but I stand by all of it though. > data from the experts monitoring the reef did not line up with the climate change predictions of the reef. That's normal. > He didn't say HE knew the truth, Well, that was a paraphrase of the unwarranted confidence in each of these statements, which I find extremely dubious: > This fact is already a major problem for the claim that corals are hurt by global warming - if it were true, there should have been declines in this period It's easy to imagine that warming would not have any effect up until reaching a certain tipping point, so this is overstated as evidence-against. > This time series is incompatible with the idea of a link between CO2 and coral health. Basically a restatement of the above. They're not incompatible. > Whatever caused this set of changes is unlikely to be human driven "Unlikely" is also an overstatement. These data can cast doubt but aren't strong enough to say that anthropogenic causes are unlikely, given how likely it frankly is due to the scale of changes in the ocean. > But we can safely say that corals are already heat tolerant. No, we can't say this. Some corals are heat-tolerant. > they have existed throughout history in which natural climate change has created vastly greater differences than seen in the last 100 years. This is... borderline misinformation. It ignores the rate of change, which is just not really a credible way to discuss climate change. Also, specifically, which changes has coral survived? I don't actually know how old coral is or which mass extinctions it has survived which is actually pretty important for making a comparison. Etc. Not really worth going over every point, you get the idea.
- irthomasthomas 2y agoI thought nitrogen pollution was now considered the main cause of harm to corals?
- yogurtboy 2y agoAccording to what?
- manvillej 2y agoNitrogen pollution compounds with heat stress, it makes the coral more susceptible to heat stress: https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1915395117 https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1915395117
- eleveriven 2y agoNitrogen pollution and warming ocean temperatures a deadly combination
- eleveriven 2y agoI think it's not the only one
- joshtbradley 2y agoI find it tragic that it’s easier for scientists to perform miracles than it is for humanity to care for the planet. I understand the issue is complex, fraught with incentive, and has disparity between the developed and undeveloped world. But if the outcome is a clear collective benefit, why don’t we do it? More practically. What will it take to create a world where humanity can align to help ourselves?
- slibhb 2y agoScientists "performing miracles" is humanity caring for the planet. Ask yourself why you (apparently) prefer degrowth to this.
- uulu 2y ago> Scientists "performing miracles" is humanity caring for the planet. Scientists "performing miracles" is one of the ways humanity is caring for the planet.
- michaelteter 2y agoScientists have been doing things (with good intentions) which initially look like great ideas but ultimately cause new/greater problems in the future for ages. To f with nature and believe the full impact is understood in advance is human hubris.
- simianparrot 2y agoDepends. Do we know the ecosystem impact of corals that are more heat tolerant? Do we understand the evolutionary biological reasons why they aren't? Maybe it's not a problem, or maybe it is, like with so many other things we've messed with in the name of acceptable science (at the time) until we realize ecosystems are not that simple to model. I'm not saying we shouldn't do research like this. But it is not an automatic good, and it must go hand in hand with proper biological field work looked at from an evolutionary lens. Or we risk making things worse with our good intentions.
- ASalazarMX 2y ago
- pvaldes 2y agoSorry to pop the party but we need perspective. "Scientists breed successfully corals" is not a big deal, marine aquarium keepers reproduce many easy species for decades and have developed the technology to help with that. The problem is that this is a titanic task. There are >350 species of hard corals with zooxanthelae and they have very long life cycles. The second part of the title is more problematic. The real meat in the article is that the results, the increase in heat tolerance, were minor. Even the authors say that will be unable to cope with the changes coming. Is interesting and relevant to know that the larvae could grow, but we don't even know if this changes are permanent or will have consequences later on a species able to live for 3000 ears. And sadly half of the coral reefs in the planet present in 1950 were lost in just a generation of humans.
- soco 2y agoAnd then there are only other 65654867142 species the scientists should increase the tolerance to heat, ash, plastics, oil and a few others, and we're done! </s>
- keepamovin 2y agoNot sure this is a good idea. What if the disappearance of corals at higher temps is part of a natural regulation system for Earth, where if they are artificially preserved, homeostasis will be perturbed? In general I am against these ecosystem engineering type projects: because the systems are so complex, we do not understand them, and we cannot test in isolation.
