8 ms·
Why Is Light So Fast?
- SomeHacker44 2y agoThere is already a Part 2 out (read it yesterday) and a Part 3 planned.
- ivansavz 2y agoDirect link to Part 2: https://profmattstrassler.com/2024/10/03/why-is-the-speed-of-light-so-fast-part-2/ https://profmattstrassler.com/2024/10/03/why-is-the-speed-of...
- nyc111 2y agoI was reading this article carefully. I noticed that he uses the word "stationary" to mean both "absolutely stationary" and "relatively at rest". The reasoning in this article is based on conflating and mixing the two meanings. So for instance when he writes "photons are always in motion" [1] he assumes that there are objects that are not always in motion, that is, they are in absolute rest. But he also writes "specifically its 'rest mass' m, which is the mass as measured by an observer who is stationary relative to the object." In this quote, he defines the word "stationary" as relative rest. This rhetorical trick is so common in physics, that's why I wanted to mention it. The trick is to define the same word twice with its opposite meanings and use the word with both meanings sometimes even in the same sentence. I wonder what is the name of this trick in logic. [1] This quote is from a different articla: https://profmattstrassler.com/waves-in-an-impossible-sea/waves-in-an-impossible-sea-commentary-and-discussion/chapter-5/ https://profmattstrassler.com/waves-in-an-impossible-sea/wav...
- SetTheorist 2y agoGenerally, "equivocation" is the fallacy of using the same word with different meanings in an argument. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivocation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivocation
- kccqzy 2y agoI read the same article and I didn't find "absolutely stationary" in the article. My physics is rusty but even from my recollection of high school physics there is no such thing. It's clear that the word stationary means zero velocity, and first year high school physics taught that any measurement of velocity must be done in a reference frame. The idea that a photon is always in motion is true regardless of which reference frame you pick; it does not imply there are objects that are in absolute rest.
- thfuran 2y agoThere is no absolute reference frame that would distinguish "absolutely stationary", as you call it, from "relatively at rest". There is only relative motion. Photons are "always in motion" in that there does not and cannot exist any massive object with respect to which a photon is at rest.
- jerf 2y agoI do not know where I first saw it, but I saw someone observe that the shocking thing about Einstein's theory of relativity is not that everything is relative; that was understood reasonably well for a long time before him. What is shocking is that the speed of light in a vacuum, or the speed of causality, is a constant. You can derive huge swathes of relativity from that fact alone. As a result, of all the speeds, when discussing the speed of light (which conventionally means "in a vacuum" unless otherwise mentioned), you can in fact ignore the question of reference frame, with the exception of you don't want to use a reference frame itself moving at the speed of light. But other than that, an article exclusively confining itself to the discussion of the speed of light in fact doesn't need to worry itself about the relativity of reference frames. For that speed alone, you can't level the complaint against it that it ignores the issue of different frames, because it uniquely doesn't matter. (Relatedly: It is frequently given as the reason you can't reach or exceed the speed of light is some stuff about masses rising. While mathematically true in its own way, I think there's a cleaner reason to explain why you can't reach or exceed it, which is that you can't even get closer to it. No matter what you do, the speed of light is c. You accelerate to a thousand miles a second in some direction, and how much closer are you to c? The answer is, none. Light continues fleeing from you, in all directions, at c. There is no "get really close to c somehow and then just push yourself over really hard" because there is no "get close to c" in the first place. No matter how hard you accelerate, in what direction, in what order, in what manner, you not only can't get "close" to c, you can't even get closer. For similar reasons, in this paragraph, I don't need to qualify in which reference frame you go a thousand miles per second different than before, because it doesn't matter for c. You can't even get slightly closer to it, let alone "exceed" it somehow. It is an absolute.)
- thfuran 2y ago
- elashri 2y agoIt is not a fallacy. In special relativity the important concept is the frame of reference. For photons there is not no inertial frame of reference where photon will be stationary (relative or absolute means nothing actually). The whole concept of measurement (which you will need to describe something as stationary) depends on an observer travelling at speed velocity less than speed of light. If you Try to assign a inertial frame of reference to a photon you will break laws of special relativity - photons always travel in speed of light from perspective of any inertial observer whether it is moving or at rest (verified by experiment) - relativity prohibited mass less particles (like photon) to be stationary. E = mc^2 doesn't apply in photon and apply only on stationary objects. The complete equation is E^2 = (p^2 c^2) + (m c^2)^2 Where m is the rest mass. In photon case the second terms vanishes and the energy is merely the first term. -Time and space behave differently for photons. In relativity, time dilation and length contraction become extreme at light speed. A photon does not experience the passage of time in the way objects with mass do. Therefore, trying to define a reference frame for a photon would lead to contradictions in our understanding of spacetime. So in general it doesn't mean much absolute vs relative on photon case.
