8 ms·
Correcting the record for Continue and PearAI
- WiiManic 2y agoSomething that I've really not seen mentioned, is that they are also (and still!) ignoring the licensing that Microsoft has around VSCode. VSCode is built on open source of course, but the the OSS version is "Code - OSS". When Microsoft builds it and releases it, it becomes VSCode with the Visual Studio trademark and what not. PearAI's Code fork is using the real VSCode marketplace which has strict "This has to be used with Visual Studio products" (well, and some other MS / GitHub bits), so they can't use that. If you look at other VSCode-adjacent editors, they all use open-vsix.org instead. They also use extensions that are licensed in the same way: https://trypear.ai/blog/wsl-setup https://trypear.ai/blog/wsl-setup They have instructions on setting up the WSL extension...which has a "This can only be used in Visual Studio Code" License too, so it can't be used in their PearAI fork. You can see some examples of the terms of use / LICENSEs here: https://cdn.vsassets.io/v/M190_20210811.1/_content/Microsoft-Visual-Studio-Marketplace-Terms-of-Use.pdf https://cdn.vsassets.io/v/M190_20210811.1/_content/Microsoft... https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items/ms-vscode-remote.remote-wsl/license https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items/ms-vscode-remote.... It just shows a complete lack of regard for licensing...
- kibibu 2y agoThe "dawg I chatgpt'd the license" tweet was absolutely egregious. Honestly it also reflects equally badly on Coinbase if they were paying these guys $300k. One positive outcome is that this might have cured a lot of people's imposter syndrome.
- Dansvidania 2y agoeven working face to face with relatively incompetent people has never helped with my imposter syndrome. If anything this is a stark reminder of the hiring bubble we were in the past few years..
- DonHopkins 2y agoThe bad reflection goes both ways: Working for Coinbase already reflects badly on anyone no matter what they're paid.
- rlnvlc 2y agoHow so?
- kibibu 2y agoOne might hold the position that crypto coin companies (particularly those working with POW coins) add very little value to the world in exchange for significant social and environmental cost. One who held this position would see working at Coinbase as an indicator of a moral failing.
- DonsDiscountGas 2y agoI imagine coinbase has a legal department and these guys were paid to code. Using chatgpt to write a license is a ridiculously dumb thing to do since there are so many public templates to choose from, it sounds like they're just overly enthusiastic about AI.
- kevinmchugh 2y agoI think there's a line where AI enthusiasm becomes disdain for human expertise. If you can't be bothered to learn about licenses, what else are you just going to assume chatgpt can figure out for you?
- kibibu 2y agoIt was less work to just leave the license alone
- aster0id 2y agoI've interviewed for Coinbase and it was a shit show. The recruiter initially said my interviews went well but then never got back to me, even after me reaching out multiple times. Plus there are lots of reports from people working there that things are held together by strings and glue, and the work life balance is terrible.
- appendix-rock 2y agoSo, “it was a shit show” was “the recruiter ghosted me”?
- toneyG 2y agothat is indeed one of the signs that a recruitment process is a shitshow
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tech-historian 2y agoThey also lied about having 100+ contributors to PearAI.
- ActionHank 2y agoThis had some real SBF playing lol during meetings vibes. It's been said that YC invests in the founders and not the ideas, these oranges don't seem worth the squeeze.
- ErikBjare 2y agoI thought the crazy part was "I don't have time for legal", but he did have time to change the license, lol.
- foretop_yardarm 2y ago> It just shows a complete lack of regard for licensing This is the MO of all AI companies
- CMS_Flash 2y agoWait, isn't WSL extension also available on Cursor? Did they reach an agreement with MS?
- Obertr 2y agoWhatever everyone thinks, YC is playing to win. And they make winners >>if you don’t make mistakes it means you are not trying hard enough. << Elon Musk Big picture, people who never heard of PearAI or continue dev just did. I did. I tried it. It’s as good as cursor And guess what? whatever side you are on, YC and those startups won either way. More developers heard about each one of them and more tried it.
- mpalmer 2y agoCounterpoint: PearAI was launched as a trivial copy of another product and framed by its creators as the greatest thing since sliced bread. It's obvious that these people are less interested in making something useful than they are in making something that will generate enough hype to get another round of funding.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pjs_ 2y ago.
- lukev 2y agoThe premise of a startup is that your investors expect you to mature and build something valuable. If you want to be a "funny little guy," stick to hackathons.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Yusefmosiah 2y agoMuch of the criticism comes with a tinge of envy. "How did those guys get funding and not me?" Envy is insidious. Focusing on how other people have unfair advantages eats away at your principles, motivation, creativity, and presence of mind to capture the opportunities available to you. As a founder myself, I appreciate the fact that it's so easy (for some people) to raise money. It means that the competition is softer than it seems.
