18 ms·
Is the attack helicopter dead?
- bhouston 2y agoI think most manned war vehicles are dead now. We are definitely entering into the era of drone-vs-human warfare. Drones are cheap and deadly and can be remotely operated, and soon probably operated by AI.
- hollerith 2y agoYeah, well, the Ukrainian army is on record saying they'd rather have more artillery shells than more drones.
- rdtsc 2y agoThey work well together, so give them both.
- recursive 2y agoArtillery shells are not manned vehicles.
- HPsquared 2y agoThat's another instance of quantity beating quality. It's the same type of thing.
- ponector 2y agoThat means only they need more shells at the moment than drones. Ukraine has capacity to produce enough FPV drones.
- Animats 2y agoBoth work together. The drone finds the target. The artillery then destroys the target.
- taneq 2y agoI’d guess they can reuse the drones most of the time?
- ponector 2y agoOnly reconnaissance drones and few heavy bombers. Mostly they use kamikadze FPV drones in pair with Mavic for surveillance.
- matusp 2y agoI am not surprised, drone warfare today requires a lot of people and a lot of manhours, and it does not scale that well. Several guys are often moving the equipment on foot to get as close to the frontline as possible, so that the pilot can have a few shots at delivering a pretty small explosives to a target they might not even found. On the other hand, few conscripts can jump on a Grad and start shooting rockets on a whim.
- bamboozled 2y agoFighter jets, gone ?
- krunck 2y agoThey will be when there are AI controlled aircraft/drones that can exceed the G-force limits that humans require and can thus out maneuver any human controlled fighter.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoCan it out maneuver a missile?
- foota 2y agoThis doesn't seem right to me. The limiting factor here is the ability of an air to air missile to hit a target (and to find the target in the first place). A drone might be more survivable (if it's better at avoiding missiles because of the G-forces etc.,.), but it shouldn't be any better at destroying an enemy jet, right? That theoretical highly maneuverable drone with a highly advanced sensor suite isn't going to be cheap either. At which point, what's the advantage? You wouldn't be bound by the number of pilots, but if the drones are too expensive it doesn't matter.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hagbard_c 2y ago> what's the advantage? You wouldn't be bound by the number of pilots You gave part of the answer right there. Not only would you not be limited by the number of - hard to replace and time-consuming and expensive to train - pilots but you don't run the risk of losing them either. > but if the drones are too expensive it doesn't matter. The large expense for fighter aircraft tends not to lie in the actual production costs but in the development costs which are spread over a limited production run. Build more drones and they get less expensive per item. Build enough of them to overwhelm the enemy and you win drone superiority.
- jltsiren 2y agoHumans have a place in high-end weapon systems until there is a locally running AGI in the system. An actual near-peer war never works the way people expected, and fancy new weapon systems tend to underperform initially. In the absence of an AGI, humans can adapt their behavior in the field faster than tech companies can fix their software and deliver new features.
- throwaway48476 2y agoI've seen people training yolo models on ukraine footage.
- thenaturalist 2y agoI highly doubt that such a general presumption holds. As seen in the case of Russia’s super drone being downed by their own this week after presumably loosing control, only relying on unmanned vehicles en mass leads to a single point of failure. Disrupt or corrupt signals, disrupt the entire force. The US is the force it is because it can do combined arms like nobody else. Unique capabilities don’t matter if your opponent saturates them with low tech or combined arms. Look at last weeks Iran ICBM barrage vs. iron dome and David’s sling. Sure, unmanned vehicles bring unique capabilities to any field of battle, but combined arms is as much the future as it was the past.
- bhouston 2y ago> Look at last weeks Iran ICBM barrage vs. iron dome and David’s sling. I believe the issue was not overwhelming the defences but rather the defences (Iron Dome and David's sling) were designed for short range and slow rockets from Lebanon or Gaza and not long range fast/high rockets from Iran. It may be that the cost per Arrow missile (for long range intercepts) is $3M as well, so they didn't fire that many of them? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrow_(missile_family) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrow_(missile_family)
- daedrdev 2y agoIron dome is only used against small rockets, and was never intended to hit ballistic or cruise missiles. Thus it's not a failure since they aren't used for that kind of defense. There are separate anti ballistic systems that were used and shot down many of the rockets.