- nyc111 2y ago"In special relativity the important concept is the frame of reference." I study motion not special relativity. Motion is a fundamental concept. We don't need to use Einsteinian lingo to study motion.
- nyc111 2y ago"For photons there is [] no inertial frame of reference where photon will [appear to] be stationary (relative or absolute means nothing actually)." I added my comments to your sentence. Obviously, if photon appears to be stationary, this means relative to something else. So relative and absolute are not meaningless.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AndrewOMartin 2y agoThis article mentions that the speed of light seems fast to humans living daily lives, but is not so fast on an astronomical scale. The best demonstration of this I've ever seen is on "If the Moon Were Only 1 Pixel - A tediously accurate map of the solar system" [1]. If you've not seen it before, I recommend opening it, using your mouse wheel to scroll from the beginning (near the Sun) to Earth. It should take about a minute, but there's some commentary on the way. Then, to save your mouse and your finger some work, try clicking the icon in the bottom right hand corner to auto-scroll the map at the speed of light. [1] https://joshworth.com/dev/pixelspace/pixelspace_solarsystem.html https://joshworth.com/dev/pixelspace/pixelspace_solarsystem....
- jzl 2y agoOn the topic of perfectly crafted depictions of scale in the Universe, I love this one: https://youtu.be/vcJHHU9upyE https://youtu.be/vcJHHU9upyE
- alex-moon 2y agoShameless plug: during lockdown I did a whole series of these, called Spacewalks: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLul2c76M6HJySkSXYMoLXW9VCp2xbeNxf&si=Acesf9KP2jAluvQr https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLul2c76M6HJySkSXYMoLXW9VC... These videos were super fun to make and kept me sane when I found myself with far too much free time and a bunch of world news to avoid. I never did the fifth (and final) walk but it's only about 100 meters long so I hope one day to do it in person (if I ever end up with that much free time again).
- steve_adams_86 2y agoThis was awesome. It's strange to know that I already understood this (conceptually at least), yet seeing how slow it really is at this scale is confusing. Maybe that's not quite the right word. It makes my brain pause and go "that can't be right", but... It's right. Brains are bad at these scales. Maybe mine is worse than average. I can't fully believe how impossibly far away so many things truly are.
- S04dKHzrKT 2y ago
- PaulHoule 2y agoOur energy scale is set by the energy scale of chemistry. When you run it is powered by chemistry. Chemical rockets are powered by chemistry. Hypothetically you could go faster if you used fission or fusion energy but practically the chemical bonds get in the way. Even https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_thermal_rocket https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_thermal_rocket is limited by the strength of chemical bonds of the reactor so it gets a factor of 2 or 3 or so on exhaust velocity compared to a chemical rocket.
- api 2y agoThis is why somewhat realistic high-power fusion rockets like those portrayed in The Expanse require magnetic nozzles. The fusion plasma would never come into contact with the material the engine is made of or it would melt. We could build a decent fusion pulse drive today if we had higher temperature more compact superconductors and super-efficient compact lasers that could fit in a spacecraft and ignite a strongly net-positive inertial confinement fusion pulse. Our superconductors are almost good enough, but our high-power lasers are way too inefficient and bulky. We can't even make economically viable ICF on Earth with current lasers.
- PaulHoule 2y agoD + He3 and H + B are attractive precisely because the product is entirely charged particles that you can catch with such a magnetic nozzle. D + T is easier to ignite, but releases a lot of energy in neutron kinetic energy which you need to absorb in some material which lowers the temperature. D + D is the most common fuel on outer solar system and interstellar bodies but it also releases neutrons and might be most valuable in an energy system in that it products He3 and T some of which could be separated from the plasma and used to fuel reactors that are either aneutronic or low ignition energy.
- api 2y agoYep, there was a physicist who did the math on the Epstein Drive (unfortunate name) in The Expanse and found that it was at the edge of possibility if you use very efficient lasers, ICF, and D+He3 fuel. There is mention of helium-3 and fuel pellets in the books, so it sounds like that was the idea. The biggest un-realism in The Expanse is the lack of huge heat-sinks, at least in the show. (They aren't mentioned in the books but I assumed they'd be there.) Without heat-sinks even if the drives were >95% efficient the ship would melt. Also in the show the thrust plumes from the engines are portrayed as looking like grill flames. In reality they'd look more like beams of light fading off into space.
