6 ms·
CoRncrete: A corn starch based building material (2017)
- thevtm 2y agoThis has been out for quite a while, there's even a YouTube video from 2015 showing how to make it using a microwave. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7dYcJaCOMU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7dYcJaCOMU
- acchow 2y agoThey mix 225g sand with 50g of corn starch. It's more "sand based" than "corn based".
- aaronblohowiak 2y agoin concrete, cement makes up less than 25% of the mix, and here corn is like 20%, so I think when you're comparing this class of materials (concrete, epoxy granite, concrete), it makes sense to describe in terms of the binder even if it is a smaller % of the complete product.
- szvsw 2y agoAll concrete is more aggregate than binder… but it’s the binder that matters from an emissions perspective.
- yunohn 2y agoWell, tbf the paper clearly says it was published in 2017 and the first author is the same person who uploaded the presumably experimental stage video to YouTube in 2015.
- orbisvicis 2y agoHow does it handle water?
- hlieberman 2y agoIt's a concrete that: 1) breaks down in water in a day(!), and 2) has a "5 times higher impact on human health and 3 times higher impact on eco-toxicity as compared to concrete.". Cool research, but I'll pass on using it.
- klysm 2y agoHaving 'negative' results like this published is so good though because then it's harder to scam people with this idea in the future.
- mythas 2y agoYeah when the CORN-FREAKING-CRETE skyscraper crowd funding video comes out we can all be more skeptical than we were for SOLAR-FREAKING-ROADWAYS.
- disillusioned 2y agoSweet jesus was anything stupider than the solar roadways idea? "Let's take a technology that can easily be aggregated in appropriate, economies-of-scale implementations and _distribute them_ and require them to be extraordinarily more durable while running voltage through a surface that's being contacted by random people thousands of times a day, with the miles and miles of additional distributed infrastructure necessary to boot!"
- HideousKojima 2y agoMy favorite part about the video was them talking about how much square footage roads take up and how that space could be used for solar panels, while showing footage of vast fields of open land right next to a road.
- ben_w 2y agoGiven how often I still see people dunking on PV due to the land usage, I unironically think that's one of the better points. Yes, I know there's plenty of better land, but comparing the scale needed to something we've already got likely helps change people's minds about the practicality of PV.
- szvsw 2y agoInteresting. The degradation in wet conditions seems like a major challenge to solve. I initially was skeptical of the utility when I saw the mention of heating requirements, but the temperatures aren’t that extreme, and seem very reasonably achieved with electrified energy sources (which in turn can easily be supplied via renewables). Being able to produce concrete without the emissions involved with the production of portland cement is a major goal of decarbonizing the building stock, so it’s always good to see new lines of research in this front, even if still in the germinal stages! ARPA-E Hestia has some cool alternatives (a bit further along in research stages) for those interested: https://arpa-e.energy.gov/technologies/programs/hestia https://arpa-e.energy.gov/technologies/programs/hestia
- danans 2y ago> Being able to produce concrete without the emissions involved with the production of portland cement is a major goal of decarbonizing the building stock AFAICT, cornstarch has a similar emissions to portland cement: https://apps.carboncloud.com/climatehub/product-reports/id/75110207553#:~:text=%E2%80%9DCorn%20starch%E2%80%9D%20currently%20has%20a,of%200.96%20kg%20CO%E2%82%82e%2Fkg https://apps.carboncloud.com/climatehub/product-reports/id/7...
- szvsw 2y agoYep, the authors do a relatively straightforward LCA and estimate essentially equally carbon footprint between concrete and “corncrete.” Point still stands - it’s a major goal of building technology to mitigate the embodied carbon of buildings due to concrete.
- danans 2y agoA big possible issue with this is that cornstarch (at least the way it's currently produced) has the same carbon footprint as portland cement, which it replaces in this process. https://apps.carboncloud.com/climatehub/product-reports/id/75110207553#:~:text=%E2%80%9DCorn%20starch%E2%80%9D%20currently%20has%20a,of%200.96%20kg%20CO%E2%82%82e%2Fkg https://apps.carboncloud.com/climatehub/product-reports/id/7....
- szvsw 2y agoThe authors do mention approximately equivalent carbon footprints in their LCA, but they don’t really explain how they account for the energy involved in heating the corncrete. If they are assuming a clean grid or renewable source already, then there’s not much potential for reducing that carbon footprint. But if they are assuming a typical or dirty grid, then that’s one area where the footprint can come down a significant amount. I was only skimming but I didn’t see a mention of what assumption they used there.
