3 ms·
Class 'Inequity' Fuels Air Rage
- Scoundreller 2y ago> Regulators have been relying on a punitive approach to stem the tide and some violators have been hit with fines in the tens of thousands. Did it work? Because it’s not sounding like it.
- zem 2y agothe thing about punitive measures is that they don't need to work in order to be perpetuated; they simply fit the way the people in power think the world ought to work.
- libraryofbabel 2y ago> The study found that just having a first-class section on an airplane quadrupled the chance of an air rage incident and that loading economy passengers through first class doubles that again This sounds like a study full of confounding factors that are very difficult to control for, to do with sizes of planes and lengths of flight and different seating configurations of different airlines. And indeed there is a response to the original study questioning the statistical methods: https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.1611704113 https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.1611704113 On the wider subject, I’m a frequent flier and also have a few friends who are flight attendants. It’s a difficult job, and not well-paid. Please, every time you fly, imagine yourself in your flight attendants’ shoes, tasked with controlling a large number of grumpy primates packed into a long airtight cylinder for several hours, many of them intoxicated when they board and then expecting you to serve then even more alcohol. A little empathy goes a long way and I’m quite happy to see some draconian penalties for anyone who is physically violent on a flight.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bradleyjg 2y agoYou aren’t wrong about flight attendants but also big companies exploit your empathy. You aren’t ever allowed to see or communicate with anyone other than ill paid employees with no responsibility. This is intended to defuse and disarm your anger and frustration at the company—-whether legitimate or not.
- libraryofbabel 2y agoeh, sure, but I don’t think it’s hard to make the distinction in this case. When something egregious happens with a flight, do I bitch at the flight attendants and take out my frustration on them? No. Did I make a huge stink to the airline complaints department afterwards? Yes. I don’t feel my empathy is being exploited here.
- stavros 2y agoI agree with everything you said, I just found myself compelled to point out that the fuselage is not airtight (there are air intakes from outside, the toilet flush uses the pressure differential, etc).
- libraryofbabel 2y agos/airtight/pressurized/g then :)
- stavros 2y agoThank you :D
- libraryofbabel 2y ago(I originally wrote “metal cylinder” but then thought, waiiiit this is hacker news, someone is going to correct me and give me a mini seminar on composite fuselages.)
- stavros 2y agoAt least you dodged that bullet!
- trilbyglens 2y agoThat you for confirming that I am indeed reading a hacker news thread
- _dain_ 2y agoYes, also effect sizes of 4x and 8x are just ridiculously huge. I flat-out don't believe it. This study won't replicate.
- polotics 2y agoRegulations say pilots have responsibility and authority over who they accept on the plane, one commercial airliner pilot did tell me he does refuse entry to clearly inebriated passengers. For this of course the pilot has to not be too busy, has to take the time to stand at the door for the whole boarding, and has to have a company that will not veto such (legal) decisions to refuse boarding, with associated luggage removal delay etc, to happen... How much has this changed in the past ten years?
- derriz 2y agoYes the conclusion sounds like the authors have bent some statistics to support their theory. I fly frequently and have occasionally felt these feelings of anger but NEVER have I started actual boarding in a good mood only for my mood to sour as I get to my seat. The anger has always built up earlier. To be clear, I'm not trying to refute the study by stating this fact. But I am suggesting that there are obvious other explanations for the observation. For example, the existence of a first class section is highly correlated with the size of the airplane. Larger airplane size is associated with significantly more queueing - which are far more likely sources of "ragey" feelings. Especially queues which stop moving or are unfair - for example where you have multiple queues and you get put into a slow/stuck one. I mean who doesn't feel a little surge of irritation, stuck in a queue, when someone is holding up a check-in desk asking a bunch of irrelevant questions. Also larger aircraft (with first class sections) are more likely to be international which usually means passport checks/visa control - thus more queuing.
- maxweylandt 2y agoWould've enjoyed a randomized approach to this. A paper I like a lot randomly exposed south Africans to luxury cars and found increased support for reidstribution. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2763-1 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2763-1
- k__ 2y agoShowing median people what the upper class steals from them seems like a reasonable thing to do. I think, there isn't any situation where it's so obvious. One type of humans gets cramped like farm animals, and the other gets pampered like pets.
- tjpnz 2y agoMight motivate them to work harder, right?
- trilbyglens 2y agoOr to be born into the right family/country/situation in their next life?