- Animats 2y agoPart 2: [1] It's kind of an anthropic principle argument.[1] If the fundamental constants had substantially different values, the resulting universe would be boring. All the mass collapsed into one black hole, or evenly distributed as fundamental particles. Or atoms don't work. Or stars don't work. This leads to the usual problems - many-worlds theory, gods, etc. Strassler hasn't gone there, but others have. [1] https://profmattstrassler.com/2024/10/03/why-is-the-speed-of-light-so-fast-part-2/ https://profmattstrassler.com/2024/10/03/why-is-the-speed-of... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle
- JdeBP 2y agoIt also kind of is not, inasmuch as it doesn't argue that there's the possibility of a universe where a "slower" speed of light (whatever that might mean) would not permit the existence of humans. It merely argues that the speeds of the human-centric world have to be small fractions of c, whatever value c is, by dint of how the macroscopic relates to the subatomic. In natural units, in all such theoretical universes, c is 1; and all that this argument really states is that humans and similar atom-based things have to move at very small fractions of 1.
- ithkuil 2y agoI.e. it's not that light it's fast but rather it's us who are slow
- kibwen 2y ago> In natural units, in all such theoretical universes, c is 1 I think this could be an instance of falling prey to the same sort of assumptions that the anthropic principle is intended to expose. For example, imagine theoretical universes where the speed of light is non-constant, or varies depending on where you are, or changes over time, etc.
- griffzhowl 2y agoI'm not sure this affects the argument. Even if c were to change, creatures made of atoms would still have to be in conditions where their velocities relative to the objects around them are low compared to c, otherwise they would disintegrate on contact. There are other assumptions about atoms that go into this of course, but the goal of the article is to explain why any creatures made of atoms would think of the speed of light as very fast compared to the interations they're accustomed to.
- jzl 2y agoI’ll steal a line from a superb YouTube physics channel (Arvin Ash): it’s not the speed of light, it’s the speed of causality. And the universe must have a finite speed of causality. Without even getting into math and physics, you can intuitively understand how infinitely fast causality would prevent time, and therefore everything else we know, from being possible.
- JdeBP 2y agoIt's not just Arvin Ash. That's actually fairly common terminology amongst physics educators nowadays. For starters: You'll find a lot of physics YouTube channels that say "speed of causality". It has even started to make its way into the astrophysics and physics textbooks in the last couple of years.
- Jsebast24 2y agoEinstein was not talking about light in his SR and GR theories. He was talking about the "speed" of light. As simple as that is, took me a long time to get it.
- jzl 2y agoInteresting thanks. I hadn’t seen it elsewhere myself but I could see how it’s taken off. OP’s article almost gets there, but never says that specifically. Rather it says “c is not a property of light, it’s a property of the universe.”
- griffzhowl 2y agoLandau & Lifshitz, in their (classic) book on The Classical Theory of Fields, begin with a section called "Velocity of propagation of interaction".
- jprete 2y agoAnd the other half of this is that brains are extremely complicated casual chains. Causality can traverse the diameter of the brain something like 10^8 times in the period it takes for light to be perceived.
- chongli 2y agoThe speed of light is not fast. It's really, really slow! That is, slow relative to the size of the universe and the timespan of the universe, relative to human scales of size and timespan. Humans can travel around the world (our domain) in a matter of hours (on rockets, our fastest mode of travel thus far). Similarly, the fastest waves can cross the ocean in a matter of hours. Light, on the other hand, takes billions of years to cross the visible universe. It's downright glacial at those scales!
- sghiassy 2y ago^^ this
- JdeBP 2y agoYes, it takes forever to get anywhere at Warp 9. (-: More seriously: Your very point is already made near to the beginning of the headlined article, in the book quote. You might want to read beyond the headline question, otherwise you're just repeating what the article already says.
- chongli 2y agoI did read the article and it is not making the same point I’m making. It takes the position that humans are extremely slow, relative to the speed of light. I’m taking a different position: that humans are extremely fast, relative to the domain in which we operate (the earth, our cities, our neighbourhoods, our households).