- bhouston 2y agoWhy are you repeating what I said? I am just confused as to why you are "correcting" me in a reply when you are saying the same thing.
- jdietrich 2y agoInterception comes with risks - the debris from that missile has to land somewhere. The only person confirmed to have been killed in the recent Iranian attack was a man in the West Bank who was crushed by part of a destroyed missile. It's clear that at least some of the missiles that got through were deliberately ignored because they were on target to hit open ground.
- BurningFrog 2y agoShouldn't it be more drone-vs-drone?
- bhouston 2y ago> Shouldn't it be more drone-vs-drone? For the sake of humanity, I wish that was the case, but it won't be. Defensive drones will exist for sure, but generally the targets will be human or infrastructure, not other drones.
- ahartmetz 2y agoYou want to destroy the more valuable thing (human) with the less valuable thing (drone). It could get worse than World War 1.
- nordsieck 2y ago> I think most manned war vehicles are dead now. IMO, submarines - especially nuclear subs probably have decades of life left at a minimum. But yeah - everything else is starting to look very vulnerable.
- decafninja 2y agoWhat’s to stop development of unmanned drone SSNs? Including ones that act as motherships for underwater drone swarms to boot.
- kayodelycaon 2y agoCommunication and detection underwater is a major issue. Radio is not effective at any range. Audio datalinks are short-ranged, low-bandwidth, unreliable, easily jammed, and give away your position. Active sonar gives away your position. High speed both gives away your position and makes passive sonar useless. Torpedoes are forced to use physical wires for remote guidance because nothing else works. It would be pretty easy for someone to develop a quiet, long-range torpedo that can be launched undetected outside active sonar range. (Assuming this capability doesn’t already exist.) Also, SSNs already carry long-range drones called cruise missiles. Manned subs will take a long time to become obsolete.
- decafninja 2y agoMost of what you listed would not be necessary for an autonomous SSN without a “man in the loop” no? Order it to perform a patrol or sit on the seabed, periodically sending up an antennae to listen for updates to orders. If it receives a kill order, it starts hunting. Preposition them at strategic locations if necessary. To be fair, I’m (partly) playing devil’s advocate, but I don’t think the tech to create a fully or nearly fully autonomous attack sub is that far out. Key point is that you would have to be willing to give it more autonomy than the current crop of UAVs.
- anonylizard 2y ago
- ponector 2y agoIFV are not dead, rocket launchers as well. Even tanks are still a key. At the end people are capturing land/city, not drones. But drones are changing warfare. Drone hunting other drones, drone with self guidance - they are being used in battle right now. 500$ or even less is the cost of FPV drone with night camera capable to carry 2kg bomb. Russia is buying soldiers for up to $25000 to be killed by such cheap drone later.
- SJC_Hacker 2y agoThose drones are getting lost / shot down / missing their targets at high rate. But since they are relatively cheap, they almost effectively artillery shells right now. Don't need a high kill rate when you have lots of them.
- ponector 2y agoThat is true, not every drone hits the target. But the same with any other weapon. How many 155 shells are needed to actually hit the target? A moving target? And one regular 155mm shell is 5x more expensive than FPV drone.
- murkt 2y ago155mm shells are $3k-10k per piece. So it’s more like 5-20x than FPV drone.
- verdverm 2y agoBetter discussion by Perun https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnoKpXvj41A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnoKpXvj41A (there is a saying or word for titles as questions, and the answer is always no)
- shawn_w 2y agoBetteridge's law of headlines.
- Pet_Ant 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- googledocsftw 2y ago"Are Betteridge headlines dead?"
- verdverm 2y ago"Is this the one weird trick to rule them all?"
- aspenmayer 2y agoPerun seems to know his stuff. That said, I’d be curious to know more about his research process, as well as that of other Russia-Ukraine war mappers/vloggers. Determining whether grainy drone footage is current or past alone seems difficult to me as an outsider and fan of their work, though I wish it weren’t necessary and that the war were over.
