10 ms·
It is ridiculous. From Google's reply (https://blog.google/outreach-initiatives/public-policy/epic-games-verdict-appeal/ https://blog.google/outreach-initiative
by xnx 2y ago
It is ridiculous. From Google's reply (https://blog.google/outreach-initiatives/public-policy/epic-games-verdict-appeal/ https://blog.google/outreach-initiatives/public-policy/epic-...): "These Epic-requested changes stem from a decision that is completely contrary to another court’s rejection of similar claims Epic made against Apple — even though, unlike iOS, Android is an open platform that has always allowed for choice and flexibility like multiple app stores and sideloading."
- gjsman-1000 2y ago[flagged]
- meiraleal 2y ago> Initially, there wasn't a requirement to ship Android with an app store That's exactly the same case for iphones, Steve Jobs initial plan (and execution) was to install apps from Safari, the prototype of PWAs.
- gjsman-1000 2y agoTrue; except that the iPhone didn't allow apps from anywhere, at all. Consider damages, from a legal perspective. Can you claim damages, because you can't write apps for your proprietary 3D Printer? Can you claim damages, because you can't write apps for your dishwasher? Can you claim damages, because you can't write apps for an ecosystem which is, and was, always closed? No, no, and (currently) no. You absolutely can claim damages though for building up an ecosystem that then turns into a bait-and-switch. Case: Android. Edit: Also, the commenter below is wrong. Steve Jobs talked about the 30% cut in the very introduction of the App Store. The 30% cut was also required on all in-app purchases, but by a legal agreement instead of an automated collection method.
- meiraleal 2y agoAs someone mentioned, the app store started without a 30% cut so they also baited and switched. The only difference is that Apple won the case because Justice works like that. Different judges and it would have lost too.
- placeholderTest 2y agoExcept the App Store was announced 16 years ago and the 30% cut was definitely part of the announcement. There’s a whole slide with Steve Jobs discussing it 3 minutes in. The other commenter was mistaken.
- whimsicalism 2y ago> Apple's claim is simple: The monopoly was from the very beginning, when the iPhone had 0.0% market share. If it was anti-competitive, the iPhone would have failed. If developers didn't like it, the iPhone would have failed. Has Apple unfairly done anything new now that they have a monopoly? No. Did Apple raise their 30% royalty to 70% when they had a monopoly? No. Apple did not have a 30% cut for in-app purchases when the iPhone was created, just App Store purchases. In-app revenue tax was instituted in 2011 e: No clue why this is downvoted
- gjsman-1000 2y ago> In-app revenue tax was instituted in 2011 However, Apple still collected a 30% fee, just manually. It wasn't an integrated system, but you had to sign a legal agreement for the kickback.
- whimsicalism 2y ago> However, Apple still collected a 30% fee, just manually. It wasn't an integrated system, but you had to sign a legal agreement for the kickback. Source on this prior to 2011? I don't believe it is true but I might be mistaken.
- sbuk 2y agohttps://youtu.be/xo9cKe_Fch8?t=214 https://youtu.be/xo9cKe_Fch8?t=214 Video is from 2008, literally took me all of 5 minutes to find.
- jncfhnb 2y ago> Apple's claim is simple: The monopoly was from the very beginning, when the iPhone had 0.0% market share. If it was anti-competitive, the iPhone would have failed. If developers didn't like it, the iPhone would have failed. Has Apple unfairly done anything new now that they have a monopoly? No. Did Apple raise their 30% royalty to 70% when they had a monopoly? No. The problem is not a monopoly on hardware. The problem is gatekeeping access to software markets.
- gjsman-1000 2y ago> The problem is gatekeeping access to software markets However, it started out this way, from the beginning, and developers accepted it. This is easily demonstrable - customers would not have bought devices without apps, and vice versa. Very hard to show, in a court of law, that the terms which were once acceptable now magically aren't. The law isn't interested in people who say, "yes, it was a perfectly fine contract, 10 years ago, but now it's a problem even though it hasn't changed." Imagine what would happen to mortgages.
- talldayo 2y ago> it started out this way, from the beginning, and developers accepted it. Developers did not accept it. Some did, but any amount does not constitute complete acceptance. From the very beginning, iOS had people developing alternatives to the App Store a-la Cydia. Apple's terms were always controversial. Apple's constituent of app developers does not even remotely reflect the attitude (or assent) of the development community as a whole. It certainly doesn't represent a competitive or regulated market of software comparable to the web, the Mac, Android or Windows.
- gjsman-1000 2y agoThe legal agreement, and the fact developers signed it, even if begrudgingly, back when iOS did not have a monopoly in any way, is the only assent the law needs to consider. Student loans certainly don't have much assent 5 years after graduation.
- frizlab 2y agoTHIS. And this is the main reason why I hate the EU decisions. Apple was always 100% clear on their message. The App Store is a closed ecosystem. You hate it? You don’t have to use it. You can do PWAs. If they attacked Apple on their PWA support, I’d have backed the case (though nobody cares, obviously). But the case as it is now is dumb.
