5 ms·
Tesla's value drops $60B after investors fail to hail self-driving 'Cybercab'
- johng 2y agoElon overpromising and underdelivering is finally starting to catch up to him. I'm amazed it has lasted this long. The whole FSD and their false advertising, and the danger it has put people in should have been illegal. I'm a huge fan of SpaceX but Tesla is another matter.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoI hope Tesla survives, they just need someone honest in charge to continue to focus on EVs and stationary storage. > I'm a huge fan of SpaceX but Tesla is another matter. The competency and skill of Gwynne Shotwell cannot be overstated.
- jprd 2y agoWell said thread. The whole "Cybercab" event had me thinking "who is actually believing this? This just feels like stock fraud". I don't want to be that cynical. I want to drive a car that is all torque and no fumes. I mean, the "Cybercabs", THEY DON'T HAVE CONTROLS. Where is that going to be legal in 2-3 years?
- wcoenen 2y agoIf SF, LA and Phoenix are already allowing Waymo cars that don't have anyone in the driving seat, then why not cars without controls? What's so special about leaving out the controls after having eliminated the driver?
- andrewmcwatters 2y agoFirst responder overrides exist for Waymo.
- ahahahahah 2y ago> What's so special about leaving out the controls after having eliminated the driver? Waymo can give direct control of their vehicles to police or others when appropriate. This mitigates the cost of potential edge cases.
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoThere was a recent evaluation of Tesla's latest self-driving software that showed it's still only averaging 13 miles between necessary human interventions, so comparison with Waymo at this point seems wishful thinking.
- decafninja 2y agoNext year, President Trump, 47th, last, and eternal PoTUS, will reward Elon for his support by legalizing Unsupervised FSD and Tesla Robotaxi across the entire country while prosecuting Waymo and Cruise for tech heresy. Uber, Lyft, and NYC taxi drivers will also be prosecuted for heresy just to be sure. Elon will be appointed to a new cabinet position - the Fabricator General and will be given license to lobotomize people into servitors - AKA Optimus. This will also allow for true FS(ervitor)D. I’m joking of course. I think.
- ensignavenger 2y agoWithin the Boring Companies tunnels? Other private roads and campuses? Of course, that isn't going to drive high sales figures. It sounds more like a specialized vehicle for a narrow market, but the self driving technology should be applicable across their product lines.
- rsynnott 2y ago‘Self-driving’ vehicles (they really run on virtual rails, in practice) for private roads have been around for a while now. They’re generally buses, and it’s _super-niche_; there just aren’t that many obvious use cases.
- sschueller 2y agoGwynne Shotwell promised p2p starship travel. If you want to talk about over promise under deliver, this is straight up vaporware and will never ever happen. Their list of cities include Zürich Switzerland. If you launch a rocket of that size on Zürich lake you will blow out every window in the city...
- r00fus 2y agoYou really think that promise was from Gwynne herself? It sounds like Elon's words coming out of her mouth.
- eigen 2y agowell, she said it in a Ted talk in 2018. https://www.ted.com/talks/gwynne_shotwell_spacex_s_plan_to_fly_you_across_the_globe_in_30_minutes https://www.ted.com/talks/gwynne_shotwell_spacex_s_plan_to_f... at 14:42. starting at 16:37: CA: So you really believe this is going to be deployed at some point in our amazing future. When? GS: Within a decade, for sure. CA: And this is Gwynne time or Elon time? GS: That's Gwynne time. I'm sure Elon will want us to go faster.
- ensignavenger 2y agoSo they still have a few years.
- timeon 2y ago> and will never ever happen That is good thing. It was vanity.
- ChumpGPT 2y agoRegardless how I feel about the guy, I really hope he is successful with FSD and the CyberCab comes to fruition. Society needs these options, they will benefit everyone.
- lesuorac 2y agoI mean, that's the beauty of competition. Self driving cars don't need to come from Tesla.
- rvnx 2y agoThe robotaxi concept was supposed to be that you can hail ANY tesla that the owner opted-in to join the taxi network. Not a separate car model.
- huijzer 2y agoIf I remember correctly, Model Y and Model 3s will start running the network next year in Texas and California, is the plan. The cybertaxi will be available later.
- runako 2y agoDo people still believe this will happen? Like are there people who actually believe that if they buy a Model 3 this year, that it will be able to run completely autonomously next year? Do people really believe that Musk, who said in 2016 that Summon would work across country by 2018, is being at all on the level with any of this? If so, why?
- beAbU 2y agoDo you honestly, hand on heart, believe that this will happen next year?