- verdverm 2y agoPerun brings lots of citations and discusses his sources regularly, and always adds caveats. I wouldn't liken his weekly video to those of the daily mappers or telegram video collectors. Very different kinds of content.
- sneed_chucker 2y agoPart of a broader pattern in military technology right now. All weapon systems that consist of an expensive vehicle and an expensive-to-train crew are being re-evaluated against drones right now. If you're fighting a highly asymmetric conflict where your enemies can barely touch your expensive toys then it's less of a concern. If you're fighting near-peer it's a different story.
- HPsquared 2y agoEfficiency starts to matter in a near-peer conflict.
- Retric 2y agoNear-peer conflicts have more meaningful targets which favors these kinds of expensive weapons platforms. A drone that can do meaningful damage to a factory 500+ miles from a front line is either an easy target or it starts to look a lot like a missile with all the associated costs from that.
- torginus 2y agoI think it's more complex than that. The US made Switchblade drones which cost tens of thousands of dollars were outperformed with lightly modified FPVs with grenades, which came in under a thousand.
- SJC_Hacker 2y agoWe don't know if they underperfomed so much as weren't cost effective. If the switchblade costing $10k results in a kill 80% of the time, while the $1k drone is 30% of the time, you just get 3 times as many $1k drones, average about the same kill rate, and save 70% to boot. Or spend the same amount and get about 3x the kill rate.
- OrigamiPastrami 2y agoYour analysis assumes collateral damage is irrelevant.
- paulddraper 2y agoI'm surprise the article didn't mention the US military history. The US Army has not had a evolution of its attack helicopter since the 1970s. I remember because one of my favorite childhood games was Comanche 3. [1] Control a helicopter, not crash, not get shot down, neutralize enemies, and achieve mission objectives -- it was cutting-edge for 1997. The Comanche program was scrapped after more than a decade of development. And the Defiant program was just cancelled last year as well. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comanche_3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comanche_3
- stonethrowaway 2y agoBetween that, F-22, JSF, Hind and A10, we had some great great games that decade. Still miss Fighter Ace on MSN Gaming Zone.
- verdverm 2y agoVTOL VR is a pretty great VR first mil flight sim. It has f-18, f-35, and apache like vehicles. They recently introduced wind effects and EW. Allegedly the radar cross-sectioning is better than DCIS (actually accounts for orientation towards the radar)
- the_af 2y agoIf you haven't already, be sure to checkout MicroProse's [1] "modern" retro flightsim, Tiny Combat Arena. Sure, it's beta and continuously in development (and likely won't be finished, ever), but still, you can take off in a Harrier and blow up stuff. The graphics are charmingly retro. -- [1] published by MicroProse, but actually a one-man effort.
- howard941 2y agoTornado was another terrific sim. It had the best mission planner and immersion even though its simulation of the ALARM was busted. Digital Integrations? Don't remember if that was the publisher.
- russdill 2y agoI remember quite clearly when it was scrapped, because suddenly it was much easier to find a parking spot.
- siliconc0w 2y agoWhoever can most cost effectively put explosives on target wins. The future will be annihilation at a distance with cheap standoff weapons followed by swarms of cheap drones loitering over battlefields to clean up.
- paulddraper 2y agoWe've had ICBMs for some time.
- titanomachy 2y agoDon’t those cost 10s of millions each?
- paulddraper 2y agoLook up what a drone costs.
- SJC_Hacker 2y agoICBMs are not useful in a conventional conflict. BTW Russia and the US at least, saw this coming decades ago. Which was the reason behind the intermediate range missile treaty, which was sadly ripped up in the early 2000s.
- vFunct 2y agoThey likely are useful now, given their costs are going down and can be used in saturation attacks like Iran just did. A single ICBM with a dozen 500lb bombs can take out an fleet of fighters.
- SJC_Hacker 2y agoIf launched from a nuclear country, the attacked country would have to assume nuclear payload. In the case of another nuclear country, this means nuclear retaliation.
- Dwedit 2y agoI've been so overexposed to the meme about criticizing gender identity that I've forgotten that attack helicopters are actual military vehicles.
- punkspider 2y agoNow that you've pointed it out I've also realized there was something off about how I thought about attack helicopters when I first read the title.