- dvektor 2y agoThe other day I was browsing the two most recent YC batches. There were so many times that I stopped in awe and thought: "WOW.. I cannot believe they funded that". But each time I would think, OK this looks like a terrible idea, but they have to know something that I don't, and I'm just being cynical. This lack of due diligence makes me think that I may have been wrong, and they are really just throwing money at everything with AI in the pitch. However, I do salute him for the honesty, and for apologizing.
- cadamsau 2y agoThese people of PearAI made a series of mistakes and felt the burn of the community. Give them a chance to learn from it, you might be pleasantly surprised. They’re people, and most people learn from mistakes. I’m assuming it was all done in good faith, for now at least.
- ActionHank 2y ago"These people acted wholly incompetent, proceeded to act clownishly in public when people asked questions and then still ended up with a bag of money and a product that is largely not their own. Let's give them another chance."
- allanrbo 2y agoI’m so confused by these guys. Stumbled upon them on YouTube and thought it was satire https://youtu.be/18cHBU05zK0 https://youtu.be/18cHBU05zK0
- zwaps 2y agoThis says too little of substance. What errors were made in YCs assessment, which will be corrected? What is the path forward?
- tptacek 2y agoPeople have weird ideas about what YC is and does. People apply to YC: you can go look at the application. They get gajillions of them. They downselect applications to interviews. The interviews are brief. They downselect interviews to offers to join a cohort. Every company in the cohort gets a group partner that they do regular "office hours" meetups with. There are internal events and talks and stuff. There's a standard investment, and demo day. That's it. YC doesn't operate YC companies. They're investors. They aren't your boss. They're not looking at your code. They're almost certainly not doing any meaningful technical due diligence. These are things that happen, to an extent, in priced rounds that happpen after your seed round (A-round technical due diligence is also a joke, but whatever, stipulate). The whole point of YC is that they're investing in big batches of startups, at a scale that is a big multiple of what an A-round VC does in a whole year. Tan is apparently apologizing because he spoke up on behalf of a batch company, or repeated some misinformation TechCrunch published. But it is very weird to ask them how their selection process would change to account for this happening.
- FridgeSeal 2y ago“Don’t blame them, they just haphazardly throw money at projects without vetting them properly” Well uuhhh, maybe they shouldn’t? Would a bare minimum of due diligence not be ok lol?
- tempusalaria 2y agoYC cannot do a ton of due diligence. Their strategy is to back many companies with small amounts of money, basically in the hope that a few companies in the batch end up as unicorns. This means they want to select founders capable of getting those outcomes, which will also select many liars/psychopaths due to the need for variance/risk taking behaviors in these founders. Now is there a problem where YC and many other VCs basically advise founders to commit fraud and lie to customers/stakeholders? Yes but that has nothing to do with YC admissions strategy. I’ve seen many VCs (including YC) advocate for lying and unethical behavior by their founders. It’s a big problem in the startup industry, and often the biggest brunt of this is taken by unsuspecting employees. One reason I would never advise someone to join a startup is the massive prevalence of unethical and dishonest founders.
- stonethrowaway 2y ago[flagged]
- jazzypants 2y agoCredit to Garry for unequivocally apologizing and shouting out https://amplified.dev https://amplified.dev . The whole PearAI situation was a bad look, and it made it seem like YC had not done their appropriate research before investing. I doubt this really did permanent damage to their reputation (I don't know if anything can at this point), but this move was definitely necessary to placate anyone who was paying attention.
- yunohn 2y agoBut this post doesn’t provide any details about Pear.AI outside of them scrapping their stolen code, which is all they had?
- groby_b 2y ago"Credit to Garry" is a funny thing to take away from this. He is ultimately the person responsible for setting up an environment that got them funding in the first place, and he's the one responsible for defending them without checking the facts. It's good he finally apologized, but let's also be clear that's the minimum bar when you mess up so hard. Of course, if you think this was just "a bad look", and the apology was just a "move [...] to placate", it might make sense to consider it as a cynical business move only and give credit to the shrewdness of that. I sincerely hope it's more than that.
- throwaway314155 2y ago> it made it seem like YC had not done their appropriate research before investing It still seems like that. Moreso, even.
- badgersnake 2y agoDeveloper tools startups generally don’t make money. Seems like a pretty risky bet all round.
- madeofpalk 2y agoDeveloper tools startups always seem 100% to be an acquisition move.
