6 ms·
> many late stage companies have valuations that are too high to IPO without taking a big valuation haircut. Isn't the market what determines the value of a co
by SoftTalker 2y ago
> many late stage companies have valuations that are too high to IPO without taking a big valuation haircut.
Isn't the market what determines the value of a company? If they can't get the IPO price they want, then they aren't worth what they think they are.
- AYBABTME 2y agoIf they have enough cash/free cash flow, they don't have to take money at a lower valuation.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> If they have enough cash/free cash flow, they don't have to take money at a lower valuation Sort of? You're describing either a healthy business, at which point their market value shouldn't be an issue, or management holding the business hostage because they prefer their salary to shareholders having a return.
- gtCameron 2y agoThere isn't a return for shareholders if the valuations are lower. The problem is not management holding the business hostage today, the problem was investing at unsustainable multiples a few years ago. Now the only options are to either cash out at a lower valuation and not make any money, or wait and hope the business grows to the point where you can get a higher total valuation despite the lower multiple and see a return on your capital.
- candiddevmike 2y ago> management holding the business hostage because they prefer their salary to shareholders having a return. But Ive been fed that the principal agent solution of equity and executive privilege prevents this! Next you'll tell me capitalism doesn't allocate resources efficiently.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> the principal agent solution of equity and executive privilege This phrase is distilled nonsense. Executive privilege [1] has precisely nothing to do with the principal-agent problem [2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_privilege https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_privilege [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_proble...
- s1artibartfast 2y agoValue isnt singular. Every single transaction in the economy is the result of a difference in opinion about value. My House has a public valuation, but the value it me is much higher, so It is not for sale. Im sure there are several things that you dont buy for their market price because they have less value to you. You dont go into the store and buy every Item you see, or put every item you own for sale.
- SoftTalker 2y agoAgreed, but if I decide to sell my car, what I originally paid for it, what I think it's worth, or how much I've invested in repairs, or how much I still owe on it, all has nothing to do with the price I can get.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoThere are an infinite number of ways you might choose to price your car. If you want it sold in the next 30 minutes, you'll have to settle for what anyone has in their pocket. If you're willing to wait 20 years, you might get a much higher price. Anyone who has bought or sold a used car will know that market price is an average, in reality prices are diverse. With all that said, my point was to highlight the role of choice in deciding to sell or not. I wouldn't recommend selling your car if you owe more than the market price, and don't have money for a replacement.
- ajsharp 2y ago100%. A lot of companies effectively waited too long to exit, and in retrospect probably should've gone public in 2021.
- aantix 2y agoThe Reddit IPO appears to be holding strong. 11.129B market cap. There's an appetite for companies with low profitability, but promising future growth.
- CalRobert 2y agoReddit might be in an unusually good position since they hold a huge amount of natural human language they can sell.
- skrtskrt 2y agobit of a stretch to call that natural human language - forget the type of actual people that post there, it's been a massive astroturfing target for political and marketing bots for over a decade.
- Apocryphon 2y agor/HailCorporate
- nostrademons 2y agoThat's the point. The value of a company is determined by the price that people are willing to buy & sell its shares at, but you don't have to be that person. The VC fund in the article is basically saying "We believe that anyone buying late-stage startups at these valuations is a fool and is unlikely to get a better price when it goes to the public markets, and we are not going to be the greater fool with your money."
- surgical_fire 2y agoI wonder if that means that the grift is over. The whole VC/startup grift needs the greater fool to be either a big company with money to burn to do an acquisition, or the retail investor to be the greater fool via IPO. This is bad.
- nostrademons 2y agoThe previous grift is over, the new one (AI) is getting started. VC fund actually wants to exit the old market, where they are the greater fool at the bottom of the pyramid scheme, and enter the new one, where they can find new fools to unload on.
- tombert 2y agoYeah, it really bothers me that as a society we've decided that ponzi schemes are actually fine as long as it has some loose "tech" branding associated with it. It seems like the startup strategy in Silicon Valley is "grow at all costs, worry about profit later, IPO, now it's the public's problem". Of course someone could say "well they're not forcing you to buy the IPO'd stock!", and that's sort of true, but only in the strictest sense. My 401k, like I think nearly everyone's, is a mutual fund, and it invests in a little of everything. I also buy ETFs that do the same thing, because it's really the only way to preserve wealth, for better or worse. Even if I, for example, thought that WeWork's business model was unsustainable, I don't really have a way of "opting out" of buying their stock without effectively starting my own index fund, or having my cash lose value in an FDIC savings account.
- 2y ago
- TrackerFF 2y agoYour house isn't always worth what you want it to be. FOMO and free cash can work like magic for all kinds of assets.
- no_wizard 2y agoA startup I used to work for within a year of interest rates rising and lower spend by businesses and consumers ended up cutting staff by ~84% and they nearly 100% outsourced development (it may in fact be 100% now but idk for sure). They did this to avoid any changes to their sky high valuation, as if they went and fundraiser it would have tanked it. At this point I think they’re hoping to meander along until they’re forced into fire sale or they get acquired for their customer base
- shivasaxena 2y agoNot really, the DCF value of a company is sum of its discounted Future cash flows. But the value to a acquirer usually exceeds it because they can can extract a "hidden value" specific to them. It's called "acquisition premium" If interested, look up "Valuation: Measuring and Managing the Value of Companies"
- akira2501 2y ago> Isn't the market what determines the value of a company? There are several markets involved here. > then they aren't worth what they think they are. Which is an indication that your market is corrupt or lacks the information discovery necessary for accurate pricing information to be generally available.
- everforward 2y agoYes, but the driving motivation is probably more financial than emotional. Trying to IPO at a price lower than the last valuation is announcing to the world that the last investors lost money, while simultaneously trying to convince the world to be the next investors. In theory, the market will bounce back so IPOing now is effectively selling low.