- empath75 2y agoThere is no natural regulation system for the earth, and the earth makes no attempt at homeostasis. It has been tipped over into states almost completely inhospitable for then-existing life more than once.
- carapace 2y agoMulticellular lifeforms are the machinery that microbes build to improve homeostasis. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaia_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaia_hypothesis
- Vecr 2y agoI think the theory is doubtful. Sounds too outcome oriented/group-selection-y.
- carapace 2y agoAre you at all familiar with the work of Michael Levin et. al.? E.g. "What Bodies Think About: Bioelectric Computation Outside the Nervous System" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjD1aLm4Thg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjD1aLm4Thg
- keepamovin 2y agoThere is. It's chemistry and physics, even basic reactions have equilibria. There's multilayered homeostasis mechanisms interacting around the world. It's a large part of weather. You should read up on it, it's interesting.
- andrewmutz 2y agoPerhaps a dumb question, but wouldn't we expect the rise in ocean temperatures to be cause nature to be doing this selective breeding right now?
- DoreenMichele 2y agoNature doesn't do selective breeding. "Survival of the fittest" means "whatever doesn't die, wins." First you need things capable of not dying in x circumstances. After adversity kills everything else, you have the "winners." This will incline species to develop tolerance over time, usually several generations. Human caused climate change is happening on a timescale that isn't very supportive of that process.
- worldsayshi 2y agoAt least some corals must be able to survive the current transformation? At least some past extinction events must've been very abrupt and things like corals lived through that?
- DoreenMichele 2y agoSupposedly one past extinction event killed off all dinosaurs, leaving rats and other small mammals to take over the world. Dragonflies used to have like two foot or four foot wings spans. Now their relatively small and presumably play a very different role in the ecosystem. Mother Nature isn't some Christian God that loves you and looks out for you. The fact that nature isn't looking out for our welfare is likely why things like Christianity are popular: Because actual reality scares the hell out of people and they need some kind of emotional opiate so they can go "La la la not listening!" and get through the damn day.
- blindriver 2y agoWrong. This is not how evolution works. RIGHT NOW there are coral that are already heat resistant. When the ocean temperature rises, the corals that can’t tolerate it will die off and the ones that can tolerate will survive. Then because of less resources being used by those that died, the coral with heat tolerance will thrive. This is how evolution works.
- jmyeet 2y agoSo while I 100% agree we have man-made climate change, there are two principles to live by: 1. Not everything is climate change. This has come up a lot with Hurricanes Helene and Milton recently, saying they're "unprecedented" or similar superlatives. Consider the 1916 flood of Asheville [1], also caused by a hurricane. Also, hurricanes aren't more frequent [2] but there's an argument to be made for intensity. A moving statistical distribution takes a lot of data points to quantify, however; and 2. We really have no idea of how the EArth will respond to climate change. This comes up when people talk about "runaway climate change" a la Venus. My argument is that if that was going to happen, it would've happened at some point in the last 4 billion years. That's a really long time. So in relation to coral and the seas, the argument is made that warming is a lot more rapid than what naturally occurs. It turns out that's not true either. Consider abrupt climate change in the last Ice AGe (~100K years) [3]: > One of the most surprising findings was that the shifts from cold stadials to the warm interstadial intervals occurred in a matter of decades, with air temperatures over Greenland rapidly warming 8 to 15°C (Huber et al. 2006) That's a massive change and it's happened many times in the last 100,000 years. So what's happened over 4 billion years? This is likely associated with sea changes too so what happened to all the coral? Did it die and regrow? Did it adapt? I understand the motivation here but fearmongering (even if justified) just doesn't work to educate people and ultimately change policy [4]. Psychologically, catastrophic predictions will tend to get ignored because hey, there's nothing you can do. [1]: https://www.frenchbroadrafting.com/blog/remembering-the-flood-of-1916 https://www.frenchbroadrafting.com/blog/remembering-the-floo... [2]: https://www.npr.org/2024/10/09/nx-s1-5146477/how-climate-change-is-powering-more-intense-hurricanes https://www.npr.org/2024/10/09/nx-s1-5146477/how-climate-cha... [3]: https://www.nature.com/scitable/knowledge/library/abrupt-climate-change-during-the-last-ice-24288097/ https://www.nature.com/scitable/knowledge/library/abrupt-cli... [4]: https://heartland.org/opinion/climate-change-fearmongering-isnt-working-anymore/ https://heartland.org/opinion/climate-change-fearmongering-i...