- bbunix 2y agoDid you go through their commits? Hint: https://x.com/minitru/status/1840549001797701984/photo/1 https://x.com/minitru/status/1840549001797701984/photo/1
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- paulgb 2y agoHere’s the commit that tweet dunks on: https://github.com/microsoft/vscode/commit/78c1777cd1255974531ab6408cb3e71a2998a533 https://github.com/microsoft/vscode/commit/78c1777cd12559745... It came from the upstream VSCode repo, and merely removed the words “all rights reserved” which do not appear in the “official” MIT license.
- BestHackerOnHN 2y ago> Out of instinct to defend YC companies Credit to Garrry for realizing he is very biased and offering a tepid "apology."
- shashanoid 2y agoHe's an idiot
- Maxious 2y agoICYMI > In 2024, Tan attracted criticism for a profane tweet wishing death on seven of the 11 members of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors. In a later apology, he said he was referencing a rap track. https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/garry-tan-tech-exec-angry-tweet-die-slow-supes-18635493.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/garry-tan-tech-exec-a...
- jumping_frog 2y agoI sometimes think private individuals in America are held to much higher standard than public representatives. Somehow, it is like "all things considered" my party did the right thing under the circumstances but that "all things considered" leniency is not shown to private individuals.
- atleastoptimal 2y agoThe thing about doing something like what PearAI did is that worst case, they get flamed, they apologize and make changes, but overall don't lose much. They still have the YC label, the money, and free publicity. In a few months nobody will care, so overall their decisions were a net benefit. Has any startup founder ever really suffered due to bad publicity? Short of extreme cases like Theranos, worst case scenario is they get a golden parachute, enjoy a few months/years "soul searching" then emerge with another startup. However most of the time nothing really happens. People only came after PearAI because their founders' arrogance was particularly egregious. A bit of preemptive covering their tracks and nobody would have done anything.
- gkbrk 2y agoI don't know what happened to the people behind it, but bad publicity basically killed livecoding.tv. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10486476 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10486476
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- imiric 2y agoI agree with you, but what do you think should be done instead? What they did was misleading and dishonest, but it wasn't illegal. Should they be expelled from YC because of it? Maybe, maybe not. I feel like endless persecution for "bad" behavior, part of the current cancel culture we're living in, is not healthy for society. People can make mistakes, and as long as they acknowledge and make an effort to correct them, they should be allowed to move on with their lives.
- kibibu 2y agoWell, they could be kicked out of the program for one.
- DonHopkins 2y agoPeople who say shit like "dawg I chatgpt'd the license" aren't healthy for society.
- nixosbestos 2y agoSo PearAI is actually forking VSCode? I wonder if they'd have been better off building on the latest iteration of Eclipse Theia.
- tripplyons 2y agoPearAI is forking Continue's VSCode extension, from what I can tell.
- nixosbestos 2y ago> Afraid of switching editors? No need, PearAI is a fork of VSCode and Continue so you'll feel right at home Literally from the smack center of their homepage.
- santiagobasulto 2y agoThis is a good and thoughtful response. As much as we’d like to get mad at it, there’s not much more to do.
- threeseed 2y agoYou do know that Garry banned a bunch of people who criticised him over this. And that when told about PearAI violating the terms of the license said to the effect "who cares it's open source" as though none of this actually matters and it's just a bunch of nerds over-reacting. It's arguably worse than what PearAI did in the first place.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dotty- 2y agoI was one of the people Garry blocked on Twitter and after this article was published, I was unblocked. So to be fair, it does seem like Garry has taken steps to reverse that.
- ActionHank 2y agoRescind the funding? Address that some partners or internal processes clearly failed? Nah, nothing to be done.
- crystal_revenge 2y agoI had the same reaction. I'm usually quite cynical about these things and was ready to scoff at it, but I thought that was about the most you could really accomplish in an apology. The key to me was that it wasn't focused on how sorry YC is, it focused on how great of a team Continue is. Far too many apology posts are just another way to get attention, so it was nice to see that attention directed at the party receiving the apology.
- throwaway562if1 2y agoIdeally it would have a section on next steps and how YC will prevent such events in the future, but definitely preferable over a corporate nonapology.
- dang 2y agoRecent and related: The AI startup drama that's damaging Y Combinator's reputation - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41722507 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41722507 - Oct 2024 (48 comments) "Our view is that PearAI should start over from scratch" - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41712589 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41712589 - Oct 2024 (4 comments) YC criticized for backing AI startup that simply cloned another AI startup - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41707495 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41707495 - Oct 2024 (257 comments) Pear AI founder: We made two big mistakes - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41701265 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41701265 - Sept 2024 (228 comments) Y Combinator Traded Prestige for Growth - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41697032 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41697032 - Sept 2024 (244 comments) Did I miss one?