- metaphor 2y agoWiki entry[1] and archived short story[2] for anyone else reading the parent's remark and wondering how does one coherently map attack helicopters to gender identity meme. Wow, now I can't unsee it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Sexually_Identify_as_an_Attack_Helicopter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Sexually_Identify_as_an_Atta... [2] https://archive.ph/20200101232918/http://clarkesworldmagazine.com/fall_01_20/ https://archive.ph/20200101232918/http://clarkesworldmagazin...
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoI did not know it was based on a short story!
- dragonwriter 2y agoIt wasn't based on the short story, the short story is a piece of trans literature that took the transphobic meme (which was around first) and turned it into a powerful work of art (for which fhe creator was literally hounded out of public exposure and into a major mental health crisis largely because of people's kneejerk reaction judging the work by its title.
- Kye 2y ago[flagged]
- 2y ago
- bubaumba 2y agoThey shouldn't die, just become robotic with optional remote control. Comparing to copters helis have significant advantages and disadvantages too. I.e. different enough to have different roles
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Animats 2y agoThe US Army is cutting back in this area. The Future Attack Reconnaissance Aircraft, which was a small attack helicopter, has been cancelled.[1] If it flies low and slow over the enemy, it's going to be shot down. Better to send many drones and lose some of them. The concept of tactical air superiority is now questionable. The USAF used to boast that American troops have not had to fight under a hostile sky since 1952. That era seems to be over. There are so many portable systems now that can take out an aircraft. Jam-resistant drones are already a thing. Drones are going to have to be shot down one at a time. This is quite possible but the missiles to do it can cost more than the drones. [1] https://www.defensenews.com/air/2024/02/08/us-army-spent-billions-on-a-new-helicopter-that-now-will-never-fly/ https://www.defensenews.com/air/2024/02/08/us-army-spent-bil...
- Spooky23 2y agoWe’re seeing a spike in UFO sightings, so something has been cooked up and is being tested.
- jvanderbot 2y agoDumb question: Why are 12ga shotguns, possibly on small auto-targeting platforms, not a thing yet? Like a CWIS/CRAM but tiny and for close-in engagements?
- drawnwren 2y agoThe problem with shotguns is that you either have a small number of pellets (12ga) or a small amount of mass to do damage (bird shot). So with 12ga specifically, while it's more effective than a rifle round -- the pellets spread quickly enough that it's only a huge advantage when the drone is in the terminal phase. This is why in WW2, they would put timed fuses inside the AA shells so that they didn't have to hit the aircraft directly with the shell but the round didn't spread so far that it was useless.
- newsclues 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shotgun_slug https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shotgun_slug
- paganel 2y agoA BS article if I ever saw one. Take for example this: > Moreover, the threat is not the organic air defences of battlegroups or a Soviet Motor-Rifle Regiment or Brigade, but dispersed and well-hidden infantry and special forces units equipped with modern MANPADS missile systems. Furthermore, because the enemy forces are operating over the defenders’ own ground, the defence can be cued and alerted to approaching helicopters, given good data connectivity. which is exactly what did NOT happen when the Ukrainians counter-attacked on their own territory, in Southern-Ukraine, when the Russian Ka-52s had a field day (actual, several field days) against incoming Ukrainian heavy armour. These Anglo guys still live in the 1980s, they should ask the Ukrainians what they feel about the "demise" of the attack helicopter, that way maybe non-sense like this won't get published anymore.
- phatfish 2y agoBattle vs war. In the right situation any weapon is effective.
- ponector 2y agoThat counter attack was more than a year ago. Now Ukrainians have drones capable of intercepting slow air targets like drones or helicopters. And they are ten times cheaper than manpads.
- paganel 2y agoThey don’t, plus Russia’s EW capabilities are now so good that stuff like HIMARS has now only a 10% chance of hitting its target (from a recent Western article on the issue), so there’s no chance in hell they’ll let some drones fight their attack helicopters and them (the Russians) not doing anything about it. Which is to say that these delusions won’t help the Ukrainians one bit, nor any other Eastern European army that will possibly fight the same Russians in the near future.