- JdeBP 2y agoThe paragraph beginning "And yet c is also slow." in the article is pretty much what you said. If you now want to make the point that humans are fast on human-centric scales, which you did not really make above, you enter a whole other discussion that involves biology, and humans not really being very fast at all compared to some other creatures. You have, after all, to introduce non-human entities, rockets, to show examples of humans being "fast". And really fast rockets aren't examples of humans being fast, as they are good examples of humans becoming dead, from the accelerations involved for starters. Take a human out of a rocket system, and it can go much faster. Human-ridden rockets are in fact slow, too, even on human-centric scales, compared to the things that are extremely fast in the human-centric world. So that argument falls down. Which leads to part 2, pointed out in a top-level comment by Animats, at https://profmattstrassler.com/2024/10/03/why-is-the-speed-of-light-so-fast-part-2/ https://profmattstrassler.com/2024/10/03/why-is-the-speed-of... which goes on to explain that humans are by necessity slow. There are even biological discussions of the same idea: why humans are slower than, say, houseflies. We're slower than c for physics reasons, and we're slower than things on our own scale for biological reasons. We actually are not extremely fast. We aren't as fast as our machines, nor even as fast as some other creatures.
- jacknews 2y agoBut why mv^2 ? Is the universe 2D? And it's E=mc^2 because the only 'consensus' value in the universe is c? Why is that? And so the 'mass' (whatever that is) must be moving at the speed of light for the equation to make sense, even though it's stationary? The blogs demonstrate great factual knowledge and 'mastery', but don't really explain anything IMHO
- prerok 2y agoWell, depends on your viewpoint, I guess. When you really get into the details, it turns out we don't "really understand" anything. We are just making more and more detailed observations and then creating mathematical models of these behaviors. For example, we observe that space is curved around mass. We can model that and it helps us understand what's going on, so it's useful. We don't, however, understand what exactly is curved and what is this empty space that curves.
- af3d 2y agoIf you break up "mv^2" into its constituent dimensions you get m(d/t)^2 = m(d^2)(t^-2). Now the so-called kinetic energy of the object only "manifests itself" whenever there is a change in velocity of the object in question. Well, the derivative of velocity is an acceleration, so the object in acceleration would be represented as mdt^-2, aka "a force". Hence the energy of the system is simply that force acting over some distance d. As to the internal/intrinsic energy of a given object, think of it as "hidden potential energy". It is essentially the energy that was required to turn photons into the matter that you, and I, and everything else are made of! The equation itself is mc^2 simply because that is what you get when you rearrange and simplify the experimentally-verified equations which it was drawn from. Likewise, for c is nothing more than the measured value of the speed of light in vacuum for any observer. Of course the choice of units is completely arbitrary. Whether you state it in miles per hour, kilometers per second, or whatever, the ratio remains constant.
- pharrington 2y agoThe mv^2 isn't a geometrical property - it's because the kinetic energy can also be thought of as the integral of an object's momentum with respect to time.
- idunnoman1222 2y agoThe speed of light is in its Goldilocks zone. I wouldn’t worry about it too much.
- MarkusWandel 2y agoLight isn't that fast. It only goes about a foot per nanosecond. It can be fun to work out for people how many bits are in a piece of cable at any moment, and that's assuming electrical information in a cable travels as fast, which it doesn't. A real demo is to talk via VOIP with someone on a satellite internet connection. The old, geostationary satellite kind. It takes so long for the audio to get there and back that you have to practically say "over" when you're done talking.
- epohs 2y agoHere's a 5 and a half hour long video of a photon travelling across the solar system.. spoiler the photon in this video doesn't move quickly https://youtu.be/_qKOpvDa82M?si=HyO5TGSvxw0DN5yF https://youtu.be/_qKOpvDa82M?si=HyO5TGSvxw0DN5yF
- greenhearth 2y agoWe are trying to speed everything up all the time and speed is seen as a virtue and something desirable. Could it be that we are trying subconsciously on a collective scale to get close to the natural state of the universe?
- whatshisface 2y agoThe argument given in part 2 (that the strength of nuclear forces compared to electric forces make nuclei very heavy relative to the energies that would rip their chemistry apart) does not make a lot of sense in the context of the fact that binding energy reduces the mass of bound states. For example, 56Fe is lighter than 26 protons and 30 neutrons. The ratio of the Hydrogen atom's ground state electron binding energy to the electron's mass-energy is one half the fine structure constant squared. That implies the nuclear forces don't have much to do with it - electromagnetism is simply, and dimensionlessly (i.e. independently of any arbitrary units or scales), a weak force.
- goatmanbah 2y agoBetter to ask why light is so slow...