- darkwater 2y agoWhy the downvotes? They just exposed a statement about what Tesla has said it will do in the near future. Downvotes might think Tesla/Elon lie, sure, but this is not enough to downvote a normal comment.
- doodda 2y agoMusk could unveil the most dazzling technology, but would anyone believe he could actually deliver? It's a self-inflicted credibility issue.
- bitshiftfaced 2y agoI remember being skeptical that anyone would buy a Cybertruck. It was delayed quite a bit, but sure enough I now see them on the road.
- bdcravens 2y agoThey still haven't released everything they promised for the Cybertruck, and the Roadster 2 is still MIA. I suspect it'll all come to fruition, but investors tire of new promises when old ones take such a long time to ship.
- joejohnson 2y agoCybertruck is the perfect example of over promised / under delivered. The Cybertruck is the modern day Delorean, with even worse build-quality issues.
- huijzer 2y agoI don’t know where you get your information from but it seems to be having some bias. Many owners are very happy with the car, and report few build quality issues.
- yladiz 2y agoWhere do you get your information? You're both anecdotal but you accuse the parent of having bias and refute it, yet provide no evidence/link/etc.
- joejohnson 2y agoThere was a recall of the entire first production run because the accelerator pedal would slip off and jam the pedal down.
- rsynnott 2y agoWhat baffles me is, well, did anyone really think they were going to release something? Really? I mean, clearly, yes, some people did, hence the price movement, but _why_?
- SpicyLemonZest 2y agoA price movement doesn't have to mean that anyone expected something better. Tesla's beaten expectations before, so I think a reasonable person could have assigned a 10% chance that they would announce something genuinely game-changing, and a 10% chance is still priced higher than a known 0.
- tim333 2y agoI thought the cab might be something more like a Waymo or Baidu robotaxi, both of which are out there driving passengers around. But no.
- renegade-otter 2y agoRight, this demo was supposed to show the future, but instead it showed the present. It would have been better for the stock if Elon hadn't done anything. "A year away".
- tim333 2y agoHe's got a bit of a problem in that he's said his self driving and taxis should work safer than humans using vision only but the trouble is humans are quite good at navigating the world using vision and who knows when better than human AI will turn up. Waymo etc get around it buy using lidar and the like to make the cars safer than humans even if not as smart. Maybe Musk should have backtracked on the taxis and stuck lidar on as a temporary fix till the human level AI turns up? Otherwise he's stuck with saying maybe next year.
- LarsDu88 2y agoFunny. The article says investors were looking for a lower priced vehicle. Instead they got a "cybercab" that has an outline suspiciously similar to Model 2 concept drawings from China. And also this cybercab also happens to be impractical for ridesharing dimension-wise, but would've slotted directly where the Model 2 would've been had that car been released. Basically they took the steering wheel off the Model 2, came up with a demo, and had a bunch of dudes wearing Oculus headsets remote controlling a bunch of robots.
- piyuv 2y agoCan you share a link/source for “bunch of dudes wearing oculus headsets” claim? I’d love to prove to people tesla is as funny as I think it is.
- aquatica 2y agohttps://gizmodo.com/elon-musks-beer-pouring-optimus-robots-are-not-autonomous-2000510899 https://gizmodo.com/elon-musks-beer-pouring-optimus-robots-a...
- whamlastxmas 2y agoTLDR a reporter asked a robot and believed what it said even when very vague
- gcr 2y ago> Scoble made a follow-up tweet saying he talked with a Tesla engineer to get clarity.
- eig 2y agoFrom Gizmodo article, a reporter asked: Scoble can be heard in the video asking one of the robots, “Hey Optimus, how much of you is AI?” The robot, or whoever was controlling it, seemed to scramble for an answer, saying “I can’t disclose just how much. That’s something you’ll have to find out later.” “But some or none?” Scoble asked with a laugh. “I would say, it might be some. I’m not going to confirm, but it might be some,” the robot responded.
- kleiba 2y agoI don't understand this "car parks will no longer be needed" vision. Is the idea that everyone will use ride sharing to go everywhere? Because that's not going to happen.
- object-a 2y agoEven if everyone does, you'll need enough cars to meet peak demand (which is a lot, especially with a 2 seater model). Where do those cars go to charge outside peak demand?
- sanjayio 2y agoBattery swap and back on the road. Obviously moving to this model would require changing conventional thinking. Cars don’t need to be parked, just like an IP address doesn’t need to “rest”. It’s just a pool of resources.