- danans 2y ago> But if they are assuming a typical or dirty grid, then that’s one area where the footprint can come down a significant amount. Not sure I understand how, since regular concrete made from portland cement does require heating to cure - in fact it's exothermic. The vast majority of the emissions from traditional concrete come from the manufacturing of portland cement. It's not clear how a renewable grid would significantly lower the emissions of producing cornstarch, since the majority of emissions happen at the agricultural stage, via the petroleum based fertilizers.
- danans 2y agoOops typo, corrected: "regular concrete made from portland cement doesn't require heating to cure"
- scythe 2y agoBefore you get too excited: - Global production of corn: 1.2 gigatonnes, source https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/cropexplorer/cropview/commodityView.aspx?cropid=0440000 https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/cropexplorer/cropview/commodityVie... - Global production of Portland cement: 4.1 gigatonnes, source https://gccassociation.org/key-facts/ https://gccassociation.org/key-facts/ And of course, cornstarch is only about 70% of the weight of corn. IIRC grain production statistics are usually by dry weight, but if we assume wet weight, it's even worse. Even if we completely obliterated the meat and biofuel industries worldwide, we would struggle to meet a quarter of the current demand for cement, which anyway is forecast to increase.
- dylan604 2y agoHere's hoping that corncrete doesn't interfere with all of that wonderful ethanol. /s
- photochemsyn 2y agoPortland cement is not easily replaceable in its main use (building construction) because concrete made with organic substances as sand grain binders, be it cornstarch or epoxy-polymer, isn't fire resistant. The compressive strength of cornstarch concrete maxes out at 26 MPa according to the paper, while different Portland cement formulations range from 20-50 MPa, and epoxy-polymer can go up to > 100 MPa, though brittleness is a problem. The optimal strategy for cleaning up Portland cement production is probably (1) renewable-based electrification of the kilns used to make CaO from CaCO3 (limestone), and (2) capture and stabilization of the CO2 from the kilns in a form like carbon fiber or diamond. Still a bit sci-fi but technologically feasible (but not economical at present).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- szvsw 2y agoAnother major area for decarbonization is also just better design - just by making it easier to fabricate and deploy shaped beams/floor systems which allocate material in a way that mildly follows the moment diagram, you can knock out massive amounts of emissions, just by virtue of the fact that the developing world will largely be building all floor systems out of concrete… https://doi.org/10.1016/j.engstruct.2021.112955 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.engstruct.2021.112955
- notamy 2y ago> Under water submerged conditions (20˚C), hardened CoRncrete specimens showed partial to complete degradation within a day. While this certainly isn't great for most obvious building use-cases, I wonder if it would have utility for ex. building a research base on the moon someday.
- szvsw 2y agoI actually have some friends working on construction materials for moon bases! ie turning regolith into bricks, using drones/robots to assemble the structures etc. pretty cool stuff. There’s a fair bit of research going on into this problem. I think the main challenge with your idea is that you have to get the corn starch to the moon… you really want your solution to be focused on ISRU (in-situ research utilization) as much as possible.
- elif 2y agoIt's a 1:5 ratio starch:regolith I think you'll find that transporting the water is far more costly, which would be the case with any lunar concrete
- szvsw 2y agoMakes sense!
- SoftTalker 2y agoThere is water on the moon. Not a lot, but there is some ice in deep craters at the poles. But there's no cornstarch.
- Animats 2y agoThis is much like staff.[1] Staff is a kind of cheap artificial stone, made from gypsum, cement, dextrin, and glycerin, with some long plant fibers for tensile strength. It was used for temporary exhibition buildings for various fairs a century ago. The Palace of Fine Arts colonnade in San Francisco, built for a 1915 fair, was originally made from staff. By the 1960s, it was a ruin. The current version is a full rebuild from 1974 in more durable materials. There are more promising bio-materials for construction. Attempts have been made to make boards from bagasse, the leftover fiber from sugar cane processing. It works, more or less. The most useful application for bagasse is making clamshell containers and plates for fast food. It's cheap, biodegradable, and non-toxic. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Staff_(building_material) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Staff_(building_material)
- yunohn 2y agoSometimes I wonder if buildings really should last hundreds of years taking up that space. Similar to how laws last almost forever and lead to byzantine requirements and tricky interpretations. Would be interesting if transient infrastructure and time-limited laws would lead to a more beneficial way of living.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoJapanese buildings are designed to last about 50 years iirc, after which they're demolished. Temples are rebuilt every X years as well. The building materials, at least in those temples, are mostly natural (wood, mostly cleverly jointed so minimal metal required). IDK if they're still popular but the tatami mat is made out of rice straw, also fully biodegradeable (assuming the stitching isn't plastic).