- moi2388 2y agoKind of. Climate change has occurred in the past, and climate and weather are chaotic systems. But we can still determine where the attractor lies, and that it’s moving. I still think we shouldn’t focus on climate change, since the majority of the population won’t understand, nor care. Instead focus on environment, which is what you’re living in right now. The benefit is that doing what’s good for the environment year on year would also accomplish what’s good for climate
- MarkMarine 2y agoI’ve been scuba diving for 20 years and I’ve seen the devastation first hand. Once healthy eco systems, teeming with life, just completely wiped out. It’s heartbreaking. Corals grow so slowly, this might improve things 100-200 years from now, which is not nothing, but no one should delude themselves into thinking this is a solution. The fish that depend on these reefs will not be able to wait 100 generations for us to engineer a solution. That biodiversity will be lost and will take millions of years to recover. A great doc about this: https://youtu.be/aGGBGcjdjXA?si=fnYuvjTDqAkRE3Ad https://youtu.be/aGGBGcjdjXA?si=fnYuvjTDqAkRE3Ad
- candiddevmike 2y agoHave you stopped scuba diving? Aren't you concerned that your scuba diving contributes to the destruction?
- consumer451 2y agoI am aware of only three ways that diving could affect coral. 1) Boat's anchor doing physical damage, which is why popular dive spots have mooring buoys. 2) Many popular sun screen lotions are really bad for coral. 3) Physically touching the coral can do damage, even if gently. Are there any other factors of which I am unaware?
- theultdev 2y agoThis is a valid concern as Thailand barrier reefs made great recovering during the covid period (hinting that tourism could have had major effects)
- chris_va 2y agoMy understanding is that there are lots of existing corals well adapted to high heat/low pH, mostly from shallow atolls. ... But, if you transplant them they get outcompeted immediately. Corals are constantly engaged in a WW1-style trench warfare for space, so spending metabolic energy on something other than eradicating one's neighbor is not a great strategy. (I work in a tangential area)
- swayvil 2y agoGod forbid we stop consuming everything in sight like a fat kid in a candy shop.
- daedrdev 2y agoI mean its easy to say this, but asking people to live worse lives is basically impossible.
- carapace 2y agoThis is a common misconception. The choice isn't between a mildly worse life -or- a better life. The choice is between a mildly worse life -or- a horrible life as the planetary life-support system reconfigures itself into a radical new climate regime. And really, living in harmony with Nature is fun and fulfilling, so the choice is between a mildly inconvenient transitional period to a hip, swinging, easy living, eco-friendly life -or- a horrible life as the planetary life-support system reconfigures itself into a radical new climate regime.
- DoreenMichele 2y agoTry to promote walkable, mixed-use development that supports a car-optional lifestyle.
- MaxHoppersGhost 2y agoFeel free to stop taking flights, delete your Amazon account, and never buy another plastic-based product again.
- javajosh 2y agoMore like a crew of a spaceship dismantling their life-support system to create disposable junk.
- swayvil 2y agoFunny how improving self-awareness and self-control is always at the bottom of the list of solutions. It's always a new machine, product or pill. (But I think that public access to hallucinogens is a step in the right direction, actually)
- jeffreyfq3000 2y agoAs far as I know there is one local guy here in Yomitan, Okinawa doing this already for quite some time.