- chacham15 2y agoThe idea is that if enough people use ride sharing, the total number of cars needed will decrease, therefore, the needed space to put those cars will decrease. It doesnt necessarily require that everyone use it, but its about reducing the total number of cars necessary. If the density of these cars are sufficiently high, I can see a world where not owning a car is more convenient than owning one (if it isnt cost prohibitive).
- piyuv 2y agoThat world and system exists, its called public transportation and Europe
- orwin 2y agoEven in europe a lot of people do own cars. If you have a friend network that really works you can manage without (we share two cars between 5 drivers), but realistically extremely cheap rideshare would be better for us in the long term (we lucked out on a deal with a car dealer who closed shop in a hurry, but now the cars are 12 years old and it start to show, even sharing the repair bills)
- kleiba 2y agoThe closest city from where I currently live has been trying really hard to push for alternative means of transportation. They envision more bycicles and public transport, and in order to get there, they've been systematically making it harder for cars to operate in the city. Measures include less parking, low speed limits in the inner city, lots of one-way streets everywhere, presumably all with the intention of making car usage less appealing. And it is. Except that the result is that instead of switching to bikes or PT, people still use their cars but drive around in circles much longer which cannot be in anybody's interest. Or, if folks are sick of being nannied, they just drive to another big city that's not too far away, and do their shopping there.
- sgu999 2y ago> Except that the result is that instead of switching to bikes or PT, people still use their cars but drive around in circles much longer Do you have sources for that claim? Most cities in western Europe have been doing that, and it seems to pay off. The whole of the Netherlands or Copenhaguen are very good examples of policies like these having worked to the perfection, but it takes time for people to change their habits.
- kleiba 2y agoNo source as in peer reviewed study, no, only anecdotal evidence (personal experience). To me, if you want less cars driving around, it would make sense to build the infrastructure in a way that they can get to their destination as quickly as possible. And it is certainly not a secret that inner cities in Europe - apart from maybe the big tourist magnets - have been dying for a number of years. There's already a big threat for stores in cities through internet shopping, and I've heard of concepts to counter that by designing cities in a way that shopping trips will become more wholesome "experiences". That is, if you go for a shopping day, it's not just from one store to the next, but there's an offer of exhibitions, shows, music etc. mixed with excellent dining opportunities etc., all interwoven with the commercial stores. But, if your "experience" begins with a drive designed to make it as hard as possible to get to where you want, I'm not sure it's going to work. You can try to change people's attitudes, but all things equal, for many people I would bet the ideal shopping experience would be the comfort of their own car to get to and from the shops, together with having the chance to drop off your bags every now and then in your own trunk.
- dzink 2y agoThis event feels like Tesla has lost its product sense completely. A two seater taxi? Seriously? What about families with kids? Doors that open out and up - what about all the right spaces in cities where you need to open a car door? Look at minivans or London cabs for taxi design, not two seaters. Then there is the whole: any tesla can be a part of the fleet, then only extra paid FSD teslas can be part of the fleet, and now no-wheel nobody-wants-this-mobiles bait and switch. Investors ought to be upset. This was a shot from the hip instead of proper innovation.
- janalsncm 2y ago“Innovation” is generous here. That usually requires a working prototype. Maybe they should put together a “demo” of faster-than-light travel next. This was closer to ideation.
- xnx 2y agoTesla cars are fine, but [even after today] the stock is still way overpriced compared to other manufacturers. The previous explanation was some handwaving about how autonomous-driving was super-valuable. After last night it is mor clear than ever that Tesla autonomous driving is a running joke that not funny. I'd love to have a real competitor to Waymo, but everyone else is [at best] 5 years behind.
- janalsncm 2y agoBased on the performance of Tesla stock, it seems like their demos are their product, rather than their cars. Investors have bought Tesla stock based on hype and promises of future performance, rather than actual company fundamentals. You can only distract people for so long with grand promises for the future. The problem is that the fundamentals aren’t amazing. Tesla is getting its butt kicked in China (world’s biggest auto market) and tariffs are the only thing stopping BYD and Nio from taking a huge bite out of Tesla. Tesla has essentially saturated the “has a place to charge and $35k+ for a new car” market in the US. The sub $20k market is up for grabs. And US protectionism won’t save Tesla in other countries’ markets.
- debian3 2y agoI’m in China, there’s a few Tesla, but the bulk of it is BYD and Geely. Not sure why Nio always get mentioned, they are not that popular.
- _sys49152 2y agofirst of all this stock has been highly manipulated ever since the "funding secured" tweet. the stock price cannot be taken seriously either direction.