- admissionsguy 2y agoThis sentiment just promotes learned helplessness. While the world is by no means fair, flying first class is achievable for any able bodied person living in a first world country.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- SideQuark 2y agoThe majority of the rich are first generation. It’s far easier to become rich than to be born rich.
- bradley13 2y agoHow is first class stealing anything? Without it, there would just be more second class seats. Not more space per seat.
- bamboozled 2y agoTo start with, if there was no first or business class, there would be more room for everyone else on the plane ? It’s pretty simple actually.
- anovikov 2y agoI'm all in for class segregation everywhere, including on airplanes. In the "good old" Soviet days, first class (there was no "Business" as there was no business in the Soviet Union) section was in front and used the same toilet and entry door as the pilots and the crew, AFTER it was the attendant's rest section, galley, luggage storage compartment, and on THEN the economy section. So those "animals that are more equal than others" could never intermix with the rest and most passengers were not even aware the first class existed. Thus the impression of egalitarian society was maintained and industry/government elites enjoyed their flights with no annoyances (the Party elites flew private planes).
- kuldeepbhai 2y agoThis is a link was avery inportant click here in link
- flohofwoe 2y agoHeh, I'm not exactly the 'raging', more the 'eye rolling' type, but I can relate each time I travel in German ICE trains with a cramped full second class and empty first class (which is the common situation on weekends). Just getting rid of the first class would pretty much double the train capacity between cities (regional trains already either don't have a first class at all, or a very small section - which also is always empty anyway).
- Freak_NL 2y agoSame in the Netherlands. First class in trains isn't beneficial to 95% of the travellers. I suspect the hefty first class season tickets used by upper middle class managers and civil servants count towards keeping it even in newly ordered trains.
- bradley13 2y ago"the ever-shrinking personal space available might be a significant factor" What, really? You mean, people don't like having the fat blob next to them overflowing into their seat, while their knees are mashed against the seat in front? Who could have guessed?
- mschuster91 2y ago> The rates of air rage skyrocketed during the COVID pandemic, but most of that was due to the mask mandate. What's puzzling regulators is that it hasn't dropped to pre-pandemic levels. According to University of Texas researchers the ever-shrinking personal space available might be a significant factor. It's so funny how everyone willfully ignores the elephant in the room: COVID causes serious neurological damage [1]. The shrinking personal space is a myth, at least in the timeframe we're looking at - airlines are flying whatever is remotely airworthy, no one sends a plane off for months of being reconfigured and upgraded (maybe except Lufthansa who have pushed their renovations so far that the aged interior is now seriously crippling their competitiveness). The planes are the same that were flying pre-COVID. > Transport Canada says the bad behavior sometimes starts before boarding. Earlier this year it reported an increase in the number of unruly and sometimes violent people in the security lines. It's considering adding a fine structure for passengers who abuse security agents. And that one is the second elephant: Of course people get unruly when they have to wait for delayed boarding, lose baggage and whatnot. During COVID many airports let staff go because they didn't have money, those people left the industry forever, and now they can't hire enough replacement staff - airports usually are outside of the cities, so long commute times, pay is shit, and bureaucracy is often a nightmare too(in Germany, everyone working on the airfield side has to pass a governmental, very extensive background check). Fines won't work, not when many people have to deal with lingering COVID aftereffects and service quality is dog shit. [1] https://theconversation.com/mounting-research-shows-that-covid-19-leaves-its-mark-on-the-brain-including-significant-drops-in-iq-scores-224216 https://theconversation.com/mounting-research-shows-that-cov...
- ggm 2y agoFirst party to make FAA regulations on seat size get 6" more legroom and width wins.
- akmarinov 2y agoThat’ll probably bump up flight prices quite a bit and with the US not having a rail or bus alternative and basically commuting on flights - that’s not going to “fly” at all
- ggm 2y agoAll change to least cost economics involve cost rises. The question is what degree the airlines compete or collude on price. Price is already so mutable, arguments to the cost of seating changes beg questions. The same seat slot can be sold for unit cost or 3x unit cost depending. That strongly implies two things: firstly the cost-price relationship is mutable and secondly, the airline is prepared to sell seats at or under cost simply to compete, given other loading. Airlines make huge profit off premium economy and business. If the FAA didn't mandate a seat? I observe Tony O'Rielly has already indicated he'd fly standing, and put cash locks on toilets (both said in humour)