- theultdev 2y agoJapan is not in the same era as what you're describing. There are many modern buildings that are built the same way as other modern cities and designed to last. They have very modern infrastructure, and while what you're describing does exist, but is by no means the norm nowadays.
- bigfryo 2y ago[dead]
- qup 2y agoDo ants eat it? They eat some corn-based insulation I have.
- elif 2y agoI'm gonna guess it's more likely that it won't last as a building material, rather than believe no one thought to mix sand, cornstarch and water until now..
- ncphil 2y agoEncouraged to see the skepticism here. Recalling when, after years of hype, the demand for corn-based ethanol as a fuel competed with corn for food, leading to even greater food insecurity world-wide. Grifter's gotta grift, but that doesn't mean their BS gets to go unchallenged.
- metada5e 2y agoCorn-based electrical insulators proved problematic in cars due to rodents eating the tasty insulators. Something to check in testing this material. Mycelium based construction materials may be more beneficial due to fire resistance, insulation and excellent R values and relative unpalatability. Ecovative is a good place to learn about this (no personal affiliations, just a fan.)
- bfung 2y agoHN meta: an actual research paper vs product posing as science. Nice.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- a1371 2y agoThis is a thing not because it adds strength or sustainability. We produce way too much corn and they are looking for ways to use them up.
- jxf 2y agoUnclear on that first point. The authors claim 26 MPa for CoRncrete, which is about the same as the higher end of the range of concrete (~28 MPa) but much cheaper. On the other hand, it sounds like the paper's saying it's also much less durable.
- LegitShady 2y agoI wouldn't count anything under 40 MPA as "high strength concrete" at all. Thats where high strength concrete starts for me. High strength concrete mixes can go up to 180-200 MPA although thats some crazy specialty stuff for very niche uses. 25 mpa concrete is "i'm doing my driveway" concrete or "I bought a bag at home depot" concrete not high strength concrete.
- elgenie 2y agoProducing less corn rather than subsidizing it is the better way to go. This just seems like another fake-green boondoggle, similar to ethanol.
- gigatexal 2y agoFull article here: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0950061817315283?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09500...
- major505 2y agoplease, let it be the registed commertial name. I would be awsome.
- 29athrowaway 2y agoTopsoil is very limited, this seems like a bad idea.
- otterley 2y ago(2017)
- dang 2y agoAdded. Thanks!
- andai 2y agoDoes the polymerization prevent biodegradation (e.g. digestion by fungus) I don't think I have access to the full paper, but it is described as biodegradable, which seems to be the opposite of what you'd want your house to be made of?
- arrobbiato 2y agoSiliation or esterization of the long carbohydrate chains would make them close to indigestible, and also far more water-resistant, but at that point the cost (including environmental) would outweigh the benefits over concrete.
- mystified5016 2y agoOhio has entered the chat
- zouhair 2y agoStop using food for anything else than food, people. We don't have enough arable land to waste on this stuff.
- MBCook 2y agoWe have enough food to feed something like an extra 1.5 billion people. Fixing waste and distribution would more than make up for it, and that’s not including the possibility of shifting corn over from ethanol instead if this proves actually useful.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dukeofdoom 2y agoInteresting, just watched a guy that turned cooking oils into plastic (with a catalyst like iron). And he got into how canola oil, was a rebranded industrial lubricant that needed a new market post wwII. (just with lowered toxicity levels) "Seed Oil converts to PLASTIC" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ra_tCL5-4c0&t=1s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ra_tCL5-4c0&t=1s And earlier listened to Robert Kennedy on a podcast where he discussed how offshore wind farms, have turbines placed in the ocean with giant blades that can explode and pollute water with shards that close beaches and kill Whales. While significantly more expensive than terrestrial wind farms. Public opinion is often swayed by such labels like "environmentally friendly", "reusable", "pro environment". Who could not support such things ... Turns out environmentally friendly products, often are just a swindle to get massive amount of subsidy money from government ... for bad ideas. It's a form of corruption, as politicians that approve these things often benefit in some way. While public loses.
- DrNosferatu 2y agoWon’t that compete with food production?
- imtringued 2y agoThis is meaningless. Hempcrete or strawbale construction with a load bearing wood structure is more sustainable than this.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]