- jcd000 2y agoThat was a nice read.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- p4bl0 2y agoEDIT: Sorry I came back from the article to say this before reading the comments here… I should have, the top comment is already saying the exact same thing! The speed of light isn't that fast. The website "the moon is one pixel" is a webpage where our solar system is represented at scale if our moon were 1px in diameter : https://joshworth.com/dev/pixelspace/pixelspace_solarsystem.html https://joshworth.com/dev/pixelspace/pixelspace_solarsystem.... You can scroll through it. It's so long to go from one planet to another. So much empty space. At some point you're tempted to click on the C button which you see on the bottom right of the page. Speed of light! Surely that will autoscroll fast! … Nope, to scale, the speed of light is waaaay slower than your scrolling was! And then you realize, at the size of the universe, how even light isn't that fast.
- FredPret 2y agoIf I had to write a “game of life” simulation that simultaneously calculated the effects of all events at each point in a 3D matrix over time, I would: - make the matrix as rough as possible while still enabling interesting events (ie, try and maximize the Planck length) - make the maximum speed at which events propagate across the matrix as slow as possible to save the CPU (ie, try to minimize the speed of light) - limit the size of the simulated universe But our Planck length is tiny and the universe is probably humonguous unless we’re being deliberately deceived by This Simulators. So despite the suspicions aroused by the slow speed of light, we might live in the mother / “real” universe after all.
- hoerensagen 2y agoI think you might have the same misconception about the planck length that I had: "The Planck length does not have any precise physical significance, and it is a common misconception that it is the inherent “pixel size” or smallest possible length of the universe.[1] If a length smaller than this is used in any measurement, then it has a chance of being wrong due to quantum uncertainty.[2]" https://simple.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_length#:~:text=The%20Planck%20length%20does%20not,wrong%20due%20to%20quantum%20uncertainty https://simple.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_length#:~:text=Th....
- shadowgovt 2y agoThis is a very good author. "What's a Proton, Anyway?" is also both educational and entertaining [https://profmattstrassler.com/articles-and-posts/largehadroncolliderfaq/whats-a-proton-anyway/ https://profmattstrassler.com/articles-and-posts/largehadron...]. "Ok, then, what’s a hydrogen atom? It is the simplest example of what physicists call a “bound state” — the word “state” basically just meaning a thing that hangs around for a while, and the word “bound” meaning that it has components that are bound to each other, as spouses are bound in marriage. In fact, the image of a married couple, especially one with one spouse weighing a lot more than the other, is probably the one you want."
- dboreham 2y agoAs fast as the GPUs running the simulation.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- darkhorn 2y agoI didn't find why. When you make a wave with a rope or on a water the speed of the wave is formed by the speed of the interaction of the molecules in it. I believe similar thing happens with the light in subatomic level. There, may be the spped of light is limited on how fast an higs boson interacts with the neighbpring higs bosons.
- kazinator 2y agoWhy is light so slow is the question. It takes a whopping 8 minutes to get from the Sun to here.
- chemmail 2y agoSome people also don't realize how linked to time C is. If you were to say not move at all. You will be moving through time at C. But if you were moving say at 50% the speed of C, you will only be moving through time at 50%. So you can never exceed natural speed + natural time.
- hilbert42 2y ago"Why is the Speed of Light So Fast?" Seems to me that we should be asking the question why is the speed of light so slow! We're forever discussing the Higgs and how matter gets (some of) its mass but we spend precious little time discussing this relationship: c0 = 1/(μ0 ε0)^0.5 That is why vacuum permittivity and vacuum permeability 'conspire' to slow down light to its known value.
- Jyaif 2y agoThe content of this blog is amazing, thanks for the submission. Regarding E=1/2mv*v, where does the 1/2 come from?
- mikhailfranco 2y agoIt comes from the fact that force is proportional to acceleration (F=ma). Then the factor of 1/2 comes from the formula for the area of a triangle, or equivalently, integrating a constant twice wrt time, gives term in t, then a term in t²/2. Consider constant force acting on a mass initially at rest, for time t producing final velocity v and distance travelled x. F = ma [Newton's 2nd Law] v = at = (F/m)t, so mv = Ft [momentum transfer is force times time] x = (1/2)vt [area under v-t curve: triangle formula] E = Fx = F(1/2)vt = (1/2)v(Ft) = (1/2)mv²
- jessekv 2y agosee also: https://tauday.com/tau-manifesto#table-quadratic_forms https://tauday.com/tau-manifesto#table-quadratic_forms
- tim333 2y agoI'm not sure he gets to the answer of the 'astonishing' bit of the speed. Fast is relative but astonishment is a human reaction based on our brains being slow because evolution gave rise to large molecules which have to jiggle around before things work so the light is already at the moon by the time we've registered much. If instead you use a computer processor it only goes about 10 cm per clock cycle or not so fast in practical terms.