- wiseowise 2y agoYou hate EU decisions because they cracked down on clown monopoly?
- frizlab 2y agoHow is the iPhone a monopoly? You don’t want an iPhone you don’t buy an iPhone, there’s literally thousands of alternatives…
- wiseowise 2y agoWhen it occupies half the market and life is increasingly dependent on your phone it’s no longer “don’t like - don’t buy”. How about “don’t like the changes - stop using Apple”? Huh? What’s stopping you from finding another Apple if there are thousands of alternatives?
- frizlab 2y agoThere are no closed-ecosystem alternatives!! However there are thousands of alternatives to Apple. It is don’t like don’t buy, as literally NO ONE NOR ANY SITUATION FORCES YOU TO BUY AN iPhone. You need a PHONE, not an iPhone. Also in what world does Apple have half the market?
- wiseowise 2y ago> There are no closed-ecosystem alternatives!! Any Android phone is closed-ecosystem if you don’t enable sideloading. > However there are thousands of alternatives to Apple. Nice! So you have plenty of choice if you don’t like where it goes with Apple. > It is don’t like don’t buy, as literally NO ONE NOR ANY SITUATION FORCES YOU TO BUY AN iPhone. You need a PHONE, not an iPhone. That’s correct, so there’s no issue with someone enforcing Apple to make changes, because you can always switch to something else? > Also in what world does Apple have half the market? In a world called US, Canada and good chunk of Europe. https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/iphone-market-share-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/iphone-ma...
- fredgrott 2y agounlike Google's reply read the OEM terms that they sign....its not open like Google claims....
- ascagnel_ 2y agoThey got caught doing the same thing Microsoft got caught doing in the 90s with IE/Netscape -- using their monopoly position on one piece of software (Windows, the Google app suite) to prevent their OEMs from shipping another piece of software by default (Netscape, Epic Games Store) that directly competed with their own offering (Internet Explorer, Google Play Store). Since Google and Microsoft both use OEMs, unlike Apple in their parallel case, there's a clearer line to how Google is being unfair compared to how Apple is being unfair. In short, Epic sued and won because Google got between them and Samsung. In general, in the courts, it's a lot easier to ask a judge or jury for someone to stop doing a thing (blocking their software from being pre-installed) vs. forcing someone to do something they're not currently doing (allowing any third-party app stores).
- to11mtm 2y ago> In short, Epic sued and won because Google got between them and Samsung. This is actually very insightful given the history between Google and Samsung with Tizen.
- nijave 2y ago>allowing any third-party app stores Couldn't you reword that as allowing unsigned and self signed software to be installed? You can push your own apps to your iOS device but iirc Apple artificially limits the number of self signed apps that can be installed
- ascagnel_ 2y agoAside from the EU explicitly mandating it, the developer agreement you sign with Apple in order to ship software on their platform prohibits you from doing so. And while you theoretically can write your own storefront, running self-signed apps isn’t going to be a viable user story with the way Apple’s set it up (intentionally, in my opinion).
- ethbr1 2y agoIt's probably not a great idea to point at a monopoly, as a defense of one's own monopoly, and claim "Yeah, but he did it worse." Both Google and Apple's platforms need to be cracked open to competition.
- zamadatix 2y agoI can see why they'd want to say "our competitor does it worse but we're the only ones being regulated". Sure, they'd rather not be regulated at all... but, if they are, then they want to be regulated no worse than their competitor.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mvdtnz 2y agoWell because it's their competitor, who now has a huge legally-enforced advantage.
- Electricniko 2y agoI liked the absurdity of one of the top comments on the Verge article, which was that under the requirements of this ruling, Apple could open up an app store for Android and Google would be forced to put it on their Play Store.
- freedomben 2y agoMeanwhile, Google can't even put their own wildly popular web browser on the Apple app store
- SllX 2y agoChrome is on there and people still use it. It’s just not using Blink. Web browser ≠ rendering engine.
- jiggawatts 2y agoNext, EBay should be allowed to use Amazon warehouses and their distribution network.
- Urgo 2y agoEbay sellers already can do this [1] [2] [1] https://www.edesk.com/blog/ebay-fulfillment-amazon-fba/ https://www.edesk.com/blog/ebay-fulfillment-amazon-fba/ [2] https://sell.amazon.com/fulfillment-by-amazon https://sell.amazon.com/fulfillment-by-amazon
- kristjank 2y agoIt has allowed it, but it intentionally cripples alternative markets. For example, I cannot allow F-Droid to autoinstall and autoupdate apps on my phone if I don't have a rooted device.
- MemoryOfSand 2y agothat has been untrue for a little while: https://f-droid.org/2024/02/01/twif.html https://f-droid.org/2024/02/01/twif.html
- shrx 2y agoAlso, applications installed through FDroid cannot be used in Android Auto. For example OsmAnd navigation.
- getfroggie 2y ago[dead]
- hilbert42 2y ago"even though, unlike iOS, Android is an open platform that has always allowed for choice and flexibility..." It would be informative to know—by jurisdiction—the stats of what type of smartphone OS the key deciders had in their pockets.