- ponector 2y agoThey don't? Stinger costs $100+k, high speed drone around 1k. There are no viable ways to EW counter man-operated drone capable of locking the target with autopilot. The biggest issue in such approach is opportunity cost: you can quickly fire another manpad, but not a drone.
- colechristensen 2y agoThis is the kind of thing I'm interested in discussing but then stop myself because I'd rather not give anybody any ideas.
- the_gorilla 2y agoI don't know anything about warfare but it's impressive that everyone here is an expert in it. AI, drones, AI powered drones, I just can't keep up.
- bongodongobob 2y agoAll you have to do is Google + GPT and you can be an expert too!
- H8crilA 2y agoMANPADS have generally not changed since the Afghanistan war. And here I mean the Soviet-Afghanistan war, not the twice as long but more or less equally ineffective American-Afghanistan war. If the attack helicopter is dead, then it has already been dead for ~40 years.
- twilo 2y agoWhat does "full scale invasion" mean exactly?
- morkalork 2y agoRussia's Ka-52 were a significant problem for Ukraine in the summer 2023 offensive. When Ukraine's armour would meet massive mine fields and get stymied, it was Ka-52s arriving, popping up over tree lines and taking pot shots at them with ATGMs from a distance that outranged most of their MANPADs. Only a few were taken out by lucky hits near the front. The only reason they aren't seen as much anymore is because Russia was idiotic and kept them parked at an airfield within ATACMS range.
- jonstewart 2y agoCame here to say this. Ukraine also adapted by, most likely, having a roving Patriot that ambushed a few Ka-52s (and a few fixed-wing jets). Western militaries don't seem to have much capability for tactical/mobile medium range air defense. The Russian Air Force has been extremely unimpressive, but has cobbled together an effective tactic now of launching glide bombs at front line targets from relatively safe territory. I am surprised no one has figured out how to put one or two long-range air-air missiles on a loitering high altitude drone.
- indymike 2y ago> Russia's Ka-52 were a significant problem for Ukraine in the summer 2023 offensive This is why in 2024 Ukraine is now shooting down helicopters (they have shot down three now) with FPV drones.
- _3u10 2y agoHelicopters like all CAS require air superiority / supremacy to operate effectively. Neither side has either, so it is not an ideal environment for a helicopter to operate in.
- nl 2y agoPeople in this discussion are concentrating on the drones (which are a big factor) but the massively effective HIMARS and ATACMS is worth noting too. Precision guided artillery has been a game-changer in Ukraine.
- grogenaut 2y agoDonnyR must be calling in joy from his grave
- spacebanana7 2y agoIsn’t there a great deal of overlap? A guided artillery shell is kind of like a fast moving loitering drone. Sometimes shells can even be given more instruction after being fired.
- tetromino_ 2y agoPrecision guided artillery looked like it could be a game changer for about a month or two, then Russia figured out how to spoof and jam it, making guided artillery worse than useless. Ukraine is back to using good old dumb artillery, which isn't too accurate but at least cannot be jammed. Source: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2024/05/24/russia-jamming-us-weapons-ukraine/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2024/05/24/russia-jammi...
- ls612 2y agoThere is high variance in the ECCM capability of US weapons supplied thus far. JDAM and GLSDB have fallen flat while ATACMS and GMLRS have done well for themselves.
- epolanski 2y agoYou're out of loop, HIMARS hasn't been effective for quite some time, since the Russians figured how to remotely jam the GPS and make them miss. That's not to say they are useless as you need extensive coverage over a large front, but it's largely worthless right now. This is by the way why most NATO countries don't love the idea of sharing the latest weapons with Ukraine, they give opposition intelligence on how to counter them. https://thedefensepost.com/2024/05/27/us-himars-ineffective-ukraine https://thedefensepost.com/2024/05/27/us-himars-ineffective-...
- aftbit 2y agoAsk not what you can do to the attack helicopter, but instead what the attack helicopter can do to you. Increase vulnerability is only one side of the coin. If there are still valuable missions that can be better done by an attack helicopter than by a competing system, then they are not dead. But yeah, drones will probably take most of the missions away.