- lukev 2y agoWas doing a bit of searching to get context on this story and found an unrelated but interesting tangent... there's another unrelated startup named pear.ai that's been around for years. It's in a different domain, but the name is basically identical. Are people just... not doing any due diligence around company names any more? At all?
- yunohn 2y agoI see similar name overlap criticism by people in every other HN thread. Are you of the opinion that once somebody names their company something, that name is forever unusable for a similar or different company ever again? I’ve seen both kinds of examples being criticized, even for acronyms! Mind boggling.
- DonHopkins 2y agoPear is an anagram for Rape! I didn't even have to use the Internet Anagram Server to perform that minimal amount of due diligence. https://new.wordsmith.org/anagram/anagram.cgi?anagram=pear&t=500&a=n https://new.wordsmith.org/anagram/anagram.cgi?anagram=pear&t...
- raincole 2y agoThis drama kinda happened on a platform called "X" so...
- pclmulqdq 2y agoThey are not. It's currently hip to use a single word from the dictionary as your company name, no matter how many others are using it.
- masswerk 2y ago> Are people just... not doing any due diligence around company names any more? At all? Well, there was a famous tweet/post/("X"?), answering to the claims of illegal relicensing, reading, "dawg i chatgpt'd the license (…) we busy building rn can't be bothered with legal" – I guess, the answer may be indeed "no"…
- 2y ago
- minimaxir 2y ago> PearAI has apologized, removed the offending repositories, and is working to correct all their mistakes. If the issue at heart is a forked repo...then what's left?
- wmf 2y agoNothing. It sounds like all the problems have been fixed.
- threeseed 2y agoAnd now all we are left with is two random guys who have built nothing, have no novel idea and have given the middle finger to the open source community.
- taytus 2y agoYes, pretty much. I hate what they did and how YC (not only Garry) reacted. Let's hope these guys come out with something unique to benefit humankind. Hope is all we have left.
- cityzen 2y agoall their mistakes... that they are working to correct.
- skeptrune 2y agoSubtle touch here in linking repeatedly to Continue and not Pear. Really nice implicit message on what Garry's final view of the situation was after getting more information.
- minimaxir 2y agoThe article reads as diplomatically throwing PearAI under the bus, which may be a conflict of interest.
- throwaway314155 2y agoWhy shouldn't YCombinator just drop PearAI from their program? I mean they literally stole another YC startup's work wholesale and effectively defrauded YC investors. I don't know much about startup land but it seems there's an absurd amount of forgiveness given to a company that is clearly fraudulent. Who cares whether or not they received the standard amount of due diligence/vetting? The only reason a system like that can work is if participants act in good faith, and this company obviously didn't. edit: Like I said, I'm not exactly knowledgeable about the world of tech startups. If i've learned anything though, it's that the money being given to obvious scam artists being excused as "vetting batch investments doesn't scale" has made me even more depressed and cynical about tech startups than I previously thought was possible.
- auggierose 2y agoWhy should they drop them, though? The damage is done, the money is spent, and they can just as well wait it out now, to see if anything comes from it anyway. In the worst case, it is a failed investment, and they will have plenty of those, and the reason doesn't actually matter, except in learning from it for the future. There definitely are things to get depressed about, I just don't think this is one of them.
- blitzar 2y ago> I mean they literally stole another YC startup's work wholesale and effectively defrauded YC investors. Didn't YC know it was a fork of one of their existing investments? If they knew then it is bad, if they didnt know then it is bad. If they didnt know and continue to fund this startup then they are stupid. > The only reason a system like that can work is if participants act in good faith If you are a professional investor you need a better bullshit detector. If you fail any time someone acts in bad faith, it is not the game for you.
- JoeAltmaier 2y agoThe investment world is full of functional sociopaths. You get used to it I guess. YC's bullshit detector would be blaring nonstop if that was enough to tank a deal.
- threeseed 2y agoThis is a pretty poor apology. Open source has been infinitely more valuable and important to humanity than the latest LLM or AI trend will ever be. Without it Linux or Apple would simply not exist. And every startup would be solely dependent on Microsoft for their future. It would've set back software decades and seriously harmed the take up of the internet. And all of it hinges on everyone agreeing to play by the same rules which are codified in the licenses. And acting like it's no big deal that can be safely ignored is to frankly spit in the face of all of the selfless developers who contributed their code for no financial benefit over the many decades.
- blinding-streak 2y agoApparently YC has over a dozen active partners. They don't coordinate tightly. They compete against each other for investments and often overlap verticals. That's why you see 2, 4, or more redundant investments in the same space from YC. It's a mess but not uncommon.