- booleandilemma 2y agoI hope our military is thinking about drones, because when WW3 starts our enemies are going to have millions of tiny software-controlled drones and if we're still fighting like we're in WW2 it's all over for us.
- jandrewrogers 2y agoThe US military pioneered drones at every scale and price point, and has been deploying them operationally in very large numbers for decades. They have by far the most mature and diverse capability of any country at this point. Also, the drones being used in Ukraine by both sides would not survive in a more sophisticated electronic warfare environment.
- happakid7 2y agoAre the Russians not using sophisticated electronic warfare?
- don_esteban 2y agoI would challenge this view: a) every price point - definitely not the low end b) in very large numbers - definitely not 6 digit numbers we see in Ukraine c) Ukraine IS the most hostile EW environment, and various US weapon systems do not fare that great there Yes, US were the first movers and invested a lot - but into expensive high-end systems (and not really tested in challenging EW environment), not ubiquitous low-end. Presumably they are catching-up. Maybe. They are not catching-up in building warships.
- stackedinserter 2y agoAsk Ukrainians, their last year counter-offensive was stopped primarily by Ka-52 helicopters with LMUR/Vikhr guided missiles.
- rjurney 2y ago> There were about 11,846 U.S helicopters that served in the Vietnam War. The U.S records show 5,607 helicopter losses. Are 310 helicopter losses in Ukraine that high? I don't think so. Russia has lost =~ 3K tanks. That's a 10:1 ratio for tank:helicopter, is that high? Helicopters' role may change. They would be ideal drone operator platforms - they already have a weapons operator in a back seat. The right cannon / loadout could take out small drones. Collaborative Combat Aircraft (CCA) style wingmen would work with quadcopters for helicopters. They could expand the sensory capability to avoid surface to air threats.
- warner25 2y agoToday's US Army is dwarfed by the size of the Vietnam-era Army. I love putting this into perspective for people who don't know the history. Those 5,500+ losses would be more than the Army's entire helicopter fleet today; active and reserve components combined. 300+ losses would be huge, like half of the current Apache fleet. I'm not sure that we ever had more than 300 helicopters in Iraq or Afghanistan, even at the peak of the 2007-2010 surges. The co-pilot/gunner actually sits in the front seat of the Apache, by the way.
- rjurney 2y agoThanks, I figured but do you know just how much larger? I am listening to Ken Burns' Vietnam on Audible and I believe we had 200K personnel in Vietnam at the peak... oh shit I just double checked and it was 543K personnel JUST IN VIETNAM. Thanks, mang! Enlightening. That is 25% of our entire military today.
- warner25 2y agoYeah, at the peak of Vietnam we had more troops on the ground than the Army has on active duty today (about 450k). The Army's size declined by half after Vietnam, and then declined by half again in the 1990s. This is a nice figure illustrating active duty end-strength for all services since 1950: https://www.laits.utexas.edu/gov310/media/fad_milper_400.gif https://www.laits.utexas.edu/gov310/media/fad_milper_400.gif That figure doesn't go back as far as WWII, of course. Even the Korea and Vietnam-era Army would be dwarfed by the WWII Army: 8 million troops in 1945. Note that we do also have the Army Reserve and Army National Guard, which effectively doubles the total Army end-strength to about 1 million today. As a career Army officer, I could go on about this, and what it means, and what worries me, all day.
- wisty 2y agoIt's always worth remembering that a soldier who costs a million dollars to train can be killed by a 20 cent bullet. But soldiers still exist. Everything in a war will involve losses that appear asymmetric if you consider losses in isolation. War is a horrible affair. Helicopters won't disappear because they can be shot down, but if UAV, communications, plus artillery can replace them. Communication is the most likely weak link due to countermeasures. All IMO of course.
- anonylizard 2y agoSoldiers exist, but expensive western soldiers are basically a different species compared to the cheap militia of the third world. All the strategic decisions of western militaries is based on the sheer expensiveness of their foot soldiers, which means reluctance to fight ground wars, extreme aversion to casualties etc. It also meant advanced militaries generally shrunk massively in terms of soldier count, ending conscription, making the existing forces more elite and more equipped (Since the meat solider is so expensive anyways). So helicopters, given their decreasing cost effectiveness, is likely to entirely disappear as a tactical weapon. They will be transport only going forward, or some sort of a big drone carrier.
- ericmay 2y agoI’d say western militaries will avoid extreme casualties if they can, but read a bit about the Second Battle of Faluja - the U.S. for example has no problem sending troops into hardcore combat. In fact, I would argue that the U.S., U.K., Israel, and now Ukraine and Russia are the only countries today that have demonstrated the capability to engage in extremely fierce fighting. We’ve also become a lot better at keeping troops alive, which I wouldn’t mistake for a reluctance to engage in heavy fighting. It’s important to remember, and Russia in particular has learned this lesson again most recently, that you need to exercise your military to work out cobwebs and operational problems, and while you can conduct training exercises, nothing resembles the experience from fighting a war. The number of countries with this institutional knowledge and experience continues to dwindle.
- 2y ago
- MarkMarine 2y agoIn the war I fought in, there was a markedly different approach to combat air ops between even just the different service branches. The Army tended to use the Apache like it was a flying tank, hovering and delivering ordinance; the Marines (which is where I fought) flew as low and as quickly as possible even while sending rounds and hellfire missiles downrange. The marines were not losing aircraft in anywhere close to the numbers of the Army when I was there. You need a skilled operator to hit a helicopter moving at 100 knots when it's 15m over the buildings, and we mostly operated at night. I remember watching a ZPU gunner pointing the cannons directly at us and firing, and laughing as the rounds just flew behind the tail. It's my understanding (and from watching the videos that I can get as a civilian) that the Russians still aren't operating their helicopters in a manner that I would be comfortable with if I was inside one. I certainly wouldn't be pumped flying in the environment they are in, with so many MANPADS out there, but there is no way a machine I was in would be hit with an anti-tank missile while we hovered (as was in the article.) Lot of preamble to say: no, I don't think the attack helicopter is dead. Attack helicopters are nimble and can hide in terrain quite well, and even when an attacking force can see them it takes a skilled operator to actually hit them. The single use drones that operate like kamikaze vehicles may throw a winkle into the mix, but a helo flying at 150knots is going to be very challenging to hit for one of those. I expect there will be quite an arms race countering and then counter countering these in the future wars.
- Sephr 2y agoI imagine that moderately sized autonomous VTOL jets will eventually become cheap enough to completely displace attack helicopters for most use cases.
- richardw 2y agoI’d think a variation (vary size, shape to suit task) of this with weapons would do well, since it’ll already be replacing the black hawk. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_V-280_Valor https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_V-280_Valor
- 2y ago
- exabrial 2y agoThe way Russians use them is obsolete… just like Russian tanks. Combined arms maneuvering is what they _should_ be doing. In fact Russia reorganized to theoretically be setup for this sort of maneuvering; they organized into BTGs (battalion tactical groups) which contain basically everything: air defense (area denial and SHORAD), logistics (refuel, resupply, rearm, repair), infantry, armor, air attack, engineering, artillery, and I’m probably leaving a few out. To this end they’ve been completely ineffective. They started as the second best army in the world, then went to the second best army in Ukraine, and now they are the second best army in Russia.
- hajile 2y agoHow do you do combined arms into a minefield? It's a WW1-style mess where combined arms simply don't work. Ukraine tried NATO tactics summer of last year and suffered a catastrophic defeat. Going across minefields requires convoys. Russian helicopters outside of MANPADS range (and too low to be visible to SAM site radar) take out the minesweeper and rear vehicles. Now you've got a bunch of sitting ducks. If it looks like escape is possible, artillery remote-mines the path the minesweeper cleared. Try your luck in the minefield and you get destroyed. Get out to fight and the anti-personnel mines take everyone out. Stay in place and the regular artillery takes out all the troops. At night, you get grenade and RPG-dropping drones with IR cameras so you can't even hide. I ask again, what is your combined arms solution to this mess?
- tomjen3 2y agoDo what Ukraine did: attack in another place. But it is like asking what is the healthy thing to do when you are 300 pounds and can run because you have heart issues: the answer is to never be in that position in the first place. Anyway I assume the US has some sort of remote detonation mine plan for if shit gets hot with NK.
- hajile 2y agoRussia didn't defend Kursk because they didn't think Ukraine would be stupid enough to make that attack. That was a temporary PR win and a permanent strategic loss. The results have been the elimination of Ukraine's best troops AND losing the ability to reinforce faltering lines which is why Russian advances have increased. Maneuver warfare relies on secrecy to a large degree. You can hide strategic troop buildups from the Taliban because they don't have satellites, but not from a near peer. With current spotter drones and IR cameras, you can't really even rely on tactical secrecy.
- throwup238 2y agoWe’re still in the very early stage of drone development for warfare and Ukraine is using a lot of civilian gear. Now the armed forces of the world are plowing their funding into R&D I expect them to develop quickly. For example, aluminum air batteries are perfect for this use case but havent been developed because until now single use batteries haven’t seen any demand. Those will at least double or triple the range for armed drones. High end solar panels can allow them to sit and wait for a trigger to attack. Combine that with the tech behind the Redbull F1 camera drone [1] that can fly at 200mph and drones become much deadlier to attack helicopters. Slap a rocket motor on it for final approach, even a sub-M civilian model rocket motor, and it’s over. Imagine the drone just sitting there listening for a helicopter to get close enough - humans wouldn’t even need to be involved except to place it strategically. [1] https://youtu.be/NDUcoNlgPrk https://youtu.be/NDUcoNlgPrk
- ahmeneeroe-v2 2y ago>Imagine the drone just sitting there listening for a helicopter to get close enough Imagine a drone which outputs the signature of an attack helicopter to draw out that loitering drone and then destroy it, leaving the space open for an actual attack helicopter to swoop in and do its business.
- throwup238 2y agoHow? A helicopter is on the order of 75-80 decibels at 1000 feet. That’s the equivalent of a giant flying stadium speaker consuming kilowatts of power, that has to catch a much smaller 200mph drone while being just as cheap. The attack drone can just move and triangulate the sound, eliminating anything that’s trying to mimic a helicopter without outputting enough decibels.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 2y agoUse your imagination. The counter-drone doesn't have to output the exact same energy profile as an attack helicopter, just close enough to trigger the anti-helo-drone's activation. Examples: the counter-drone outputs only a specific frequency (the anti-helo drone isn't running a whole sound analysis, just a narrow range). It outputs that at much lower decibels (the anti-helo-drone just thinks the helo is farther away). It outputs that sound in bursts and directionally (the anti-helo-drone is only listening in a specific place). Once found, the counter-drone dispatches a kill drone which can match the anti-helo drone's speed. Sure all of these "hacks" will be countered by future versions of the anti-helo-drones, but that's kinda my whole point.
- mdaniel 2y agoAt the risk of being off-topic for an article about helicopters, I will never stop loving the A-10 -- brrrrrt for life
- rjurney 2y agoThis seems to be the takehome. The helicopter has to be a drone operator and behave very defensively, with effective active measures. > Given the right network integration and the right weapons, you could inflict a deal of pain in a fairly basic helicopter while staying well out of the way of any air defence. You still have to protect yourself against chance encounters – partisans or special forces with shoulder-launched weapons, for example. This appears easier said than done.
- rjurney 2y agoBrimestone 2 is 50kg - what's his deal with medium helicopters?
- moi2388 2y agoRemember when the Ukrainian counter offensive failed, in part due to the Russian helicopters coming in and absolutely annihilating the offensive? I do. The helicopter isn’t dead, neither is the tank. But their tactics might change, and they might become optionally manned, because why not? But if you need quick reaction, massive firepower, or troop transport either quickly or in difficult to reach places, good luck doing it with drones or wheeled vehicles.
- sgt101 2y agoWhat a pity that Brimstone isn't integrated with the Apache.
- Havoc 2y agoAll piloted combat aircraft seem questionable at this point. More weight, more vulnerability, more ethical issues, less ability to take high g force, more expensive, more focus and endurance issues, more constraints on taking risks. When bombing runs are guided bombs anyway and air to air is all about over the horizon missiles anyway then there really questions around why you need a human in it at all.
- silexia 2y agoThis article appears to be written by AI.